Vaccination News Home Page subscribe Vaccination NewsLetter
http://bmj.com/cgi/content/full/326/7396/986
| Home | Help | Search/Archive | Feedback | Table of Contents |
|
EDITOR
Szatmari's editorial implies more certainty
about the existence of an autism spectrum and causes of autism than is
warranted.1 Debate remains about the validity
and usefulness of a broad definition of autism.2
Autism and Asperger's syndrome are distinct, and although they share common difficulties in social relatedness and obsessiveness, they can be distinguished in these.
In autism children are withdrawn, whereas in Asperger's syndrome they desire social contact but cannot negotiate rules.
In autism, which, unlike Asperger's syndrome, is associated with mental retardation, obsessiveness commonly entails routine behaviours and physical objects, whereas in Asperger's syndrome it entails idiosyncratic and often highly intellectual interests.
The distinction is comparable to that between schizophrenia and schizoid personality disorder. Like autism and Asperger's syndrome they share common features and genetic loading, but clinically their distinction is crucial. A broad definition risks confusion and overdiagnosis, an increasing problem when worried parents demand diagnostic certainty.
Szatmari's statement that autism is a neuropsychiatric disorder plays into this. Neurological problems have a bearing on autism, but the relation remains obscure and the implied claim that autism results from a primary neurological disorder is based on slim evidence. A genetic link does not necessarily imply neurological damage.
Szatmari acknowledges environmental factors but omits social and emotional factors, although the importance of these for psychological and brain development is well established. Evidence indicating their role in autism comes from studies of Romanian adoptees.3
Szatmari believes that research that supports organic causation helps temper
parental guilt. In my experience, helping parents understand their
unwarranted feelings of blame about their children is more productive
than allaying anxiety with premature certainty about
causation.
David Simpson
Tavistock Clinic, London NW3 5BA
dsimpson@tavi-port.nhs.uk
Competing interests: None declared.
| 1. | Szatmari P. The causes of autism spectrum disorder.
BMJ 2003; 326: 173-174 |
| 2. | Volkmar FR, Klin A. Diagnostic issues in Asperger's syndrome. In: Klin A, Volkmar FR, Sparrow SS, eds. Asperger's syndrome. New York, London: Guildford Press, 2000:60-63. |
| 3. | Rutter M, Anderson-Wood L, Beckett C, Bredenkamp D, Castle J, Groothues C, et al. Quasi-autistic patterns following severe early global privation. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1999; 40: 537-549[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]. |
© 2003 BMJ
Publishing Group Ltd
Read all Rapid responses
|
| Home | Help | Search/Archive | Feedback | Table of Contents |
© 2003 BMJ Publishing Group Ltd
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
