By
Nicholas Regush
What a week for cloning! I almost wrote "clowning."
We get news of a possible cloning pregnancy. Then we get news that two
colleagues -- Severino Antinori of Rome and Panos Zavos of the U.S.-based
Andrology Institute - who have been hopeful about producing a human
clone - are splitsville. So says Zavos. Severino isn,t talking.
Each is on his merry own way to get the human cloning job done sometime
this year. That is, if you believe in the Tooth Fairy.
First
guys, if monkeys (very genetically similar to humans) have yet to be
cloned (the embryos are a horror show), then you can understand why
some people, me included, suspect you both may be sipping on some peculiar
plant extract. Never mind that most people think you are nuts (scientifically-speaking,
of course) to even want to try to do this.
Meanwhile,
back at the ranch, or more specifically, President George Bush spoke
today about the need for an outright ban on cloning. Now, this is controversial
territory because while it appears mostly everyone (who is not sipping
on some peculiar plant extract) is opposed to cloning high-tech that
would produce a baby, many, however, think that the use of technology
to create embryos that would serve as sources of embryonic stem cells,
is an idea whose time has come.
There
has been a lot of hoopla lately about how these stem cells could be
fiddled with to grow into tissue that might save lives. In other words,
not doing baby cloning is pretty well agreed-upon (except by those who
sip a peculiar plant extract), but there are two camps when it comes
to so-called "therapeutic cloning." George Bush, for instance,
doesn,t want Congress to pass a bill that would allow for any sort
of cloning experimentation with embryos. Many scientists say this religious-tainted
attitude is nothing less that a proposed death sentence for many people
who might greatly benefit from the potential results of stem-cell research.
Well, maybe and maybe not. This is still an incredibly speculative area
in medicine with a lot of biotech hype raining down on all of us.
But
there is something missing in this entire debate about cloning. And
it is shameful that it has not become a major issue. It has to do with
the overall process of generating embryos. And, as one might expect
in these less-than-civilized times, it is women AGAIN that are being
used as guinea pigs to service the visionaries.
Here's
the bottom line that no one is talking about: women are being given
powerful fertility drugs (Lupron, in particular, which has numerous
serious side-effects and has never been approved by the FDA for fertility
treatment), to superovulate so that multiple eggs and embryos can be
produced. Those so-called "left-over" embryos that have been
created and have gone to stem-cell research labs have been products
of an unregulated fertility industry that has managed to escape the
radar of Congress. Where has the oversight been for those women who
undergo in vitro fertilization? What about their short-term and long-term
risk for serious health problems?
Does
anyone in Congress give a damn? Apparently not.