Sacramento - ASCRIBE NEWS via COMTEX - In response to a 1999 groundbreaking
study that found elevated peptides in children with either autism or mental
retardation, the University of California, Davis M.I.N.D. Institute is launching
the most comprehensive study of its kind to identify diagnostic markers for
children who are likely to develop autism.
"Being able to predict who might develop autism will have a enormous impact
on children with the neurodevelopmental disorder by allowing us to intervene
earlier with effective treatments or, hopefully, by preventing autism from
occurring," said David G. Amaral, research director of the UC Davis M.I.N.D.
Institute and principal investigator of the new study. "The 1999 study proved to
us that finding a biomarker is possible, and it is a top priority for the
M.I.N.D. Institute to identify it."
To conduct this important research, the M.I.N.D. Institute has entered into
an initial agreement with the Mountain View, Calif., company, SurroMed, Inc. to
analyze clinical samples from about 105 children -- about 70 with autism and the
remainder with typical development. Using SurroMed's advanced technologies for
profiling and analyzing thousands of immune cell populations, proteins and
low-molecular-weight organic molecules, such as sugars, peptides or lipids, in
small volumes of blood and/or other biological samples, SurroMed and the M.I.N.D.
Institute will be able to identify any unique properties present in the blood
chemistry of children with autism. The results of these studies will be a major
step toward the development of diagnostic tests.
"Although this is a relatively small study, it is the most comprehensive
analysis for biological markers of autism conducted to date, monitoring more
biological variables than ever before," Amaral said.
One of the first studies funded by the M.I.N.D. Institute looked at the
prevalence of eight peptides in blood spots collected from children at birth.
The research discovered that several of the peptides were elevated in children
who later became autistic or were mentally retarded, but not in children with
cerebral palsy or normal control children. This work, conducted under the
auspices of the California Birth Defects Monitoring Program by a team of
researchers that included physicians Karin Nelson at the National Institutes of
Health and Robin Hansen at the M.I.N.D. Institute, led to optimism that a
diagnostic marker for autism could be identified using more sophisticated
techniques.
"While their discovery was groundbreaking, the technology used in that study
was slow, making it difficult to replicate or broaden," Amaral said. "With
SurroMed's proprietary platform, we now have a technology that overcomes those
earlier constraints."
Results from this current study are expected by December 2003 and, if
promising, the M.I.N.D. Institute would enter into negotiations with SurroMed to
transfer the entire research platform to the institute to better accommodate the
analysis of larger numbers of children.
The UC Davis M.I.N.D. Institute in Sacramento, Calif., was founded in 1998 as
a unique interdisciplinary organization of parents, community leaders,
researchers, clinicians and volunteers to study and treat autism, fragile X
syndrome, dyslexia, attention deficit disorder, Asperger's syndrome and other
neurodevelopmental disorders. More information about the institute is available
on the Web at
Durham County, N.C. - Childhood vaccinations are arguably the most important
public health advancement of the past century and have have saved countless
lives.
A growing contingent of parents believes a mercury-based preservative in
those vaccines may have done more harm than good.
In 1999, at the request of the Food and Drug Administration, drug companies
agreed to begin removing a controversial preservative called thimerosal from
vaccines. Some families believe the removal comes too late.
Jackson Bono is a happy, curious 13-year-old challenged by a myriad of
medical and developmental problems. Jackson has trouble speaking and focusing
and works with a tutor.
"The toll it takes on a family is remarkable," said Scott Bono, Jackson's
father.
Like most parents, Scott and Laura Bono had their son vaccinated when he was
a baby. They now blame his problems on thimerosal and its main ingredient,
mercury.
"Little did we ever suspect that the very immunizations that were to protect
him from childhood diseases were poisoning him with mercury," Scott Bono said.
Thimerosal kills harmful bacteria and has been in vaccines for decades.
In the early 1990s, the number of recommended childhood vaccines increased.
Over the last decade the national autism rate has risen drastically. In North
Carolina, the rate has more than quadrupled, according to the state Department
of Public Instruction.
Some people see a connection.
If you add up the amount of mercury in baby vaccines with thimerosal, the
levels exceed those considered safe for adults by the FDA.
The Bonos said Jackson was a normal, healthy baby until he received a bundle
of vaccines when he was 16 months old. They said, soon after, he stopped talking
and making eye contact.
Jackson developed autistic tendencies, like spinning uncontrollably. He also
suffered severe allergies, seizures and stomach trouble.
"It was a cruel tragedy that happened with our son," Laura Bono said.
Dr. Samuel Katz, chairman emeritus of pediatrics at Duke, is considered one
of the foremost authorities on vaccines in the country. He raises doubts that
thimerosal ever hurt children.
"Whenever we have a problem, we like to know whose fault is it.
Unfortunately, vaccines have become an easy target," he said.
Katz said, "The evidence to support these claims is lacking." However, in
1999, he recommended drug companies take thimerosal out of vaccines.
A 2001 report from the National Institute of Medicine also concluded the
evidence does not support the claims. Researchers conceded, "the hypothesis is
biologically plausible."
"Given that its mercury and we know that mercury has no beneficial effects,
my statement to the FDA was that there's really no reason to use something like
thimerosal," said Michael Aschner, a Wake Forest University neurobiologist.
Aschner has studied mercury for 20 years. Research from the University of
Calgary backs up his work and found mercury can destroy brain cells.
Aschner points out that the ethylmercury in thimerosal is different from the
damaging methylmercury found in some fish. He feels the issue clearly deserves
much more study.
"If you do it in a dish, ethylmercury does cause significant effects, toxic
effects. There's no question about it," Ascher said. "But, again, what you have
to be careful of is how you translate what you see in a dish into a human
being."
The biggest obstacle parents of special needs children face in making the
thimerosal argument is the fact that millions of children, a vast majority, got
the same vaccine and never got sick.
"Why is it that all people who smoke don't get cancer? The body reacts
differently to different antagonists," Salisbury attorney Bill Graham said.
Graham represents 40 families who believe thimerosal hurt their children. He
believes evidence is mounting that federal regulators knew that thimerosal could
be harmful long before drug companies felt pressure to remove it from vaccines.
A study sanctioned by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shows
infants immunized with thimerosal vaccines were 2.5 times more likely to develop
neurological disorders, but it was never released.
Instead, the study continued and the results changed. Graham questions why
vaccines were never recalled.
"Do you think that thimerosal vaccines that are potentially harmful could
still be out there? They could be. They could be on the shelf right now," Graham
said.
"I really think the thimerosal issue has become a feeding frenzy. It's like
the sharks with blood in the water," Katz said.
The Bonos said they do not want blood. They want families like theirs to be
heard for Jackson's sake, and others like him.
"He's lost his childhood and he may not ever be what he should have been,"
Laura Bono said.
Parents like the Bonos can file claims with the National Vaccine Injury
Compensation Program.
Because of the debate over thimerosal, the federal government has put all the
claims on hold until further studies are completed.
There was no recall of thimerosal vaccines, so it is possible some could
still be on shelves.
Anyone with concerns should talk to their child's pediatrician and ask for
thimerosal-free vaccines. Both sides of the debate stress the importance of
immunizing children.
* * *
New Issue of Mothering Magazine "Best Coverage" of MMR-Vax Link
[Report by Tory Mead.]
The new issue of Mothering Magazine, November/December issue, 2002, has the
best coverage of the thimerosal/MMR issue I've seen to date. Over half of the
magazine is devoted to "Vaccines and Autism? Is there a Connection," with
contributions from the following:
Poison in our Vaccines: Investigating Mercury, Thimerosal, and
Neurodevelopmental Delay - by Lyn Redwood, Safeminds.
Searching for Reasons Why: A Mother's Report on Autism - by Lyn Redwood
Fighting For Matthew: A parent's Activism - by attorney Liz Birt
Toxic Overload: Assessing the Role of Mercury in Autism - by Boyd Haley,
University of Kentucky chemistry professor and his research on mercury
Gathering the Evidence: ASD, New Findings, and Public Policy - Dr. Jeff
Bradstreet, a researcher's congressional testimony criticizes the Centers for
Disease Control's record on vaccine safety
Balancing Biochemistry: An Interview with Dr. Stephanie Cave
To Order: Subscription Orders: 800-984-8116 Subscription Questions:
760-796-4859
E-mail for orders and questions: mother@pcspublink.com General
Inquiries: 505-984-6299
* * *
CARE
Living Under A Violent Shadow
[By Susan K. Livio and Ted Sherman in the Newark Star Ledger.]
When Richard Fort was found bloodied and beaten under his bed at a South
Jersey institution for the mentally retarded, investigators didn't need to look
far.
Fort's roommate at the New Lisbon Developmental Center, 26-year-old Ronald
Watts, admitted to the beating after police found his blood-stained sneakers in
the closet of the bedroom where both men lived.
The real mystery was how Watts -- who spent time in two state psychiatric
hospitals, had a history of assault and had been diagnosed with "intermittent
explosive disorder" -- was permitted to share a room with anyone at all.
Advocates for the mentally retarded say the homicide at New Lisbon last year
represented the worst-case scenario of what can happen when disabled people with
aggressive tendencies live in close quarters with others least able to protect
themselves.
It's a volatile combination.
"There are assaults every day," said Joseph Young, deputy director of New
Jersey Protection and Advocacy, Inc., a legal watchdog agency for the disabled.
Critics say the problems are three-fold: the state does not know who is
dangerous; residents of the state institutions live in crowded,
difficult-to-manage conditions; pervasive staffing shortages make supervision
impossible at times.
In response, state officials said they are committing significant resources
to address staffing problems at New Lisbon, one of seven such centers that 3,300
people with autism, spina bifida, mental retardation and other developmental
disabilities call home. Human Services Commissioner Gwendolyn L. Harris said she
intends to hire enough people so the daily ratio at the institutions is one
staffer for every four residents, half the current daytime ratio.
New Jersey has also spent $1.2 million for a team of consultants to assess
the treatment for about two-thirds of the 579 people living at New Lisbon. In
addition, the state spent $500,000 to assign nine psychologists there and is
setting up a victim's counseling program.
Overall, the number of violent attacks reported at the state developmental
centers has been climbing. An examination of state records found reported
assaults more than doubled in the past five years, to 275 such cases in 2001.
New Lisbon, where Fort was killed, had 1,100 reported episodes of assault, abuse
and suicide attempts since 1995 -- more than any other institution in the state.
Officials explain that more residents at New Lisbon have behavioral problems,
and are more likely to hurt themselves or others. They attribute the higher
numbers to better reporting and staff training.
The Ravenswood City School District is spending so much on a special
education lawsuit that it could soon run out of money, the county schools chief
said Friday.
A Mercury News review of legal bills found the embattled East Palo Alto
district spent $430,970 in July, $631,437 in August and $658,982 in September,
nearly all of that to defend itself against the lawsuit, in which a judge has
found the district failed to provide needed services to hundreds of children
with disabilities.
"No school district could keep up with this level of expenditure," said San
Mateo County Schools Superintendent Floyd Gonella, whose office could assume
financial control over Ravenswood if it cannot rein in its spending. "You can't
spend $400,000 a month and not be in trouble very quickly."
In fact, Ravenswood's spending on lawyers far outstrips that of other, larger
school districts. For example:
The Redwood City School District, nearly twice Ravenswood's size but not
facing any significant lawsuits, has budgeted $58,000 for legal fees this school
year, from July 1 to June 30.
The San Jose Unified School District -- which, with 32,000 students, is
more than six times bigger than Ravenswood -- spent just under $1 million on
legal fees last school year. Of that, $365,000 was spent on a desegregation
case.
In New York, a legal challenge to the state's system of providing aid to
public schools -- a case affecting millions of children -- cost the state $11.4
million last year for a nine-month trial, according to published reports.
Ravenswood Superintendent Charlie Mae Knight said Friday that the district
would be out of money if such spending continues for more than another month.
And even though the school district agreed to a tentative settlement of the
contempt charges Thursday, the proceedings may not end anytime soon.
Knight said this week that she expects the lawsuit to cost the district $7
million this school year -- nearly a quarter of its annual $30 million budget.
The district serves 5,000 children in East Palo Alto and eastern Menlo Park,
about 500 of whom have been identified as needing special education services.
Most of that $7 million will pay for legal fees, Knight said.
Ravenswood and the California Department of Education were sued in 1996 for
failures including unnecessarily segregating students with special needs and
providing them with untrained teachers.
Ravenswood's legal bills have long exceeded those of neighboring school
districts. But until last year, county superintendent Gonella said, the district
maintained a reserve of 12 to 15 percent in its budget, far above the legal
requirement of 3 percent.
Last year, the reserves dwindled as the district assumed the cost of Knight's
personal legal fees for a separate conflict-of-interest trial -- which ended in
her acquittal -- and a federal judge held Ravenswood in contempt for failure to
serve children with disabilities.
In the 2001-2002 school year, which ended June 30, Ravenswood spent $1.4
million on legal fees. The district paid $136,583 for Knight's trial, but most
of the remaining fees involved the special education lawsuit. The district also
spent hundreds of thousands of dollars more on special education consultants and
court fees.
By the time Ravenswood submitted this school year's budget to the county for
approval, its reserves had dropped to just above the legal 3 percent limit,
Gonella said.
Now, with contempt proceedings against the district dragging on, legal fees
have skyrocketed. In addition to paying its own counsel, Ravenswood is also
responsible for paying part of the bills of lawyers for special education
students.
U.S. District Court Judge Thelton Henderson first held Ravenswood in contempt
in August 2001. He was scheduled to preside over an evidentiary hearing this
fall to determine whether the district is still in contempt and, if so,
determine an appropriate punishment that could be as severe as a state takeover.
But in August, lawyers for the district and children with disabilities asked
Henderson to put plans for the hearing on hold while they tried to settle the
contempt proceedings -- in part because of the high cost of such a hearing.
On Thursday, the Ravenswood school board announced it had approved a
tentative agreement with the children's lawyers to settle the contempt
proceedings. But the children's lawyers then said the agreement may be
meaningless because the district and the state cannot agree on how to pay for
new measures to improve Ravenswood's special education program.
Ravenswood cannot afford to implement a new special education improvement
plan, and the California Department of Education has not agreed to provide
financial support. If the deal falls apart, plans for the evidentiary hearing
before Henderson will resume.
Meanwhile, state auditors have recommended that the education department
require Ravenswood to return $1.4 million it received last school year for
federally subsidized meals because the district could not adequately document
how the money had been spent. That alone could place Ravenswood on the verge of
bankruptcy, Gonella said.
Ravenswood must submit an interim budget report to the San Mateo County
Office of Education by Dec. 15. If the district is no longer fiscally solvent at
that point, the county superintendent could assume the power of the locally
elected school board to make financial decisions. Three of five seats on the
school board are open in Tuesday's election.
* * *
TREATMENT
Groups: USP Supplement Labels May Confuse Consumers
Reuters Health - A national standards-setting organization will begin
certifying dietary supplements this year, but some argue that this certification
may be misleading to consumers.
Verification by the US Pharmacopeia (USP), which sets standards for the
quality of medicines and their use, will mean that the USP guarantees the amount
of an active ingredient contained in a supplement, as well as its freedom from
contamination. But the labeling does not certify that a product is safe or prove
that it is beneficial.
"Neither the mark, which says 'Dietary Supplement Verified,' nor the
accompanying explanations make that distinction clear and we think the mark
should be more specific," said David Schardt, senior nutritionist at the Center
for Science in the Public Interest, a Washington, DC-based education and
advocacy group. "There shouldn't be any question in the consumer's mind."
The National Consumers League, another DC-based advocacy group, also
criticized the USP verification program. "We hope that USP will go back to the
drawing board and design something that will be clearer and convey to consumers
that the product has not been tested for safety or efficacy," the league's
president, Linda Golodner, said in a statement.
But Dr. Srini Srinivasan, the vice president of the USP's Dietary Supplement
Verification Program, says the organization's market research shows that there's
no need to revise the mark. The first product to bear the USP label--Pharmavite's
vitamin E pills--is set to come on the market this month, and about 50 USP-marked
products are expected before the end of the year, according to Srinivasan.
Under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994, supplement
manufacturers are required to have on file substantiation of any claims they
make about how a product affects the structure or function of the body. They
must also notify the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) of claims that they are
making within 30 days of marketing a given dietary supplement.
However, the FDA does not regulate ingredients in supplements or dosage
levels.
Dietary supplement manufacturers are increasingly feeling a need to reassure
consumers about their ingredients, noted Tod Cooperman, the president of
ConsumerLab.com, a commercial testing company based in White Plains, New York,
that licenses its "Seal of Approved Quality" to products that pass testing.
"It's become an important marketing tool for companies," he said.
Indeed, findings that some dietary supplements didn't contain what they
claimed to or were contaminated with heavy metals or pesticides led to public
suspicion, Cooperman added. "There was a definite need for the testing. We have
found that one out of four supplements has some kind of problem and it's even
worse with herbal products: 39% have some kind of problem," he explained.
The USP is the third group to begin offering certification for dietary
supplements, along with ConsumerLab.com and NSF International, a non-profit
group based in Ann Arbor, Michigan.
While ConsumerLab's certification tends to reach "the more Internet-savvy,
heavy supplement user," noted Tom Zimmerman, vice president of customer
marketing for Pharmavite, the new USP program is directed to "regular supplement
users at the retail shelves.
"Different programs are important for reaching different audiences,"
Zimmerman noted.
* * *
FUNDRAISING
$50,000 Grant Given to The Mariposa School in Cary, N.C.
The Michael & Laura Brader-Araje Foundation Gives to School that Provides
One-on-One Instruction to Children With Autism
Durham, N.C. PRNewswire via COMTEX - The Michael & Laura Brader-Araje
Foundation announced today that it has awarded its annual Spark Grant to the
Mariposa School for Children with Autism. The Mariposa School, based in Cary,
North Carolina, provides intensive, individualized instruction to children with
autism, targeting the broad range of educational, behavioral, speech, social and
motor dysfunctions that affect them.
Cynthia Peters founded the Mariposa School in December 2000. Peters is the
mother of a nine year-old son with autism. Her goal is to help children and
their families deal with the challenges of autism. "I want people to know that
autism is not a hopeless condition. There are very tangible changes that can be
made with the right kind of treatment early on," explained Peters. "It is
possible for these children to lead a functional life instead of being
institutionalized."
"Laura and I believe that our financial support and our personal involvement
can have a genuine, positive impact on the school and the children it serves,"
said Michael Brader-Araje. "As part of our due diligence, we talked to parents
of children with autism and saw the overwhelming challenges they face. We want
to do whatever we can to make those challenges a little less daunting."
"The Mariposa School helps fill a tremendous need for these families," said
Laura Brader-Araje. "It not only meets an educational need, but also provides a
valuable support network to help these children and families deal with the
realities of autism."
In addition to financial assistance, the Foundation will provide support and
resources to facilitate business planning, budgeting, additional
fund- raising, and the creation of an outreach program. Michael Brader-Araje
will also join the school's board of directors.
About 350 motorcyclists distribute presents to Kennedy Krieger patients By
Gabriel Baird Sun Staff Originally published November 4, 2002
Boys and girls pointed, cheered and covered their ears yesterday as hundreds
of motorcycles thundered into the parking lot behind the Kennedy Krieger
Institute on Greenspring Avenue in Baltimore.
Jimmy McHenry, a 16-year-old inpatient at the institute, marveled at the
parade of chrome and custom paint jobs, while the younger children seemed most
excited when the last bike pulled in towing a red sleigh piled high with toys.
"It really gives the kids a time to come out and have a good time," said
McHenry, who watched over some of the smaller patients as if they were younger
siblings. "You know how hard it is for them to cope and all."
The institute treats children with autism, cerebral palsy and other
disabilities of the brain.
Each of the nearly 20 patients on hand received at least one early Christmas
present, thanks to more than 350 motorcyclists who participated in one of the
season's first toy drives.
Piles of other presents were left for children who could not attend.
Several of the kids had an opportunity to mingle with bikers, honk horns or
try on helmets. When one girl with an oxygen tank mentioned to a leather-clad
rider that she liked the stuffed bear at the top of the pile of goodies, he got
it for her immediately.
Gary Stahl, 52, of Baltimore saw the way such acts affected his fellow
riders.
"You bring all of these kids out here, and you see some of these big, bad
riders get choked up," Stahl said.
He and Rich Bernard of Jarrettsville, 42, said they prefer this interaction
to less-personal opportunities for giving.
"This toy drive isn't like the rest of them," said Bernard, who had pulled
the sleigh behind his 2001 Harley-Davidson Ultra Classic. "We pull up here, and
these kids get the toys right now."
The drive was started in 1999 by April Darchicourt, 40, of Baltimore.
She and her husband had been active members of the area's motorcycle
community long before their daughter, who had been a patient at the institute,
died in 1999.
That first year, the event attracted nearly 100 riders. Each year it has
grown.
Darchicourt had hoped that 1,000 bikers would participate this year in the
ride, which began at the Harley-Davidson dealership in Rosedale and traveled to
the institute with a police escort. But she was pleased with the turnout.
"This is my way of helping the kids," Darchicourt said. "It eases my pain."
Even more than the gifts, McHenry enjoyed having his brother snap pictures of
him in front of his favorite three-wheeled Harley-Davidsons.
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"