Hot Topics - Legal/political - Laws/legislation/political - includes compensation/VICP
FREEDOM OF CHOICE IS NOT FREE
Vaccination News, A Non-Profit Corporation
All the News (includes Breaking News) - a running tab of everything posted on this website since October 29, 2003
Return to Vaccination News Home Page (for best results, right click to "open in new window")
View past & current Scandals (columns by Sandy Gottstein aka Mintz)
Subscribe to Scandals
Search This Site using keywords
click here to download Adobe Reader
The Topics: *Alternatives *Big pharma *Big trouble *Conferences *Conflict of interest *Diseases and their vaccines *Legal/political *Miscellaneous *Research *Vaccine-related issues
Legal/political - Laws/legislation/political - includes compensation/VICP
March 1-7, 2004
►March 3, 2004 -
House
debates malpractice bill (requires registration) - The Kansas City Star
►March 5, 2004 -
In Texas, Hire
a Lawyer, Forget About a Doctor? (requires registration or subscription) -
The New York Times - "As domestic security director for 16 north Texas counties,
Greg Dawson of Fort Worth has many dealings with doctors and hospitals,
preparing for a terrorism emergency he hopes will never come...So, Mr. Dawson
said, he was stunned this week to find that his name had been added to a
little-known Internet database for doctors attacking "litigious behavior." His
offense: filing a medical malpractice lawsuit against a Fort Worth hospital and
doctor over the death of his 39-year-old wife, whose brain tumor was missed, and
winning an undisclosed settlement."
►March 1, 2004 - Parents
Lobby to Ease Immunization Laws - St. Louis Post-Dispatch via
www.immunizationinfo.org
(abstract)
►March 4, 2004 - Changing
rules for the disabled - It is an uphill battle but parents and caregivers
are supporting the Bar Council’s ongoing signature campaign to end
discrimination against the learning disabled in the education system, writes
Pang Hin Yue. - http://thestar.com.my
►March 5, 2004 - Parents
furious as strike chiefs snub talks plea - The Scotsman
►March 5, 2004 - Safeguarding
science - A new government panel will attempt to prevent research data from
falling into the hands of terrorists - Newsday
►March 5, 2004 - Bill
seeks to broaden druggists' powers - Measure would let them administer flu
vaccine - The Baltimore Sun
►March 5, 2004 - House
committee votes to kill immunization bill - AP via Charleston Daily Mail -
"A bill that would have allowed parents to refuse to have their children
immunized for religious reasons was killed by a House subcommittee...A House
Health and Human Resources subcommittee voted 6-1 to postpone indefinitely
consideration of the proposal, preventing further legislative action on it this
year."
►March 4, 2004 -
U.S. Lawmakers Push for Drug Monitoring Systems - Reuters via Yahoo!
►March 4, 2004 - Minnesota Senate: Bill offering bounty for mercury advances - Pioneer Press via www.twincities.com
►March 4, 2004 - Immunization controversy: Should colleges require the bacterial meningitis vaccine? - The Stanford Daily - "'I don’t think it would be a good policy to require the vaccine,' said Dr. Ira Friedman, who works at Vaden. 'A vaccine should be required only when its benefits far outweigh its costs, in dollars and otherwise. This is not the case for the meningococcal vaccine. That’s why public health authorities support an educational approach.'”...However, other medical professionals disagree with Friedman’s opinions and claim that there is no significant reason not to get the meningitis vaccine. According to the CDC, the vaccine proves 85 to 90 percent effective against the most common strains,with rare side effects of mild redness or slight fever."
Comment: For a different take on the vaccine, go to Scandals: Another Unnecessary Vaccine? Here Comes the Hype for a New Meningitis Vaccine.
►March 4, 2004 -
Immunization
Exemption Debated in W.Va. House - The Intelligencer and Wheeling
News-Register - "Tucker pointed out West Virginia and Mississippi are the only
two states in the nation that do not have the possibility of such exemptions in
their immunization laws, but Mercer said he does not see that as a downside for
the state...'That does not mean we're the two backward (states). We're the two
forward ones,' Mercer said, adding that some states are looking at reversing
their exemptions."
►February 28, 2004 -
Genuine concern or corporate greed? - opinion- Broomfield Enterprise via The
Daily Camera - "Does Senate Bill
139 represent genuine concern or corporate greed? Follow the money...SB 139 will
set forth a statewide database of all Colorado's children. The system will be
used to call parents and coerce them to have their children "fully" vaccinated.
This means the child must have every single recommended vaccine...When I was a
child I only had two immunizations: polio and smallpox. These shots were for
serious diseases that affected large populations. I am truly grateful for
advances in modern medicine that have eradicated deadly diseases. Today, though,
Colorado's children are required to receive 29 vaccinations by the age of 4. The
risk of children contracting some of these diseases is miniscule."
►March 3, 2004 - Jacksonville Parents File Claim in Vaccine Court (includes video) - First Coast News - "'The cover-up from all this just drives me crazy.'...It's a massive cover-up, says Jacksonville mother Cindy Hartman. She's referring to the potentially damaging effects of a preservative once commonly used in childhood vaccinations. That preservative, thimerosal, is 49.6 percent mercury, one of the most toxic substances on the planet."
►March 3, 2004 - We fight on - Northwich Chronicle via Liverpool Daily Post via http://iccheshireonline.icnetwork.co.uk - "A FAMILY who have been fighting for answers for more than 30 years say they will never give up hope of getting justice for their daughter...Fred and Pat Pye, of King George Avenue, Northwich, claim their daughter Debbie was left severely disabled when she was given a DPT injection, a fore-runner of the MMR vaccine, in the late 1960s...Now the couple have taken their fight to the next level, writing to Conservative Party leader Michael Howard in a bid for justice for them and the other 500 families in the region who have found themselves in the same situation."
►March 2, 2004 -
Senate
Passes 2 New Bills On Vaccinations - Colleges Could Be Required To Give Info
On Meningitis - www.theiowachannel.com
►March 8, 2004 - Safety
reporting now in Senate's hands (opinion) - Congress should finish
what it started and pass medical error reporting legislation this year. -
www.ama-assn.org
►March 8, 2004 - Tort
reform for obstetricians fails in the Senate - A similar bill
targeting help to emergency physicians is likely to be offered next. -
www.ama-assn.org
February 23-29, 2004
►February 27, 2004 -
Frist to Bring Up Asbestos Bill by April - Reuters via Yahoo! - "Senate
Republican Leader Bill Frist said on Friday that "good progress" had been made
on a bill to reform the asbestos litigation system, and he planned to bring
legislation to the Senate floor by the end of March or the first week of
April...Frist has been trying to jump-start stalled legislation to end asbestos
lawsuits and replace them with a victims' fund supported by asbestos companies
and insurers."
►February 29, 2004 -
The Mercury Threat: Too Dangerous to Wait (requires registration or
subscription) - letter - The New York Times - "Mercury's harm to fetal and child
development is well documented."
Comment: Indeed.
►February 23, 2004 - UK reviews approach to GM (requires registration or subscription) - BioMedNet
►February 22, 2004 - FDA, States at Odds Over Drugs - Minnesota Web Site Points Way to Canadian Pharmacies (requires registration) - Washington Post
►February 24, 2004 - Frist says Democrats threaten class action bill - Reuters via Forbes
►February 19, 2004 - Bush Administration Distorting Science? - Transcripts of Paula Zahn Now - CNN
►February 25, 2004 - Senate set to allow exemption from school shots - AP via Charleston Daily Mail
►February 27, 2004 - Commission urged to take aim at mercury - www.edie.net
►February 26, 2004 - Bill banning mercury dental fillings fails - Executive director of the Alabama Dental Association calls legislation 'inappropriate' (requires registration) - Mobile Register via www.al.com
►February 25, 2004 - County
Officials Want Help With Hospital Laws (requires registration or
subscription) - L.A. County and O.C. supervisors ask the governor for legal
waivers and repair funds if facilities lag in nursing ratios and safety. - Los
Angeles Times
►February 26, 2004 - House
approves patients' rights bill - 'Taylor's law' allows testimony before
disciplinary board - The Boston Globe
►February 27, 2004 - Survey
Finds Confusion on Medicare Drug Law (requires registration or subscription)
- Kaiser poll reveals that few seniors understand the new prescription benefits
plan. Education efforts are in the works. - Los Angeles Times
►February 26, 2004 -
EPA
rules on mercury responsible - guest column - The Atlanta
Journal-Constitution
►February 26, 2004 - Schools send hundreds home for lack of shots - Multnomah County districts turn away students missing vaccines for diseases from mumps to chickenpox - The Oregonian via www.oregonlive.com
►February 26, 2004 - Vaccine Program Remedies Must Be Exhausted Before Filing Suit - The Legal Intelligencer via www.law.com - "A couple whose son suffers from autism because of an alleged adverse reaction to thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative once present in vaccines for newborns, may not file suit in Pennsylvania against a group of pharmaceutical companies until they exhaust administrative remedies available through the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, the Pennsylvania Superior Court has ruled...According to the Superior Court opinion, the federal Vaccine Act of 1986 requires that before commencing any state or federal claims, vaccine claimants must first file a petition with the "no-fault" compensation program, a special tribunal of the Federal Court of Claims known as the Vaccine Court and located in Bethesda, Md."
►February 23, 2004 - Michigan targets mercury Initiative aims to cut exposure to neurotoxin (requires registration) - Bay City Times via www.mlive.com
►February 24, 2004 - Mercury plan falls short, say activists - Coalition from Ohio, other states to tell EPA proposal may do harm - Akron Beacon Journal via www.ohio.com
►February 26, 2004 - Bush Plan to Cut Mercury Emissions 'Dangerously Inadequate,' Environmental Activists say - Voice of America
►February 26, 2004 - Bush plan for mercury lambasted - Critics say the proposal would actually weaken control over industry (requires registration) - Charlotte Observer
►February 26, 2004 - Immunization bill passes Senate - AP via Charleston Daily Mail - "Senators passed a bill that would expand mandatory immunizations for public school students while for the first time allowing them to decline shots for religious reasons."
Comment: It is not clear from this whether or not the ambiguous wording in the bill re: homeschoolers (i.e., can they be charged with a misdemeanor and fined for not vaccinating?) has been dealt with.
►February 25, 2004 - Indian Experts Urge Political Parties to Make Health a Fundamental Right - One World South Asia via www.oneworld.net
►February 24, 2004 -Medical Malpractice Bill Fails To Clear Hurdle - Critics Say Bill Is Bailout For Insurance Companies - www.ksat.com - "Senate Republicans failed Tuesday in their latest effort to limit medical malpractice awards...They fell 12 votes short of the number needed to force the Senate to consider the bill, which would have capped malpractice awards against obstetricians and gynecologists...But Democrats say the bill is a bailout for insurance companies who have made bad investments and that a cap on damages doesn't lead to lower insurance premiums. They called the bill an election-year ploy, arguing that capping damages has no impact on insurance costs."
►February 24, 2004 - What do you think of setting limits on malpractice awards? - online poll - www.ksat.com
►February 23, 2004 - West Virginians for Vaccination Exemption Demands Amendments to SB439 - PRNewswire via http://interestalert.com
February 16-22, 2004
►February 2004 - US Code-Vaccine Laws, Injury Codes, Case Info - Health Hippo
►February 17, 2004 - CDC granted $250 million appropriation to improve aging labs - AP via Ledger-Enquirer - "The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has been granted $250 million from Congress to improve its aging buildings and labs, it was announced Tuesday...'We are extremely proud of what we have been able to accomplish thus far at CDC, but ... our work is not done,' said Phil Jacobs, co-chairman of the Friends of the CDC and president of Georgia operations for BellSouth. 'We will not rest until we see the full $1.4 billion program completely funded.'"
►February 17, 2004 - Parents reroute efforts to get their son's test - A Lecanto teacher says she and her husband dropped their FCAT lawsuit but will work to reform state law. - St. Petersburg Times - "In October, Castillo and her husband, Joseph, who live in Brooksville, filed a legal action seeking the release of her son's results on the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test. Since her son Jordan is autistic and children with autism have trouble with language, Castillo argued that in order to help her son improve his score, she needed to know what he was asked and how he answered...A month after the lawsuit was filed, Department of Education officials told the Castillos that the department would not release the test and that, if the Castillos didn't drop their lawsuit by this week, they could be ordered to pay the state's legal fees."
►February 23, 2004 - States boosting doctor oversight - A New Jersey bill aims to bring quicker reviews of complaints against physicians; a South Dakota bill toughens discipline standards. - www.ama-assn.org
►February 23, 2004 - Tort
reform wouldn't dent health spending -- CBO report - Changes should focus on
fairness to both patients and physicians, the study concludes. -
www.ama-assn.org
►February 23, 2004 - Revisiting
the crisis in Nevada: Tort reform in need of reform - Doctors hope passage
of a fall ballot initiative will improve practice conditions. Trial lawyers say
it would only make the situation worse. -
www.ama-assn.org
February 9-15, 2004
February 14, 2004 - Doctor immunity key to secrecy - The West Australian - "THE State's Deputy Coroner wants doctors and other health professionals to be shielded from legal action in a bid to ensure all information is gathered during the investigation of unexpected deaths...Evelyn Vicker said doctors would be more inclined to reveal vital information if they didn't fear being sued. Ending secrecy also would help to restore public confidence in the health system."
►February 12, 2004 - Orange City senator offers bill to ban immunizations containing mercury-based preservatives (requires subscription) - Sioux City Journal
►February 11, 2004 - Obesity Immunity Bill - AP via www.wtol.com - "Lawmakers on Wednesday recommended passage of a bill to protect burger joints and other food suppliers from lawsuits filed by people who claim they got fat eating the companies' products."
►February 9, 2004 - When Judges Play Doctor - Wall Street Journal via www.immunizationinfo.org (abstract) - "Paul A. Offit, the chief of infectious diseases at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and professor of pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, says in an editorial in the Wall Street Journal that the spate of lawsuits filed by parents that allege their children's medical problems were caused by the vaccine preservative thimerosal could lead to judges and juries deciding whether the mercury-based preservative actually caused harm, taking that decision away from researchers who could prove or disprove the idea using science."
Comment: Sometimes judges are forced to play doctor when the doctor doesn't abide by the "first, do no harm" first principle.
January 26 - February 8, 2004 (2 weeks combined due to illness)
►February 7, 2004 - State Lawmakers Tackle Mercury Pollution - www.wbbm780.com - "May says the bill would ban the sale of mercury thermostats, switches, and relays. It would also require manufacturers to notify the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency of mercury-added products sold...The state is also expected to require power plants and factories to limit their mercury emissions."
►January 28 - February 3, 2004 - A Violation of Rights (Reflections & Observations) - Santa Monica Mirror - "The thing about experts is that they often disagree with each other, and, on the fluoride question, there are experts who allege that fluoride is toxic, as well as experts who allege that it’s safe...We don’t know how many residents want fluoride in their water, and we don’t think it matters, because this is not a question that can or should be decided for all of the people by some of the people. Nor do we know whether fluoride is good or bad for people, and we’re not sure anyone does. But we believe that every one of us has the right to choose what he or she will ingest, and we also believe that the government — city, county, state or federal — does not have the right to force-feed anything to people."
►February 6, 2004 - Legislation takes on medical secrecy - A case in which a doctor's addiction was kept secret spurs legal changes - Seattle PI - "When doctors make mistakes, they must report the errors to the state -- but they don't have to tell the patients or families who were harmed...That legally sanctioned secrecy has forced many families to file malpractice lawsuits in the hopes of learning what happened to their loved ones."
Comment: Doctors cry the blues when they are sued (perhaps sometimes unfairly), yet many insist on taking implied responsibility for all decisions, particularly when they do not want to give parents one of the most basic rights - i.e., the right to decide whether or not to accept vaccine or disease risks for your children. Some will even go so far as to refuse them further pediatric care, sometimes abandoning them at their time of greatest need. If doctors are unwilling to show even that most basic respect for their patients, they shouldn't be surprised when they and their mistakes are viewed harshly.
January 19-25, 2004
►January 22, 2004 - Compo warning over vaccines - The West Australian - "The Federal Government could face huge compensation claims if children get sick because their parents could not afford to pay for vaccinations, a consumer group has warned."
►January 19, 2004 - Mental health advocates fight for funds - Daily Press (Newport News, Va.) via www.kentucky.com
►January 21, 2004 - Groups to fight bill to limit class-action - The Hill - "A coalition of groups opposed to a Senate bill aimed at limiting class-action suits has stepped up its efforts to derail the legislation...The initiative comes despite an agreement reached late last year that won more than 60 Senate sponsors on behalf of the legislation."
January 12-18, 2004
►January 12, 2004 - The Power of Movements - www.oneworld.net - "Successful movements have internal leadership, a powerful voice for the perspectives of those most affected, and a strong people’s role in agenda setting and decision making. These are intrinsic components of what makes movements successful and their results sustainable...This is not to suggest that we do not develop new vaccines and other scientific solutions to some very serious development issues. Of course we should. But those “solutions” will work only in combination with social movement processes."
►January 19, 2004 - Litigation Could Make Vaccines Extinct - Congress must act--it has the legislative model in hand (requires registration) - The Scientist - "Vaccines have eradicated some killer diseases and protected against others. But they face eradication themselves--by litigation. As the United States rushes to defend itself against bioterrorism by developing vaccines against biological agents, Congress must pass legislation to ensure that vaccines themselves do not become extinct...All vaccines carry risks, including side effects such as encephalitis. For example, severe allergic reactions, such as breathing problems and shock, can occur in less than one in a million doses of diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis vaccine.1"
Comment: Why is it almost always assumed there is no good reason for these lawsuits? Perhaps there is ample reason to be concerned about vaccines. For instance, perhaps the incidence of vaccine adverse reactions is far higher than what is admitted to by the "experts". For more on the incidence of vaccine-associated adverse reactions go to Scandals: Avoidance Of Vaccine Truth But Not Consequences - Are We "Knee Deep in the Big Muddy"?
And what of the statistical methods to analyze the data? One commonly used tactic, using doses, as in the above example, skews the results whenever multi-dose vaccines are used. For instance, in the above example cited in The Scientist, given that children receive 4-5 DOSES of DPT vaccine, severe allergic reactions would then be thought to occur in at least one in 200,000 to 250,000 CHILDREN. If you factor in under-reporting, thought by even the FDA and at least one vaccine manufacturing company to be considerable, the numbers re: severe allergic reactions alone are not so reassuring and could be as frequent as 100/200,000 or 1 in 2,000 CHILDREN. For more on this go to Scandals: Contemporary Legends - How To Lie With Statistics I
►January 16, 2004 - Corporate CEOs Call Tort Costs a National Economic Problem - Insurance Journal - "The high cost of the U.S. tort system makes products more expensive for all Americans and inhibits investment that can create jobs. It is not an insurance industry problem, but a national economic problem, industry leaders told insurance executives attending the eighth annual Property/Casualty Joint Industry Forum, held this week in New York City."
►January 15, 2004 - Public Citizen Press Releases - 1. Mad Cow Disease an Accident Waiting to Happen; 2. Public Citizen Report Describes Some of Maryland's Dangerous Doctors as Physicians Gear Up for a March on Annapolis
►January 14, 2004 - Landrieu, Bayh announce plan to prevent future flu vaccine shortages - Leesville Leader - "As this flu season progressed into a deadly epidemic, Louisianians waited in long lines to receive vaccines in short supply...To prevent such future supply and demand problems, Sens. Mary Landrieu (D-La.) and Evan Bayh (D-Ind.) announced their proposed Flu Protection Act, which would prevent future shortages by providing a system for recommending the number of shots needed each year and for removing economic disincentives now facing vaccine manufacturers."
Comment: Those lucky dogs (the vaccine manufacturers). They are apparently making plenty on vaccines (see Healthy Defence). Unlike most markets, which are limited to those that need the drug, vaccines are targeted at entire populations, need them or not. So just think, the entire world universally getting an endless number of vaccines! They have their liability covered. They get to do the research that supports the use of their products and creates demand, and no one blinks an eye (or at least almost no one). The government and media collude in pushing their products. And now the government will guarantee sales. It's the dream business plan to end all dream business plans.
►January 18, 2004 - Children with disability at risk of victimisation - Sunday Herald, UK - "Children who suffer from conditions such as autism or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) could be wrongly caught up in the criminal justice system as a result of the Scottish Executive’s Anti-social Behaviour Bill...According to the proposed law, anti-social behaviour is anything that is likely to result in the alarm or distress of a third party, but the campaigners warn that certain repetitive or unusual behaviour by children with autism or ADHD could be misinterpreted to mean exactly this."
►January 14, 2004 - Autism fears over disorder bill - A leading charity has claimed that a new law on anti-social behaviour could be used against autistic children - BBC
►January 14, 2004 - High Court Won't Let States Out of Suits - The Washington Post - "The Supreme Court made it far more difficult Wednesday for state officials to renege on court-approved promises to improve such things as nursing home care, prison conditions or health services for the poor."
January 5-11, 2004
►January 8, 2004 - Pa. wants pledge from doctors - Physicians will have to stay in the state for a year in return for help in paying their Mcare assessment. - AP via The Philadelphia Inquirer
Comment: I should hope so.
►January 4, 2004 - A sampling of the 375 bills set for debate - www.centralmaine.com - "An Act to Ban the Sale of Novelties Containing Batteries with Mercury."
Comment: But inject mercury into the bodies of infants? No problemo.
►January 8, 2004 - New life for legislation to limit class-action lawsuits - Congress is inching closer to passing a bill that would limit class-action lawsuits and large damage awards against corporations, something big business has sought for years. - AP via CNN - "The legislation would move more class-action lawsuits -- where one person or a small group represents the interests of an entire class of people in court -- out of state courts and into federal courts. Opponents of the legislation say federal judges will either throw many of the cases out or be less likely to issue multimillion-dollar judgments against corporations...Senate Republicans and the corporate community, for whom curbing class-action lawsuits is a major priority, say the legislation is needed because businesses are drowning in lawsuits, many of them frivolous, while trial lawyers profit handsomely by sometimes just threatening legal action."
Comment: While some lawsuits may well be frivolous, many are not. Will this legislation result in the "baby being thrown out with the bath water"? For more on "frivolous lawsuit", go to Scandals: Senator Frist Frivolously Dismisses Vaccine Damage.
It's Federal Law! - You must give your patients current Vaccine Information Statements (VISs) - Immunization Action Coalition
December 29, 2003 - January 4, 2004
Dear Senator Frist...Vote Against the Frist/Gregg Vaccine Legislation and Give Them a Good Shot For Once (pdf) - National Autism Association (NAA) Ad #2
Comment: For more on Senator Frist's inappropriate use of the word "frivolous", go to Scandals: Senator Frist Frivolously Dismisses Vaccine Damage
►December 15, 2003 - Business, Bush Look for Lawsuit Limits in 2004 - Reuters
Return to Vaccination News Home Page (for best results, right click to "open in new window")
DISCLAIMER: All information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in consultation with your health care provider.