|
Flu drugs expensive and more
evidence needed-study
By Patricia Reaney
Last Updated:
2003-06-06 12:24:19 -0400 (Reuters Health)
LONDON
(Reuters) - Influenza drugs are effective in treating
and preventing the illness but they are expensive and
there is not enough evidence showing they work in high
risk groups such as children and the elderly, doctors
said on Friday.
Oseltamivir,
which is produced by Swiss healthcare group Roche
Holding AB under the brand name Tamiflu, and
GlaxoSmithKline Plc's zanamivir or Relenza, are drugs
known as neuraminidase inhibitors.
They work by
blocking the action of viral enzymes.
In an
analysis of clinical trials of the drugs, researchers at
the University of Leicester in England found they
reduced the likelihood of getting flu by about 70-90
percent and cut the duration of the illness by about a
day.
But annual
vaccination is still regarded as the best way to prevent
flu epidemics which affect between three million and
five million people each year and kill as many as
500,000.
"The drugs
are both effective at reducing the length of symptoms
and incidence if properly administered. They have to be
given within 48 hours of onset," Alexander Sutton, a
researcher at the university, said in an interview.
But he added
that more research is needed into the effect of the
drugs in the very young and old and in other high-risk
people with heart problems and asthma to see if they can
prevent deaths or other serious outcomes.
In a
commentary in the research reported in the British
Medical Journal, Klaus Stohr, the project leader of the
World Health Organisation Global Influenza Programme,
said the drugs cannot replace annual influenza
vaccination.
"Neuraminidase inhibitors are clinically effective
complements to the current influenza intervention
tools," he said.
"However,
costs and lack of data on their effectiveness in the
groups most severely affected by influenza limit their
use in many industrialised countries and make them
largely unaffordable in developing countries," he added.
The drugs,
which cost about 24 pounds ($39.23) in Britain for a
course of treatment, are used mostly in Japan and the
United States.
Only about 50
countries, most in the industrialised world, have
influenza immunisation policies. The WHO is urging
countries to increase their vaccination coverage to all
people at high risk to at least 50 percent by 2006 and
75 percent by 2010.
Copyright 2002 Reuters.
|