hen
a young child has an ear infection, many parents are not satisfied unless
they leave the doctor's office with a prescription for antibiotics, even
though the infections almost always clear up by themselves and the overuse
of antibiotics poses a public health problem.
A new study offers a possible solution, a "safety net" prescription. It
was presented yesterday at a meeting of the Pediatric Academic Societies in
Baltimore.
The researchers, from the Children's Hospital Medical Center in
Cincinnati, described an experiment in which parents who sought treatment
for their children's ear infections were given antibiotic prescriptions, but
with a twist.
They were asked not to fill them for 48 hours unless the symptoms
worsened. The parents were also given pain medications, including ear drops.
Doctors have long known that the infection, acute otitis media, can be
treated without antibiotics. Concern over the emergence of
antibiotic-resistant bacteria has led to an effort to reduce the use of the
drugs.
But the lead author of the study, Dr. Robert M. Siegel, said it had been
unclear whether the parents of children in pain could be persuaded to forgo
antibiotics, because it has been routine for doctors to provide them.
As it turned out, the parents were ready. The study looked at 179 cases
involving 179 children from 1 to 12 who went to 11 doctors' offices over 11
months. Of the 153 families contacted later, 47 had filled the
prescriptions. Most parents described the pain medications as effective and
said they would skip antibiotics again in the same situation.
Dr. Siegel said he would adopt the approach for his own practice. "I'm
sold on it," he said.
Children were not allowed to participate in the study if they had
temperatures of more than 101.5, ear infections in the past three months or
signs of other bacterial infection.