Re: Mental health bill is a dilemma by Sara Fritz, April 29.
As a business owner and a psychologist, I understand that the issue of mental
health parity is complicated. The costs of providing mental health care would
increase the cost of insurance at a time when premiums are already rising 15
percent per year on average. However, the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill
estimates that the annual cost of untreated mental illness exceeds $300-billion.
The column by Sara Fritz emphasizes increased insurance costs and how some
employers may be tempted to eliminate health insurance for employees altogether.
This risk is real, as our company had to require an employee contribution toward
health insurance premiums for the first time when we renewed our policy this
year. However, her column fails to mention that the cost of limiting access to
care results in larger general medical expenses and decreased worker
productivity. More than 50 percent of patient beds occupied in hospitals are the
direct result of emotional problems or behavioral excesses, such as substance
abuse. Meanwhile, American businesses lost $29-billion per year due to
absenteeism resulting from depression.
As a psychologist, I witness the shock of patients who seek care in the midst
of a family crisis only to discover the limitations of their health insurance.
autism, Tourette's syndrome and learning disabilities are but a few of the
diagnoses that may not be covered by a company health plan. If a condition is
covered, most managed care companies limit the number of sessions allowed per
year. Patients who suffer from chronic conditions (such as bipolar disorder) may
exhaust their annual benefits and then have to discontinue care prematurely.
Finally, the higher deductibles and co-insurance associated with mental health
services can discourage patients from seeking treatment in the first place.
The other major issue related to mental health parity is the constitutional
guarantee of equal opportunity. Most people who need mental health care have a
brain disorder. Research breakthroughs have unlocked many of the brain-based
mysteries of bipolar disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, social anxiety
disorder and attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Maintaining a double
standard for physical health and mental health constitutes discrimination
against individuals with brain disorders.
-- Michael T. Smith, Ph.D., Clearwater
* *
Autism verses Mental Illness
Letter from the Editor
Brief Commentary: Autism is not a mental illness. Disjointed thought
processes are not at its core. Some students of the disorder are starting to
think it may be a toxin-triggered, genetically vulnerable immune disorder
resulting in a broken brain, resulting in strange behavior and other things.
But science is also discovering the crazy irony that mental illness is not a
mental illness, either. Like autism, mental illnesses are increasingly being
thought of, if not discovered as something physiological, biomedical -- the
brain's genetically coached 'moving parts', being out of whack.
As catagoric distinctions between ASDs and mental illnesses blur medically,
so do the forensics of medical insurance. Insurance providers are increasingly
told by state lawmakers and judges, "If you're going to cover a broken arm,
you'll have to cover a broken brain, too." And autism gets lumped in with mental
illness along the way.
Mental Health Parity Bill (AB 88) in California, A Model? Letter to the
Editor, Sacramento Bee
The above bill, which the Sacramento Bee refers to as a model for other
states to follow has some severe flaws. First, it took a considerable amount of
time after its passage for some insurers to come into line with its provisions.
Before its inception, primary care physicians (for the most
part) controlled referrals for services necessary for autistic syndrome
children. In many, if not most, cases, these referrals for service were denied
for such things as speech therapy. occupational therapy, and the like, because
these services were considered too long-term to fit the criteria for short-term
fixes. This is an oversimplification but enough of a short explanation to make
my point.
Some of the larger HMOs are now turning all coverages for autism over to
their mental health providers. Because of the California state restriction on
creating vendor contracts with only "mental health practitioners"
(Psychiatrists, neuropsychologists, psychologists, or marriage and family
counselors), these mental health insurance companies do not coordinate through
the child's primary care physician. In fact, the HMOs cannot vendorize other
than those mental health professionals identified above. They make individual
contracts for each child when they approve speech, ot, or other auxiliary
services. This leaves the doctor out of the loop and requires the family to
request these services directly.
This absence of coordination and cooperation certainly leaves California and
its "Parity" law lacking.
There's much more too it, but I couldn't let the Bee's editorial comments
pass without comment.
Peter McLean [peter@webaccel.net]
* *
Services, Compassion For Autism Rare In Colorado
Letter to the Editor, Denver Post
Re: "Mom held in boy's 3-story fall; Autistic child, 7, was pushed out of
window, police say," April 24 news story.
As the mother of two young children with autism, I am following the story of
the Denver autistic boy who fell from a third-story window with heartbreak and
anguish. I think I can imagine what the life of the mother and son have been
like for the past several years.
I am an advocate for children and families affected by autism, and sadly the
story is very much the same for the dozens of families I have worked with. From
identification, to diagnosis, to early intervention, to special education, to
social and family support, the services for children with autism in our
communities are woefully inadequate or simply nonexistent.
The state of Colorado continues to look the other way when it comes to
providing basic educational and social services for children and families
affected by this disorder. Perhaps this tragic event will cause us to pause and
question how we address autism in Colorado. Perhaps it will cause Gov. Owens to
pause and reflect on his rationale for vetoing HB 1389 in the summer of 2000.
This bill would have provided Medicaid coverage for intervention for children
with autism similar to that provided in other states.
Perhaps it will cause people responsible for special education policy to take
notice when Dr. Bernard Rimland, founder of the Autism Research Institute, makes
a comment about our state. He said, "... Colorado is exceedingly negligent in
providing needed services for autistic children" in a September 2001 letter to
hundreds of his Colorado clients.
You see, from my perspective, children with autism in Colorado are "thrown
out the window" every day. How sad that in the Denver case, the mother is the
only one being charged.
Shawna Boller hopes the fence 5-year-old Ryan found a way through Thursday
keeps him in. Ryan, who is autistic, likes to run. His older brother, also
autistic, doesn't like to leave the house, putting their mother in a bind. The
Bollers moved to their home outside Woodland Park to get away from traffic in
case Ryan ran away.
"It restores your faith in people," she said Tuesday from her log home in a
rural subdivision north of Woodland Park.
Ryan Boller was found safe in the woods Friday, curled in the fetal position
and wearing his Teletubbies underwear. He was missing for more than 24 hours and
survived a brief snowstorm and freezing temperatures. He took off the sweat
shirt and jeans he was wearing before he was found.
What complicated the search was Ryan's autism, which prevents him from
communicating with people. It also makes him run whenever he's unattended.
That's what happened Thursday afternoon when Shawna took her eyes off him for a
few minutes. Ryan managed to find a way through a fence in the yard and into the
neighboring Manitou Experimental Forest.
The Bollers had known this was a possibility. For the past year, Ryan has
loved to run. That's why they moved from Woodland Park to their mountain
property in November, thinking it would be safer for Ryan to live away from
traffic.
The fence around their yard is reinforced with chicken wire and looks secure.
But Ryan wiggled out.
"When he runs, he's laughing and giggling," said Shawna, 37. "He thinks it's
a game. I don't know why he does it. He can't tell you. Maybe it's the
excitement of the chase or the feeling of freedom."
When Shawna noticed Ryan wasn't in the yard, she panicked. Her other son,
6-year-old Jesse, also is autistic but hates going outside. Shawna couldn't
leave Jesse alone to look for Ryan, so she put him in the car and drove to the
neighbors. They watched Jesse while she searched the woods briefly before
calling 911.
Shawna says now that she is frustrated that it took so long for the Teller
County Sheriff's Office to respond to her call and to call out search and
rescue. By her account, it took hours.
But Sheriff Frank Fehn said records show his office received her call at 5:05
p.m. and a deputy was on the scene in eight minutes. He immediately called
search and rescue.
"I can understand her frustration," Fehn said. "But I think it's a case of
being upset that her child is missing and minutes seem like hours."
The search lasted through the night. The boy's father, Shawn, was out looking
while Shawna was at home with about 20 people - neighbors, her husband's
co-workers and people from Ryan's school - who gathered there. They kept Shawna
updated, but there was no good news.
"The next morning, I was asking, what child could survive 27-degree
temperatures," she said. "I kept asking when does hypothermia set in. No one
would tell me."
About noon, searchers found the boy's shoes near a creek. By that time,
hundreds of volunteers joined the search, taking time off work and joining
rescue crews.
The sun was starting to set Friday when Shawna got the best news of her life.
They found Ryan. The cell phone conversation was breaking up, so Shawna had to
go to a corner of the house to hear it.
"I said, 'Is he alive?' Is he alive?'" she said.
He was. Dave Douglas, who is in the Colorado Army National Guard with Ryan's
father, found the boy while riding a motorcycle on a trail about three miles
northwest of the Boller home. Ryan was curled up under a tree. He had a
sunburned face, but everything else was fine, doctors later concluded.
"It's a miracle," his mother said Tuesday while Ryan was at school in his
kindergarten class.
"The child didn't even have a bug bite. The paramedics couldn't believe it.
People have been coming up to me and saying they didn't believe in God until
now. There isn't any other explanation."
Today, the fence has been fortified. But the Bollers know this could happen
again. They also believe that living in the woods is better than living in a
city near traffic.
Shawna said she needs help, that she can't possibly watch two autistic boys
at the same time. For now, however, she'll continue doing what she's always
done. And she just hopes next time the gate will stay shut.
* * *
Student's Inspiration Aids Therapy 'Steamroller' Calms Kids
[By Meg Heckman in the Journal Tribune, Acton, Maine. Note URL is
temporary.]]
Occupational therapy student Alicia Wells never thought of herself as an
inventor but then years of experience with special needs children and anxiety
over a looming school project collided during a trip though the car wash.
The 22-year-old University of New England student needed to find a way to
help children deal with high sensitivity to touch. In a moment of inspiration,
Wells realized sliding a child though rollers, like a car in a car wash, could
provide the kind of deep, steady pressure that often calms oversensitive
children.
So she conceived of a device with two padded, thick rolling pins on a tension
spring that children - and adults - can roll through on their tummies.
The "Steamroller" can be used to help kids with everything from autism to
ADHD (attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder) to cerebral palsy by calming the
central nervous system.
"It allows the child to focus to work and play," said Wells, standing next to
the foot-high device.
Wells could visualize how she wanted the Steamroller to look, but she didn't
have the supplies to build it. So she called Andy Ruse, a representative with
Southpaw Enterprises, a catalog retailer of therapeutic devices and described
her concept.
Three weeks later the plywood and plastic device arrived and the Steamroller
began to catch on.
It's been almost two years since Wells handed in her project but now the
therapeutic device is making waves at local clinics and the national catalogue
that manufactures and sells the roller device, priced at $279, can't keep it in
stock.
"The kids and the adults loved it," said occupational therapist Molly Arnold
of UNE. "It was really a lot of fun."
Arnold is the coordinator of UNE Community OT Clinic on Saco Island. The
clinic was the first facility to use Wells' invention and the kids and
therapists there helped demonstrate its clinical benefits.
For several months they used the roller on its own and as part of therapeutic
obstacle courses to help youngsters attending therapy sessions learn to better
control their bodies.
"After they've gone though the roller they're a little calmer and when
they're calm they can focus a little better," said Arnold. "It can help the
nervous system feel just right instead of off kilter."
* * *
Facial Identity And Facial Emotions: Speed, Accuracy, And Processing
Strategies in children and adults.
De Sonneville LM, Verschoor CA, Njiokiktjien C, Op het Veld V, Toorenaar N,
Vranken M. Pediatric Outpatients Clinic, Vrije Universiteit Medical Center,
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
As yet, nearly all studies in face and facial affect recognition typically
provide only data on the accuracy of processing, invariably also in the absence
of reference data on Abstract information processing. In this study, accuracy
and speed of abstract visuo-spatial processing, face recognition, and facial
emotion recognition were investigated in normal school children (7-10 years) and
adults (25+/-4 years).
In the age range of 7-10 years, accuracy of facial processing hardly
increased, while speed did substantially increase with age. Adults, however,
were substantially more accurate and faster than children. Differences between
facial and abstract information processing were related to type of processing
strategy, that is, configural or holistic processing versus featural or
piecemeal processing. Improvement in task performance with age is discussed in
terms of an enhanced efficiency of the configural organization of facial
knowledge (facial information processing tasks), together with a further
increase in processing capacity (all tasks).
The differential developmental course of speed and accuracy levels indicates
that speed is a more sensitive measure when children get older. Moreover, it
also suggests that speed of performance, in addition to accuracy, might be
successfully used in the assessment of clinical deficits, as has recently been
demonstrated in children with autistic disorders of social contact.
Lauritsen MB, Borglum AD, Betancur C, Philippe A, Kruse TA, Leboyer M, Ewald
H. Department of Psychiatric Demography, Institute for Basic Psychiatric
Research, Psychiatric Hospital in Aarhus, Risskov, Denmark.
Though genetic risk factors are important for the development of autism, no
specific risk alleles have yet been identified. DOPA decarboxylase (DDC) is
involved in both the catecholaminergic and serotonergic pathways and may be
considered a functional candidate gene for autism. The present study is the
first to test if two new variants of possible functional significance in the DDC
gene increase the susceptibility to autism.
A total of 90 parent-offspring trios recruited in Denmark and France were
investigated using the transmission disequilibrium test (TDT). We found no
evidence of linkage disequilibrium between autism and either of the two
polymorphisms. Nor did we find linkage disequilibrium between autism and
haplotypes of the two variants using a multiallelic TDT. These findings suggest
that the DDC gene is unlikely to play a major role in the development of autism
in our data set. Copyright 2002 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
PMID: 11992572 [PubMed - as supplied by publisher]
* * *
Craniosynostosis, Telecanthus, Scalp Hair Abnormalities, And Sensorineural
deafness in two sibs.
Unite de Genetique Medicale, Laboratoire de Biologie Moleculaire et
Cytogenetique, Faculte de Medecine, Universite Saint-Joseph, Beirut, Lebanon.
A sister and a brother with anomalous skull configuration, facial
abnormalities, abnormal scalp hair growth, sensorineural hearing loss and, in
the boy, proven craniosynostosis, severe mental retardation, and autism were
reported in 1986 in an abstract by Hersh et al. We reexamined this family and
here review the literature focusing on the major clinical findings, and suggest
that their clinical manifestations may represent a previously unreported
syndrome. Copyright 2002 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
PMID: 11992488 [PubMed - as supplied by publisher]
* * *
Nociceptive Changes In Rats After Prenatal Exposure To Valproic Acid.
Institute of Applied Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Poland.
Abnormalities in anatomy and function of the cranial nerve motor nuclei and
brain stem structures have been demonstrated in some people with autism and can
be modeled in rats by exposure to valproic acid (VPA) during very early nervous
system developmental stages (neural tube closure).
The aim of this study was to investigate if VPA will have an impact on
nociception in rats because of reported hypoalgesia in a subgroup of autistic
patients. Pregnant females were treated ip with 600 mg/kg of sodium valproate on
day 12.5 of gestation.
Nociception was measured in offsprings by tail-flick and thermal paw
withdrawal tests in two developmental stages: prepubertal (80-90 g) and
adulthood (360-440 g). Results showed significant differences in pain
sensitivity with hypoalgesia in male rats treated with VPA compared to male
control in both developmental stages.
The outcome of our study suggests that rats exposed prenatally to VPA show
abnormalities in nociception similar to those observed in human autistic
patients. Interestingly, naloxone (1 mg/kg) had no impact on nociception in
offsprings of VPA-treated rats.
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"