trains
of gonorrhea that are resistant to a major class of antibiotics have reached
the mainland United States after steady migration from Asia to Hawaii and
now to California. Meanwhile in Hawaii, researchers have identified the
first cases in the United States of gonorrhea resistant to multiple drugs.
The standard mainland treatment calls for single-dose therapy using one
of two classes of antibiotics, fluoroquinolones like ciprofloxacin and
ofloxacin and the cephalosporins cefixime and ceftriaxone. But resistance to
fluoroquinolones is now found in 60 percent to 80 percent of cases in some
East Asian countries and 20 percent of those in Hawaii, where
fluoroquinolone use has been largely abandoned.
In the major metropolitan regions of California, fluoroquinolone-resistant
gonorrhea has become persistent. Officials at the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention expect to address the problem on Thursday, when they
announce new guidelines for treating sexually transmitted diseases.
The new guidelines most likely will change recommendations on
fluoroquinolones in treating gonorrhea, said Cynthia Glocker Crick, a
spokeswoman. She declined to say whether the changes would be specific to
California, but said its health department would issue similar guidelines.
Drug-resistant gonorrhea poses two problems for public health. Incorrect
treatment can eliminate symptoms, but not the infection. Patients who think
they are cured can pass their resistant bacteria to others. Untreated or
undertreated gonorrhea can cause pelvic inflammatory disease and ectopic
pregnancies in women and infertility and other problems in both sexes.
Generally, health officials recommend against using a certain antibiotic
to treat gonorrhea in local populations where at least 3 percent to 5
percent of the cases show resistance to the drug.
"We began seeing true resistant isolates here in 2001," said Dr. Jeffrey
Klausner, deputy health officer of the San Francisco Health Department.
"They appeared at a level of 2 to 3 percent a month, and sometimes 5
percent, and have been pretty steady since."
In April 2001, the department advised against fluoroquinolones for
gonorrhea.
An epidemiologist at the disease center, Dr. Susan Wang, said similar
levels had been reported in Southern California.
"The warning signal from Hawaii told us, It's close to our doorstep, but
it's still in the Pacific," Dr. Wang said. "But now it's on the continent
and very worrisome. Now, the borders are really down."
In March, Dr. Wang presented data on three cases of gonorrhea in Hawaii
with intermediate resistance to one of the cephalosporin drugs and high
resistance to fluoroquinolones, the first cases resistant to multiple drugs
in the United States.
She presented data on mainland fluoroquinolone-resistant gonorrhea in
March at the National S.T.D. Prevention Conference. Its presence showed that
the resistant microbe followed the migration of its penicillin-resistant
cousin, which first arose in Asia in the 1970's and migrated to Hawaii and
California. By 1987, penicillin was abandoned nationally for gonorrhea
treatment.
"As goes California, so goes the nation," said Dr. H. Hunter Handsfield,
director of S.T.D. control at Public Health-Seattle and King County, where
resistant cases were also identified. "It's not a question of if, but when."
The potential loss of half the nation's first-line anti-gonorrheal
arsenal has health officials concerned. Dr. Jonathan Zenilman, associate
professor of infectious diseases at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine,
said widespread fluoroquinolone resistance would not become a major problem
for five or six years.
"So then we look at what is the next option," Dr. Zenilman said. `'It's
cephalosporins. These would then become our only first-line therapy."
Relying on cephalosporins and, perhaps, second-tier antibiotics would
pose other challenges. Cefixime can cause allergic reactions, and it costs
slightly more than fluoroquinolones. Ceftriaxone requires an injection,
increasing costs and risks.
"If we eliminate quinolones and are left only with cephalosporins," Dr.
Zenilman said, "that's putting a lot of antibiotic pressure on that
organism, and eventually it's going to become resistant."