WASHINGTON -- Nearly 10 years after the film
Lorenzo's Oil profiled a couple's race to develop a treatment for their
desperately ill son comes the first scientific evidence that their remedy works.
The world's top expert on the rare degenerative
brain disorder that affects Lorenzo Odone has found that the oil invented by the
youth's parents staves off symptoms in boys who have not yet developed them.
This research has spurred the development of a
low-cost newborn screening test for adrenoleukodystrophy, or ALD, which is
passed from mother to son on the X chromosome.
''I think if I had a son (whose ALD symptoms had
not yet appeared), I would put him on it,'' Johns Hopkins University neurologist
Hugo Moser said after presenting his findings earlier this month before a packed
hotel ballroom here. ''Things have been publicized as treatments with much less
evidence.''
Moser cautions that Lorenzo's Oil isn't a cure,
but it at least delays the disease and allows boys to lead normal lives into
their 20s.
Oscar-nominated Lorenzo's Oil, starring
Nick Nolte and Susan Sarandon, depicted how scientists and some ALD parents were
skeptical that a pair of non-scientists, albeit highly intelligent ones, could
develop an effective treatment. Lorenzo's Oil is a combination of two fats
extracted from olive oil and rapeseed oil and is given orally.
''But now, all this is put to rest because of
the study,'' said Lorenzo's father, Augusto Odone, after Moser presented his
findings. Two weeks earlier, Moser had discussed his work at a symposium in
Ghent, Belgium. Ronald Wanders of the University of Amsterdam was there.
''It really looks quite convincing,'' says
Wanders, co-author of a 1999 study that helped dispel the notion that the oil
was effective in ALD boys whose brains were already abnormal. ''It's not the
final cure of the disease. That's obvious. But it at least gives additional time
to come up with alternative therapies.''
In Lorenzo's Oil, Peter Ustinov plays a
character based on Moser. At one point, Ustinov's character tells the Odones,
''I will have nothing to do with this oil.''
That's where the film and the facts diverge.
''The movie was a little bit unfair to him,''
Odone says of Moser. ''He knows ALD inside and out, and he's a very
compassionate person. Where other people said, 'This is Hollywood stuff,' Dr.
Moser always kept his mind open.''
As a youth, Moser left Austria to escape the Nazis; he joined the Hopkins
faculty in 1976. Now 78 and the director of the Neurogenetics Research Center at
Hopkins' Kennedy Krieger Institute in Baltimore, he has been trying to unravel
and defeat ALD for more than 40 years.
''He's really still obsessed with the idea to come up with a treatment for
ALD before his time is finished,'' Wanders says.
Moser's decade-long study, funded partly by the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration (news
-
web sites), involved 105 U.S. and European boys known to have inherited the
ALD gene. Symptoms usually don't appear until between the ages of 4 and 10.
The boys who entered Moser's study were 18 months to 6 years old and had
normal neurological examinations and brain MRIs.
To his surprise, Moser found that the boys who stuck to a strict regimen of
daily doses of Lorenzo's Oil and a very low-fat diet were, in a two- to
four-year follow-up, a third as likely to develop brain abnormalities as the
boys who did not adhere to the regimen.
Without mass screening, most boys with ALD would not be diagnosed until
symptoms appear -- too late for treatment with Lorenzo's Oil or for a bone
marrow transplant, another therapy that has had some success.
Neo Gen Screening, a company in Pittsburgh, received a National Institutes of
Health (news
-
web sites) grant in August to iron out the details of its screening test,
which it hopes to begin offering parents within the next six months. Because
newborns have never before been screened for ALD, company President Edwin Naylor
can only estimate that the disease is about as common in boys as phenylketonuria,
or PKU.
All states require that newborns be screened for PKU, leading to the
identification and care of several hundred affected babies each year.
Lorenzo cannot see or move
Sadly, none of these developments will benefit the young man whose parents'
love led to the invention of Lorenzo's Oil. Lorenzo Odone was not diagnosed
until he began acting out of character, moving awkwardly and losing his hearing.
He wasn't quite 7 years old.
Now 24, Lorenzo has survived years longer than doctors had predicted. He has
outlived his mother, Michaela, portrayed by Sarandon in the film. She died of
lung cancer in 2000. Augusto Odone, played by Nolte, attributes his son's
longevity to the eponymous oil he continues to take. That is more a father's
conviction than a scientifically proven fact.
Lorenzo survives, but he cannot see, talk or move. His father cares for him
at their suburban Virginia home with the help of nurses and Oumouri Hassane, a
young man the family befriended when they lived in the Comoros Islands off East
Africa. At the time, Odone, an economist, worked for the World Bank (news
-
web sites), and Lorenzo was an extremely bright child who could speak
several languages.
One need only meet Ramon and Maritza Casso's sons to understand the potential
of Lorenzo's Oil.
For the first eight years of his life, Juan Casso was a healthy, normal
child. Then one day he went blind. Soon, he could no longer walk. Finally, he
stopped talking. The relentless decline happened in a matter of months.
His frantic parents sought answers from top research centers. At Johns
Hopkins, they learned the awful truth: Juan had inherited ALD, and there was
nothing they could do to stop it.
As soon as Juan was diagnosed, his 6-month-old brother's blood was checked
for high levels of VLCFAs, the very long chain of fatty acids that signal the
presence of ALD. The Cassos were devastated to learn that they had twice lost
the genetic coin toss: Baby Jose also had inherited ALD.
''Oh, my God, my two children will be the same,'' their mother recalls
thinking. ''One in one bed, the other in another bed.''
Today, the brothers share a bedroom in their family's tidy third-floor walkup
apartment in Washington's Adams Morgan neighborhood. But the contrast between
the two boys is sharp.
Jose will turn 9 next month. By that age, Juan, now 16, was blind, mute and
bedridden, getting nourishment through a tube in his stomach. Jose, on the other
hand, is a bright, active fourth-grader. He's a computer whiz, speaks English
and Spanish fluently and hopes to find a cure for his brother someday. Oh, and
to be an astronaut.
There is no doubt in the Cassos' minds that the Odones' discovery has saved
Jose from his brother's fate. Juan took Lorenzo's Oil after he was diagnosed but
stopped when he continued to deteriorate. Jose began taking the pale yellow
concoction when he was 18 months old. That's the earliest experts feel it is
safe to do so. In addition, he follows the low-fat diet that goes hand in hand
with Lorenzo's Oil.
Jose likes chicken with rice and beans and doesn't miss the pizza and
hamburgers he's never had. When asked how Lorenzo's Oil tastes, Jose screws up
his face and exclaims, ''Bad!'' But he faithfully gulps 5 teaspoons of it every
day. If he doesn't, his parents have warned, he'll end up like Juan.
Moser is not so sure. He thinks there's no compelling reason to keep boys on
Lorenzo's Oil and the special diet indefinitely. If, like Jose, a boy has a
normal MRI at age 7, it's highly unlikely he'll develop the form of ALD that
manifests itself in childhood, Moser's research has found.
Studies have not shown a benefit from Lorenzo's Oil in boys older than 10 or
11, Moser says, and it's unrealistic to ask a teenager to stick with such a
restrictive diet.
The adult form
Moser is the first to acknowledge that Lorenzo's Oil is not a cure. The
treatment is highly effective at lowering blood levels of very long chain fatty
acids, or VLCFAs, which accumulate in the brains of boys with ALD, but it can't
cross the blood/brain barrier.
Unless researchers can find a treatment that prevents the accumulation of
VLCFAs in the brain, Moser says, boys taking Lorenzo's Oil eventually will go on
to develop the adult form of ALD.
''The adult disease is mild compared to the childhood disease, but it's a
very bad disease,'' he says. Still, Moser counts a judge, a CEO and a
psychiatrist among affected adults.
Moser's and Wanders' labs are studying another promising compound, called
4-phenylbutyrate, which at least temporarily lowers brain levels of VLCFAs in
the mouse version of ALD. They have not yet tested it in patients.
But what of Lorenzo and Juan and other ALD patients in whom the damage
already has been done? In ALD, the accumulation of fatty acids strips nerves of
their protective sheath, called myelin. Without myelin, impulses cannot travel
from one part of the body to another. Besides rare inherited disorders such as
ALD, acquired diseases such as multiple sclerosis can destroy myelin.
Toward the goal of restoring even a fraction of what his son has lost, Odone
founded the Myelin Project to support cutting-edge research into regrowing
myelin. So Odone, at 69 ever the charming Italian, is still raising money and
prodding scientists, although his only doctorate is an honorary one.
''We are pioneers,'' says Odone, who is president of the Myelin Project. ''We
want to put in some seed money. Then we'd like other, bigger organizations to
take over.''
With a grant from the Virginia-based Myelin Project, scientists at Yale
University have transplanted myelin-producing cells into the brains of three
patients with advanced multiple sclerosis.
A biopsy of the first patient, transplanted in July 2001, failed to find
signs of the cells, but Odone is not discouraged. That patient received only 1
million cells, a relative pittance, he explains.
Any day, Odone says, he expects to learn the biopsy results from the second
patient, who received 5 million cells in March. Even if none of those took,
Odone says, the two attempts at least showed that the procedure is safe. And
that, he says, would spur at least one other institution to consider trying it.
''It's like a long shot, but it's better a long shot than no shot at all,''
Odone says. ''All he needs is a little bit of myelin around the nerves. Who
knows? He might recoup some functions. If he could start talking, it would
change our life completely.''
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"