| Tuesday, May 07, 2002
- Re: "How much compassion is too much?" May 1 Al Knight column.
If we are to throw out compassion, dodge moral responsibility and
forget that one in four families includes someone with a mental illness,
then let's at least get our understanding of the financial issues
correct.
Mr. Knight indicts the high cost of insurance coverage for mental
illnesses, but forgets that far more expensive, both to employers and to
the taxpayer at large, is the cost of taking care of the fallout when
someone with a mental illness isn't treated. For many mental illnesses,
drugs combined with therapy are effective in a high percentage of cases.
Medicine and therapy are far cheaper than jails (where more than half of
the incarcerated are mentally ill), cheaper than paying for services for
the homeless (a high percentage of whom are mentally ill), cheaper than
paying for expensive emergency-room visits (where the mentally ill
usually end up when their untreated illnesses get out of hand) and
cheaper than employee absenteeism (due to turnover and on-the-job
problems that can occur when mental illness is not treated).
The treatment of mental illness on a par with other illness can be
managed, just like other medical treatments can be managed, and result
in earlier and cheaper treatment with enormous cost savings overall.
("An ounce of prevention ... ")
KATHY PALMQUIST
Aurora
Deserving compassion
Mr. Knight says not everyone is mentally ill and that President
Bush's proposed mandate for insurance coverage for the mentally ill
"requires those who are not mentally ill to pay - for treating the
mentally ill."
Mr. Knight does not usually exhibit such convoluted thinking. Does he
believe we should insure only those who have a condition that everyone
has? Does he think everyone has cancer, or multiple sclerosis, or is a
victim of stroke or any of the other devastating so-called "physical"
illnesses that are equally expensive to treat and yet are fully covered
by insurance?
Of course not. I can only conclude that his comments are the perfect
example of the stigma against mental illness that pervades our land.
I agree that the term "mental illness" should not be construed to
mean the "worried well." But those who have biologically based brain
disorders deserve the same care and treatment as anyone with any other
physical illness - and the same compassion as well. Shame on you, Mr.
Knight!
CAROL VAN LEW
Centennial
Services, compassion for autism rare in Colorado
Re: "Mom held in boy's 3-story fall; Autistic child, 7, was pushed
out of window, police say," April 24 news story.
As the mother of two young children with autism, I am following the
story of the Denver autistic boy who fell from a third-story window with
heartbreak and anguish. I think I can imagine what the life of the
mother and son have been like for the past several years.
I am an advocate for children and families affected by autism, and
sadly the story is very much the same for the dozens of families I have
worked with. From identification, to diagnosis, to early intervention,
to special education, to social and family support, the services for
children with autism in our communities are woefully inadequate or
simply nonexistent.
The state of Colorado continues to look the other way when it comes
to providing basic educational and social services for children and
families affected by this disorder. Perhaps this tragic event will cause
us to pause and question how we address autism in Colorado. Perhaps it
will cause Gov. Owens to pause and reflect on his rationale for vetoing
HB 1389 in the summer of 2000. This bill would have provided Medicaid
coverage for intervention for children with autism similar to that
provided in other states.
Perhaps it will cause people responsible for special education policy
to take notice when Dr. Bernard Rimland, founder of the Autism Research
Institute, makes a comment about our state. He said, "... Colorado is
exceedingly negligent in providing needed services for autistic
children" in a September 2001 letter to hundreds of his Colorado
clients.
You see, from my perspective, children with autism in Colorado are
"thrown out the window" every day. How sad that in the Denver case, the
mother is the only one being charged.
MICHELLE A. LINN
Colorado Springs
Editorial dishes liberal dose of liberal neuroses
Re: "Polisophobia in the GOP," May 4 editorial.
I like to live by the motto, "If you can't beat 'em, join 'em." So in
that vein I offer the following to my conservative friends in the Denver
area:
The Doctor is in. The diagnosis is complete and the prognosis grim.
The editorial board at The Denver Post is suffering from a serious but
common form of liberal neurosis bordering on psychosis. It is a common
development brought on by extreme ideological paranoia after years of
participation in opinion Nazi practices where you will frequently see
them uncontrollably blurt out forceful phrases like "No views for you"
when they get agitated.
It is also common to see them develop a psychological diagnosis
obsession with words like "homophobia," "xenophobia" and "polisophobia."
This is a direct result of their problem with systematized delusions of
conservative persecution and hallucinations of liberal grandeur. You
will also notice they will be excessively and irrationally suspicious
and distrustful of conservatives because they view them as their enemy.
The prognosis is very poor, so the best thing you can do is love them
in spite of themselves and be sure you get a healthy dose of balanced
opinion from another source. I recommend the Internet.
And, please, don't call me in the morning.
DEBI CHESSON
Stilwell, Kan.
United pact gives lowest raise to lowest-paid staff
Re: "Ground staff, United reach pay raise deal; Union urged to OK 29%
hike," April 26 news story.
It is particularly interesting that the least amount tendered (29
percent) goes to the worst paid of all the workers involved in the
recent pay hikes at UAL. Pilots got 37 percent and before the pay raise,
were the best-paid and well deserving of it. Likewise, the mechanics got
a long-overdue 37 percent.
It seems to follow some kind of a corporate strategy that the
worst-paid workers, ramp and customer service, will get the worst
percentage raise. Today's paper reports that the economy is growing by
5.8 percent. Recession cannot be used as an excuse for not giving these
folks the same percentage raise that pilots and mechanics got.
CHUCK SMITH
Denver
Beware globalization
Re: "Business leaders, protesters head downtown," May 5 business
story.
The Post quoted International Chamber of Commerce top dog Maria
Livanos Cattaui: "Our experts work closely with ambassadors, negotiators
and staff at the WTO; not to lobby but to represent the perspective of
business."
Those of us who are concerned that transnational corporations are
destroying the democratic process are called "activists," implying that
attempting to participate in decisions that affect our lives is
eccentric. The millions of dollars that corporations put into political
campaigns are not just acts of good citizenship.
Not lobbying? Ha!
As for the wonders of globalization and big business, didn't they
bring us the savings and loan debacle that cost American taxpayers
hundreds of billions of dollars? The same lack of restraint has given us
Enron and a secret business team making our national energy policy.
The ICC is hatching more of these great ideas this week in Denver.
TOM MOORE
Boulder
The writer is a member of the Front Range Fair Trade Coalition and
the Boulder Labor Council.
|