Bush proposes smallpox compensation fund
WASHINGTON (AP) — After months of delay, the Bush
administration is proposing a compensation fund
for people injured by the smallpox vaccine, trying
to plug the most prominent hole in its inoculation
program.
The proposal, which Congress
would have to approve, is based on a similar
compensation package now available to police officers
and firefighters injured on the job.
Under the plan, the government
would pay $262,100 for each person who dies or is
permanently and totally disabled by the vaccine. Those
less severely injured could receive up to $50,000 plus
medical expenses.
The vaccine, effective in
preventing the transmission of the highly contagious
disease, carries rare but serious risks, including
death. Smallpox was declared eradicated globally in
1980, but there is fear it could return in an act of
bioterrorism.
The plan announced Wednesday by
the Health and Human Services Department would
compensate people who are being asked to participate in
the vaccination program — as many as 10.5 million health
care workers and emergency responders. The fund also
would cover people injured because they came into
contact with a vaccinated worker.
"We are asking these health
professionals to perform a vital public duty, so we are
proposing to provide them the same sort of benefits that
we provide our public safety officers when they are
injured on the job," Julie Gerberding, director of the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said in a
statement.
The government is making the
vaccine available to the general public but not
recommending it, and these people would not be eligible
for compensation from the fund.
An existing federal compensation
fund covers those injured by other vaccines, but not
smallpox. People injured by the smallpox vaccine are not
likely to be fully compensated for lost wages or medical
expenses without a separate fund.
That partly explains the tepid
early response to the federal vaccination program,
according to state and local officials, unions,
hospitals and health care workers.
Federal officials initially aimed
to vaccinate as many as 450,000 people on special
smallpox response teams in about a month. As of Tuesday,
about six weeks into the program, 12,404 people had been
vaccinated.
Officials are hoping the fund
will increase the numbers. "We would expect that this
would provide a level of comfort to those who are
concerned about the vaccine," said Jerry Hauer, the top
bioterrorism official at HHS.
The nation's largest union of
health care workers agreed.
"The administration has given the
smallpox program a much-needed shot in the arm," said
Andy Stern, president of the Service Employees
International Union, which represents 750,000 nurses and
other health care workers.
But the American Nurses
Association worried that the payments are not large
enough and many people won't qualify because they are
sick for just a few days.
"The compensation doesn't kick in
until a person has been out five days," said Carol
Cooke, spokeswoman for the nurses' union.
The government said its
compensation plan, modeled after the Public Safety
Officers Benefit program, would:
- Offer $262,100 for people who die or are
permanently and totally disabled because of the
vaccine. The money would be paid even if the
victim had other death benefits.
- Pay up to $50,000 in lost wages for people
temporarily or partially disabled by the vaccine.
The government would pay two-thirds of lost wages
after the fifth day away from work, with a maximum
of $50,000. This would be in addition to any
workers' compensation or disability insurance
benefits available.
- Pay reasonable out-of-pocket medical expenses,
other than minor injuries, for people injured.
This would be secondary to any health insurance
benefit available.
- Retroactively cover everyone who has been
vaccinated since Jan. 24, when the civilian
program began.
The smallpox vaccine is made with
a live virus called vaccinia, which is related to
smallpox and can infect the body. Experts estimate that
as many as 50 people out of every 1 million vaccinated
for the first time will face life-threatening
complications, and one or two will die. Reactions are
less common in people being revaccinated.
Officials in Florida, Minnesota
and Virginia have said they are investigating a handful
of cases of people sickened after getting the vaccine,
and there have been several reactions among military
personnel being vaccinated. None of the reported
reactions have been serious.
The most common serious reaction
comes when vaccinia escapes from the inoculation site,
often because people touch the site and then touch
themselves or someone else. The virus transferred to the
eye, for instance, can cause blindness.
More deadly is encephalitis,
which can cause paralysis or permanent neurological
damage. Also fatal though very rare is progressive
vaccinia, where the vaccination site does not heal and
the virus spreads, eating away at flesh, bone and gut.
Copyright 2003 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved. This material may not be published,
broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
|