If
Smallpox Breaks Out: Questions and Answers on the U.S. Vaccination
Plan
outine
smallpox vaccinations were discontinued in the United States in
1972, and the disease was declared eradicated in 1980. But now,
faced with the possibility of a terrorist attack, the federal
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have adopted guidelines
for a mass vaccination in the event of an outbreak.
The vaccine carries some risk of serious complications. But the
C.D.C. says anyone who has definitely been exposed to the virus
should be vaccinated. For those not yet exposed, or uncertain
whether they were exposed, the picture would be more complicated.
Following are questions and answers about the governments plan.
THE RISKS
What are the complications? In the 1960s the rates of severe
side effects were about 12 cases of encephalitis and 39 cases of
severe eczema per million vaccinations. The death rate from
complications was about 1 per million. Milder but more common side
effects include fever, sore arms and swollen lymph nodes.
What if Ive already been vaccinated? It is not known how
long a childhood vaccination will protect an adult, so the C.D.C.
recommends vaccination for anyone who has definitely been exposed to
the virus, regardless of age or medical condition.
Should anyone avoid vaccination? Health officials say some
people should avoid the vaccine unless it is certain they have been
exposed to smallpox.
Children younger than 1 Infants have a greater risk of complications
from the vaccine. About 42 children out of a million will experience
brain swelling, which can lead to retardation or death. Small
children are also more likely to touch their vaccination sore and
then their eyes or mouth, causing new sores.
Pregnant women The risk from smallpox vaccine to the fetus is
relatively small, but health officials recommend that pregnant women
who have not been exposed to smallpox wait until after childbirth.
If they have been exposed, vaccination is recommended.
People with weakened immune systems When smallpox was declared
eradicated in 1980, little was known about immune-system problems,
but experience with other serious infections suggests that such
people will be more vulnerable, both to smallpox itself and to
severe side effects from the vaccine.
The C.D.C. says those who have not been exposed to smallpox should
think about not being vaccinated or waiting to be vaccinated until
you have completed any treatments that affect your immune system
function. The waiting period can be as long as three months.
People with skin conditions Vaccination creates a high risk for a
severe skin condition called eczema vaccinatum, which has been
compared to third-degree burns all over the body. People with a
history of eczema should not be vaccinated unless they know they
have been exposed to smallpox. Those with allergic reactions, severe
burns, impetigo and chicken pox should wait until the condition
clears up.
What precautions follow vaccination? The vaccinia virus in
the vaccine is a cousin of the smallpox virus. Studies suggest that
those who have been vaccinated rarely transmit it to anyone else.
But they should not let anyone especially children touch the
vaccination spot until it has healed and the scab has fallen off.
How are complications treated? Two treatments exist for severe
side effects: vaccinia immune globulin, which is derived from the
blood of donors vaccinated with smallpox vaccine, and cidofovir, an
antiviral drug marketed as Vistide. At the moment, there is only
enough globulin for about 600 patients, the number of serious
complications expected from vaccinating five million people. More is
being produced.
THE GOVERNMENTS PLAN
What would happen first? The C.D.C. is playing down the
possibility of a massive rush to vaccinate and anticipates providing
vaccine to state and local health officials to carry out their own
plans. But if a single case is confirmed we will act as if the
nation were under attack unless it clearly stems from a lab
accident, a C.D.C. doctor said. In an outbreak, the president could
declare a health emergency and take control of the vaccination
effort.
Would vaccination be mandatory? Under the new plan, vaccination
is voluntary even if someone has definitely been exposed to the
smallpox virus. But anyone who has been exposed and refuses
vaccination may be involuntarily quarantined for up to 18 days.
Must I consent to be vaccinated? Because all smallpox
vaccines are considered investigational new drugs, written consent
is required. The C.D.C. envisions showing all patients a video about
the disease, vaccination and side effects. Medical personnel will
then ask for a medical history to screen out those who should not be
immunized.
Is there enough vaccine? About 155 million vaccine doses are
available now, and enough for all 280 million Americans should be
ready by years end. The vaccine is not available through private
doctors, only through the C.D.C. The procedures for using such drugs
are complex, but would be streamlined in an emergency.
What are the logistics? Mass vaccination would require
enormous resources. Clinics would take over schools, warehouses,
stadiums. Huge numbers of workers would be needed to give
injections, screen patients, get consent forms and control crowds.
Isolated hospital wards would have to be set aside for smallpox
victims and those suffering complications, and to quarantine those
who refuse vaccinations.
What about the cost? The C.D.C. estimates $5 to $10 a
patient, but that covers only the screening and injection itself.
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"