DELHI (Reuters Health) Sept 10 - Zinc supplements do not reduce the severity
of pneumonia in children with measles, a multinational team of researchers
reports.
Zinc supplements have been shown to reduce the duration and severity of
acute and persistent diarrhea in children, the researchers write in the
September issue of the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. Dr. Dilip
Mahalanabis, from the Society for Applied Studies, Calcutta, India, and his
colleagues sought to study the effect of zinc supplementation in children with
measles accompanied by pneumonia.
The researchers conducted a randomized, placebo-controlled trial on 85
children admitted with measles and pneumonia. All of the children received
100,000 International Units of vitamin A orally on admission and a full course
of antibiotics. Forty-two children received 20 mg of oral zinc supplements
twice daily during the course of hospitalization, while the remaining 43 were
given placebo and served as controls.
Dr. Mahalanabis and colleagues observed that the time taken for clinical
improvement was similar in both the zinc-supplemented and control groups. The
time taken for regaining appetite, becoming afebrile, resolution of tachypnea
and clinical cure or "much-improved" status showed no significant differences
between the groups.
The serum zinc levels at the time of admission were low in 50% of children
in the zinc-supplemented group and 68% of controls, the researchers note. By
discharge, serum zinc levels rose to a similar degree in both groups.
Long-term zinc supplements have been shown to prevent pneumonia in children
in developing countries, the researchers explain. However, when given during
acute illness, there "probably is insufficient time" to produce a beneficial
effect on the immune system, they hypothesize.
"The study did not show a clinically worthwhile benefit from the
administration of zinc as an adjunct therapy in children with measles and
pneumonia," Dr. Mahalanabis and colleagues conclude.
Am J Clin Nutr 2002;76:604-607.