http://sns.wgntv.com/news/local/evening/wgntv110601soldier.story

 

A Soldier's Nightmare

Taking a closer look at the anthrax vaccine

Dina Bair
Reporter

It's mandatory for our troops fighting in Afghanistan, but the vaccine is not FDA approved for public use. And some medical experts are calling for greater access to the vaccine.

The company that makes the anthrax vaccine says it could protect you from death, from getting the inhaled, fatal form of the anthrax disease. However, WGN uncovered information that shows the vaccine is not without problems.

A woman and her fellow servicemen, who received the vaccine, say they are now living a soldier's nightmare.

"When the joint pain is acting up severely and also the migraines where you just go sit in a dark room and cry," says Robin Hawes.

Three strong, healthy Michigan Air National Guard members who volunteered for duty in the Persian Gulf never made it overseas.

"Imagine having the flu the worst that you could have it and that visits you every week," says Tom Starkweather.

"I felt really fatigued, I was in bed constantly. I couldn't get up. I was tired all the time," says David Churchhill.

Shortly after receiving four of the six required anthrax vaccine shots in 1998 and 1999, the military confirms, nine out of 12 members of the 110th Air Fighter Wing got sick.

Tom Starkweather says his wife remembers how it changed him.

"That's something you maybe have to ask my wife because hardly a day goes by that she doesn't say I wish I had my husband back. I look at her and say I don't know who he was or I don't know if he'll ever come back," Starkweather says.

Starkweather was a recruiter for the Battle Creek unit of the guard. In Bosnia, he was selected to receive an outstanding support award for Operation Deny Flight. However, he says following his complaints about the anthrax vaccine, he was not selected for retention and was forced to retire.

"I was at the base and I went home and covered up in a blanket and since that time it's pretty much been the position," says Starkweather.

"I've literally had to crawl up the stairs before because it hurts to walk," says Hawes.

These veterans don't know how many others are suffering too. According to the Department of Defense, since 1998, more than 1,500 people have filed military vaers forms, vaccine adverse event reports.

Two hundred of those were classified as fatal, life-threatening or leading to permanent disability. That's out of a total of 500,000 people vaccinated.

According to the military, less than one percent experienced major medical complaints following the vaccine. However, critics say that number is low. In fact, the FDA criticized the manufacturers of the vaccine and the military for not actively investigating adverse reactions.

"If you have the lump in the arm that I did, the diarhea, the vomiting that has continued since September 1998, they say you have the flu. So in the military's eye I've had the flu since September of 1998," says Starkweather.

For former military honor guard member Hawes, the hand that held her weapon so steady is now completely unstable. Air Force medical records site a possible neurological reaction to the anthrax vaccine as a cause for her tremors. She takes a series of medications she says never seem to help completely.

"For vomiting, for rashes, for pain, for the achy joints, for another one of the achy joints arthritis medication, this controls the tremors and also helps the achy joints," she says. "I've never had a standard prescription in my life before this. This is all new, this is my new way of life."

Although doctors have no experience using the vaccine on people who have been exposed to anthrax, as a precautionary measure, The Centers For Disease Control is considering possibly vaccinating anyone who may have come in contact with the bacterium. The vaccine is supposed to help the body produce antibodies which would neutralize the toxins from anthrax spores.

"I think the benefits are potentially very good. And I would want all the possible medical treatments available pointed in my direction," says Dr. Phillip Hanna of the University of Michigan Medical School.

"For somebody to go out and say I want to be vaccinated with this vaccine, so I can be healthy, I don't think that's the answer," says Starkweather.

However, the public seems to welcome the potential for added protection. Bioport, based in Lasing, Michigan is the only company in the nation that makes the vaccine. It is gearing up for increased demand.

The company recently applied for FDA approval to ship mass quantities of the anthrax vaccine for widespread use. However, in the past two years the lab here has failed every federal health inspection with health experts citing "quality control problems," specifically lack of sterile environment to make the vaccine.

Based on results of those FDA inspections, Bioport was no longer allowed to ship any vaccine samples. The military could continue to use stock it had on hand. Yet, there are concerns about those vials as well.

WGN News obtained Food and Drug Administration records dating back before Bioport took over this facility in 1998 when it was run by the state of Michigan. Health investigators found, "multiple contaminations." In one onsite visit, officials "discarded some vaccine samples, from lots 030 and 031," due to "unknown microbial contaminant."

"There is very aggressive, very extensive testing on every lot that's released," says Kelly Rossman-McKinney, a Bioport spokesperson.

And there's been extensive remodelling of the lab since Bioport bought it. In its recent application for FDA approval to ship newly made vaccines, the company submitted thousands of pages, documents Bioport says prove the plant may be aging on the outside but it is new and clean inside.

A company spokesperson says the information contained here should prove to the FDA and to those who have had or are considering the vaccine, the anthrax shot is safe.

"As someone who has had four doses of the vaccine myself, I recognize that they truly do believe those illnesses are the result of the vaccine. At the same time, my own experience is similiar to a vast majority of people who had very very minor local reation," says Rossman-McKinney.

However, according to military records at last "one person died who had received the anthrax vaccine: lot 31," The very same lot cited for contamination.

Lot 030, also red-flagged by federal health investigators was administered to members of the 110th who say three years later after receiving four anthrax shots, they are still sick.

"It was kinda hard to tell when the effects of the one ended and the other one started. But each time I said look this makes me sick," Starkweather says.

There are no long term health studies to say if the side effects will last.

"I'm just a mom and a housewife now and some days I take care of my kids and some days my kids take care of me. That's my life now. It's nothing like it used to be," says Hawes.

Robin, Tom and Dave are now using their experiences to educate the public about what they believe are problems with the vaccine. WGN News has learned that two other servicemen and the family of a woman who has died have filed lawsuits against the U.S. government and the makers of the vaccine.

Currently, the vaccine is only available through the military, but in its application, Bioport is asking for permission to not only resume shipping to the Department of Defense, but also to release shots on an as needed basis to people who are not in the military.

Copyright © 2001, WGN-TV, Chicago

 

Email this story
Printer friendly format

A Soldier's Nightmare
A Soldier's Nightmare

WGN News Online Poll

 

If the anthrax vaccine gains FDA approval, will you choose to be vaccinated?
Yes
No

 

 

Video

WATCH THE VIDEO!


A Soldier's Nightmare

On The Web

U.S. Department of Defense

Food and Drug Administration

General Accounting Office (report on safety and effeciency of vaccine)

Gulf War Vets

Centers for Disease Control

Centers for Disease Control

www.majorbates.com

Top Stories

Medical Watch

WGN News Cover Stories

WGN News Investigates

 

 



News
| Programming | Station Info | Weather | Live Cam | Employment

Copyright © 2001. Tribune Interactive, Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE.  THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.