* Action Alert: Drug Companies Out to Gut Vaccine Compensation Reform
RESEARCH
* Lay Summary Explanation of Murch, "Wakefield" Study
EDUCATION
* Challenges of Special Ed Extend To Finding Teachers
CARE/TREATMENT
* Editorial: Mental Health Parity
* British TV Shows 'Linked To Pond Drownings'
* Asher's Assuring Progress Is Kiddie Garden's Reward
* Drugs For Ossie Children, US-Style, On The Rise
AWARENESS
* China Has 400,000 to 500,000 Children Suffering from Autism
* Xingxingyu: Boon for Families With Autistic Children
* Readers' Posts
Action Alert: Drug Companies Out to Gut Vaccine Compensation Reform
[From from New York Attorney John F. McHugh.]
As you may know Congressman Dave Weldon of Florida and Jerold Nadler of New
York had introduced a bill to make obtaining compensation under the Vaccine
Injury Compensation Program easier. Today I was informed by Stuart Burns.
Congressman Weldon's legislative director, that the bill, now sponsored by Dan
Burton of Indiana and Henry Waxman of California, is in trouble. The vaccine
manufacturers have lobbied heavily against it.
The Bill is HR 3741, the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program
Improvement Act of 2002. Mr. Burns tells me that to get this bill passed we need
to have a major letter writing campaign by parents of injured children directed
both to the representative and to the
J. Dennis Hastert, Speaker,
United States House of Representatives,
The Capitol,
Washington, D.C. 20515.
Fax: 202-225-0697.
If we do not do this, the bill has only about a 30% chance of passage. Local
representatives need to be urged to co-sponsor the bill. The Speaker must be
urged to bring the bill up for a vote. If possible parents should visit their
representative's district office and if possible ask to speak to the
representative personally.
The bill provides for the payment of the costs of medical experts from the
trust fund as they are incurred. This provision will be particularly useful to
the parents of Autism Spectrum children as the tests needed to link this type of
disorder to a vaccine are expensive and hard to find. Further, expert witnesses
who are willing to testify in vaccine cases are also hard to find as many
doctors fear ostracism by their profession if they
do so. It is equally useful to parents who do not have surplus funds as
the medical costs which must be incurred to prove even a case supposedly
automatically covered by the Vaccine Act can be considerable.
The bill also deals with the statute of limitations problem. Most parents and
practitioners do not connect their child's disability to a vaccine immediately.
Sometimes medical practitioners never make the connection. Therefore, many
parents do not learn of either the cause of their child's disability or of the
compensation program until the limitations period has expired. This bill extends
the period from three years to six years and allows anyone with a claim which
has now expired to file within two years of the bills becoming law.
This situation is urgent. Thank you for your assistance to these Congressmen
who have taken up this cause, notably a coalition of conservative Republicans
with Liberal Democrats. If these diverse thinkers can see the need for this
Bill, those of us most affected must help. A suggested text of the two letters
now needed is following, but if you can draft your own that would be preferable,
particularly if you can explain your own situation emphasizing that you are a
constituent of the representative addressed.
* * *
Lay Summary Explanation of Murch, "Wakefield" Study
[In yesterday's FEAT Newsletter we clipped and reprinted the abstract for the
latest research paper from Murch, Wakefield, et al. titled "Small intestinal
enteropathy with epithelial IgG and complement deposition in children with
regressive autism." under the headline "New Wakefield Study Finds A Novel Form
Of Enteropathy in ASD Kids". Thanks to Richard Miles.]
This study is part of a continuing investigation into a novel
gastrointestinal pathology in children with regressive autism. Inflammatory
pathology has already been confirmed in the large intestine and upper
gastrointestinal tract by independent investigators.
The current study confirms the presence of immunopathology in the mucosal
lining of the small intestine. It identifies the unique nature of the pathology
when compared with developmentally normal children with normal intestinal
tissues, those with known inflammatory pathologies, and children with mental
retardation without autism.
The study reports the detection of an antibody in the circulating blood of
affected children that binds to a target(s) molecules on the membrane of the
epithelial cells that line the intestine. The antibody appears to bind in the
same distribution as a chemical complement component C1Q - that forms part of
the activated inflammatory cascade. The co-localisation of these two molecules
at this site is unique to the children with regressive autism and indicates a
likely autoimmune basis to the intestinal disease, in which the bodies immune
system turns upon itself to cause tissue injury.
Autoimmune diseases tend to occur in families, and are often linked to a
genetic susceptibility that requires an environmental trigger to initiate and
propagate the disease itself. The pathology in these children is consistent with
a virally driven autoimmune entero-colitis (intestinal inflammation), and the
study adds an important piece to the evolving jigsaw of autistic regression,
intestinal disease and the presence of measles virus in many affected children.
Hundreds of thousands of American students need the benefits of special
education, but nearly half of the nation's special ed teachers aren't qualified
to provide them, according to a national education group.
More than 30,000 special education teachers nationwide teach without the
appropriate license, reports the Council for Exceptional Children, a teachers
organization.
"It's pretty dismal," said Lynda VanKuren, council spokeswoman. "You have
your inexperienced people or teachers who aren't even prepared to take the
special education classes."
In Arizona, the state Department of Education has been under scrutiny, the
result of a lawsuit by parents claiming the state failed to meet the needs of
their special education children.
"When fully certified teachers can't be found, the vacancies are filled with
people on emergency certifications; the law allows for that," said Steve
Mishlove, Arizona's director of Exceptional Student Services.
"There is no requirement . . . to have special education training or
experience."
Federal laws don't require school districts to inform parents about a
teacher's lack of qualifications.
Arizona has granted about 400 emergency credentials this year to help teach
some of its 100,000 special education students. Arizona has about 6,500 special
education teachers.
Finding qualified teachers is an uphill battle for many reasons, including
low pay, a high volume of paperwork, heavy caseloads, lack of support and
limited resources.
Kathy Smith, a 30-year special education veteran, is familiar with the job's
many challenges. Her 10-hour days include working with other teachers, aides and
seven students with multiple disabilities. At lunch, she feeds a student with
Down syndrome.
"Some of the students can be very challenging," said Smith, who works at
Carminati Elementary School in Tempe. "But your pay is the satisfaction in
knowing that you have had a positive impact on students and families."
VanKuren said, "Special education teachers are more likely to leave than
general education teachers. It's a hard job, bottom line. It takes our kids a
long time to learn."
The state Education Department has intensified efforts to increase the pool
of special education teachers by working with colleges and universities on
internship programs, upgrading its online job bank, recruiting teachers from
other states and applying for a $5 million federal grant.
The grant would be used to hire more teachers, improve special education
services at charter schools and implement reading programs.
A typical day
Smith's busy schedule is fairly typical of those who choose to be special
education teachers. Her day is organized into half-hour sessions, including
teaching sign language to third-graders and working one-on-one with students on
reading.
And Smith has developed a lunchtime game for her Down syndrome student.
"Bite number one, let's go," Smith says. The student takes a bite after about
two minutes. "Good job," she says. "Bite number two, you know what to do."
After five bites, the student is rewarded with a gulp of chocolate milk. Then
the game continues.
Smith works with students from kindergarten through sixth grade who have
multiple disabilities, including autism, hearing loss and speech problems.
Teaching such a range of students requires creativity.
She develops strategies with other teachers to get students to pay attention.
For example, she suggests a kindergarten teacher touch one student and tell him
he is off task rather than just communicating verbally. Some students respond
better to touching.
Smith also recently developed a color-coded card system to teach sentence
composition to a student who may be autistic. The colored cards serve as cues:
subjects are yellow, verbs are green, adjectives are blue and articles are
orange.
Teachers hard to find
A recent state survey showed that teachers for students with multiple
disabilities are in highest demand. But the state also found a scarcity of
specialized teachers, such as occupational and physical therapists and autism
specialists.
"Even for the lower incidences of impairment, it's still a challenge to find
qualified personnel," said Miriam Podrazik of the state Education Department,
who helps recruit special ed teachers.
Podrazik recently attended the National Council for Exceptional Children
conference, where she found 50 special ed teaching candidates interested in
Arizona. Low starting salaries are the chief barrier to recruitment, Podrazik
said.
"When you talk to students, the first question they ask is: 'What is the
starting salary?'" she said. "So that's a significant hurdle."
The average special education teacher in Arizona earns about $26,000, just
$1,000 more than general education teachers.
"So even when they're hired, many leave the field for higher-paying jobs,"
Podrazik said.
Diane Bruening, director of special education for Chandler Unified, said her
district's starting salary for special education teachers is about $32,000.
"Even that salary is pretty miserable for someone with a professional
degree," Bruening said.
Podrazik and Bruening said another obstacle is the workload required by the
143-page 1997 Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. More than 60 percent
of special education teachers spend a half-day to a day and a half a week doing
paperwork, according to a survey by the Council for Exceptional Children.
A long way to go
Karen Deadrick became a special education teacher after she struggled to find
adequate services for her child, who is learning disabled.
"Having a child in special education, I know just how difficult it can be,"
Deadrick said. She works at Westwind Academy charter school in Phoenix.
Despite the job's additional challenges, Smith said special education has
come a long way. When she started her career, special education students were
institutionalized because few educators knew how to reach out to these students.
Federal special education laws were adopted in 1975.
"This is a good time to be in special education," Smith said. "It's hard work
and it has its challenges, but people in special education have such an
important role they need someone to advocate for them. They need someone to . .
. make sure their needs are met."
Bucking the insurance industry and business interests who have argued that
mandated mental health coverage would add billions to already soaring health
care costs, President Bush last week signaled support for increasing insurance
coverage for the mentally ill. "Our health insurance system must treat mental
illness like any other disease," the president said. Overall, that's good news.
The president is right to support expanded coverage for mental illnesses.
Still, the cost concerns raised by business groups cannot be ignored. A
bipartisan mental health bill pending in Congress would require companies that
offer mental health coverage to do so on parity with coverage they offer their
employees with physical ailments.
That means a patient would be charged the same co-pay for a her asthma
medicine as for drugs to control her depression; the same deductible would apply
for a toddler's visit to the pediatrician for an ear infection as for a suicidal
teenager's visit to the psychologist's office.
All that makes sense. But the breadth of the federal legislation should give
Congress pause. As currently drafted, the measure would force companies to cover
every mental disorder listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, the bible of mental illness. As one would expect, the manual lists
things like schizophrenia or manic depression. But it also lists a range of
emotional upsets that most people would dismiss as the ordinary stresses of
modern life. Among them, jet lag, caffeine induced sleep disorder, malingering,
academic and occupational problems.
Rather than forcing employers to provide insurance coverage for this
exhaustive list of mental ailments, Congress should follow California's lead.
California's 2-year-old mental health parity law limits mandated coverage to
only severe mental illness, including but not limited to such conditions as
schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorders, anorexia, autism,
bulimia and any serious emotional disturbance of a child.
Mental illness is real and can be every bit as debilitating as cancer or
heart disease. Untreated, it can lead to complete mental break downs and costly
hospitalization. Even the life stress issues can cause extreme pain, even
incapacitation. But there is a limit to what employers can realistically afford
to pay. The president and Congress can look westward for a sensible balance of
compassion and realism.
Gardening programmes on television may be partly to blame for a sharp rise in
the number of children drowning in garden ponds, researchers have suggested.
A study found that while the overall number of children drowning in the UK
had fallen over a 10 year period, the number of deaths caused by children
falling into ponds had almost doubled.
The researchers said the rise might be due to an increased number of water
features in gardens - perhaps inspired by TV gardening shows.
The team, from the University of Wales College of Medicine, the Royal Life
Saving Society, and the Royal Society for Prevention of Accidents, compared
statistics for deaths by drowning in children aged up to 14 in 1988-9 and
1998-9.
They looked at drownings in baths, garden ponds, domestic pools, private and
public pools, rivers, canals, lakes and the sea.
In total, 104 children drowned in 1998-9, compared with 149 in 1988-9.
In all categories, except garden ponds, there were as many or fewer deaths in
1998-9 compared to 10 years earlier.
Eleven children drowned in garden ponds in 1988-9, but this figure rose to 21
a decade later.
Three times more boys than girls drowned during both periods, and autistic
children were particularly at risk, the researchers found.
* * *
Asher's Assuring Progress Is Kiddie Garden's Reward
When 9-year-old Asher Johnson-Dorman threw loud, raving temper tantrums that
lasted a half-hour or more at Kiddie Garden, his after-school child care center,
owner Paula Matheos could have said the autistic child needed more than her
staff could provide, and shaken Catriona Johnson's world.
"As a parent, you worry that somebody's going to come and say, 'Sorry, his
behavior is too bad we can't take him in,'" Johnson, Asher's mother, said. "I'm
not hearing that. I'm hearing, 'Let's get technical assistance, let's get more
information, let's get a copy of the school behavior plan, let's get more
training.'"
Kiddie Garden is one of several child care businesses and programs that were
honored last week by the county Child Care Resource Center during the fourth
annual Celebrating Successes awards reception.
The event highlighted 65 individuals, child care and early childhood
education programs and businesses throughout the county that have made a
difference in the life of a child.
Although Kiddie Garden teaches about 70 children each week and is seeking
accreditation of its early childhood education program from the state, it is
being recognized by the county for helping Asher.
The school, founded in 1996 by Matheos and her husband, George, does not
specialize in working with children with special needs, but the award highlights
the need for more centers like theirs in Laurel.
The Americans with Disabilities Act provides for special needs children to be
able to attend any child care center - it is up to the center to show if there
is too much of a burden.
But a 2001 report on care for children with special needs by the Maryland
Committee for Children showed many proprietors are reluctant to accept children
with special needs in their programs because of liability issues and the costs
of adding and training staff members. The industry is burdened with staffing
problems of high turnover rates, low wages and few or no benefits.
"They can't afford to hire another staff to be with children one on one ...
[for] children with emotional needs. That is a very legitimate thing," said
Vickie Scrivener, special projects co- ordinator at the Howard County Child Care
Resource Center, who was on the steering committee that produced the report.
"There's a lot involved in every child with a special need, even if it's
asthma," she said. "You need a protocol for the child's medication - what sets
the asthma off, how severe does it get before I call 911?"
The need for child care is expanding in the county. Census figures for 2000
show Howard County has the highest percentage in the state of children younger
than age 5. As the number of centers grows to accommodate the need, child care
providers should pay more attention to providing for special-needs kids, said
Debbie Yare, program manager for the county's resource center.
Too often, children like Asher, whose behavior is difficult to control, don't
stay in one place long, she said.
"Those kids are dismissed from one center, and they're bounced around from
center to center," Yare said. "That's why its so wonderful what's going on with
Kiddie Garden because they're really working with Asher."
Asher's mother knows that scenario well. Kiddie Garden is the first center
that her son, who has moderate to severe autism, has been able to stay in since
he was about 4 years old.
When Asher arrived at Kiddie Garden in September, he would wander around the
center with no regard for the routine, or he would play alone, counting objects
and building with toys, staff members said.
Fascinated with machinery, he loved the hum of the fans coming through the
ventilation ducts - so much so that the center incurred high electric bills
before officials found that Asher had discovered the thermostat and was turning
the fans on at will.
Karen Tracht, Asher's teacher at the center, got help from Project Act, a
program of the nonprofit Abilities Network Inc. that trains and provides
technical assistance to teachers of special-needs children to help the kids
learn and be included. She also asked Johnson questions, and got information
from Asher's school to learn the phrases and activities to which he responded
best.
Over time, Tracht has learned a few key things about Asher and about
communicating with children who have autism - how to use pictures to prepare him
for changes in his schedule, and how a pair of safety goggles and a cold Sprite
soda make Asher feel more comfortable.
Most important, the staff at Kiddie Garden has better learned how to tackle
the biggest challenge with autistic children - drawing them out and helping them
socialize.
Now one of Asher's favorite games is one he plays with Tracht. He pretends to
be a school bus, slowly swinging his arm out perpendicular to his body like the
yellow bar on a bus and holding it there. Tracht waits patiently until Asher
tells her she can go.
doctor who is writing out a prescripton. She says ". . .and his dad's
never there and he watches lots of telly and he eats junk food."
Doctor replies: "All of which can be fixed with medication."
Australian doctors are following United States trends by prescribing an
increasing range of mood-altering and behaviour-controlling drugs to children,
according to a survey to be unveiled this week.
Medications for aggression, anxiety and sleep disorders are being given to
children younger than three, and some parents are misusing the drugs by giving
them to siblings with sleeping problems, the study found.
Little was known about the long-term effects of some of the drugs on
children, particularly the mixing of medications, said researcher and Royal
Children's Hospital paediatrician Daryl Efron.
"I don't think there is cause for alarm (but) there is cause for concern and
we need guidelines on their use," he said. "We need further research to ensure
the gaps in research . . . are filled and research catches up with the
practice."
Dr Efron said the study tried to discover what was happening with drugs other
than Ritalin, the use of which boomed in Australia in the early 1990s. "Ritalin
is old news and most people think that it's appropriate treatment for children
with ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder)," he said.
"There were reports from the United States of a big trend using other
medications beyond stimulants. Anecdotally, it seemed to have started in
Australia."
Dr Efron said there was no national data on the amount of drugs prescribed to
children. Data on drugs that are on the PBS, such as Ritalin, did not
differentiate between adult and child recipients, he said.
The nationwide survey asked paediatricians and psychiatrists for children and
adolescents about their prescriptions of psychostimulants, clonidine,
antidepressants, neuroleptics and mood stabilisers in the preceding 12 months,
and asked what, if any, drugs they would prescribe in nine hypothetical
situations.
The survey was completed in late 2000 by more than 600 doctors (more than 70
per cent of those sent a questionnaire). It will be presented to the Royal
Australasian College of Physicians conference in Brisbane on Wednesday.
"It pretty much confirms the impression from anecdotes reported that these
trends from the US are being repeated in Australia," said Dr Efron. "There is an
increasing menu of psychotropic medication which is being prescribed to
Australian children."
Statistics show among the 380 million Chinese children about 400,000 to
500,000 are suffering from autism, who need concern and help from the whole
society.
Statistics show among the 380 million Chinese children about 400,000 to
500,000 are suffering from autism, who need concern and help from the whole
society.
Many children, being the only-one child in their families, are over-protected
by their parents, being restricted to a narrow confine of living and lack of
exercise for both body and mind. Besides, many parents, not knowing much about
children's mind, experience much more problems on children's behavior.
Some children, though "emperor" of the family, are as timid as a mouse on
public occasions, some having difficulty in concentrating and others being
sluggish in action. In most cases, they are not "naughty" or "awkward", but
autistic and in an ill state of mind.
Now the problem of autistic children has roused wide concern from related
departments, and three advanced treating centers have been set up in Beijing, an
expert said. There have appeared more and more doctors for psychological
treatment, hoping to usher autistic children into a warm, colorful reality
world.
* * *
Xingxingyu: Boon for Families With Autistic Children
Xingxingyu (Star Rain) Education Institute for Autistic Children, or
Xingxingyu for short, is playing an increasingly important role in helping
families with autistic children.
Nearly 500 families with autistic children across China have benefited by
Xingxingyu, which lies on the outskirts of Beijing, since it was founded in 1993
by Tian Huiping, whose 15-year-old son was diagnosed as profoundly autistic 11
years ago.
Up to now, 10 children who have gone through the school's short- term
training programs have been accepted by normal schools and special schools,
including Tian's son, who stayed at Xingxingyu for two years.
There are 600,000 Chinese diagnosed with autism, 500,000 of them are
children. But other than Xingxingyu, there is no hospital on the Chinese
mainland or other facility specializing in care of autistic children.
Tian said that her center does not attempt to cure children with autism. "The
most we can hope for is to draw these special- needs pre-school children out of
their own world into a normal reality," says Tian.
The facility enrolls special-needs children, aged between three and six, who
work with their parents in 10-week training programs that cost 3,000 yuan (about
US$361.5). It does not board students, so parents and children have to live
outside the school, mostly renting housing from farmers nearby.
As a NGO, Xingxingyu is largely dependent on international donations, said
Tian Huiping.
According to Tian, the waiting list is so long that some parents will have to
wait until 2003 to get help for their children. "Some of them want to come back
for a second training program," said Tian.
Other parents who cannot wait have invited teachers from Xingxingyu to their
homes to give lectures on the special therapy advocated by the school.
Encouraged by the success of Xingxingyu, Tian is considering opening a
training program for teenage children with autism and their parents.
* * *
Readers' Posts
To parents of school-age children in Ontario with Autism Spectrum Disorders
Re: Education Survey for Parents of Children with ASD. A Province-wide parent
survey is being conducted by Autism Society Ontario until June 1, 2002. It was
designed to empower parents of children with ASD with useful information about
the education of their children in Ontario. To accomplish this, an electronic
survey was designed. Before June 1st, 2002, parents are invited to participate
by going to:
We are the custodial grandparents of a ten-year old girl who has a condition
known as Lennox-Gastaut syndrome and who displays autistic behavior. We are in
need of any resources near Kentucky which may offer training and respite care.
Please respond to: Wallyg8er1@aol.com
******
Moving to the Houston area end of July. My son is 7 years-old with
mild/moderate austism. Looking for contacts for support groups, advice on
schools, anything that will help. I am a single mom and have been struggling for
five years trying to get him the help he needs. I hear that the system in Texas
is better than here in Colorado. tlmwilson@yahoo.com Tamra Wilson, mother of
Henry.
******
Has anyone had any experience (good or bad) with York Nutritional Labs in
Hollywood, FL? Offers a food test, but does it work? dvm77@juno.com
******
The Gray Center for Social Learning and Understanding (a non-profit
organization dedicated to individuals with autistic spectrum disorders and those
who interact with them in the home, school, workplace, and community) now has a
new web site at
www.thegraycenter.org.
Visit it for information on our upcoming autism conference in Grand Rapids, MI,
and to purchase a gfcf cookbook and Carol Gray's newest Social Stories book!
Laurel Hoekman
******
>> FREE (Almost) READERS POSTS <<
For Individuals, organizations, non-commercial and
commercial. Limit your posting to no more than 60
words please. There is no charge for this service,
but posters are obligated to thank all those who take
the time to answer your ads. This is a consideration
for others with autism after you and yours, who seek
assistance from appreciated readers. Send submissions to:
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"