| |
|
|
By ERNST LAMOTHE JR.
© 2002 THE NEWS-GAZETTE
Published Online October 1, 2002
Rising costs and delayed shipments of vaccines are causing more
problems for health officials in Vermilion County than in Champaign
County.
To say Vermilion County Health Director Steve Laker is upset about
the rising costs of vaccines and this year's staggered dose arrival
would be an understatement.
Laker, whose department is waiting on a shipment before flu
vaccination clinics can resume, questions whether there is a genuine
vaccine shortage or a plan by greedy suppliers to force prices higher.
He also isn't sure how much longer his department can continue to give
the shots.
“I don't believe there is any shortage of vaccine anywhere,” said
Laker, who instead of getting his full order of 6,500 doses of flu
vaccine received only 1,500, and now must wait through two more
shipments. “I am not very happy about that. I'm frustrated and
expressing some big dissatisfaction.”
In Champaign County, flu vaccinations are not a problem because of
smaller demand. Even though Champaign County's population is three times
that of Vermilion County, it ordered half as many doses.
“We are fortunate that most people who need flu shots receive them
through private providers,” said Dave King, the administrator of the
Champaign-Urbana Public Health District/Champaign County Public Health
Department. “We don't give a high percentage of shots like some
communities where their health department is one of the biggest outlets.
We have pretty good coverage here with Carle and Christie clinics.”
In Vermilion County, the health department kicked off its flu
vaccination season Friday at Vermilion Manor. More than 200 people were
served in the first hour, said Lynn Galloway, county health services
director. A second flu clinic was conducted Monday at the health
department.
Now, the vaccination schedule takes a three-week hiatus while the
health department waits for a 2,500-dose shipment on Oct. 11. Another
2,500 doses should arrive in November, but no date was given to the
county.
Laker said he began seeing a disturbing pattern in 2001, when
Pennsylvania-based vaccine supplier Aventis Pasteur Inc. increased its
price, resulting in a cost that was triple what it was three years ago.
In 1999, the vaccine cost $2.05 per dose. Now, it costs the county
$6.25 per dose, exclusive of administrative costs. Medicare reimburses
the county $8.56, based on a formula that allows for $4.92 in vaccine
and $3.64 in administrative costs per dose.
“I'm not sure that the prices aren't driven by greed and
opportunities to capture market share and seize opportunities to
permanently increase their prices and profits,” Laker said. “This
doesn't make any sense.”
Aventis-Pasteur officials did not return calls for comment.
Laker said the health department might have to terminate the public
vaccination program because Medicare reimbursement rates barely cover
costs.
In Vermilion County, each flu immunization costs $14, while pneumonia
shots cost $17 each. The extra charge per dose goes to pay part-time
employees who work at the vaccination sites during the program and are
not on the regular staff, Laker said.
In Champaign County, a flu immunization costs $6, while pneumonia
shots are $12.
Flu vaccinations were delayed last year by almost three weeks, and
the Vermilion County health department requested that people younger
than 60 without chronic illness wait until higher-risk patients were
served. Many opted to go another route, including major pharmacies such
as CVS, Osco Drug and Walgreen, Laker said.
“We ended up with 400 surplus doses of influenza vaccine,” he said.
“Many well people refused to defer their vaccinations, and they were
able to get them at large pharmacy outlets.”
Champaign County orders its vaccination shots from the same
purchasing consortium as Vermilion County, which is administered by the
Illinois Public Health Association. Champaign County will give its first
flu clinic Oct. 21 at its offices at 710 N. Neil St.
King said he has also seen the rising costs of vaccine suppliers and
doesn't believe in the notion of a shortage.
In July, Laker sent a letter to U.S. Rep. Tim Johnson, U.S. Sens.
Dick Durbin and Peter Fitzgerald, Illinois Department of Public Health
Director John Lumpkin and the Illinois Association of Public Health
Administrators. He has yet to receive personal contact from any senator
or congressman. Laker said he wrote the letter to express concern about
the inadequacies of the current federal reimbursements.
Vermilion County has provided annual influenza vaccinations to the
elderly and at-risk individuals since 1976, while receiving Medicare
reimbursements for the past seven years. Last year 5,973 people received
vaccinations, half of them eligible for free vaccinations through
Medicare.
Because of the shortage, the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention urge people at risk for influenza to seek immunization during
October and early November. High-risk candidates include those with
chronic illnesses, including heart or kidney diseases, asthma, diabetes,
cancer or HIV/AIDS. Healthy adults younger than 64 are encouraged to
wait until November, when the last shipment is expected.
“We are asking everyone to be patient with us and understand we will
get them immunized as soon as we are able, based on when the vaccine
arrives,” Galloway said.”We will let people know as soon as we are made
aware of the need for any changes in the schedule.”
Health departments recommend pregnant women seek out their health
care providers for immunization during the flu season.
Call 352-7961 for information on Champaign County's program and
431-2662 for more information about Vermilion County's.
Other stories appearing in the
online edition of Tuesday, October 1, 2002:

|