Doctors are planning an unprecedented clinical trial in which the smallpox
vaccine will be tested in a small number of children in two states,
federal health officials confirmed yesterday.
The idea is to establish vaccine dosages suitable for children in the
event that mass vaccination is needed because of a bioterrorist attack.
Tests, which will be conducted at Cincinnati's Children's Hospital Medical
Center and Harbor-UCLA Medical Center in Southern California, will mark
the first time the vaccine has ever been tested in children, using the
rigors of modern science.
Though doctors administered the vaccine successfully to children for two
centuries prior to the deadly disease's eradication in 1980, a formal
controlled clinical trial had not been performed even in 1960s, a period
well within the era of evidenced-based medicine.
Doctors involved in the design of the trial hope testing will begin before
the end of the year. Fewer than 50 children are expected to be entered
into the trial in both states.
"We're just waiting for the final word, to hear that it's a go. All of the
pieces seem to be in place," said Dr. David Bernstein, director of the
division of infectious diseases at Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical
Center. Bernstein will be the chief investigator of the study's Ohio arm.
He does not foresee trouble enrolling children into the trial and is in
discussion with Cincinnati pediatricians about the test. Because test
subjects must be closely monitored and wear special bandages after their
inoculation, neither site will accept enrollees from out of state.
"This is a good vaccine and millions of children have been safely
immunized with it," said Dr. Michael Lane, a smallpox expert now retired
from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Medical researchers plan to test the Dryvax vaccine, Bernstein said, which
was the same one used to eradicate smallpox in an aggressive global
campaign in the 1960s and '70s. It is also the same vaccine administered
in a nationwide adult clinical trial that began late last year. Findings
announced in March showed that Dryvax could be diluted and still maintain
its effectiveness.
"It's obvious that we should study this in children if we're going to use
it in children," Bernstein said. "Children are not small adults."
But Dryvax is not problem-free. Although doctors believe current medical
knowledge may make the vaccine's use safer, it is a live-virus vaccine
that has caused encephalitis and brain damage in some recipients. It also
carries a 1 in 1 million chance of death, a ratio worked out by Lane and
colleagues in a series of groundbreaking studies on the vaccine conducted
at the CDC in the 1960s.
Vaccine doses to be used in the pediatric trial are more than 40 years old
and are based on viral stocks that first were prepared by the New York
City Health Department at the turn of the 20th century. Dryvax, public
health officials say, is a mainstay in the National Pharmaceutical
Stockpile. The stockpile is the government's cache of medications,
vaccines and other supplies that are deployed in the event of an attack.
The stockpile is kept in several secret locations.
Dr. Carol Heilman of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Diseases, and one of the pediatric trial's designers, said researchers
will be seeking some of the same answers that were sought in the adult
study.
"We would like to know, for example, if a dilution [of the vaccine] can be
effectively administered and still have it maintain its potency," Heilman
said.
In the adult trial, lower strengths than would have been administered in
the 1950s or '60s proved powerful enough to generate a "take," evidence of
an immune response.
Heilman said there are still technical matters that must be resolved
before the trial can begin. For that reason, no one can set a starting
date, she said.
In addition, the trial's protocol is still under review by the National
Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. A core unresolved matter is
the age groups of children that will be sought.
Heilman noted that a number of ages have been suggested, but key protocol
administrators at the institute and the Food and Drug Administration have
yet to settle on a specific age group. The trial is to be jointly overseen
by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and the Food
and Drug Administration.
She said a separate study is being planned for elderly people and will be
designed to address problems associated with declining immunity. The
immune system weakens with age, and researchers will attempt to see which
dosages works best in older people.
Heilman added that the Institutional Review Board at Harbor-UCLA, a panel
that must approve human-subject testing, had some questions about risks
and benefits from the proposed pediatric trial, but is in favor of the
study. Dr. Joel Ward of the UCLA Center for Vaccine Research will lead the
investigation's California arm. He was out of the country yesterday and
unavailable for comment.
Dr. Jon Abramson, chief of pediatrics at Wake Forest University and
liaison to the CDC's national immunization committee, said the study is
vital.
"Can you imagine using any medication or vaccine and never studying how
you're going to use it? I could never make that leap of faith. Never
having studied it in a pediatric population is inconceivable."
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"