The dangers of only partially vaccinating a population against polio was
underscored today in a report that blamed an outbreak of the deadly disease in
the Caribbean on incomplete vaccination, which allowed the virus to mutate,
escape and then infect 21 people, killing two children.
"The outbreak probably began in Haiti, when a routine oral poliovirus
vaccine dose was given to a child living in a community with low vaccine
coverage," the researchers, led by Olen Kew of the U.S. Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, wrote today in the journal Science.
One of those who died was a 12-year-old boy and another was a 35-month-old
boy. "He didn't see his third birthday," Kew said. "If they had only used the
vaccine appropriately, this would not have happened."
Two factors are to blame for the outbreak, the researchers say. One is the
low vaccination rate in Haiti and the Dominican Republic, which share an
island in the Caribbean.
In Haiti, political strife and poverty have interfered with vaccination
efforts, Kew said.
The second factor was the use of an oral vaccine, which uses a live but
weakened strain of the virus. The oral vaccine, developed by Albert Sabin,
helped rid many countries of polio, including the United States, because it is
easy to administer and highly effective. But the virus used is still alive,
although it has been altered so it should not cause disease.
It stays alive in the body, and it turns out, can hook up with other,
related viruses called enteroviruses. They swap DNA and the polio virus can
become deadly and highly infectious again. It is shed in the feces and gets
into the water supply.
People get polio from infected water, so when sewage gets into drinking or
washing supplies, the newly energized polio virus can infect them with
crippling effects.
Kew said the study shows the importance of getting everyone vaccinated, as
the few vaccinated children were, in essence, infecting everyone else.
"Even in developed countries, when people don't vaccinate their kids, the
virus can find them," Kew said.
Most people infected with polio have no symptoms. But in a small percentage
of cases, the virus attacks the nerves -- usually the spinal cord -- and can
paralyze the victim. Between 2% and 5% of children with paralytic polio die
and up to 30% of adults.
Humans are the only animals that can be infected with polio, so health
officials think vaccination can wipe it out.
There is another vaccine, the inactivated poliovirus vaccine based on one
invented by Jonas Salk. This injected vaccination is now widely used because
the virus is killed and cannot become dangerous again. But people who receive
the injected vaccine can become infected with wild polio and, while they do
not become sick, can spread it.
Kew and colleagues noted that outbreaks of polio have been traced to the
oral vaccine not only in Haiti and the Dominican Republic, but in the
Philippines and Egypt. But they stressed that the oral vaccine is still
useful, not least because it works better.
"We don't want people to jump to the conclusion that inactivated polio
vaccine [the injected version] is the answer," Kew said.
The World Health Organization wants to eradicate polio globally, but says
the effort has been hampered by a lack of funds and political will in the
affected countries. In the United States, polio killed thousands of people and
disabled tens of thousands before it was wiped out in 1979.