Today's Top Stories (all those selected for the Home Page, Plus Other important news)
Vaccination News
Breaking News Archives - each day's breaking news from December 1, 2003 (check here for breaking news you might have missed and breaking news that didn't ever hit the "front page")
More News - all the news most recently posted on this website
All the News - a running tab of everything posted on this website since October 29, 2003
Daily News Archives - all the news posted on this website each day (beginning with April 2001)
Hot Topics - selected stories, by category
Return to Vaccination News Home Page (for best results, right click to "open in new window")
Subscribe to the Vaccination NewsLetter
View past & current Scandals (columns by Sandy Mintz)
Search This Site using keywords
click here to download Adobe Reader click here for Picks of the Week click here for the old "Recommended List"
To receive daily "top stories" updates, send an email to sandym@touchngo.com with the words "subscribe top stories" in the subject line.
Posted March 1, 2004:
*For most of the Wakefield "conflict of interest" articles posted on the site, click here (check periodically for updates)
►February 29, 2004 - Twisted conflicts - (letters) The Observer via The Guardian, UK - "It seems a scientist, such as Dr Andrew Wakefield (News and Leader, last week), who uncovers genuine concerns about the safety of a vaccine has to be 'squeaky clean'...In contrast, scientists who are vocal in support of the vaccine, and are responsible for checking its safety, are allowed to receive research funding from the company that produces it and to hold shares in the company, or act as consultants." (sent by Dr Milton Wainwright, Department of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology, University of Sheffield)
►February 29, 2004 - Dirty tricks drug firms use to get publicity - The Scotsman - "SHOCKING tactics including bribery, fabrication and plagiarism are being used by unscrupulous drug companies to get their research published in influential medical journals, according to a damning new report...Only a week after controversial research on the MMR vaccine was discredited by the journal which published it following a 'fatal conflict of interest', an influential committee has revealed the widespread use of underhand tactics by researchers."
►February 29, 2004 - Doctor demands apology for MMR claims in Lancet - Telegraph, UK - "Andrew Wakefield, the doctor who first raised fears of a link between autism and the MMR vaccine, has hired a libel lawyer to demand an apology from The Lancet after claiming that the medical journal has cast doubt on his honesty...Dr Wakefield's decision to enlist the support of Carter-Ruck, the London law firm that specialises in defamation suits, follows the denunciation of his work last week by The Lancet."
►February 29, 2004 - Autism is a mystery, not a medical conspiracy - opinion - The Scotsman - "In contrast to Wakefield, I intend to declare an interest at the outset. My son Josh is autistic. Like most children, he was given the MMR vaccine at around 18 months. Shortly afterwards, he began exhibiting the first signs of what we now identify as autistic behaviour. The link between these two events is tempting, but, for reasons of sanity, I have resisted it...In the vast majority of cases, autism manifests itself at around two years, or, in other words, just after the MMR is administered. This coincidence inspired Wakefield’s study. In 1998, his team reviewed reports of children with bowel disease and autistic symptoms. Their research led them to conclude that the MMR shot caused developmental regression, in some cases within 24 hours of vaccination."
Comment: A temporally related relationship alone does not prove causation. But a recent event raises a red flag and is, in fact, the most likely cause. Moreover, the fact that autism didn't used to occur at two years old, nor did it result in the loss of skills as does the new, "regressive" form of autism, means cavalierly dismissing the temporal relationship as "coincidental" is neither wise nor scientific. Sadly, however, this is characteristic of what happens re: the vaccine issue. The fact that others are beginning to corroborate Wakefield's findings, in spite of the difficulty finding funding to do so, and the potential risks to one's reputation and livelihood, make easy answers like the ones voiced in the opinion piece above even harder to swallow.
►February 26, 2004 - MMR medics challenged over child spinal taps - Times Online - "NEW questions about the ethics of the controversial study that linked the MMR vaccine to autism in children will be raised in Parliament today, The Times has learnt..Less than a week after the doctor who pioneered the research was accused of failing to disclose a £55,000 payment, ministers are to be asked whether he had received proper ethical approval. The fresh doubts centre on whether the lumbar punctures to which autistic children were subjected by Andrew Wakefield’s team at the Royal Free Hospital were clinically justified."
►February 29, 2004 - Wakefield unlikely to be charged over MMR scare - www.independent.co.uk
►February 29, 2004 - MMR docs' links with drugs firms - Sunday Mercury via http://icbirmingham.icnetwork.co.uk - "Four leading Midland doctors who deemed the controversial MMR vaccine safe have links to the drug giants who make or supply the jab...Campaigners have called for the General Medical Council to investigate the senior Government advisors, who all hold scientific posts in the Midlands and sat on key committees which declared the vaccine safe."
►February 24, 2004 - This carefully orchestrated campaign must not be allowed to stifle real debate on MMR (requires subscription) - www.independent.co.uk
►March 1, 2004 - Unexpected
Lessons Learned This Flu Season - Los Angeles Times via
www.immunizationinfo.org
(abstract)
►March
1, 2004 - Parents of Vaccine Injured
Children Support West Virginia Religious Exemption -
NVIC
►February 27, 2004 -
Jury still
out on safety of male hormones - New York Times via The Houston Chronicle -
"Given the shocking recent discovery of potentially serious ill effects of
hormone replacement for women, it is hardly surprising that many experts are
warning against assuming that supplemental testosterone is safe and effective
for men experiencing the normal effects of aging."
►February 28, 2004 -
Netherlands
to crack down on complementary medicine - journal article
(BMJ) - "The
Netherlands is considering tougher laws on practitioners of
complementary medicine after government health inspectors who were
investigating the death from breast cancer in 2001 of the actress and
comedienne Sylvia Millecam severely criticised her treatment...The
investigators found that alternative practitioners contradicted the
diagnosis of breast cancer made by her doctors and offered her
instead the prospect of a cure with 'unfounded methods of
treatment.'"
Comment: Would that unfounded allopathic methods
of treatment and misdiagnoses were eyed with the same level of scrutiny.
►February 23, 2004 -
Doctors pressure human guinea pigs - MDs are paid up to $5,000 per patient
to sign up volunteers for drug trials - CanWest News Service via The Vancouver
Sun via www.canada.com
Comment: Wow. If that isn't a conflict of
interest, I don't know what is. This article is chock-full of disturbing
information.
►February 28, 2004 -
Only 6% of
drug advertising material is supported by evidence - journal article
(BMJ)
►Mad Cow Disease, Mad Deer
Disease - Chronic Wasting Disease, Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy -
feature articles - Organic Consumers Association
►February 29, 2004 - New
Vaccine Shortage - CDC via www.about.com
►March 1, 2004 - Misreporting
Measles Research - National Electronic Library for Health (archive) -
www.nelh.nhs.uk - "The research study found
that a higher proportion of children with developmental disorder and new variant
inflammatory bowel disease had measles virus in their gut tissue than healthy
children."
Comment: This analysis tries to make it appear as if there is no evidence linking MMR vaccine to the measles virus in these children or good reason to believe they might be connected. As for research, there is research evidence linking the two. As for good reason, these children were vaccinated and had never had the measles. So the presence of measles virus in their gut probably either means that a) it is measles vaccine virus or b) vaccinated children who get the measles can suffer gastrointestinal problems which may or may not be related to autism.
►The Exemption Debate - West Virginians For Vaccination Exemptions
►March 1, 2004 - Vaccinations: Irrational fear isn't confined to Third World - editorial - The Dallas Morning News - "Polio is back in northern Nigeria, thanks to a conspiracy theory spread by some Muslim clerics. They're telling their people that a United Nations vaccine program is part of a Western plot to render their women infertile. African children will be left crippled because of such barbaric nonsense, and a dread disease that could have been eradicated by scientists will live to maim countless others...But before we start feeling too superior to the superstitious Nigerians, let's consider how vulnerable our own irrational fears of vaccines leave our population to potentially calamitous outbreaks of disease."
Comment: It's only an irrational fear if you
dismiss or ignore the evidence against vaccines.
►February 29, 2004 -
Nil by mouth - For thousands of Britons battling the debilitating effects of
cancer, depression, even eczema, diet is crucial. They view the vitamins and
minerals they take as vital in their fight against sickness. So why does the EU
want to cut off their supply? Rose Shepherd makes the case for rescuing remedies
- The Observer via The Guardian, UK - "In the 21st century we live under siege.
There are concerns about pesticides, herbicides, antibiotics, GM, mobile phones,
microwaves, amalgam fillings, falling sperm counts, mad cows, MMR - even milk.
Farmed salmon is a Trojan horse for carcinogens. Obesity and diabetes are on the
march. There is a mass of documentation on all this. So what is the European
Commission's big idea? 'Let's clamp down on vitamins and minerals.'...It would
be funny if it weren't so tragic. While the EU has been busy drafting
legislation, we seem to have been sleepwalking into a situation where chemists
and health stores will be purged of hundreds of nutritional supplements."
►February 29, 2004 -
Parents lobby to ease immunization laws - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - "The
same vaccines that many credit with ushering in a public health miracle were a
curse to 4-year-old Caleb Mueller, his father believes...Keith Mueller of Kansas
City blames a batch of state-mandated vaccines with causing a severe allergic
reaction in his son when the boy was just over 1. Today, the father is certain
that his son's autism is tied to the shots, as well...Mueller is joining several
parents rights advocates this year to support bills in the Missouri Legislature
that would make it easier for parents to exclude their children from
immunizations."
►February 27, 2004 -
Drugs limit deadly side effects of graft-versus-host disease - Could make
bone marrow transplants an option for more cancer patients - University of Michigan Health System via
www.eurekalert.org
►February 28, 2004 - Panel Urges Stricter Limits on Acne Drug - Reuters via Yahoo! News
►March 1, 2004 - CDC Says Ads Getting Kids to Play Outside - AP via The Herald-Sun
►February 29, 2004 - Dismal payout record for radiation-induced illnesses - Government programs aimed at compensating cancer-stricken nuclear-era workers or survivors criticized for complexity and heavy denial rate - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
►March 1, 2004 - Studying Hyperlexia May Unlock How Brains Read - Children With Rare Disorder Have Heightened Reading, Learning Skills (requires registration) - Washington Post
►February 29, 2004 - Religious exemption worries Ripley mother - Sunday Gazette-Mail - "'How can these groups call themselves pro-life and pro-family if taking a moral stand against abortions performed in the 1960s takes precedence over protecting the lives of those with weakened immune systems today?' she asked."
Comment: As I said in my 2002
speech:
"Public
Health will say that these vaccines must be mandatory or these diseases will
spread. But if the vaccines work, anyone choosing them will be protected. If
they don’t prevent the spread of the disease to the vaccinated, what is the
point? It hardly seems right that those who don’t want to be vaccinated should
be required to be vaccinated, because vaccines don’t always work...And to
whatever extent vaccines are being required because the “immune suppressed”
cannot be vaccinated, and are more vulnerable to the adverse effects of disease,
while my heart goes out to such people, they are not more important than
children who are harmed by vaccines. Nor should the notion that vaccination may
in itself be creating immune suppression be left out of this equation...Besides
there is documented proof of outbreaks in
100% vaccinated
populations.
Now, whose fault is that?"
►February 27, 2004 - Alliance
Sets Goal to Increase Child Vaccinations - Reuters via Yahoo! - "The Global
Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GAVI) and The Vaccine Fund, its
financial arm, hope to raise $400 million annually from governments and private
sources to immunize 30 million children against diseases such as polio,
hepatitis and yellow fever...'Our goal is to allow every child, everywhere in
the world access to immunizations,' Jacques-Francois Martin, the president of
The Vaccine Fund, said at the London launch of the campaign."
►February 29, 2004 - Problems
of modern children often take a back seat to the seemingly more urgent problems
of adults - Growing up pains - Times Leader
►February 29, 2004 -
Red tape
delays hepatitis-B vaccination - The Daily Star
Comment:
For a different perspective on both the risk of acquiring hepatitis B as well as
its seriousness, go to
Scandals:
The CDC and “The New Math”, where 1 + 1 does not equal 2.
For more on the the spread of hepatitis B in developing nations and why
advocating the use of vaccination, under the circumstances, is very revealing,
go to
Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear
falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals
- update and "flashback").
►February 29, 2004 -
NHS
scornful of Charles on alternative medicines -
www.independent.co.uk - "National
Health Service managers yesterday dismissed calls by Prince Charles for more
complementary medicines to be made freely available on the NHS, saying most of
them did not work...Dr Gill Morgan, chief executive of the NHS Confederation,
the umbrella body for managers, said the NHS could use only those medicines that
had been proven effective, ruling out the majority of complementary therapies."
►February 29, 2004 -
Is Biotechnology Losing Its Nerve? (requires registration or subscription) -
The New York Times - "S a founder of four biotechnology companies, Dennis A.
Carson can practically write an encyclopedia entry on risk. After all, his first
start-up, a gene therapy and vaccine company called Vical, still does not have a
product on the market after 16 years and more than $100 million spent...But now
Dr. Carson, who is also the director of the cancer center at the University of
California at San Diego, is playing it safe, or at least safer. Rather than
develop radical new technology or invent new medicines, his latest venture,
Salmedix, plans to sell drugs licensed from other companies - drugs that are
already on the market or that have at least gone through some clinical trials."
►February 29, 2004 -
Research slowly helping despair give way to hope (requires registration) -
The Arizona Republic - "'Your child has autism.'...More than 10 families contact
the Phoenix-based South- west Autism Research & Resource Center every week after
hearing that devastating diagnosis...I say 'family' because autism not only
affects your child, but every member of the family. How you feel, what you do,
where you eat, how and where you sleep largely depend upon your child with
autism."
►February 27, 2004 -
HRT risks 'were known
years ago' - Women could have been told about the risks of taking hormone
replacement therapy years ago. - BBC
►February 26, 2004 -
Mix of Chemicals Plus Stress Damages Brain, Liver in Animals and Likely in
Humans - news release - Duke University Medical Center
►February 22, 2004 - WHO
‘suppressed’ scientific study into depleted uranium cancer fears in Iraq -
Radiation experts warn in unpublished report that DU weapons used by Allies in
Gulf war pose long-term health risk - Sunday Herald, UK
►February 26, 2004 -
Leslie
Burke is terminally ill. Today he will ask a court for the right to live -
www.independent.co.uk
►February 29, 2004 -
Great Influenza killed quickly, cruelly, perversely - Vivid history of U.S.
epidemic of 1918 is also a cautionary tale for our times (requires registration)
- book review - The Providence Journal
►February 25, 1999 -
Antimicrobial
Resistance: The NIH Response to a Growing Problem - National Institute of
Allergy and Infectious Diseases and the
National Institutes of Health
►February 29, 2004 - 'Unless pin-up parents rally round, we will see the return of dread diseases' - comment - The Observer via The Guardian, UK - "Meet 'John' and 'Jane', pin-up parents. They insist on organic food for their toddler, bring him to the best baby group in town, buy him only all-cotton outfits from Baby Gap and won't let him watch more than three hours of television a week...Despite this perfect parenting, however, John and Jane put their child's health at risk every day. They are among the 5 per cent of British parents who have opted out of vaccinating their child."
Comment: This
argument rests on assuming that the epidemic of autism, the rise in chronic
disease (including cancer, asthma, diabetes), and other concerns raised by
so-called "pin-up parents" could have nothing to do with vaccination and have
been scientifically settled. But condescension does not truth make.
And buying the propaganda generated by the vaccine manufacturers as to the
safety of their product does not prevent harm from being done. To the
contrary, if these parents are right, it merely serves to perpetuate and
compound the damage.
►February 29, 2004 -
Most `stomach
flu' avoidable - In case you haven't been listening, wash those germy hands!
- AP via Akron Beacon Journal via www.ohio.com
►February 29, 2004 -
Health
bosses deny MMR deception - Health bosses have denied university students'
claims that they were tricked into having the MMR vaccine without their
knowledge. - BBC - "A mass inoculation programme against mumps took place at the
University of Kent at Canterbury earlier this month after six students caught
the disease...Now some students have told a national newspaper they were not
told they were being given the MMR vaccine."
►February 29, 2004 -
Tragedy saves
twin, motivates his parents - The Modesto Bee - "RSV is something most of us
can shrug off as a common cold: a shot of Nyquil, a box of Kleenex and a few
nights of discomfort...Many babies get it, too, from shopping carts and from
being around others with colds. But for infants in the high-risk category, it
can be deadly. For them, RSV can have the same impact as double-pneumonia would
on an adult."
►2004 - Red Wine
Maintains Immune System - www.about.com
►February 29, 2004 -
Activists get help in fight on AIDS - Grant: Maryland groups receive $335
million, part of the president's pledge to fight the disease and help victims in
Africa and elsewhere. - Baltimore Sun
►February 28, 2004 -
CDC
chief urges better effort to stop diseases that affect women - The New York
Times via Seattle Post-Intelligencer
►February 29, 2004 -
Campaign: Scandal of the Anthrax Babies: A Deadly Chemical Weapon - The
Sunday Mirror, UK
►February 29, 2004 -
Campaign: Scandal of the Anthrax Babies: Our Worst Nightmare - Baby Kye
died: 5 weeks - The Sunday Mirror, UK
►February 29, 2004 -
Study:
Vaccine benefit fades - Less effective after a year - The Cincinatti
Enquirer - "A new study might spark debate among pediatricians and parents about
the effectiveness of the chickenpox vaccine and when it should be given to
children...Researchers at Yale Medical School say the effectiveness of the
vaccine fades significantly in the first year after vaccination. And the vaccine
also doesn't appear to be as effective in children younger than 15 months."
Comment: Prior to the vaccine being developed,
chickenpox was universally considered a
benign
disease. If it has become more serious since that
time, why might that be?
►February 29, 2004 -
Experts say Flu to Cost Asia $500 Million (requires registration) - The Los
Angeles Times
►February 29, 2004 -
Daughter's disability fuels mother's desire to bring program to Siouxland -
Sioux City Journal
►February 29, 2004 -
Trapped In A World Of Hurt - 50 Million Americans Have Chronic Pain, And So
Far Doctors Can't Offer Much Relief (requires registration) - The Hartford
Courant via www.ctnow.com
►March 8, 2002 - Serial letter
writer, Dr. Elphinstone exposed - Private Eye via
www.whale.to
►February 28, 2004 -
Anthrax: Vital fact the diggers weren't told - The Australian
►March 2004 -
My
life with Asperger’s syndrome - journal article
(Archives of Disease in Childhood)
Return to Vaccination News Home Page (for best results, right click to "open in new window")
DISCLAIMER: All information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in consultation with your health care provider.