Vaccination NewsLetter: Top Stories - posted January 12-18, 2004
FREEDOM OF CHOICE IS NOT FREE
Vaccination News, A Non-Profit Corporation
All the News (includes Breaking News) - a running tab of everything posted on this website since October 29, 2003
Return to Vaccination News Home Page (for best results, right click to "open in new window")
View past & current Scandals (columns by Sandy Gottstein aka Mintz)
Subscribe to Scandals
Search This Site using keywords
click here to download Adobe Reader
Picks of the week - updated 1/18/04
The Newsletter is now linked to the new Hot Topics section here and to specific categories and sub-topics below
Alternative treatments/prevention
►January 18, 2004 - Millions in quest for 'miracle cures' - The Japan Times
►January 15, 2004 - Plant extracts found to fight deadly virus - Sansoke effective in lab tests, says lecturer - Bangkok Post
►January 15, 2004 - Try these 13 powerful foods (requires registration) - The Los Angeles Times via The Charlotte Observer - "Eating well starts with good planning. Dr. Steven Pratt says forget the obsession with carbs, protein and fat. Focus instead on micronutrients, which include vitamins, minerals and other powerful plant chemicals."
►January 15, 2004 - Echinacea juice: Cold aid in jar? - Knight Ridder via The Charlotte Observer
►January 2004 - Use of cough and cold products - (registration required) - This month’s column will review the use of these products in children and the published evidence of their efficacy. - Infectious Diseases in Children
►January 12, 2004 - Crackdown on GPs who tout bogus cures - www.smh.com.au
Comment: And when will there be a crackdown on the false claims of the drug companies and their merchants, the medical profession? Even they know their drugs often do not work, yet where is the outrage, the clamping down, over that? For a recent article on this, go to The drugs don't work.
►January 14, 2004 - Magazine
Bares All, Has Shop Covering Up Cover - The Santa Fe New Mexican - "Increasing
the number of women who nurse their babies is a goal of the U.S. government. But
pictures of breast-feeding, which is as old as humankind and strongly
recommended for infant health, is apparently offensive to some...After receiving
several complaints about the latest issue of Mothering magazine, which shows a
nursing mother and contented baby, the Vitamin Cottage on Cerrillos Road covered
the offending breast with paper."
Comment: This
kind of thing is a big part of what's wrong with health in America. And at
a vitamin shop, of all places.
►January 16, 2004 - Fish Oil for Mom May Prevent Allergies in Baby - Reuters Health via Yahoo!
►January 16, 2004 - Guinn: The nitty-gritty details of MSG - Carolina Morning News
►January 12, 2004 - The un-cola - The Globe and Mail - "Soft-drink purveyors say they will remove colas and other carbonated drinks from vending machines in Canadian elementary and middle schools by the start of the next school year. While insisting that all its products are suitable for kids -- a dubious claim at best -- the industry acknowledges that it is responding to increasing health concerns...It is obvious, though, that this voluntary action is designed to forestall the sweeping bans being imposed or considered by an increasing number of governments alarmed by soaring rates of childhood obesity."
Comment: Click here to learn about A Miracle in Wisconsin.
►January 12, 2004 - Taking vitamin D supplements lowers risk of multiple sclerosis - American Academy of Neurology via www.eurekalert.org
►January 17, 2004 - Puzzle of delay in exposing report - The Scotsman - "ONLY two weeks into new year, and the first significant health scare story of 2004 was shown to be seriously flawed in its scientific methodology...Just as the concern prompted by a study which claimed to "prove the link" between the MMR jab and autism was shown to be incorrect and a case of bad science, so the evidence of toxic contaminants in salmon has been shown to be seriously wanting...Minute scrutiny of the report, written in scientific language that tends to obfuscate rather than elucidate, was diverted. Thus everybody missed the final footnote of the article which revealed: 'This research was initiated and supported by the environmental division of the Pew Charitable Trusts', and questions that should have been asked about the organisation were not."
Comment: Would that they would apply the same high standards of scrutiny to the alleged proof that an MMR/autism link had been disproved.
►January 14, 2004 - Foregone conclusions - The public is being regularly deceived by the drug trials funded by pharmaceutical companies, loaded to generate the results they need - The Guardian, UK - "How then do companies usually manage to fund research that is favourable to them? An answer is supplied in a recent issue of the BMJ by Dave Sackett and Andy Oxman, two tireless campaigners for the better use of scientific evidence in medicine...The trick is in the question asked and the design of the trial."
Comment: And if you think none of this has anything to do with the validity of vaccine safety and effectiveness research.....
►January 13, 2004 -
The Medical Industry's Practice of Giving Gifts to Doctors - How Should the Law and Professional Regulations Address it? - FindLaw's Writ - "As part of their multi-billion dollar marketing efforts, many companies in the medical industry give gifts to doctors. They do so in order to gain a competitive edge: For the companies, doctors' choices are key. Nearly two-thirds of all patient visits in the United States end with the doctor writing a prescription. And for the medical industry, doctors' prescriptions control sales...Gifts to doctors may have negative effects."Comment: My guess, my opinion, is that that is a huge understatement.
►January 17, 2004 - Shooting up on hype - The chief executive has a chequered past. The biggest shareholder is elusive. Ben Hills investigates a company that claims it has found the Holy Grail. - The Sydney Morning Herald - "Alan Shortall plunges a hypodermic into an orange and injects it with one millilitre of water. He then carefully extracts it and releases the plunger, to demonstrate how the needle automatically retracts into the transparent barrel of the syringe and flips to one side so it can't be reused...'This is the Holy Grail of syringe technology,' he recites for the thousandth time, 'Of course, it's different when you are injecting a person, but you can see that it works. This is not a rort, this is not a scam, we are building a legitimate business.'
Comment: The irresponsible use of re-usable needles has done untold harm in developing nations. For more on this, go to Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals - update and "flashback")
►January 14, 2004 - Biotech's Babies: Doing Well by Doing Good - As Big Pharma pulls out of the low-margin vaccine business, upstart outfits are exploiting new technologies to tap niche markets - Business Week Online
►January 13, 2004 - Putting a Price on a Good Night's Sleep (requires registration or subscription) - The New York Times - "Americans are about to be reminded again how much they need sleep — and sleeping pills...A new effort appears to be developing to expand the use of sleeping pills, which because of their potential for abuse have long had a reputation as being in some ways more dangerous than the insomnia they are meant to treat."►January 13, 2004 - VaxGen gets big boost - Government gives firm $80.3 million anthrax contract - www.sfgate.com
►January 12, 2004 - Crackdown on GPs who tout bogus cures - www.smh.com.au
Comment: And when will there be a crackdown on the false claims of the drug companies and their merchants, the medical profession? Even they know their drugs often do not work, yet where is the outrage, the clamping down, over that? For a recent article on this, go to The drugs don't work.
Pharmaceutical industry/FDA oversight
►January 16, 2004 - FDA Sees Rebound In Approval Of Innovative Drugs In 2003 - FDA via www.intelihealth.com
►January 5, 2004 - Biological Products; Bacterial Vaccines and Toxoids; Implementation of Efficacy Review - FDA/HHS via the Federal Register Online via GPO Access
►January 14, 2004 - U.S. rethinking rules on importing bovine tissues - Abilene Reporter-News - "Now that the United States has mad-cow disease, federal regulators are reconsidering long-held policies aimed at prohibiting importation of products or ingredients with bovine tissue or blood from countries with documented cases of the illness...The products include vaccines, nutritional supplements and cosmetics, all of which can contain ingredients derived from cows."
Comment: Interesting dilemma. If the ban is continued, we now would be unable to use our own products (at least, theoretically).
►January 7, 2004 - The Political Economy of FDA Drug Review: Processing, Politics and Lessons for Policy - (requires registration) - Health Affairs www.medscape.com
►January 13, 2004 - FDA Advances Consumer Health and Safety in 2003 - PharmaLive - "At the heart of the Pharmaceutical Industry" - "The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today released a white paper highlighting some of FDA's priorities and major initiatives to protect and advance consumer health and safety in 2003, and describing how the agency intends to build on many of these initiatives in 2004...The major consumer achievements noted in the paper, "Protecting and Advancing Consumer Health and Safety," include efforts to: bolster consumer safety through major industry regulations and risk communications; combat new forms of terrorism and emerging diseases; crack down on false products and false claims; reduce preventable medical errors; speed access to safe and affordable medicines; and help consumers improve their health through better information and greater 'health literacy.'"
Conferences, workshops, seminars, courses
Diseases and their vaccines (current and in the pipeline)
►January 15, 2004 - Scientists warn big AIDS vaccine trial in Thailand will fail - AP via www.sfgate.com - "A massive human experiment testing an AIDS vaccine now underway in Thailand is bound to fail and the U.S. government is wasting $119 million funding it, 22 leading HIV researchers charged...The scientists allege the 16,000 Thai volunteers who are expected to receive a shot over the next two years will receive a cocktail made of two antiquated AIDS vaccines, each of which failed previous human tests."
►January 15, 2004 - Experts: Halt HIV Vaccine Trial - HealthDayNews via The Atlanta Journal-Constitution - "Continuing a U.S. government-sponsored, large-scale trial of an HIV vaccine in Thailand is throwing good money after bad, a team of leading experts claims...The U.S. government defends the trial, saying this combination has not been tested on humans before now and it should at least be attempted."
►January 15, 2004 - Clinton Gets Five Companies to Reduce the Cost of AIDS Tests (requires registration or subscription) - The New York Times - "Former President Bill Clinton announced yesterday that his foundation had negotiated deals with five major medical companies to steeply discount the price of two crucial diagnostic tests for H.I.V./AIDS in Africa and the Caribbean."
Comment: But what if HIV has nothing to do with AIDS, as many believe?
►January 2, 2004 - New York Data Reveal More New HIV Cases Are in Women - (requires registration) - Reuters via www.medscape.com
►January 14, 2004 - Conmen Cash in On HIV/Aids Scourge - The Herald (Harare) via www.allafrica.com - "'Diagnosed with Aids? Look no further, we have holy water and herbs that cure the virus and boost the immune system!...The increase in the number of people succumbing to the deadly HIV/Aids has resulted in an upsurge of 'miracle cures'."
►January 13, 2004 - Animal and human DNA link may give AIDS clue - The Sydney Morning Herald - "Human and animal DNA can combine naturally in a living body, a new study has shown...The dramatic discovery, in which pigs developed human and hybrid cells in their blood and organs, could help explain the origin of AIDS."
Comment: It's certainly looking more and more like using animal cell cultures for human drugs and biological products may have been a dangerously misguided venture. For more on their use go to Scandals: On "mad cows" and sick monkeys: From the people who brought you SV40 in vaccines.... Perhaps it's time to take seriously the notion that what we don't know can hurt us.
►January 12, 2004 - The blame game - The strategies for reducing HIV rates in Australia seemed to be working. But now, Jock Cheetham reports, the experts are wondering what went wrong. - The Sydney Morning Herald - "HIV rates are rising again after years of decline, dragging NSW into line with many other states and international trends. The AIDS Council of NSW is searching for the best response after years of safe sex messages that may have missed their targets."
Comment: But what if, as many believe, HIV has nothing to do with AIDS.
Comment: Again, what if, as so many believe, HIV has nothing do with AIDS?
►January 7, 2004 - Switching Off Plaque Genes Halts Alzheimer's Symptoms -www.betterhumans.com
Anthrax/anthrax vaccine/Gulf War Syndrome see also The Anthrax Vaccine Ruling
►January 15, 2004 - Ohio National Guard soldier again refuses anthrax vaccine - Mansfield News Journal - "An Ohio National Guard member again refused an anthrax vaccine Wednesday, an action that could trigger his court-martial or administrative discharge, his lawyer said...Spc. Kurt Hickman said he feels it’s illegal for the government to force his vaccination, lawyer Kenneth Levine said."
►Anthrax Vaccine is Dangerous - The following warning on the pending anthrax vaccine also recalls the hazards of aspartame, the artificial sweetener. Not coincidentally, the current U.S. Secretary Of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld, was the influential head of GD Searle, the pharmaceutical company that won FDA approval for aspartame after the FDA advisory committee had recommended AGAINST approval of aspartame –- also known as Nutrasweet™. - www.naturodoc.com
Comment: It is not clear that it is "not coincidentally". That is sheer speculation, in my opinion.
►January 14, 2004 - Veterans to lobby Govt on vaccine illness link - The Canberra Times, Australia - "Now out of the army, Mr Romer said he and others suffered from debilitating intestinal and skin conditions they believed were caused by the medication...'It scares the hell out of me,' he said...'I'm not there to sue them, I'm not that sort of a bloke. I just want something to be done over all this. Surely to God they can do something to help us.'"
►January 14, 2004 - Zimbabwe Suffers Anthrax Outbreak - www.voanews.com - "An outbreak of anthrax in Zimbabwe has killed three people and infected nearly 200 others. Health officials are struggling to deal with the outbreak."
►January 13, 2004 - Report blames Gulf War vet sickness on injections - ABC Local Radio program transcript via www.abc.net.au
►October 2003 - Lymphocytic vasculitis associated with the anthrax vaccine: case report and review of anthrax vaccination. - journal article (J Emerg Med)
►January 13, 2004 - Granville soldier still embroiled in anthrax dispute - The Newark Advocate - "As a battle over the safety of anthrax vaccines heats up, Spec. Kurt Hickman of Granville is left with few clues on how his refusal to take the vaccine will affect his military future...'I think it is only a matter of time before he is asked to take it again,' said Hickman's attorney Kenneth Levine. And if Hickman again refuses -- and Levine would expect him to -- he could face a second court martial hearing, this time by the Army."
►January 12, 2004 - Vaccine link to Gulf War syndrome - AFP via The Australian - "GULF War syndrome was probably caused by vaccines administered to soldiers before their departure to the region, according to a medical report whose findings are published in today's edition of The Times newspaper...The confidential report by senior army specialist Lieutenant Colonel Graham Howe, who examined a British soldier who suffered osteoporosis and depression after the Gulf War, found that 'secret' injections he received before his expected deployment to the Gulf 'most probably led to the development of autoimmune-induced osteoporosis'...The theory has extra credibility because the soldier in question, ex-Corporal Alex Izett, did not end up going to the Gulf. His regiment, based in Germany, was not deployed there."
►January 12, 2004 -
Official report links vaccine to Gulf War syndrome (requires registration or subscription) - www.timesonline.com - "For 13 years, the Ministry of Defence has denied that the vaccines , some of which were classified as “secret”, could be blamed for the wide range of debilitating diseases...A copy of the report, dated September 22, 2001, but never made public, has been handed to The Times by Mr Izett, who won a landmark ruling at a war pensions appeals tribunal in July last year which awarded him a 50 per cent disability pension. ..The MoD did not appeal against the ruling but maintained that the vaccines could not be the cause of any Gulf War syndrome of illnesses.Comment: How many secrets are we going to have to discover before realizing we have not been told the truth about vaccines? For a recent letter from a Congressman concerning a possible CDC cover-up, click here (pdf).
►January 13, 2004 - Troops' illness linked to vaccines - Herald Sun - "
VACCINES administered to Australian troops before their departure to the first war against Iraq may have caused long-term symptoms known as Gulf War Syndrome...A British medical report has found a link between a pre-deployment immunisation program and long-term medical problems...Australian Gulf War Veterans Association yesterday seized on the British report as evidence that Australian troops also suffered permanent side-effects from their vaccination program."►January 16, 2004 - Fish Oil for Mom May Prevent Allergies in Baby - Reuters Health via Yahoo!
►January 12, 2004 - Ethnicity may affect allergies in children with asthma - Puerto Rican and African-American children with asthma at risk for multiple allergies - American College of Chest Physicians via www.eurekalert.org
►January 11, 2004 - Finding may lead to better asthma treatment - Researchers have found a compound that blocks the production of excessive mucus, which could point the way to better treatments for asthma, chronic bronchitis, cystic fibrosis and other diseases. - AP via CNN
►January 18, 2004 - Children with disability at risk of victimisation - Sunday Herald, UK - "Children who suffer from conditions such as autism or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) could be wrongly caught up in the criminal justice system as a result of the Scottish Executive’s Anti-social Behaviour Bill...According to the proposed law, anti-social behaviour is anything that is likely to result in the alarm or distress of a third party, but the campaigners warn that certain repetitive or unusual behaviour by children with autism or ADHD could be misinterpreted to mean exactly this."
►January 18, 2004 - Autism rise may be a myth (requires subscription) - The Sunday Times, UK - "A leading medical team claims to have solved the mystery of Britain’s fourfold rise in cases of childhood autism — and it has nothing to do with the MMR ..."
►January 14, 2004 - Tall in the saddle - Disability is no barrier for determined young cowboy - Star-Telegram
►January 14, 2004 - Autism fears over disorder bill - A leading charity has claimed that a new law on anti-social behaviour could be used against autistic children - BBC
►January 12, 2004 -
Science getting to roots of autism - USA Today - "High on the list of priorities is finding the genes associated with autism. At the meeting, the private autism research alliance and the public National Institutes of Health announced a partnership to do just that. The NIH is contributing $2.5 million, and the alliance is contributing $2 million to start the project, which will help to link the work of 170 researchers around the world, Shih says."C
omment from Professor Jon Kabara, BS, MS, PhD (link to references): "A seductive notion, but not to the point. In research if you don't ask the right question you'll never get the right answer. If genetics were most important then why has autism gone from one in thousands to one in hundreds, maybe even one in less than a hundred? I don't think that the gene pool has changed that drastically to account for this pandemic rise in diagnoses. If medicine/government would look in the mirror, it might find that over and inappropriate vaccine/drug use could be the main problem. Parents with autistic children have enough to deal with without the burden of genetic guilt."►January 11, 2004 -
Autism's full spectrum - USA Today - "When researchers study autism today, they are studying a more broadly defined spectrum of disorders than was once recognized...People with autism spectrum disorders can be severely impaired — mute, retarded, caught up in a world of obsessive and seemingly meaningless behaviors — or they can be so intelligent and verbal that they appear merely quirky to an untrained observer."►January 17, 2004 - Tuna could soon carry mercury warning - Naples Daily News - "As the federal government mulls slapping a mercury advisory on tuna, Southwest Florida seafood retailers say some customers are concerned that the food they thought was healthy could be hurting them...Experts say there's cause for concern, particularly for pregnant women and young children."
►January 16, 2004 - Mercury: The Latest Green Scare Campaign - www.anxietycenter.com - "The Greens have mastered the ability to conjure up a scare campaign about almost anything to such perfection, one almost forgets that they are a lying bunch of lowlifes whose past lies have harmed the timber industry, those engaged in ranching and agriculture, those who provide the chemical building blocks of everything we use every day, and those responsible for providing the energy this nation requires to function."
►January 16, 2004 - Mercury Debate Hits JAMA - The Attack of the Bernards * The DanishRoll In a Response - Schafer Autism Report
►January 14, 2004 - Letter to Psychology Today re: Autism and Mercury - "Psychology is a science. There is nothing scientific about the paper spotlighted by your article."
►January 14, 2004 - Students tested for mercury on Sunday - The Record-Courier - "Investigators from the Center for Disease Control and Nevada Department of Health offered urine analyses over the weekend for students involved in the mercury contamination at Pau-Wa-Lu Middle School...'We'll keep cleaning until we reach 300 parts per trillion -- which is about the amount given off from dental fillings,' said Douglas County School District Superintendent John Soderman on Sunday...'The danger is being overplayed, most definitely,' said his half sister Carmen Daniels, who is visiting from Pine Grove, Calif...Ricky's father, Richard Padovani, disagreed...'You can't over react with something like this. Mercury is pretty dangerous.'"
Comment: Note that this is external exposure. Not ingested. Not injected.
►January 13, 2004 - Parents complain of inadequate answers after mercury contamination - Reno Gazette-Journal
►January 12, 2004 -
POISONOUS VAPORS: EPA cleaning up mercury spill - Levels of mercury inside house six times greater than what is considered safe - Las Vegas Review-Journal - "An Environmental Protection Agency emergency response team began cleaning up a liquid mercury spill Sunday at a house on Saylor Way where a 17-year-old boy inhaled the poisonous vapors...EPA officials spent Sunday trying to save the family's dog, Snowball, who was seriously sickened by the mercury exposure."Comment: Do not inhale. But feel free to inject? Right...
►Nov/Dec 2003 - Autism and Mercury- Psychology Today - "The spike in autism prevalence is apparently not linked to a kind of mercury once used in childhood vaccines, according to a study in the journal Pediatrics."
Comment: Repeat after me: "Studies bought and paid for, or influenced in any way, by vaccine manufacturers and those with financial ties to them, should not be accepted at face value." This study, published in Pediatrics, is no different. It has been widely and soundly criticized for its methodology, analysis and conclusions, including in this critique by Mark Blaxill of Safe Minds. When are the "experts", and the mainstream media reporting on them, going to stop buying the party line and start doing some real thinking? For more on the media, go to Scandals: Tiptoeing Through The Minefield of Possible Vaccine Reactions - Mainstream Media's Sins Of Omission
►January 13, 2004 - Autism and Mercury - Psychology Today - political action alert - rate this article
►November 2003 - Intestinal Lymphocyte Populations in Children with Regressive Autism: Evidence for Extensive Mucosal Immunopathology - by (among others) the now surprising adversaries, Simon H. Murch and Andrew J. Wakefield - journal article (Journal of Clinical Immunology)
Comment: For some of what has been written on the recent controversy between the two previously aligned doctors, click here.
►January 13, 2004 - New MMR jab scare - www.femail.co.uk - "Safety fears over MMR have been increased still further by a study which detected signs of a chronic viral infection in the bowels of children who became autistic after the jab...The virus - feared to come from the measles component of the injection - appears to have sparked an abnormal response of the immune system similar to that in patients with HIV...In October last year his former colleague Dr Simon Murch insisted that he had always supported the vaccine...However, he is a co-author with Dr Wakefield of the latest paper which concludes there is further evidence of a new form of bowel disease in children with 'regressive autism' - losing the power of speech and becoming autistic."
Comment: What's the deal with Dr. Murch?
►January 12, 2004 - Parents' anger over MMR threat to GPs - Leeds Today - "Doctors used to receive bonuses for achieving targets on vaccinating children with the triple measles, mumps and rubella jab...But now, a new policy set down by the Commission for Health Improvement (CHI), states that GPs will LOSE money if they fail to convince enough parents to have the inoculation."
►January 12, 2004 -
Fury as doctor denies MMR autism link (editorial) - The Ham & High - "A ROYAL Free doctor has provoked a storm of protest after defending the controversial MMR vaccine in the Ham&High...A flood of letters in response to last week’s article – including several from the USA – accused Professor Brent Taylor of bias in casting doubt on a link between an increase in autism and bowel disease with the Measles Mumps and Rubella vaccine."Autism therapies/education/medicine (including the cost of care)
►January 15, 2004 - Love of horses, children in woman’s blood - Sun Current - "Though Jodi Townsend may receive a state award this year, she feels rewarded almost daily watching young children ride horses on her ranch...Townsend, 33, operates Majestic Hills Ranch in southern Lakeville. The ranch functions as a place where children with special needs can ride horses as a form of therapy. Townsend and her team of volunteers have operated the ranch since 1997."
►January 15, 2004 - Room is ray of hope for brain-damaged kids - Adopting a therapy that originated in the Netherlands, Jackson Memorial Hospital unveils a new multisensory room to treat children with brain injuries. - The Miami Herald
►January 13, 2004 - Kids left hanging as program to treat autism shuts down - Operator blames switch of funding to counties - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
►January 9, 2004 -
Data show states return millions to feds instead of spending it on schools - www.signonsandiego.com►January 13, 2004 - No solid evidence links vaccines, autism - www.nwitimes.com - "I've been a physician for more than 30 years, and ever since I can remember, vaccines have been accused of causing a multitude of diseases such as diabetes and hepatitis. I continue to be amazed by the rapidity with which unfounded postulations spread and take on a life of their own. Yet, when objective studies using the best current scientific methods and data examine each claim, evidence has never been found to validate these assertions. It is important to realize that no single study has ever been perfect or irrefutable."
Comment: Including the many apparently designed to vindicate (as opposed to study objectively) vaccines. Were they designed to objectively study vaccines, they would have, just for starters, always included "never vaccinated" children as controls. For more on this go to e.g., Scandals: Thank You, Congressman Shays; Out of Control; Scandals: - Shoot First, Don't Ask Questions Later; Scandals: Infant Vaccine Deaths - But Who's Counting? (No news is NOT good news.); Scandals: Why We Won't Take No* For An Answer (*No relationship between MMR and autism)
Autoimmunity/autoimmune disease
Behavioral disorders, chronic disability
►January 18, 2004 - Children with disability at risk of victimisation - Sunday Herald, UK - "Children who suffer from conditions such as autism or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) could be wrongly caught up in the criminal justice system as a result of the Scottish Executive’s Anti-social Behaviour Bill...According to the proposed law, anti-social behaviour is anything that is likely to result in the alarm or distress of a third party, but the campaigners warn that certain repetitive or unusual behaviour by children with autism or ADHD could be misinterpreted to mean exactly this."
►January 6, 2004 - The symmetry of schizophrenia - (requires registration) - BioMedNet Magazine - High-resolution mapping of brain areas that are altered in schizophrenia has highlighted regions associated with language and personality. The results lend support to a theory that schizophrenia might be the evolutionary price we pay for language.
►January 14, 2004 - Can popping fish-oil pills stop this tantrum? - Since a compelling experiment was shown on the BBC's Child of Our Time last week, sales of Omega-3 supplements have rocketed. But, asks Ian Sample, are behavioural problems so easily solved? - The Guardian, UK
Bioterror-related, other than smallpox and anthrax
►January 15, 2004 - Mad cow as bioterrorism? - Scientists worry that US gov't classification of BSE prions as 'select agents' could hinder research - The Scientist
►January 14, 2004 - Bioterrorism procedures invoked when chickenpox case first appears as possible smallpox - The Casper Star-Tribune
►January 9, 2004 - New device can help defend against novel biological agents - Vanderbilt University via www.eurekalert.org
►January 17, 2004 - The real reason women smokers are at greater risk - The Globe and Mail - "Should cancer of the lung be added to the list of health risks women face just because they are women?...A study presented recently at the annual meeting of the Radiological Society of North America in Chicago showed that women who smoke are twice as likely to develop lung cancer as their male counterparts. As a risk factor for smokers, female gender appears to outweigh age and amount smoked. Some researchers point fingers at the female hormone estrogen, but there is strong evidence implicating a more likely culprit: the bottling up of emotions, particularly anger."
►January 14, 2004 - Cancer Deaths Falling in U.S., Annual Report Shows - Reuters Health via Yahoo!
►January 7, 2004 - Cancer at Record High in UK - (requires registration) - Reuters Health via www.medscape.com
►January 7, 2004 - National Survey Finds U.S. Public Enthusiastic About Cancer Screening - JAMA via www.intelihealth.com
►December 8, 2003 - A Step Past Chemotherapy - Cancer: The five-year survival rate for all cancers is 62 percent. Specially-targeted drugs hone in on cancer cells, leaving healthy cells untouched - Newsweek via MSNBC
►January 13, 2004 - Heart Study Prompts Call for Change (requires registration or subscription) - The New York Times - "A therapy that increases patients' survival rate to 4.7 percent from 1.5 percent may not sound like a breakthrough, but that is how an editorial in a medical journal last week described a new treatment to revive people whose hearts had suddenly stopped."
►January 12, 2004 - Many Latino children well on their way to diabetes, heart disease - USC studies show nine in 10 Latino pre-teens have at least one risk factorfor type 2 diabetes or cardiovascular disease - University of Southern California via www.eurekalert.org
►January 14, 2004 - Bioterrorism procedures invoked when chickenpox case first appears as possible smallpox - The Casper Star-Tribune
►January 12, 2004 - Many Latino children well on their way to diabetes, heart disease - USC studies show nine in 10 Latino pre-teens have at least one risk factorfor type 2 diabetes or cardiovascular disease - University of Southern California via www.eurekalert.org
►January 17, 2004 - 'This could be way worse than SARS' - A deadly avian flu in Vietnam raises fears that it will be transformed into an infectious human killer. - The Globe And Mail - "When a handful of people in Vietnam recently began dying of a flu spread by birds, it set off alarm bells in the offices of infectious-disease specialists around the world...Could this be the start of a global flu pandemic, just like the one that swept the planet after the First World War, killing between 20 million and 40 million people?"
►January 17, 2004 - Vaccine aims at flu, but shots miss target: Albany -- Inoculations give little protection, but worst of season seems to be over - www.timesunion.com
►January 15, 2004 - Is It a Cold, Influenza, or Pneumonia? - U.S. Pharmacist
►January 16, 2004 - Japan to introduce vaccinations against future bird flu epidemic - China View
►January 16, 2004 - Officials Puzzle Over Flu Deaths Among Children - Newhouse News Service - "A first-ever federal analysis of influenza-related deaths among children has surprised public health experts, who are trying to understand why nearly half of young victims had no underlying medical conditions...Also notable, experts said, is the flu's high toll on older children, who have more mature disease-fighting immune systems than infants and toddlers."
►January 15, 2004 - Study: Little or no value to flu vaccine - CNN
►January 14, 2004 - Bird flu 'may be worse than Sars' - Bird flu could be "worse than Sars", if it mutates so it can spread between humans, experts have warned. - BBC
►December 18, 2003 - Vaccine makers underestimated flu's potential - Knight Ridder via The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
►December 24, 2003 - Unapproved Flu Vaccine Peddled (requires subscription) - The New York Times
►December 23, 2003 - Flu research aims at precise vaccine - Scientists Seek To Speed Production - The Mercury News
►January 16, 2004 - Preliminary Assessment of the Effectiveness of the 2003-04 Inactivated Influenza Vaccine--Colorado, December 2003 - Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report via www.immunizationinfo.org (abstract) - "The results did not show much effect from the vaccine against ILI, such as cough or sore throat, but more specific studies will be needed to define how well the vaccine protects against ILI this season. CDC still encourages that the vaccine be used, especially for individuals at high risk for influenza related complications."
Comment: Continuing to recommend a vaccine that they admit probably does not work? What more proof do we need that the CDC is on the side of industry and not the consumer?
►January 15, 2004 - Killer Bird Flu Fuels Plague Fears - New Worldwide Flu May Be Brewing in Asia - WebMD Health
Comment: What did I say earlier about this being used to fuel hysteria about a possible flu pandemic?
►January 15, 2004 - Health Department will decline free FluMist vaccines - www.ljworld.com - "Counties and private health care providers can place orders for the vaccine through the Kansas Department of Health and Environment until noon Friday. But the Lawrence-Douglas County Health Department isn't trying to get a piece of the pie...'We have not requested any because of all the other providers in the community that have given the FluMist,' said Barbara Schnitker, the Health Department's director of nurses. 'We typically are concerned about access to vaccines and health care, and if something is being provided by another provider, we don't necessarily feel we need to offer it.'
►January 15, 2004 - State lifts vaccine restrictions - Fayetteville Online - "The state has lifted restrictions on flu vaccinations...Health departments no longer have to limit treatment to people meeting 'high-risk criteria,' said Sharon Stanley, a nursing supervisor with the Cumberland County Health Department. The decision was made Wednesday by the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services, she said...'We can use our supply for any age and for anybody that wants to have a flu shot,' she said."
►January 15, 2004 - Proper nutrition could help boost seniors' immunity to influenza - www.wistv.com - "Every year more than 30,000 people in the US die from influenza, and senior citizens could face the greatest risk. Researchers now say seniors can fight the flu just by eating right...Immune function declines as people get older, making it easier for viruses like the flu to put older people in the hospital. Some researchers have suggested a lack of essential nutrients as one possible reason for that drop in immunity."
►January 13, 2004 - Jane Seymour pioneers natural flu remedies - USA Today
►January 14, 2004 - Influenza on the decline in Illinois - www.qctimes.com - "The number of Illinoisans suffering with influenza is on the decline, state health officials said, but Iowa still is reporting 'widespread,' or the highest level, cases of the flu...Kevin Teale, the communications director for the Iowa Department of Public Health, said there still is concern about flu outbreaks across the state since students generally have not yet returned to college campuses from winter break...He said the health department plans to wait and see how those and other students fare over the next couple of weeks before deciding whether the state can be ranked in a lesser category."
►January 14, 2004 - Who: Bird Flu Not Moving Human to Human - AP via Yahoo!
►January 14, 2004 - Why is this year's flu so severe? - Leading expert offers insight in New England Journal of Medicine - University of Rochester Medical Center via www.eurekalert.org
Comment: I thought they hadn't decided whether or not this year's flu was more severe than other years. According to the New York Times article Flu Has Killed 93 Children, but Comparisons Are Difficult, "Influenza has killed 93 children since October, but there is no way to determine whether this season is more severe for children than earlier years, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said yesterday." According to the CDC, however, mathematical modeling predicted about 92 influenza related deaths each year for the period 1990-1999 just among children less than 5. Although not based on serological confirmation, it suggests that the recent numbers are still below what might be predicted or expected.
►January 15, 2004 - Vaccine Is Said to Fail to Protect Against Flu Strain (requires registration or subscription) - The New York Times - "A small study conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has found that this season's influenza vaccine failed to protect against the Fujian strain that has caused most cases...Depending on the way the data were analyzed, the vaccine protected zero to 14 percent of participants in the study, said a scientist briefed on the study who would not allow his name to be used...Officials of the centers said last night that they hoped that continuing studies to be completed in the spring would show that the vaccine offered more protection than this study indicated."
Comment: The CDC is to be congratulated for revealing the results of this small study. On the other hand, the "experts" who so cavalierly and eagerly recommended widespread use of this year's flu vaccine, in spite of there being plenty of reason to believe it would not protect against this season's strain, and no data in support of it doing so, have some 'splainin' to do.
►January 14, 2004 - Docs: Vaccines help even if they don't match flu strain - Times Record - "CDC Director Julie Gerberding said studies of the current vaccine's effectiveness are under way. Based on animal studies, she said, 'there does appear to be a good promise of cross-protection, but how much efficacy with this particular situation remains to be seen.'
Comment: So much for animal studies if the recent CDC study cited just below, showing failure of the flu vaccine to protect, holds up in later studies.
►January 2004 - Influenza continues steady march across U.S. - (registration required) - Influenza activity is highest in the western United States, and the CDC is expecting even more cases as the season progresses. - Infectious Diseases in Children
►January 2004 - Influenza 2004 - (registration required) - Early outbreaks, deaths in children, not enough vaccine — this is shaping up to be an interesting flu season. - Infectious Diseases in Children
►January 14, 2004 - Flu nasal spray vaccine to be available soon - - "The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has 250,000 doses of a nasal spray vaccine, some of which will be given to state health departments free."
Comment: Of course, nothing is "free". This vaccine will be paid for by the taxpayers.
►January 14, 2004 - Landrieu, Bayh announce plan to prevent future flu vaccine shortages - Leesville Leader - "As this flu season progressed into a deadly epidemic, Louisianians waited in long lines to receive vaccines in short supply...To prevent such future supply and demand problems, Sens. Mary Landrieu (D-La.) and Evan Bayh (D-Ind.) announced their proposed Flu Protection Act, which would prevent future shortages by providing a system for recommending the number of shots needed each year and for removing economic disincentives now facing vaccine manufacturers."
Comment: Those lucky dogs (the vaccine manufacturers). They are apparently making plenty on vaccines (see Healthy Defence). Unlike most markets, which are limited to those that need the drug, vaccines are targeted at entire populations, need them or not. So just think, the entire world universally getting an endless number of vaccines! They have their liability covered. They get to do the research that supports the use of their products and creates demand, and no one blinks an eye (or at least almost no one). The government and media collude in pushing their products. And now the government will guarantee sales. It's the dream business plan to end all dream business plans.
►January 12, 2004 - Bird
flu spreading in Asia -
www.promedmail.org - "The World Health Organization says an outbreak of bird
flu among chickens in Vietnam may be linked to the deaths of 10 people. The bird
flu has also sickened and killed thousands of chickens in South Korea and
Japan."
Comment: Is the media not getting its facts
straight, or is it WHO? (See
WHO Says
No Evidence of Bird Flu Jumping to Humans)
►January 12, 2004 - WHO Says No Evidence of Bird Flu Jumping to Humans - Reuters via Yahoo! - "The World Health Organization (news - web sites) (WHO) is waiting for tests on an outbreak of bird flu in Vietnam but said on Tuesday there was no evidence it was behind the deaths of 12 people who fell ill with influenza...'We're investigating any possible link. We have no evidence of the link at the moment,' Peter Cordingley, a spokesman for the WHO's Western Pacific headquarters in Manila, told Reuters."
►January 13, 2004 - FluMist Prices May Be Reduced - Winter Sales Were Lower Than Expected for MedImmune - Washington Post
Comment: What's the sound of one hand clapping?
►January 13, 2004 - VIETNAM: 10 Dead in Human Cases of Bird Flu (requires registration or subscription) - The New York Times
Comment: Will this be described as the likely beginning of a pandemic?
►January 12, 2004 - Increasing Flu Vaccine in High-Risk Children - Pediatrics via Ivanhoe - "A simple reminder call significantly increases the number of children with a high-risk medical condition who receive a flu vaccine, according to new research. The study used billing data to identify children with high-risk conditions and evaluated whether a phone call could increase the number of children with a high-risk condition who actually get the flu vaccine."
Comment: Whoa. That's a lot of vaccine to suddenly come up with.
Comment: What of suggestion, including from the CDC, that it may have already peaked in many places? And what if interest has also peaked?
Haemophilus Influenza/Hib Vaccine
Hepatitis A/hepatitis A vaccine
Hepatitis B/hepatitis B vaccine
►January 17, 2004 - Hepatitis sufferers win appeal and state redress - The Japan Times - "The Sapporo High Court ordered the government Friday to pay a combined 16.5 million yen to three people who said they contracted the hepatitis B virus in their childhood through then-mandatory vaccinations...Presiding Judge Kenji Yamazaki said in handing down the ruling that it is reasonable to believe the inoculations caused their infections. The ruling overturned a lower court ruling dismissing the claim...'The government naturally was able to predict the risk of such infections but failed to take preventive measures,' he said."
Comment: For more on the problem of infection via contaminated needles, go to Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals - update and "flashback")
►January 16, 2004 - China: Killer Inspires Drive Against Hepatitis Bias - Los Angeles Times via www.aegis.org - "Zhou Yichao, rejected for a public servant job in Jiaxing because he tested positive for hepatitis B, killed one official who denied his application and seriously wounded another. The plight of Zhou - now on death row - has inspired a national movement against discriminatory hiring practices and lack of legal redress...More than 120 million people in China - about 10 percent of the population - are chronic carriers of hepatitis B. Many, like Zhou, show no symptoms and should not pose a threat to co- workers. Hepatitis B is spread through the exchange of bodily fluids and cannot be contracted through casual contact such as shaking hands. Hepatitis B can lead to liver failure and death. More than a million people die from it every year, about a third of them Chinese...Hepatitis B is incurable but preventable with a vaccine."
Comment: For a different perspective on hepatitis B incidence and severity, go to Scandals: The CDC and “The New Math”, where 1 + 1 does not equal 2. To learn more about why hepatitis B has spread in developing nations, and why vaccination against it is an arguable strategy, go to Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals - update and "flashback").
►December 31, 2003 - Hepatitis B Rates on the Decline in U.S. - AP via The Herald-Sun - "Hepatitis B infections have declined by two-thirds in the United States in the past decade, reflecting the routine use of childhood vaccinations against the liver-attacking virus, the government said Wednesday...However, infections are still on the rise among adults, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said. Since 1999, hepatitis B cases have risen by 5 percent among men ages 20 to 39 and by 20 percent and 31 percent, respectively, for men and women 40 or older."
Comment: For another perspective on the incidence of hepatitis B, go to Scandals: The CDC and “The New Math”, where 1 + 1 does not equal 2
►January 16, 2004 - Gov't ordered to pay hepatitis B sufferers 16.5 mil. yen - Mainichi Daily News, Japan - "Three people who launched a damages suit against the government after becoming infected with hepatitis B following group immunizations were Thursday awarded 16.5 million yen in compensation...In a Sapporo High Court decision that altered an earlier district court ruling, the court accepted the causal relationship between the immunization of the victims and their contraction of the virus."
Comment: For more on the problem of infection via contaminated needles, go to Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals - update and "flashback")
►January 13, 2004 - Health bosses criticised over Hepatitis B - Health officials in Bristol have been criticised for their handling of an outbreak of Hepatitis B. - BBC - "The Health Protection Agency urged the city's primary care trusts to deal with an increase in cases of the liver disease in 2002...But it has been claimed that health managers in the city did not come up with the cash to tackle the outbreak for almost a year."
Comment: While it's fine and dandy to be concerned about hepatitis B, inflation of figures, using questionable and unreliable methodology to bolster the case for universal vaccination, is not. Nor is generally ignoring the fact that hepatitis B is mostly a lifestyle disease, or that much of its spread is due to improperly administrated vaccination and other injections, right. For more on this, go to Scandals: The CDC and “The New Math”, where 1 + 1 does not equal 2 and Scandals: "But Faith, fanatic Faith, once wedded fast To some dear falsehood, hugs it to the last." - Thomas Moore (Scandals - update and "flashback").
Hepatitis C/hepatitis C vaccine
IBD (inflammatory bowel disease)
►January 13, 2004 - New MMR jab scare - www.femail.co.uk - "Safety fears over MMR have been increased still further by a study which detected signs of a chronic viral infection in the bowels of children who became autistic after the jab...The virus - feared to come from the measles component of the injection - appears to have sparked an abnormal response of the immune system similar to that in patients with HIV...In October last year his former colleague Dr Simon Murch insisted that he had always supported the vaccine...However, he is a co-author with Dr Wakefield of the latest paper which concludes there is further evidence of a new form of bowel disease in children with 'regressive autism' - losing the power of speech and becoming autistic."
Comment: What's the deal with Dr. Murch?
Lyme disease/lyme disease vaccine
►January 17, 2004 - The Mad Cows Finally Come Home - Family Farm Defenders via www.infoshop.org
►January 16, 2004 - Action Needed To Prevent Spread Of vCJD - BMJ via www.intelihealth.com - "Dr Sheila Bird argues that the death of the first probable victim of vCJD from a blood transfusion means that steps must be taken to define the rights and responsibilities of those at risk, as well as the general public...Because there is no way of testing blood for vCJD, people who have received products that may be contaminated need to be managed as if the disease had been diagnosed."
Comment: If this assessment is correct, doesn't it imply that anyone who has had a blood transfusion should not be allowed to donate blood?►January 15, 2004 - Mad cow as bioterrorism? - Scientists worry that US gov't classification of BSE prions as 'select agents' could hinder research - The Scientist
►January 16, 2004 - Mad People Disease (opinion) - The Jewish Journal - "In the Torah’s story about Joseph, Pharaoh has a dream in which seven sickly cows consume seven healthy cows. Joseph interprets this, and Pharaoh’s other dream of seven withered ears of corn consuming seven full ears of corn, to indicate that there will be seven years of plenty in Egypt followed by seven years of severe famine...Today, we do not have a Pharaoh’s dreams to warn us of impending dangers, but we have a somewhat comparable situation in which cows with 'Mad Cow Disease' in England, Canada, the United States and other countries are having devastating effects on cattle industries in these countries."
►January 15, 2004 - NU professor advocates testing of all cows for mad cow disease - www.vidyya.com
►January 15, 2004 - Public Citizen Press Releases - 1. Mad Cow Disease an Accident Waiting to Happen; 2. Public Citizen Report Describes Some of Maryland's Dangerous Doctors as Physicians Gear Up for a March on Annapolis
►January 14, 2004 - Mad cow's untold story - Studies quietly raise questions about threat to humans - Rocky Mountain News - "from government and the cattle industry that mad cow disease poses no threat to public health, a small universe of scientists working on a family of related illnesses are finding disturbing evidence to the contrary...Several little-publicized studies, as well as ongoing research at a government laboratory in Montana, continue to spark questions about human susceptibility not only to mad cow, but to sister diseases such as chronic wasting disease that mainly affects deer and elk, and to scrapie, which infects sheep."
Comment: For more on the mad cow story, go to the Online Mad Cow Conference at www.redflagsdaily.com
►January 13, 2004 - Cow and A: What's the Chance of Finding a Mad Cow Burger on Your Plate? - Washington Post
►January 13, 2004 - An Ecodetective's Journey Into the Center of Neurodegenerative Disease - by RFD Columnist, Mark Purdey in the Online Mad Cow Disease Conference at www.redflagsdaily.com
►January 13, 2004 - Nonfood use of cow parts faces review - www.sacbee.com - "Now that the United States has mad cow disease, federal regulators are reconsidering long-held policies aimed at prohibiting importation of products or ingredients with bovine tissue or blood from countries with documented cases of the illness...The products include vaccines, nutritional supplements and cosmetics, all of which can contain ingredients derived from cows."
Comment: For more on the presence of bovine products in vaccines, go to Scandals: On "mad cows" and sick monkeys: From the people who brought you SV40 in vaccines....
►January 12, 2004 - Doctors don't refer possible cases of CJD - Human form of mad cow disease may go undetected until surveillance improves - Akron Beacon Journal
►January 12, 2004 - Serologicals Patents Process That Inactivates 'Mad Cow' Prions - Business Wire via http://money.iwon.com
►January 12, 2004 -
Guess what's coming in dinner - Mad cow disease scare, salmon warning have consumers wondering what on their plates is safe to eat - Tri-Valley Herald OnlineComment: As well they should. But what about showing the same concern for what is injected into their bodies?
Meningitis/meningitis vaccine/Prevnar/pneumonia/pneumococcal vaccine
►January 17, 2004 - Meningitis deaths unrelated, officials say - AP via www.thestate.com - "A high school student who died Jan. 9 was thought to have meningitis, but tests came back negative. Officials think the tests may have been affected by antibiotics given before a spinal tap was done."
Comment: How often do things like this happen?
►January 16, 2004 - Life-saving baby jabs running low - The Herald Sun - "THOUSANDS of newborn Australian children will miss out on shots against the deadly pneumococcal disease as a global vaccine shortage takes effect...Australian supplies of the Prevenar vaccine will not be fully restored until at least April, according to manufacturer Wyeth...The drug company has been forced to halt production of Prevenar at its US plant amid an upgrade to meet increased international demand."
►January 15, 2004 - Doctors giving MMR 'by stealth' - www.femail.co.uk - "Family doctors have been accused of administering the MMR jab by stealth to children coming into their surgeries to receive other vaccinations...At least 50 horrified parents have complained that their GPs have 'mistakenly' given their children the combined measles, mumps and rubella vaccine, it has emerged."
►January 12, 2004 - Taking vitamin D supplements lowers risk of multiple sclerosis - American Academy of Neurology via www.eurekalert.org
►January 13, 2004 - Scientists restore crucial myelin in brains of mice - University of Rochester Medical Center via www.eurekalert.org - "Scientists for the first time have restored a crucial substance known as myelin in a widespread area of an animal's brain, opening the door toward new ways to improve treatment of an assortment of "demyelinating" diseases as well as the side effects of such common conditions as high blood pressure and heart disease."
►January 12, 2004 - Possible Relief For Fibromyalgia Sufferers - Study Shows Mystery Of Disease Lies In Brain, Not Muscles - www.cbs2chicago.com - "'We have found out that in patients with fibromyalgia, norepinephrine and serotonin are reduced in these patients,' Dr. Cutler said...And that reduction -- in theory -- makes the body more sensitive to pain. That's why Dr. Cutler is investigating a drug that raises the levels of both neurotransmitters, hoping it can help those with the disease."
►January 11, 2004 - Researchers prevent spread of flesh-eating virus - www.israel21c.org
Other vaccines/vaccines in the pipeline
►January 15, 2004 - Researchers try to develop platypus disease vaccine - www.abc.net.au - "A new tourist and research venture in Tasmania's north is aiming to find a vaccine for a devastating disease killing platypuses."
Pneumonia/pneumococcal/Prevnar - see Meningitis/meningitis vaccine/Prevnar/pneumonia/pneumococcal vaccine
►January 18, 2004 - Nigerian state upholds ban on polio vaccinations - AP via The Times of India - "Officials of a heavily Islamic northern Nigerian state said Saturday they wouldn't lift a ban on polio immunizations, after local tests failed to assuage fundamentalists' fears that the doses contain ingredients to render Muslims infertile."
►January 17, 2004 - Fanatics declare war on vaccines - The Daily News - "Northern Nigeria has been swept by a wave of Islamic fundamentalism. Muslim clerics have been urging people not to take the polio vaccine, which they say makes girls sterile...They also allege that the vaccine is contaminated by HIV, all as par