By Hannah Cleaver
BERLIN, Germany (Reuters Health) Sept 09 - The number of preschool children
in Berlin who receive some form of developmental therapy has been doubled by
poverty, poor education and unchallenging daycare, according to German
paediatricians.
The "medicalisation" of developmental problems is unfair to the health
service as well as to the children concerned, said Dr. Ulrich Fegeler
spokesman for the Berlin Association of Child and Youth Medicine in Germany.
In large German cities and across Europe, you would usually expect between
10% and 12% of children up to the age of 6 years to need therapy to develop or
enhance motor skills, speech skills or cognitive factors, Dr. Fegeler told
Reuters Health.
"But we are seeing up to 30% of children in Berlin undergoing these
therapies; and developmental difficulties that need to be treated are on the
rise," he continued. "This means up to 20% of the city's children are being
treated for developmental problems, which could have been avoided."
He said the effects of modern poverty and poor education are clearly seen
in children who sit in front of the television and who are given junk food,
instead of being mentally, emotionally and physically stimulated by their
families.
One of the main reasons such children end up in doctors' surgeries, he
suggested, is that the safety net of state childcare, which has previously
saved many children, is no longer capable of catching many of them.
"It is certain the pedagogic competence in families is not as good as it
used to be," he said. "We are living in different times and we have to adapt
to the patchwork family rather than two parents living together with their
children. But there is too much television being used as a substitute."
"The state kindergartens must be improved--if the families are getting
worse, the childcare institutions have to step in," he said. But when
childcare institutions have to deal with groups of up to 35 small children,
many of whom do not have German as a first language, little teaching can be
done.
Dr. Fegeler estimates that in Berlin alone there are 50,000 children who
need and receive therapy for developmental problems that stem from poverty,
poorly educated families and other social problems.
Concern about the problems of the German capital's youngest inhabitants
have been deepening over the last few months following education budget cuts
and the release of obesity figures showing that one in three Turkish children,
and one in eight German children in Berlin are seriously overweight.
"If now nearly every third child under school age has to undergo a kind of
therapy, something is wrong with the large preschool education system," Dr.
Fegeler said. "But the children are being sent to doctors. Medicine is a poor
crutch, a very bad substitute for a more stimulating and healthy childhood."