Twins are at risk of developing the condition autism, according to
researchers.
Previous studies have suggested that genes play a key role in
determining who is at risk of developing the potentially socially
debilitating illness.
But two studies carried out in the UK and the US suggest that
environmental factors such as experiences in the womb, may also be
involved.

You can't jump to the conclusion that everything is genetics

|
|
David Greenberg, Columbia University
|
However, the National Autistic Society has warned that more research is
needed.
In the first study, David Greenberg, a geneticist at Columbia
University in New York, examined a database of families in which at least
two siblings had autism.
He began to have doubts about the genetic basis of autism when he
identified a significant number of both identical and fraternal twins in
the database.
Of the 166 sibling pairs they identified, 17 were identical twins and
12 were fraternal twins.
The figure for identical twins was 12 times higher than the general
population.
But the figure for fraternal twins was also high, at four times the
rate for the general population.
Unlike identical twins, fraternal twins do not share the exact same
genetic blueprint.
A second study, by Christopher Gillberg of St George's Hospital Medical
School in London, also identified a high proportion of twins with autism.
He studied 79 sibling pairs and identified nine pairs of identical
twins - 14 times the level in the general population.
Environmental factors
The findings, published in New Scientist, raise the prospect that the
experiences of twins in the womb are important factors.
The authors suggested that the battle between twins for resources, such
as food, could be a factor.
They added that high rates among identical twins could be due to a
fiercer competition for these resources.
Identical twins can be more closely associated in the womb, lacking one
or two membranes that separate fraternal twins.
Dr Greenberg speculated that not having enough of these resources could
increase the risk of developing autism.
But he added: "The lesson here is that even in the age of the Human
Genome Project, you can't jump to the conclusion that everything is
genetics."
More research
A spokesman for the National Autistic Society said: "This study adds to
other work suggesting environmental exposures in the womb might play a
significant role in the development of the disorder.
"However, as the recent Medical Research Council Review of autism
reported, no specific prenatal exposures have been established as
contributory as yet."
He added: "Since the condition is not wholly genetic, environmental
factors also need to be explained.
"Only 10% of the cases of autism can be ascribed to a particular
medical condition. This leaves an awful lot of explanation still to be
done."