14.09.2002
By MARTIN JOHNSTON health reporter
Health authorities are warning people against relying on homeopathic
"vaccines" to protect them from deadly meningococcal disease.
The Herald was able to buy homeopathic vaccines for that illness and
hepatitis B this week at a West Auckland pharmacy.
The homeopath at Lincoln Mall Pharmacy in Henderson sold two bottles
of liquid at $7.95 each.
They are to be taken in doses of up to four drops three times daily
for up to five days.
One is labelled "hepatitis b" and the other "meningo coccus [and]
meningitis vaccine".
The homeopath said the latter came from two sources.
The Herald's homeopathic inquiries coincided with a New Zealand
Medical Journal report on survey findings that just 35 per cent of
health shop staff referred a researcher with asthma symptoms to a doctor
whereas 92 per cent of pharmacy staff did so.
The director of the Health Ministry's meningococcal vaccine strategy,
Dr Jane O'Hallahan, said yesterday that the availability of homeopathic
vaccines concerned her.
"I think they could potentially mislead parents endeavouring to do
the best they can for their children.
"There's no evidence [in homeopathic vaccines] of anything active or
anything that could protect a child. I'm concerned that people are
getting a false sense of security and wasting their money."
But the ministry's compliance team leader, Peter Pratt, said
homeopathic liquids and tablets were permitted under the Medicines Act,
as long as they were sufficiently diluted.
The Lincoln Mall Pharmacy's homeopath, who asked not to be named,
said the homeopathic liquid labelled "meningitis vaccine" was derived
from a meningitis vaccine.
She said the liquids she sold to the Herald could help protect
against hepatitis B and meningococcal disease. "Sometimes they can work
to boost your immunity, but they will only boost it if they come across
it [the relevant virus or bacterium] because they [the homeopathic
substances] don't hold in the body for a great length of time.
"If that person doesn't resonate with that remedy, it doesn't always
work."
The pharmacy's manager said there appeared to have been a
misunderstanding. "It's the policy of the shop not to promote
homeopathic vaccines. There are no homeopathic vaccines as far as I'm
aware."
The shop was last night putting a disclaimer on homeopathic "vaccine"
bottles stating that they were not vaccines.
Australia's Therapeutic Goods Administration has issued a warning
against homeopathic meningococcal vaccines.
"We believe that if you call it a vaccine, the inference is that it's
a preventative," a spokeswoman said. "That's a health claim, so we are
going to crack down."
Bruce Barwell, president of the New Zealand Homoeopathic Society,
said those who supplied homeopathic vaccines should be "tarred and
feathered".