Reik L Jr: Disseminated vasculomyelinopathy: an immune complex disease. Ann
Neurol 7:291-295, 1980 Disseminated Vasculomyelinopathy: An Immune Complex
Disease Louis Reik, Jr, MD
The numerous nervous system abnormalities which follow antecedent infections
and immunizations appear to share a common pathogenesis involving the immune
system. Pathologically, a small vessel vasculopathy involving arterioles and
capillaries as well as venules in both gray and white matter is the earliest and
most consistent change. Perivascular demyelination appears to develop
subsequently. Delayed hypersensitivity to myelin basic protein may not
adequately account for these changes.
Humoral immunity may be involved instead. I postulate that antigen-antibody
complexes, formed following the introduction of foreign antigen by infection or
inoculation, cause vascular injury with secondary damage to myelin. There is
considerable evidence that circulating immune complexes are present in some
postinfectious nervous system disorders, as are associated systemic features
which suggest immune complex disease. Similar clinical and pathological nervous
system changes occur in a variety of disorders in which circulating immune
complexes are thought to cause vascular injury.
Reik L Jr: Disseminated vasculomyelinopathy: an immune complex disease. Ann
Neurol 7:291-295, 1980
There is general agreement that the postinfectious and postvaccinal disorders
of the nervous system represent an "allergic" phenomenon. Current hypotheses
concerning their pathogenesis focus on the cellular immune system and an attack
on the myelin sheath with subsequent demyelination [4, 6, 15, 32]. Such
hypotheses have developed largely as a result of the clinical and
histopathological similarity between these human disorders and experimental
allergic neuritis (EAN) and experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) in
laboratory animals, both of which appear to result from delayed hypersensitivity
to myelin basic proteins [4, 15,32]. They gain support from the demonstration of
both sensitized lymphocytes in patients with Guillain-Barré syndrome or Bells
palsy capable of demyelinating peripheral nerve in culture [4] and of lymphocyte
sensitization to nerve tissue antigen in a variety of postinfectious disorders
[6, 15, 35].
These immune alterations may not be causal in humans, however, since not all
affected patients possess such sensitized lymphocytes [13, 35]. Although failure
to demonstrate sensitized lymphocytes in humans may reflect their appearance in
the peripheral circulation in numbers too small to detect or result from
inadequacies inherent in in vitro tests, the development of delayed
hypersensitivity to myelin may be merely an epiphenomenon resulting from nervous
tissue damage, since it also develops after cerebral infarction [35]. Indeed,
the Guillian-Barré syndrome has developed in an immunosuppressed patient
apparently incapable of demonstrating delayed hypersensitivity [13]. In
addition, both EAE and EAN follow sensitization with injections of Freunds
adjuyant and nervous system antigen. How a wide variety of infections,
immunizations, and vaccinations could induce similar sensitization to myelin
basic protein has not been satisfactorily explained. Only the complications
following inoculation against rabies with the nerve tissue antirabies vaccine
are strictly comparable.
The histopathological features in postinfectious diseases of the nervous
system were recently reviewed at length by Poser [32], who noted that vascular
changes almost invariably accompany demyelination. To stress the importance of
vascular involvement, he used the term disseminated vasculornyelinopathy and
suggested that vasculopathy may both precede and initiate the nervous tissue
damage itself. Vascular alterations do occur in EAE and may in fact be more
prominent, overshadowing demyelination, when the course is fulminant [15]..
However, the recent detection of circulating antigen-antibody complexes in serum
from patients with a variety of postinfectious disordeis [16, 19, 39] suggests
an alternative explanation-one that accounts for a primary vascular lesion,
secondary damage to myelin, and a uniform response to a wide variety of
precipitating events.
The Hypothesis
Common to all the postinfectious and postvaccinal complications affecting the
nervous system is the initial introduction of a foreign antigen, through either
invasion or inoculation, followed by a variable period free of nervous system
symptoms and then clinical nervous system involvement. During this asymptomatic
period, antibodies could form and combine with the foreign antigen to form
circulating immune complexes. If such complexes are of appropriate size and
contain the correct proportion of antigen to antibody, they can cause systemic
liberation of vasoactive substances. An increase in vascular permeability
results, complexes are trapped in vessel walls in a focal fashion, complement is
activated, and inflammatory cells accumulate and release proteolytic enzymes,
causing tissue injury [11]. Diffuse and multifocal involvement of both the
central and peripheral nervous systems could result from such a vasculopathy,
with the occurrence of limited or localized forms of nervous system injury
depending on the size and number of complexes formed, the inherent properties of
the vessels, and the chance occurrence of localized deposition. Because
perivascular demyelination can result from vascular injury alone [32], the
participation of delayed hypersensitivity would not be necessary. The host and
its ability to make antibody, not the antecedent illness, would thus be the
major factor in development of neurological disease: the clinical and
histopathological features would be the same regardless of the initiating event.
Examination of the clinical, laboratory, and histopathological features of
disseminated vasculomyelinopathy and comparison with other human disorders in
which immune complexes circulate and cause, or are thought to cause, vascular
injury lends support to this hypothesis.
Disseminated Vasculomyelinopathy
The Clinical and Pathological Spectrum
The data collected by Miller, Stanton, and Gibbons [26] establish that a wide
variety of clinical disturbances follow such common infections as rubeola,
rubella, varicella, scarlet fever, and mumps after a similar latent period of a
few days to several weeks. The disease is monophasic and the clinical onset
usually abrupt, with signs of multiple lesions throughout the nervous system. In
addition to encephalitis, which is frequently multifocal, cerebellar ataxia,
aseptic menigitis, chorea, myelitis, cranial neuritis (including optic
neuritis), mononeuritis, brachial neuritis, and Guillain-Barré syndrome all
arise, either singly or in combination [26, 32]. The occurrence of these
abnormalities is apparently independent of the nature, severity, and cause of
the antecedent infection [26, 32],and with only rare exceptions, the virus has
not been isolated from the nervous system in such cases [29]. The. same broad
range of nervous system abnormalities occurs after a variety of immunizations
and vaccinations [25], and clinically identical illness may follow banal upper
respiratory infections and gastrointestinal disturbances, or even occur
sporadically without identifiable antecedent infection [32].
The pathological changes in all these cases- postinfectious and postvaccinal
as well as apparently sporadic-are identical [10, 29, 32]. Although current
textbooks of neuropathology emphasize perivenous lymphocytic infiltration and
demyelination in cerebral white matter [10, 29], a wide variety of pathological
reactions actually occurs at all levels of the nervous system. Lesions of small
blood vessels are consistently present and are more prominent and more frequent
than demyelination in patients dying soon after onset [17, 26, 32]. The lesions
range from perivascular edema and lymphocytic infiltrates and endothelial
proliferation in the usual postinfectious encephalitis to vessel wall necrosis,
fibrinoid degeneration, infiltrates of neutrophils and eosinophils, and
perivascular hemorrhage in acute hemorrhage leukoencephalitis [10, 17, 26, 29,
32]. Identical lesions occur in arterioles and capillaries as well as venules
[10, 32] and are frequently more common in the cerebral cortex, basal ganglia,
and gray matter of brainstem and spinal cord than in white matter [10, 17]. The
frequency of demyelination may also be overestimated: axons are often
substantially affected in addition, and a clear differentiation between
perivascular demyelination and necrosis has not always been made [17, 32].
The frequent occurrence of these various syndromes after the same
antecedents, often in combination with one another, and their similar
pathological features suggest they all may share a common pathogenesis.
Conventional wisdom would, however, remove some of them from consideration,
especially the Guillain-Barré syndrome. This objection is due, in large part, to
the insistence of many clinicians that the term be restricted to those patients
in whom only the spinal roots and peripheral nerves are affected. The problem
may be largely one of semantics. Transitional cases with central nervous system
involvement have been reported frequently, with nervous system abnormalities
ranging from isolated Babinski signs, meningismus, or electroe ncephalographic
changes to frank encephalomyclitis [9, 18, 33, 36]. Even in cases without
clinical central nervous system involvement, lesions, mainly vascular, of the
central nervous system are present postmortem in up to 20% and include vascular
dilatation in the spinal cord and leptomeninges vith meningeal inflammatory cell
infiltrates, perivascular lymphocytic infiltrates in cerebral white matter and
subependyma; and petechial hemorrhages in the gray matter of brain and spinal
cord [18, 36].
Evidence for Immune Complex Disease
These arguments are of some importance in the case of Guillain-Barré
syndrome, since circulating immune complexes have been detected by both the Raji
cell assay and binding of the Clq component of complement in up to 93% of
affected patients [16, 39]. Although immune complexes have not been localized at
sites of vessel injury, some circumstantial evidence suggests they may be
involved in pathogenisis. Typical polyneuritis occurs in the course of serum
sickness and systemic lupus erythematosus, both disorders thought to be caused
by immune coplex vasculitis, as well as in association with a variety of
infections and immunizations [4, 14, 25]. Onset is usually one to three weeks
after the initiating event in postvaccinal and postinfectious cases; but it is
worth noting that polyneuritis following typhoid-pararyphoid immunization
usually begins three days following the second injection (its onset sometimes
coinciding with the appearance of an urticarial rash [4, 25]), since the
"incubation" period for serum sickness is similarly shortened to one to four
days by a previous sensitizing injection [11]. The pathogenesis is assumed to be
the same in all cases since the pathological features are the same [4]. Vascular
changes occur first (vasodilatation, endothelial swelling, perivascular edema,
and infiltration of lymphocytes and, occasionally, neutrophils) and are followed
only later by perivascular demyelination [4,18].
Some systemic features of the Guillain-Barré syndrome are also consistent
with immune complex disease: myalgias and arthralgias are frequent [4, 18],
muscle tenderness is common [18], skin rash may occur at onset [4, 25], the
sedimentation rate and leukocyte count are elevated [18, 36], and albuminuria
and azotemia occur [18, 36]. In some patients with albuminuria, immune complex
glomerulonephritis has been present, and epimembranous deposits of 1gM, IgG, and
C3 have been identified by immunofluorescence [5, 31]. Pathological changes
similar to those of serum sickness also occasionally occcur in other organs:
perivascular inflammatory cell infiltrates in skeletal muscle and heart, focal
mononuclear and polymorphonuclear infiltrates in liver, and focal phlebitis of
the coronary veins have all been described [9, 18].
Some evidence is also available to suggest that circulating immune complexes
may be involved in other postinfectious disorders. Complexes have been detected
in 45% of patients with monosymptomatic optic neuritis and in single cases of
acute disseminated encephalomyelitis and poststreprococcal encephalitis [19, 39]
An association between postinfectious encephalitis and renal injury, a frequent
manifestation of immune complex disease, has also been noted [7]; about 25% of
patients with acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis have proteinuria [6] and
occasional cases of postvaccinal encephalitis are associated with systemic
vasculitis [38].
Human Immune Complex Disease
Serum sickness, the model for immune complex disease in humans, develops
experimentally when antigen-antibody complexes-formed in the presence of antigen
excess appear in the circulation. Serum complement falls, and vascular lesions
develop in which immune complexes containing antigen, antibody, and components
of complement can be demonstrated by immunofluorescence [11]. Various lesions
occur, ranging from endothelial proliferition, increased vascular permeability,
and variable infiltration of vessel walls by neutrophil leukocytes to
perivascular mononuclear cell infiltration and even noninflammatory,
degeneration, depending on the amount of antigen-antibody interaction. The
tissue response is apparently independent of the antigen administered since a
wide variety of serum proteins produce the same lesions. The amount of antibody
formed is the key to subsequent development of immune complex disease: complexes
formed when antibody synthesis is minimal are too small to activate complement
or be retarded at vascular filtering surfaces, and complexes formed at marked
antibody excess are insoluble. The character of the host as an antibody former
is thus paramount in determining the development of immune complex disease, and
disease may be more likely in relatively poor antibody formers [11].
Clinically, serum sickness in humans begins seven to ten days after the
injection of foreign protein, with fever, malaise, urticaria, joint pains,
lymphadenopathy, and immune complex nephritis [11]. Like Guillain-Barré
syndrome, it has developed in immunosuppressed renal transplant recipients [21].
Neurological abnormalities are frequent in serum sickness, sometimes occur
without accompanying systemic symptoms, and resemble the nervous system
abnormalities of disseminated vasculomyelinopathy both clinically and
pathologically Like disseminated vasculomyelinopathy, the disease is monophasic,
with multilevel involvement throughout the nervous system. Most common is mild
meningoencephalitis; headache, nausea, and vomiting are common at onset, 50% of
patients have lymphocytic pleocytosis [22], and mild encephalopathy is almost
always present [30]. Papilledema, aphasia, hemiplegia, hemianopia, coma, chorea,
cerebellar syndromes, cranial neuropathies, radiculoneuritis (especially
brachial neuritis), the Guillain-Barré syndrome, and acute transverse myelitis
have all been reported in addition [22, 24, 30]. Pathologically, arterioles,
venuies, and capillaries in the brain, spinal cord, and meninges are congested
and hyalinized their endothelium is swollen, and there is perivascular edema,
demyelination, hemorrhage, and round cell infiltration plus areas of focal
necrosis in both brain and spinal cord. Similar changes occur in spinal roots,
and there is proliferation of interfascicular connective tissue and Schwann
cells in peripheral nerve [22 24].
Similar nervous system disease also occurs in a number of other human
disorders in which immune complexes circulate and cause vascular injury. In
essential mixed cryoglobulinemia the main pathological feature is a small vessel
vasculitis with perivascular lymphocytic infiltration [23], and immunoglobulin
and complement can be identified at sites of vessel injury [8]. Although immune
complexes have not been demonstrated within the nervous system, polyneuritis,
mononeuritis multiplex, cranial neuritis, myelopathy, blindness, hemiplegia, and
encephalopathy have all been reported [1, 8]. Most cases of essential
cryoglobulinemia probably represent cryoglobulinemia secondary to infection, and
immune complexes containing the infective agent, antibody to the agent, and
complement components constitute the cryoprecipitate. The hepatitis B virus is
usually the agent responsible [23], but cryoglobulinemia with encephalopathy has
also been reported following streptococcal infection [19]. In addition, serum
cryoglobulins containing the virus and antibody directed against it are
frequently present in infectious mononucleosis [41]. Multilevel nervous system
abnormalities occur as well, usually begin one to three weeks after the onset of
systemic symptoms, and have as their base vascular and perivascular changes
which resemble those seen following the exanthems [2, 37]. Cryoglobulinemia is
also common in cytomegalovirus infection [41], which may precede up to 33% of
cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome [12]. In Lyme disease, mixed cryoglobulins are
present at the onset of multilevel nervous system disease and disappear as
active nervous system disease resolves [34]. Finally, circulating immune
complexes are present in up to 100% of patients with systemic lupus
erythematosus [40], and multilevel nervous system abnormalities develop in as
many as 75% [14, 20] as a result of small vessel vasculopathy histologically
similar to disseminated vasculomyelinopathy [20]. Immunoglobulin has been
identified in the choroid plexus, cerebrospinal fluid complement is sometimes
reduced, and immune complexes have been detected in the cerebrospinal fluid
[14]; the immune complexes have not been identified at sites of vessel injury,
however.
Discussion
The numerous postinfectious and postvaccinal nervous system disorders appear
to share a common pathogenesis involving the immune system: they follow the same
antecedent events by a similar latent period, direct nervous system infection
has rarely been demonstrated, and their occurrence depends more on the character
of the host than on the severity of the initial infection. In the traditional
view, delayed hypersensitivity to myelin develops and results in perivenous
demyelination. However, how this hypersensitivity might develop after such
diverse antecedents has never been satisfactorily explained, and sensitized
lymphocytes are not always demonstrable by laboratory test. Damage to small
blood vessels appears to precede demyelination in humans, and although it now
seems that vascular damage does occur experimentally in EAE, it is possible that
vasculopathy is primary in these disorders and that demyelination is a
consequent change.
The detection of circulating immune complexes in sera from some patients with
postinfectious nervous system diseases suggests that foreign antigens,
introduced by infection or inoculation, may induce the formation of antibodies
and, subsequently, of antigen-antibody complexes which fix complement and damage
vascular endothelium. Myelin could be damaged secondarily. The attractiveness of
this hypothesis lies in its ability to
explain: (1) the monophasic character of the illness, (2) the common reaction
to a wide variety of antecedents, and (3) the dependence of the reaction on the
character of the host (as an antibody former).
These two hypotheses are not mutually exclusive. Even though small vessel
injury in itself can eventuate in demyelination, this may be mediated through
cellular immune mechanisms. Changes in vascular permeability and perivascular
inflammation could either alter the antigenicity of myelin or release antigen
previously sequestered by a competent blood-brain barrier. The cell-mediated
immune response could then perpetuate the damage initiated by the original
vascular injury.
Although some systemic features, both clinical and pathological, of
postinfectious nervous system disease resemble those of human immune complex
disease, in which similar neurological and neuropathological abnormalities also
occur, these constitute the exception rather than the rule. Why the nervous
system should be preferentially involved in immune complex-mediated vascular
injury is not clear. One could speculate, however, that the consequences of
minor vascular injury and alteration in permeability are more serious in the
nervous system, where normal function depends on an impenetrable vascular
barrier, than in other organ systems in which the vascular bed is already
permeable.
Initial immune complex-mediated vascular injury could explain the observed
facts in disseminated vasculomyelinopathy; however, only some indirect evidence
supports the hypothesis: the detection of circulating complexes in some patients
with these disorders, the presence of systemic features compatible with immune
complex disease in occasional patients, and the occurrence of similar nervous
system abnormalities in other human disorders caused by immune complexes.
Other interpretations of these observations are clearly possible. The
detection of circulating immune complexes in some patients with amyotrophic
lateral sclerosis [28] suggests that the complexes themselves may represent an
epiphenomenon-either a consequence of antecedent infection without pathogenetic
role or the result of nervous tissue injury occurring by other mechanisms and
resulting in release of antigen. Alternatively, immune complexes might be
involved in pathogenesis but exert their influence by interacting with
suppressor cells, allowing autoimmunity to develop [3]. In view of their
relative infrequency, the systemic features in some patients might indeed result
from immune complex disease while the nervous system abnormalities arise by
entirely different mechanisms. Finally, the nervous system reactions to injury
may be so limited that both sensitized lymphocytes and antigen-antibody
complexes cause similar lesions, explaining the apparently similar clinical and
pathological features in disseminated vasculomyelinopathy and human immune
complex disease.
Testing the Hypothesis
Techniques are now at hand for detecting circulating immune complexes.
Cryoprecipitation has long been available and may be most effective in isolating
complexes formed in the presence of antigen excess [42]. The Raji cell
radioimmunoassay uses complement receptors on the Raji cell surface to detect
complement containing antigen-antibody complexes [40] Complexes may also be
detected by their ability to bind the Clq component of complement [27]. All
these methods should be applied to the serum of patients with the various
postinfectious disorders. Circumstantial evidence of a pathogenetic role for
these complexes can be provided by demonstrating a fall in serum complement
components, but complement consumption and activation may occur without a
decrease in serum complement if both its synthesis and catabolism are
accelerated [42]. More direct evidence of a pathogenetic role requires
immunofluorescent study of tissue obtained postmortem or by biopsy with
demonstration of immunoglobulin, complement, and, when it is known, the inciting
antigen at sites of vessel injury [27]. Obviously, the chances of demonstrating
tissue deposition of immune complexes will be greatest in pathological material
obtained soon after the onset of illness since complexes may be eliminated long
before their injurious effect on vessels has been repaired.
References:
1.Abramsky O, Slavin S: Neurologic manifestations in patients with mixed
cryoglobulinemia. Neurology (Minneap) 24: 245-249, 1974 2. Ambler M, Stoll J,
Tzamaloukas A, et al: Focal encephalomyelitis in infectious mononucleosis. Ann
Intern Med 75:579-583, 1971 3. Antel JP, Arnason BGW, Medof ME: Suppressor cell
function in multiple
sclerosis: correlation with clinical disease activity. Ann Neurol 5:338-342,
1979 4.Arnason BGW: Inflammatory polyradiculoneuropathies, in Dyck PJ, Thomas PK,
Lambers EH (eds): Peripheral Neuropachy. Philadelphia, Saunders, 1975, vol 2, pp
1110-1148
5. Behan PO~ Lowenstein LM, Silmant M, et al: Landry-Guillian-Barré-Strohl
syndrome and immune-complex nephritis. Lancet 1:850-854, 1973
6. Behan P0, Moore MJ, Lamarche JB: Acute necrotizing hemorrhagic
encephalopathy. Postgrad Med 54:154-160, 1973
7. Brain WR, Hunter D, Turnbull HM: Acute meningoencephalomyelitis of
childhood. Lancet 1:221-227, 1929
8. Brouec JC, Clauvel JP, Danon F, cc al: Biologic and clinical
significance of cryoglobulins. A report of 86 cases. Am J Med 57:775-788,
1974
9. Cambier J, Schott B: Nosologie des polyradiculonévrites inflammatoires.
Rev Neurol (Paris) 115:811-842, 1966
10. Carpenter S, Lampert PW: Post-infectious perivenous encephalitis and
acute hemorrhagic leukoencephalitis, in Minckler J (ed): Pathology of the
Nervous System. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1972, vol 3, pp 2260-2269
11 Cochrane CG, Dixon FJ: Immune complex injury, in Samter M (ed):
18. Haymaker W, Kernohan JW: The Landry-Guillain-Barré syndrome: a
clinicopathologic report of fifty fatal cases and a critique of the
literature. Medicine (Baltimore) 28:59-14 1, 1949
19 Hodson AK, Doughty RA, Norman ME: Acute encephalopathy, streptococcal
infection and cryoglobulinemia. Arch Neurol 35:43-44, 1978
20. Johnson RT, Richardson EP: The neurological manifestations of systemic
lupus erythematosus. A clinical-pathological study of 24 cases and review of
the literature. Medicine (Baltimore) 47:337-369, 1968
21. Kashiwagi N, Brantigan CO, Brettschneider L, et al: Clinical reactions
and serologic changes after the administration of heterologous antilymphocyte
globulin to human recipients of renal homografts. Ann Intern Med 68:275-286,
1968
22. Kraus WM, Chancy LB: Serum disease of the nervous system. Arch Neurol
Psychiatry 37:1035-1047, 1937
23. Levo Y, Gorevic PD, Kassab HJ, et al: Association between hepatitis B
virus and essential mixed cryoglobulinemia. N EnglJ Med 296:1501-1504, 1977
24 . Miller HG: Clinical manifestations of tissue reaction in the nervous
system, in Williams D (ed): Modern Trends in Neurology (Second Series).
London, Butterworth, 1957, pp 164-176
25. Miller HG, Stanton JB: Neurological sequelae of prophylactic
inoculation. QJ Med 23: 1-27, 1954
26. Miller HG, Stanton JB, Gibbons JL Para-infectious encephalomyelitis and
related syndromes. QJ Med 25:427-505, 1956
27. Nakamura RM: Immunopathology: Clinical Laboratory Concepts and Methods.
Boston, Little, Brown; 1974, pp 168- 200
28. Oldstone MBA, Wilson CB, Perrin LH, et al: Evidence for immune-complex
formation in patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Lancet 2:169-172,
1976
29. Oppenheimer DR: Demyelinating diseases, in Blackwood W, Corsellis JAN
(eds): Greenfields Neuropathology. Third edition. Chicago, Year Book, 1976,
pp 470-499
30. Park AM, Richardson JC: Cerebral complications of serum sickness.
Neurology (Minneap) 3:277-283, 1953
31. Peters DK, Sevitt LH, Direkze M, et a!: Landry-Guillain. Barré-Strohl
polyneuritis and the nephrotic syndrome. Lancet
1:1183-1184, 1973
32. Poser CM: Diseases of the myelin sheath, in Baker AB, Raker LH (eds):
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"