Florida would need to set up more than 300 temporary sites to vaccinate
the state's 16.4 million residents within 10 days of a massive terrorist
smallpox attack, state health officials say.
On Monday, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced a
nationwide plan under which it would provide 280 million doses of the
vaccine within a week of such an attack.
''It's very realistic,'' said Dr. John O. Agwunobi, secretary of the
Florida Department of Health. ``Given the political realities that exist, I
think we need to be prepared for a mass vaccination.''
Florida's plan would use state and local health department personnel and
possibly even National Guard troops to administer the vaccines in clinics,
schools and hospitals.
But some health experts criticized the plan as too big to be easily
implemented.
''The plan is well done, but I'm concerned that it relies on the states
to do the work,'' said Dr. Mohammed Akhter, executive director of the
American Public Health Association. ``States don't have the resources for
the massive job of vaccinating every man, woman and child.''
Agwunobi said Florida is well positioned to help implement such a plan.
``We already have the foundations of a program to vaccinate our
population, set up as part of our pandemic influenza plan. We're prepared
not for one specific infection, but for any one.''
Florida's plan will be coordinated by the state's already existing
disaster planning apparatus -- the seven Regional Domestic Security Task
Forces and their health subcommittees, Agwunobi said.
In South Florida, the health subcommittee is co-chaired by Dr. James J.
James, director of the Miami-Dade County Health Department and Wil Trower,
CEO of the North Broward Hospital District.
Each region will identify key vaccination sites and the resources to
staff them.
In Broward, for example, vaccination sites could be set up in the same
public schools that are used as hurricane shelters, says County Health
Department spokeswoman Ellen Feiler. National Guard troops could supplement
county health personnel, she said.
The Miami-Dade Health Department is awaiting state orders before
implementing its plan, a spokeswoman said.
On the national level, it remained unclear as to who would order such a
mass vaccination and under what conditions.
''The decision around mass vaccination would be dependent on the
particulars of the outbreak we were facing,'' said Dr. David Fleming, deputy
director for science of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
``We've got to develop the plans right now.''
But since smallpox was declared eradicated from the Earth in 1980, even
one new case might trigger alarm and a major response. Routine immunizations
in the United States ended in 1971, leaving most of the U.S. population with
little immunity.
Smallpox is particularly feared by experts because it's highly contagious
-- it can be spread by a cough -- and in its most lethal form, it can kill
one out of three people who contract it. But a massive attack is considered
unlikely as the virus is believed to exist only in government labs in
Washington and Moscow.
Still, a single new case ''would suggest the likelihood of other cases of
the highly contagious disease popping up and therefore suggest the need for
a fairly widespread control program,'' said Dr. Walter Orenstein, director
of the CDC's National Immunization Program.
''Once there is a case of smallpox, what has been theoretical up until
now suddenly becomes real,'' said Dr. Julie Gerberding, director of the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. ``We would anticipate many
Americans would want to have access to the vaccine.''
Deciding who gets the vaccine first is a contentious issue.
Akhter, of the American Public Health Association, proposes vaccinating
America's 11 million or so ''first responders'' -- medics, emergency
personnel, firefighters -- now. And he would start other vaccinations if a
terrorist threat is imminent, not waiting for an actual smallpox attack.
The CDC has not decided yet what position to take on this subject but
says it will decide soon.
The 48-page CDC vaccination plan released Monday offers specific
suggestions for implementation by state and local health departments,
including:
Medical consent forms and information for
distribution about smallpox and the side effects of the vaccine.
Details about how to store and prepare the
vaccine.
A list of places where security or crowd
control will be needed, including clinics and vaccine storage sites.
Types and numbers of workers needed per
clinic, including volunteers to run an informational video, nurses to give
the shots and translators to assist non-English speakers.
Criteria for choosing a vaccine clinic site
before a smallpox attack.
Guidance about who should not receive the
vaccine due to heightened risk of side effects.
This report was supplemented by Herald wire services.