* Media Alert: Are We Making Our Kids Sick? Kids & Chemicals - Special Rept.
* Possible Autoimmune Enteropathy Found In Autistic Children
* Looking Into Autism
* No-Symptom Sensitivity To Gluten May Result In Neurological Dysfunction
PUBLIC HEALTH
* MMR Doctor Advises Giving Parents The Choice Of Single Vaccines
EDUCATION
* U.S. May Train Teachers On How To Help the Autistic
* Special Ed Graduation Rates Rise
* DREDF Tracking IDEA Political Developments
Are We Making Our Children Sick? Kids And Chemicals, A Special Report Bill
Moyers Tracks The Scientific Search For Answers About How Environmental Toxins
Affect America's Children
[In March of last year, Moyers covered the subject of industrial pollution in
a report titled "Trade Secrests." This report focuses on children. Thanks to
Dave Swartz,.] Premieres Tonight, Friday, May 10 at 9:00 (ET) on PBS (check
local listings)
It is a medical mystery marked "urgent." Across America growing numbers of
children are suffering from asthma, childhood cancers like leukemia, as well as
learning and behavioral disabilities. Scientists are searching for clues to the
causes of these illnesses, and a growing body of research suggests that everyday
environmental toxins-what kids eat, drink, and breathe-may put them at risk.
Equipped with new technology and more sophisticated analysis, these scientists
are asking compelling questions about the health risks to children growing up
exposed to an ever-increasing number of untested chemicals in our environment.
Kids and Chemicals, a special edition of NOW with Bill Moyers to be broadcast
on PBS, Friday, May 10 at 9 p.m. (ET), features medical investigators and health
officials engaged in the latest research on links between childhood illness and
environmental contamination. The program looks at families around the country
who are coping with the consequences to their children of potentially toxic
exposures.
"The disturbing increases in childhood illness in America cannot be ignored,"
says Bill Moyers. "How does the exposure affect children's health? The new
research is studying how chemicals enter the human body, and posing questions
that they could never ask before: Do chemicals affect children, babies and
unborn fetuses more than adults? What factors increase toxicity, and how can we
protect children from harm?" Kids and Chemicals' producers Gail Ablow and Greg
Henry go to Fallon, Nevada, a small desert town that has had 15 recorded cases
of childhood leukemia in just five years. A l armed, Dr. Mary Guinan, who was
one of Nevada's top health officials, called in the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention to investigate the potential links between this childhood cancer
and the environment. Could toxic substances in water, food, air, schools, homes
or the ground in Fallon be responsible for this "cancer cluster"? If so, which
chemicals? Without clear evidence of a specific cause, everything-from jet fuel
emissions to pesticides to naturally occuring arsenic in the water-is suspect.
As Moyers and his team learn in Fallon, research on cancer clusters once
focused mainly on gathering environmental samples because investigators simply
didn't have tools sensitive enough to measure which toxins had been absorbed
into people. Dr. Richard Jackson, the director of the National Center for
Environmental Health at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, explains
how his laboratories are using the latest instruments. His research scientists
are using sophisticated blood and urine analysis to test for minute traces of
toxins in the bodies of the sick children and their families in Fallon.
This work is part of a larger movement in children's environmental health
unfolding nationwide. Dr. Phillip Landrigan of the Mount Sinai School of
Medicine in New York City works with scientists around the country to understand
how kids are affected by exposure to chemicals. "Of the 3000 high production
volume chemicals in use in this country today, only 43% have been even minimally
tested," he tells Moyers. "Only about 10% have been thoroughly tested to examine
their potential effects on children's health and development."
Speaking with Landrigan, Moyers learns that children are potentially more
vulnerable to chemicals than adults. "First of all they're more heavily exposed
pound for pound," says Landrigan. "They eat more food, they drink more water,
they breathe more air. Then, of course, kids < B R>play on the ground. They live
low, they put their hands in their mouth and so they transfer more toxic
chemicals into their body than we do."
Traveling to Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, Moyers meets Dr. Linda
Sheldon of the Environmental Protection Agency's National Exposure Research Lab.
Sheldon demonstrates how her team of scientists is gathering evidence of
exposure to everyday chemicals in nursery schools, homes and daycare centers.
In New York City, a groundbreaking study led by Dr. Frederica Perera at
Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health, follows more than 500
expectant mothers. These women are wearing air quality monitors in backpacks to
trap the environmental toxins they breathe. As their children are born and as
they grow, Dr. Perera and her team will look for links between the chemicals
that the mothers were exposed to while their babies were developing in the womb
and asthma, cancer risk, and learning disabilities.
Dr. Sandra Steingraber, a biologist at Cornell University, joins Dr.
Landrigan in asserting that exposure during pregnancy doesn't, by itself, mean a
child will get ill. What matters is the intensity of the exposure and when it
occurs during fetal development. A chemical exposure occurring early in
pregnancy might cause a miscarriage, argue the researchers. If it occurs later
on, it might cause physical birth defects. Later still, it might damage brain
cells. Scientists are trying to precisely identify these "windows of
vulnerability." Says Dr. Steingraber: "Maybe certain problems that we understand
. . . as attention deficit disorders, hyperactivity, the inability to pay
attention, aggressive and violent behaviors, might have their origins during
those windows of vulnerability during pregnancy and these questions are just
being asked. Data is just beginning to come in." Dr. Perera's team at Columbia
is also studying the way that chemicals can actually bind to human DNA in the
womb and cause a mu t ation called an "adduct." Work by Dr. Perera has shown
that the greater the number of adducts, the greater the risk for cancer. "And
that's the missing link in all of this," says Dr. Steingraber. "That's the link
we're beginning to fill in."
To place the current studies in a public health policy context, Moyers
revisits the firestorm over lead research; recalling the revolutionary work of
Dr. Herbert Needleman, who correlated low-level lead exposure to lower IQ's in
children in 1979. Twelve years later, Needleman's work was attacked by the lead
industry as it tried to protect its economic stake in lead products. Ultimately,
the validity of Dr. Needleman's work was fully vindicated, and new public policy
required unleaded gasoline and restrictions on lead paint. And many scientists
believe that, as a result, children's IQ scores have risen, on average, three
points. Yet, as Moyers points out, lead remains the number one environmental
threat to children's health; many old houses and even many school buildings are
still testing positive for lead today.
In Herculaneum, Missouri, lead contamination is a very current issue. The
community is up in arms about the astonishingly high levels of lead to which
their families have been exposed because the town's primary industry, the Doe
Run lead smelter, failed to comply with EPA standards. "Doe Run played a really
good game," Robyn Warden, a mother, tells Moyers. "They told people everything
was under control and we were safe. And people weren't educated enough to know
any different. It took people actually investigating lead to figure out that we
were being lied to."
Dr. Steingraber knows the importance of informed parenting. Even in a
seemingly pristine environment in rural New York, she knows there are
possibilities of risk. "Just because there are no smoke stacks visible around
us, just because you live a long way from the source of these chemicals, doesn't
mean that natu r e won't bring them to you in some way," she says. A mother who
breast feeds her infant son, Dr. Steingraber also realizes that she passes
toxins directly to her baby every time she nurses. "No woman has uncontaminated
breast milk on this planet," she states. Dr. Steingraber tries to reduce her
children's exposure at home by using non-toxic products. "But we can't shop our
way out of our current situation," she warns. "We still need to take action.
It's time that our public policy takes action to get our kids out of harm's
way."
There are unknown answers to many questions. Moyers reports on a proposed new
project called "The National Children's Study," which will track 100,000
children from the womb to age 18 if it receives full funding from Congress. This
long-term study may provide the definitive answers necessary for new regulations
and laws protecting children from exposure to toxins. "Without conclusive
science," Moyers says, "it is a constant fight to protect children's health."
Possible Autoimmune Enteropathy Found In Autistic Children
[Wednesday we clipped a "lay explanation" of the just released Murch/"Wakefield"
study. This research may be an important first step in developing a preventative
treatment for late onset autism. Here is another, more technical explanation of
those findings from the Lancet medical journal. Written by Kathryn Senior.]
A team of UK researchers has found evidence supporting an autoimmune basis
for bowel abnormalities in children with autism. The investigators reported IgG
binding to the epithelial cell surface, lymphocyte infiltration, and increased
crypt cell proliferation in the small bowel of children with autism. "These
features raise the possibility of autoimmunity in severe autism", concludes
Julio Licinio (University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA) in an
accompanying editorial (Mol Psych 2002; 7: 329).
Simon Murch (Royal Free and University College Medical School, London,
UK) and colleagues studied intestinal samples from 25 autistic children with
small intestine lesions using various immunochemical techniques. For comparison,
they also used samples obtained from 18 normal controls, 11 children with
coeliac disease, and five children with cerebral palsy.
Routine staining showed only minor differences between autistic children and
controls, but immunochemistry highlighted striking abnormalities in the group
with autism. The density of CD8 intraepithelial lymphocytes was significantly
greater in autistic children than in normal controls or children with cerebral
palsy, but was was not as high as in children with coeliac disease. Autistic
children also showed a higher density of excess T cell infiltration within the
lamina propria than any other group. However, the most striking finding was the
deposition of IgG1 and IgG4 on the basolateral enterocyte membrane and the
subepithelial basement membrane in 23 of 25 autistic children, but in none of
the other groups. In some, deposition was patchy and incomplete; in others it
was striking and extensive (Mol Psych 2002; 7: 375-82).
"Intestinal inflammation genuinely does occur in at least a proportion of
autistic children", concludes Murch. However, he says that the big question is
whether such unexpected gut involvement either causes or exacerbates the
cognitive abnormalities that typify autism. "If the answer is yes, this may
point towards the logical use of immune-based therapy in future children at the
time of first regression", he says.
An important next step towards understanding the significance of intestinal
abnormalities to autism will be to find out whether localisation of IgG
represents specific binding to an individual epithelial antigen, and if so the
identification of this antigen. Other questions still to be answered relate to
lymphocytic infiltration, which is apparently panenteric.
"Follow-up research has indicated that these autistic children show enhanced
spontaneous tumour necrosis factor production by duodenal and colonic
lymphocytes and evidence of focal lymphocytic gastritis", reports Murch. In the
meantime, he doubts that the histological findings can be used to aid diagnosis
of autism. "The straightforward histology is too subtle for routine diagnosis,
but the same was true for H pylori infection for many years; maybe we'll get
better at pattern recognition", he says.
Milne E et al. (2002). High motion-coherence thresholds in children with
autism. J Child Psychol Psychiatry, 43:255-263.
When one thinks of autism, it is probably the communicative and social
impairments that come to mind first behaviors such as social avoidance, lack
of eye contact, or speech impairments. Indeed, it is these symptoms that are
used in the diagnosis of autism, and most research on this developmental
disorder has focused on the manifestation and treatment of these overt
behaviors.
Elizabeth Milne and her colleagues, however, have new evidence that might
help us to understand the lower-level mechanisms behind autism. Children with
autism were compared with age-matched control children on a motion-coherence
task.
Thresholds for motion detection were measured by presenting an array of
moving dots on a computer screen; in each array, some of the dots move
coherently (that is, in a common direction) and others move randomly.
Importantly, each individual dot has a lifetime of only four frames, so to
detect coherent motion, the child must be able to extract some global
information from the display.
Tracking an individual dot provides insufficient evidence to detect the
coherent motion direction. The task thus provides a measure of sensitivity to
global information in the stimulus.
The results revealed that children with autism showed a significantly higher
threshold (lower sensitivity) for motion coherence than did controls. The
authors suggest that these results represent impairment of the magnocellular
visual pathway, which projects via the dorsal stream to the parietal regions of
the brain.
Several parietal lobe structures are known to be abnormal in people with
autism, and this could result from the dearth of information coming from the
low-frequency, magnocellular pathway early in development.
Although it is presently more speculation than fact, such a model could
provide an exceedingly parsimonious account of early perceptual and later
behavioral aspects associated with autism.
These findings are also consistent with the weak central coherence
hypothesis put forward to explain other biases for preferential processing of
local features in autism. Milne et al. take an important first step in looking
at perceptual deficits, which now should be followed by further perceptual
investigation and functional imaging.
* * *
MMR Doctor Advises Giving Parents The Choice Of Single Vaccines
[By Susan Mayor, News roundup, BMJ 2002;324:1118 ( 11 May ).]
A researcher who chaired the committee that introduced the combined measles,
mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccination programme into the United Kingdom has said
that offering the choice of single vaccines could end the stalemate whereby some
parents are refusing to have their children vaccinated.
Dr Eileen Rubery, senior research associate at the Judge Institute of
Management, University of Cambridge, chaired the committee that introduced MMR
vaccination to the United Kingdom in 1994, when she was under secretary for the
protection of health with the Department of Health.
Writing recently in the British Associations journal Science and Public
Affairs (April 2002), she expressed concern that the governments policy of
insisting that children should have access only to the combined MMR vaccine was
not helping to solve the current crisis in the programme.
Some parents refused to allow their children to have MMR vaccination, after
reports that the combined vaccine might be associated with increased risk of
several disorders, including autism.
The medical community argued that the research was flawed and showed no
direct association between MMR and autism, and so urged that the triple
vaccination should continue and that single vaccines should not be available on
the NHS.
However, some parents were not reassured by this advice.
Latest figures show that 86% of 2 year olds have received the MMR vaccine,
compared with 97% who received tetanus inoculation.
Dr Rubery said that offering parents the choice of single vaccinesat their
own expensecould solve the problem, even though she considered there was no
evidence of an association between MMR and autism and acknowledged that the
single vaccines had not been tested in the same way as the combined vaccine.
"My guess is that once parents can choose, many will reflect more calmly on
the options and understand the benefits of the triple vaccine," she said.
"Just telling people that MMR is safe is not working, so the Department of
Health needs to look again at how to improve uptake of vaccination against
measles, mumps, and rubella." She based her suggestion on her experience in
advising the Food Standards Agency on how to deal with public concerns about
possible links between BSE and sheep, advice that was based on widespread and
open consultation.
"This is not rocket scienceit is applying standard psychology of giving
people a choice," she concluded.
* * *
No-Symptom Sensitivity To Gluten May Result In Neurological Dysfunction
You may have gluten sensitivity and not even know it, according to a study
published in the April 23 issue of Neurology, the scientific journal of the
American Academy of Neurology. Loss of coordination (ataxia) may result from
gluten sensitivity. This disease is known as gluten ataxia. The study found that
some patients might never experience the gastrointestinal symptoms that prompt
them to seek treatment for the disorder.
Gluten ataxia is a common neurological manifestation of gluten sensitivity,
according to M. Hadjivassiliou, M.D., of the Royal Hallamshire Hospital,
Sheffield, UK. It remains unclear why some patients with gluten sensitivity
present solely with neurological dysfunction when others present with
gastrointentestinal symptoms (gluten sensitive enteropathy) or an itchy skin
rash (dermatitis herpetiformis).
Although the cerebellum (the part of the brain responsible for
coordination) and in particular the Purkinje cells (output neurons of the
cerebellum) appear to be most susceptible to damage in patients with gluten
ataxia, other areas of the brain are not spared. We were interested to
determine the mechanism by which Purkinje cells are damaged in gluten ataxia,
commented Hadjivassiliou. Study results show that patients with gluten ataxia
have antibodies against Purkinje cells and also that antibodies against gluten (antigliadin
antibodies) cross-react with Purkinje cells.
These results strengthen our contention that eliminating these antibodies
through strict adherence to a gluten-free diet may have important therapeutic
implications for patients with gluten ataxia, concluded Hadjivassiliou.
The study was supported by the Friedreich's Ataxia Group, UK, and the
Telethon Foundation, Italy.
The American Academy of Neurology, an association of 18,000 neurologists and
neuroscience professionals, is dedicated to improving patient care through
education and research..
Federal money will go specifically for training teachers to deal with
autistic students if a bill sponsored by Reps. Christopher H. Smith, R-N.J., and
Michael Doyle, D-Pa., becomes law.
The Teacher Education for Autistic Children, or TEACH, Act would appropriate
$20 million over five years for training teachers and paraprofessionals, and
provide a tax credit for educators who take training courses in teaching the
autistic.
"We've made a number of gains in addressing the autistic issue over the past
few years, but we need to go further," Smith said yesterday. "The TEACH act will
help us reach our goal."
Smith and Doyle expected to introduce the bill in Congress today or Monday.
No federal money is specifically directed to training of teachers who deal
with the autistic. The federal government budgets about $140 million annually
for special-education teacher training.
Autism, first identified in the 1940s, is a developmental disorder that
impairs a person's social interaction and language skills. Though it once was
thought to be rare, recent studies -- one of which was conducted in Brick --
made use of state-of-the-art techniques for detecting the disorder and found
that autism occurs in up to one in every 150 children. Even with less thorough
detection methods, autism rates have been found to be increasing dramatically.
The cause is unknown, although the majority of researchers believe it is
genetic. There is no known cure, although the disorder can be treated. But
treatment requires trained professionals, and that, like continued research,
requires money.
Smith, whose district includes parts of Ocean and Monmouth counties, was one
of the catalysts for the Brick study and has been in the forefront in trying to
get federal money for training and research in autism.
The TEACH bill would authorize $15 million in grants, administered by the
federal Department of Education under its Special Education Personnel
Preparation program, for training both special-education and regular classroom
teachers and aides. Some $5 million more would be meted out by states under the
federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.
A professional who takes a certified course in teaching the autistic would be
eligible for an income tax credit up to $10,000. In addition, the bill calls for
reports on the effectiveness of strategies from the grantees and the appointment
of a task force to further study the ailment and how schools should deal with
it. "It's a good bill," said David O. Weiss, director of student services in
Lacey. "We've hardly scratched the surface regarding what we know and what we
need to know about autism. More and more children are being diagnosed . . . and
it is so critical to reach these students in the first years."
"It's a step in the right direction," said Bob Lanzieri, a Brick resident and
co-founder of Parents of Autistic Children. "Some of us have been saying for
several years that there have got to be better ways of teaching the autistic.
This funding can help us get the better methods into the classrooms."
In related actions, Smith is seeking through appropriations legislation to
increase federal autism research funding from $65 million to $100 million at the
National Institute of Health, and from $9.2 million to $17.2 million at the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
More special education students than ever graduated with standard high school
diplomas in 1999, the Education Department said Friday in its annual report to
Congress.
Special education programs serve a variety of students whose disabilities can
include mental retardation, blindness, hearing impairments, emotional
disturbances, dyslexia, autism or other conditions.
Congress currently is preparing to rewrite regulations on special education.
Most Democrats and a few Republicans have pushed for millions of dollars more in
federal money for schools to serve disabled students and a congressional
commitment to make yearly increases in special education. They say the
government has met less than half of its commitment to give states 40 percent of
the money they need to help students with a range of disabilities.
Republicans and the Bush administration have blocked the efforts, saying
states and schools must fix the current system before Congress increases funding
substantially.
In its report, the Education Department noted that:
--A record 57.4 percent of special education students graduated from high
school with standard diplomas in 1998-99, up from 51.9 percent in 1993-94.
--Dropout rates for special education students fell to 28.9 percent in
1998-99, down from 34.5 percent in 1993-94.
"Progress continues to be made, but at a time when barely half of students
with disabilities are graduating on time from high school, we still have a long
way to go," said Education Secretary Rod Paige.
Bill East, executive director of the National Association of State Directors
of Special Education, said the improvements weren't surprising, since states and
school districts have been working hard on both issues.
"If the education community as a whole continues to focus on graduation rates
and dropout rates, ... then we're going to continue to see better numbers," East
said.
The report also noted that more students with disabilities are being educated
in regular classes than ever before, with 47.4 percent of students in
"inclusion" programs. By contrast, in the 1984-85 school year, one-fourth of
special education students spent most of their school day in regular classrooms.
Black students continued to be overrepresented in special education
classes: in 1999-2000, they made up about 21 percent of special education
students ages 6-21, while representing just over 17 percent of all students.
By contrast, white students represent about 63 percent of students but only
62 percent of special education students. Hispanic students also accounted for a
smaller proportion of special education students, 14.5 percent, compared with
their enrollment of more than 15 percent.
* * *
DREDF Tracking IDEA Political Developments
[Thanks to Ben Dorman on the ASA-ChapterNetwork list.]
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"