Reuters Health - For the first time, scientists have identified in people
with autism abnormalities in parts of the brain that are involved with language.
Autism, which impairs a person's ability to communicate and form
relationships with other people, usually begins within the first few years of
life. Autism may also affect the ability to respond to sights, sounds and touch.
Though some children with the disorder are mentally impaired, about one-third
are "high-functioning," meaning that they have a normal or near-normal IQ.
Several studies have found that people with autism tend to have
larger-than-average brains, but previous studies have not focused on brain
regions specifically involved in language.
Dr. Martha R. Herbert of Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston and
colleagues did just that, using MRI scans to view the brains of 16 boys with
autism and a "control" group of 15 boys who did not have the condition.
Although it is normal for a brain region to be larger on one side of the
brain than on the other (asymmetry), abnormalities in asymmetry have been
associated with language problems, Herbert told Reuters Health in an interview.
In autism, however, she said that the asymmetry has not been well studied in a
brain region called the cerebral cortex, which is involved in language.
"We found that there are abnormal shifts in asymmetry in the brains of the
autistic boys we studied," Herbert said.
In the language-related cortex, the asymmetry was reversed in autistic boys,
the researchers report in the November issue of the journal Annals of Neurology.
In boys without autism, this area was 17% larger on the left side, but it was
27% larger on the right side in autistic boys. Asymmetry was reversed to a
lesser extent in other parts of the brain, too.
"We don't really know" what causes these differences, Herbert said. "It
remains to be seen" whether the abnormalities are a cause of autism symptoms or
are a result of something else.
Herbert and her colleagues are continuing to look for abnormalities in other
parts of the brain, including the white matter that connects other parts of the
brain. The ultimate goal, she said, is to find a way to treat autism either by
catching it early or by preventing the brain changes.
SOURCE: Annals of Neurology 2002;52:588-596.
* * *
Cerebellar Abnormalities in Very Young with Williams Syndrome. 'Cerebellar
abnormalities in infants and toddlers with Williams syndrome.'
Jones W, Hesselink J, Courchesne E, Duncan T, Matsuda K, Bellugi U.
Laboratory for Cognitive Neuroscience, The Salk Institute for Biological
Studies, LaJolla, CA 92037, USA.
jones@crl.ucsd.edu
One commonly observed neuroanatomical abnormality in adults with Williams
syndrome is an enlarged cerebellum relative to a small cerebrum.
Our study is the first to examine neuroanatomy in young children with
Williams syndrome.
Clinical brain MRI was examined in nine young children with Williams syndrome
(mean age 21 months, range 7 to 43 months) relative to nine age- and sex-matched
normally developing control children (mean age 29 months, range 20 to 42
months), and two children with undiagnosed developmental disorders (6 and 41
months).
Two neuroradiologists who were blinded to participant classification,
hypotheses, and regions of interest for the study, sorted the brain scans into
two groups on the basis of six neuroanatomical criteria.
The raters placed more of the MR scans from children with Williams syndrome
into a separate group when they analyzed features of the cerebellum, but not
when they analyzed other brain regions.
Based on their written comments, the raters focused on the large size of the
cerebellum in the children with Williams syndrome.
The results lead us to suggest that abnormal cerebellar enlargement is
evident in those with Williams syndrome at an early age.
Our results are discussed relative to the cognitive delays observed in
Williams syndrome versus other disorders such as autism, leading us to suggest
that the cerebellum may play a role in cognition.
PMID: 12418794 [PubMed - in process]
* * *
Fluoxetine Response In Children With Autistic Spectrum Disorders: Correlation
with familial major affective disorder and intellectual achievement.
Department of Pediatrics, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710,
USA. Delon006@mc.duke.edu
One hundred and twenty-nine children, 2 to 8 years old, with idiopathic
autistic spectrum disorder diagnosed by standard instruments (Childhood Austim
Ratings Scale and Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule) were treated with
fluoxetine (0.15 to 0.5mg/kg) for 5 to 76 months (mean 32 to 36 months), with
discontinuation trials.
Response criteria are described.
Family histories were obtained using the family history method in repeated
interviews.
Fluoxetine response, family history of major affective disorder, and unusual
intellectual achievement, pretreatment language, and hyperlexia were used to
define a coherent subgroup of autistic spectrum disorder.
Statistical analyses were post hoc.
Of the children, 22 (17%) had an excellent response, 67 (52%) good, and 40
(31%) fair/poor.
Treatment age did not correlate with response.
Fluoxetine response correlated robustly with familial major affective
disorder and unusual intellectual achievement, and with hyperlexia in the child.
Family history of bipolar disorder and of unusual intellectual achievement
correlated strongly.
Five children developed bipolar disorder during follow-up.
Fluoxetine response, family history of major affective disorder (especially
bipolar), unusual achievement, and hyperlexia in the children appear to define a
homogeneous autistic subgroup.
Bipolar disorder, unusual intellectual achievement, and autistic spectrum
disorders cluster strongly in families and may share genetic determinants.
Parent Autism Research Advocacy Group Claims Co-Ownership of 'Danish' Study
NAAR response to Comments on Danish Study on MMR & Autism
[NAAR Issued a press release yesterday morning announcing the results of the
Danish study and their sponsorship of the research. NAAR's press release follows
this later release that addresses some of the criticisms raised by Safe Mind's
Sallie Bernard and others since the release of the study.]
The results of a Danish study focusing on the MMR vaccine and autism that
were reported in this weeks New England Journal of Medicine have caused
widespread discussion within the autism community and general public and NAAR
is fortunate that such interest in research exists in the autism community. This
excellent study, co-funded by the National Alliance for Autism Research (NAAR)
and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), reports no association
between the MMR vaccine and autism. However, some questions have been raised
that NAAR would like to address.
First, it has been stated that the Danish study is unable to specifically
analyze the relationship between the MMR vaccine and regressive autism in
children and the implication that may have on the validity of the studys
conclusions.
While the study did not focus exclusively on children with regressive autism,
it does suggest the MMR vaccine does not contribute to regressive autism. If
such a trend had emerged, it would have clearly been reflected in an overall
increase in the number of autism cases listed in the study therefore
increasing the relative risk. As the authors themselves have stated, this was
not the case.
The study does not support the hypothesis that the MMR vaccine is associated
with regressive autism, based on the relative risk stated in the study (.92),
which is calculated from findings that examine the number of children with
autism who received the vaccine and those with autism who did not.
In other words, if a link exists between regressive autism and the MMR
vaccine, the total number of cases of children with autism who received the
vaccine would be higher, especially based on the statistic that between 10-20%
of children with autism have the regressive form of the disorder. A
population-based study of this size (over 530,000 children) would have clearly
suggested such a trend.
It is also important to explain that the Danish study was designed
specifically and solely to investigate the alleged link between the MMR vaccine
and autism. One person noted the studys failure to include a thimerosal
component, based on a hypothesis that the MMR vaccine and thimerosal may be
associated with regressive autism.
Peer-reviewed research cannot and should not be refuted on the basis of
hypothesis. Whether there is a link between thimerosal, the MMR vaccine and
autism is a hypothesis that may merit additional research, but it does not
negate the validity of the studys conclusions.
While this study is the largest to date examining the MMR/autism issue, NO
ONE AFFILIATED WITH THE PROJECT - including the research team, the CDC or NAAR -
ever claimed it was the final word on autism and vaccines.
The study provides the most solid statistical evidence to date on whether the
MMR vaccine increases the risk for developing autism on a population basis.
However, additional investigations by the CDC and other government organizations
also focusing on the MMR vaccine and autism are currently taking place in the
U.S.
The collective results of these studies as well as the Danish study will
provide an even clearer picture on the MMR vaccine and autism, helping to
develop a more accurate understanding of this controversial issue and a
responsible public health policy. In addition, NAAR encourages additional
research to address the issue of potentially vulnerable subgroups of the
population.
NAAR continues to support additional research on potential environmental
factors and autism and invites researchers to submit proposals in this area for
consideration.
* * *
NAAR-funded Study Reports No Association Between Vaccine and Autism Results
of Danish Study Published in New England Journal of Medicine Nov. 7
A study funded by the National Alliance for Autism Research (NAAR) that will
be published in tomorrows edition of the New England Journal of Medicine
reports there is no association between the MMR (measles, mumps,
rubella) vaccine and autism. The registry-based study the largest study to
date investigating the MMR vaccine and autism focused on more than 530,000
children born in Denmark between 1991 and 1998, of whom approximately one-fifth
did not receive the MMR vaccination. Researchers at the Danish Epidemiology
Science Center at Aarhus University in Denmark found no increased risk for
developing autism among children who received the MMR vaccine as compared to
children who did not receive the vaccine.
The project, Risk Factors for Neurodevelopmental Disorders: MMR Vaccine &
Childhood Autism, utilizes Denmarks unique health registry data which is
among the most complete health information systems in the world. The system
tracks birth records, vaccination records and records indicating a diagnosis for
autism spectrum disorders.
The design and population size of this study are at the core of its
strength, which separates it from any previous studies focusing on MMR and
autism, said Andy Shih, Ph.D., NAARs director of Research & Programs. By
using Denmarks comprehensive health registry system, researchers were able to
take advantage of a very large population base and compare risk factors between
children who received the MMR vaccination, and those who did not. Many other
studies focusing on MMR and autism have not been able to make this type of
detailed comparison due to the limits of the health records involved with those
studies. The study also marks the first time a national parent-led autism
organization has funded a project on MMR and autism that was published in one of
the worlds most prestigious medical journals. NAAR and the Centers for Disease
Control & Prevention co-funded the study in 2001.
As an organization of family members of children and adults with autism,
NAAR is dedicated to seeking the truth regarding the cause or causes of autism
and funding the very best science available, said Karen London, NAAR co-founder
and a parent of a child with autism. This study provides us with perhaps the
most solid statistical evidence to date on whether the MMR vaccine increases the
risk for developing autism."
Additional studies are currently being conducted in the U.S. by the federal
government, including the Centers for Disease Control & Prevention. The
collective results from all these studies will provide an even clearer picture
on MMR and autism and help the research community and the general public to
develop a more accurate understanding of this controversial issue, said London.
While the Danish study provides strong evidence against the association
between the MMR vaccine and autism, Dr. Shih noted that more research is needed
to address the issue of whether smaller subgroups of the population are
vulnerable to the MMR vaccine.
The MMR issue remains one of the most intensely debated topics concerning
autism and has caused public health situations in some countries, he said. We
support research that investigates all theories surrounding potential causes of
autism, including whether there is a link between childhood vaccines and this
devastating disorder."
Immunology is an area of research that receives steady support from NAAR. In
2002 alone, NAAR invested more than $300,000 on three separate projects focusing
on immunology and autism, including an additional two-year grant to expand the
Danish study focusing on MMR and autism.
* * *
Who Funds Mostly Biomedical / Clinical Autism Research Today?
Yesterday, in a commentary entitled "Autism A Hit and Run Epidemic", the
SAR editor reported that the Autism Research Institute only funded autism
treatment-oriented research and not biomedical / Clinical Research into its
cause. Bernard Rimland of ARI assures us that they do invest in research on "the
cause, prevention and treatment of autism." The ARI currently funds such
research by Dr. Singh, Dr. Wakefield and others focusing on mercury found in the
gut and in brain tissue.
Mercury Not Addressed, Not Controlled, Not Irrelevant
Dr. Rimland also took the opportunity to comment on the controversial Danish
study, rejecting it as "another propaganda piece intended to assuage the
public's concerns rather than shed light on the MMR-Autism connection." He
continues:
"The report starts out by saying that it has been 'suggested' that there is a
connection between vaccination and autism, trivializing the substantial body of
clinical and laboratory evidence for such a connection. By saying 'it has been
suggested', it does not impress me with the objectivity of the authors. I was
also very disappointed to see that the authors failed to mention that the
mercury-containing Thimerosal is not included in the pediatric vaccines used in
Denmark. That is a crucial omission . . .it precludes their findings from being
considered applicable to the US population where the children's immune systems,
brains and gastrointestinal systems have been subjected to many times the
supposedly 'safe' level of mercury because of mercury-laden vaccines.
"The fact that the Danish study reports much lower (50%) prevalence rate for
autism in their country than the current US figures is a likely result of their
having banned Thimerosal from their vaccines, and reinforces the inapplicability
of their findings to the US population." Bernard Rimland, ARI
* * *
AWARENESS
Voices From Inside The Cage
The World Autism Congress is being held at the Melbourne Convention Centre
from November 10-14
[Claire Miller talks to the keynote speaker, Temple Grandin, who is herself
autistic.]
The family is sitting down to dinner at a restaurant, and my bloody mary has
just arrived on the table. My eight-year-old son Tom, having downed his
favourite drink - tomato juice - in one slurp, reaches out for my glass.
"No," I say. "You can't have that. It's a bloody mary. It's a grown-up
drink."
Tom's eyes widen. "Is that blood?" he asks.
"No, it's a drink called a bloody mary."
"Is that Mary's blood?"
"No, no. That's just its name. It's tomato juice with grown-up stuff in it.
Not for little boys."
And then, staring hard and voice rising with a note of panic, "Is Mary DEAD?"
I made a mental note to order a gin and tonic next time, and set about
getting Tom's mind off this track. Otherwise, we could be having this
conversation all night.My son is very literal; it comes with the territory of
being autistic. If the drink is called a bloody something, then it must be
blood, even if it looks like tomato juice. Tom will then follow the thought to
its logical conclusion. Autistic people are also very logical. Maybe that's one
reason they struggle making sense of a world where most people play by other
rules.
It is certainly how the world appears to Dr Temple Grandin, an associate
professor at Colorado State University. Profoundly autistic as a child, she has
had to learn what others seem to know intuitively: the unspoken language of the
body, the unwritten rules of social convention, the games people play.
In the company of humans, she says she often feels like an anthropologist on
Mars, as if she is trying to find a rapport with an alien species. It is this
voice from inside the cage that has made Grandin one of the best known and most
admired autistic people.
From the outside, the autistic mind seems like a shuttered window. Grandin's
gift is opening those shutters and articulating with extraordinary insight the
way the world appears from the inside looking out.
Grandin will be bringing that insight to Australia as one of the keynote
speakers at the inaugural World Autism Congress in Melbourne from November 10 to
14. The congress will bring together medical, educational and psychological
experts from 29 countries. They are studying the causes of autism, its treatment
and social context.
Conversations with myself
In the dark of night, I wonder if I worked too hard during the pregnancy. Or
was it his severe chickenpox at 15 months? Or those odd seizures at nine months?
Is there some rogue gene lurking in the family? Could we have done something to
prevent it? But torturing myself doesn't change anything. In the morning, I can
hear Tom laughing at the cartoons. He comes running in for a cuddle and, in the
light of day, not much else matters.Autism was first clinically described in the
1940s. Once considered rare, it is now a relatively common diagnosis. A recent
study found that 17 children a week in Australia are diagnosed. The rate matches
the disorder's international prevalence. This translates to about one in every
700 people, or about four times the level recognised 30 years ago.
One of the study's authors, Monash University's Dr Lawrence Bartak,
attributes the apparent increase to more accurate diagnosis. He says that in the
past, many people were wrongly diagnosed with mental retardation or illnesses
such as schizophrenia, while those with milder forms of autism - such as
Asperger's syndrome - were just regarded as somewhat eccentric.
The condition is also literally more visible. Once, disabled people of any
description were routinely institutionalised. Now, autistic children are in
mainstream schools and adults are living in the community.
Community integration policies have led to parents demanding more services,
and greater professional interest in researching causes and treatments.
It is a puzzling biological condition whose severity depends on the degree to
which the sensory perception circuits, by which humans make order of the world,
are jumbled or undeveloped. The symptoms are as individual as the individual,
but typically, autistic people have difficulty interacting socially and tend to
focus on details rather than the big picture in a given situation.
A genetic predisposition is strongly implicated. Autistic traits are often
seen among relatives - Grandin, for instance, describes her father as pedantic,
remote and socially inept - but no one knows what triggers the difference
between a distant eccentric and a person with full-blown autism.
There is speculation about environmental triggers, including controversial
research correlating the apparent rise in prevalence with the introduction of
triple antigen vaccinations in the early 1980s. Other theoretical triggers
include infant seizures, high fevers and the chemical residues now pervading the
environment.
And there is no cure, although appropriate therapy can make the difference
between institutionalised dependency and living a life with a job and friends, a
life like Temple Grandin's.
Conversations with specialists, part I
My husband and I are thrilled that four-year-old Tom is starting to talk.
Admittedly, he is mostly parroting what we say, but there seem to be a few
spontaneous words, suggesting a desire to communicate. The neurologist is
unimpressed.
"Monkey see, monkey do," he says, dismissing what we thought was a
significant breakthrough. We are unimpressed. So we shop around until we find a
specialist who sees things our way, one who is more interested in Tom's
strengths than his weaknesses, and who thinks a fixation with Thomas the Tank
Engine is perfectly normal for a little boy, not proof of a pathological
obsession. Grandin is deeply concerned about the proliferation of the autistic
label; she thinks it is potentially more of a handicap than the autism itself,
especially in mild cases where the line between normal variations in behaviour
and a disorder is blurred.
"Autism is serious enough to be called a real disorder," she says. "You are
talking about a kid with no language, totally bizarre behaviour,
(who) screams every time you go to the supermarket or anywhere, and rocks -
anybody will tell you there is something drastically wrong with the kid.
"But when you get into these really mild Asperger's, where it is just sort of
a... computer nerd? When you just start giving computer nerds a label that they
have a disorder? I mean you have to learn the social skills but one of the
things is you are not going to turn the computer person into a social animal."
She worries that a wellspring of ideas may be stifled because society places
a higher priority on sociability than creativity. And then where would we all
be? "Just think back to the caveman's days. The really social people, they would
have been yakking it up around the fire. It was the Asperger's guy that was off
in the corner figuring out how to make the first stone spear."
Conversations with specialists, part II
Dr Bartak is musing on the philosophical question of what constitutes
"normal". He doesn't see much wrong with someone if they are working or have
activities or hobbies they enjoy, and reasonable relationships with others.
"They may have started off as a kid with autism, now they are a normal adult
with autism," he says.
He says the autism continuum is analogous to intelligence. Just like some
people are brighter than others, the cut-off for what is considered abnormal is
arbitrary. "The one thing I always say to parents with this diagnosis is that
nine-tenths of the child is normal. He is not a walking bag of autism. There is
a person in there with an individual pattern of skills and personality."At
times, autism has made Temple Grandin's life painful, especially in social
situations where what is not said matters as much as what is. It was only seven
years ago, for example, that she read about people communicating with their
eyes, using subtle expressions such as rolling them. She had no idea that such
swift, silent messages even existed.
But she appreciates her autism for making her what she is: a highly
sought-after expert in the humane care and handling of livestock. She designs
handling yards and abattoirs to reduce animals' stress and suffering. Her
success lies in a deep empathy with animals - she says she can "feel" what
cattle feel in a way she cannot fathom in humans - and a computer-like mind that
thinks in pictures as if running a simulation. She accepts autism as the price
of her talents.
It is a long way from the toddler with no language, who spent her days
screaming, pulling away from her mother's loving embrace, and painting the walls
with her faeces. By the age of three, Grandin said it was obvious there was
something seriously wrong with her.
A family doctor told her mother to trust her instincts. So Grandin was
enrolled in a nursery school for emotionally disturbed children, where a speech
therapist set to work drawing her out. At home, a nanny was hired to play games
all day with Grandin and her sister, to stop her from tuning out.
Along the long path to emergence, she found mentors among teachers and
employers. They were creative people, Grandin says - a bit "Aspergerish"
themselves. They recognised her creativity and saw her fixations as strengths
that could be channelled into study and work.
"People accept talent," she says. "One of the things that helped me was when
I showed people my drawings (for livestock handling facilities), and people
respected that. People respect talent. You can be pretty darn weird, but if you
are really good at something, people don't care."
They are bickering. This is new. Until a couple of years ago, Tom just
followed Imogen's lead. Now they bicker about the computer, about toys, about
who is poking who in moments of idle provocation. It drives their parents mad,
but we repeat our mantra that anything normal is good - even the bad things. It
means Tom is learning the rules of social interaction and can hold his own. It
is another breakthrough. In her speech to the World Autism Congress, Grandin
will emphasise the need for early intervention, the need for mentors, and the
need for identifying and developing talents. And the importance of clear,
consistent rules - because autistic people live by the rules, whatever they
perceive them to be.
"The thing that worries me, especially since an autistic or Asperger's person
learns by logic, is we have got so many bad examples of bad behaviour out
there," says Grandin.
"When I was a little kid, there was very clear right and wrong. Superman
always went after bad guys. But now you have shows where things aren't so clear
and if you are a person who learns by logic, it wouldn't be too good to be
raised in an environment where you learn that crime really does pay. One thing I
tell parents is you need to have very clear-cut rules about teaching right and
wrong. You can't get into abstract stuff."
It is the abstract stuff that the autistic mind struggles to grasp. Like the
illogical behaviour of many so-called normal people. Take the meatworks
employee, for example, who kept sabotaging equipment Grandin had designed
because he was jealous of her talent. It took Grandin a long time to work out
why the machinery kept breaking down because suspicion, like jealousy, was an
alien concept.
"I am not a political person. I am a logical person. And basically I just
wish everybody in the world could just live together and not fight. But that
doesn't seem to be the way human beings are. You seem to get into all this lust
for power. My motivation is that I am what I think and do, and if I do good
things, then I'm good, and I want to do good things."
Conversations with Tom
"What do you want to be when you grow up?"
"I want to make trains! I want to be a train manager!"
On days like this, we know Tom is going to be fine. Different, yes, but just
fine.
* * *
Readers' Posts
Does anyone know of any school that caters to Autism in the Houston TX area?
If so, please email me at jcopado@utmb.edu
******
We live in Central New Jersey (not far from Princeton). We are looking for an
ABA instructor to work about 10 hours per week after school and on weekends.
Please reply to aeswidler@aol.com
******
Looking for a Tutor to join my son's ABA program. Learn State of the Art
Behavioral Intervention Therapy. Make a difference in the life of a Loving and
good natured child. Part-Time hours.Located in Elk Grove, CA., Just 15 minutes
from DownTown Sacramento. Call (916) 683-2461 0r ddwisdom@earthlink.net
******
Check out the new Holiday cards from Autism Resource Network in Minnesota at
A.I.M. is presenting a free presentation about SID in children with autism,
ADHD and Fragile X. All parents of children affected are welcome to attend. It
will be at 6:00 PM, Thur. 11/21/02 in the Community Room at Kroger's in the
Wal-Mart Plaza in St. Clairsville, OH. Questions please call Wilda 304-232-9499
or Kaye 740-695-5287
******
The Schafer Autism Report could use some volunteer help with some basic HTML
coding. Simple one or two page projects mostly having to do with forms and some
file conversion. schafer@sprynet.com
******
>> FREE (Almost) READERS' POSTS <<
For Individuals, organizations, non-commercial and
commercial. Limit your posting to no more than 60
words please. There is no charge for this service,
but posters are obligated to thank all those who take
the time to answer your ads. This is a consideration
for others with autism after you and yours, who seek
assistance from appreciated readers. Send submissions to:
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"