Autistic individuals have a fundamental structural difference in the
alignment and wiring of their brain cells, a difference that explains these
individuals' proclivity to live in their own world, according to researchers.
"The fundamental structure by which they think and process information is
different," said Dr. Manuel F. Casanova, neurologist and neuropathologist at the
Medical College of Georgia and lead author on research findings published in the
February 12, 2002, issue of Neurology. The structural difference they have found
would result in too much communication, too little inhibition and a tendency to
shut out much of the world around them, the researchers said.
Dr. Casanova's research team members examined the brain tissue of nine
autistic people with a mean age of 12 and found to their surprise that not only
do they have smaller minicolumns - a basic organizational unit of 80 to 100
brain cells and their connective wiring - they have more of them. The team
reproduced its findings using a different method of microscopic analysis before
submitting them for publication.
"We believe that we have uncovered a major source of pathology that has been
untouched before because no one looked at minicolumns," Dr. Casanova said. "I
pray we are correct because this is standing on the verge of something that
could be very important to many people."
The team previously published studies indicating that microscopic differences
in the minicolumns of man and non-human primates help explain man's capacity for
complex communication. They also postulated that differences in the minicolumns
might hold clues to conditions such as autism and schizophrenia in which
communication is dramatically impacted.
"Intelligence is not the property of single cells, it's in the circuitry,"
Dr. Casanova said, referring to the minicolumns where cells take in information,
process it and respond.
Despite the general observation that autistic individuals tend to have
unusually large brains, the researchers found throughout those brains smaller
units of circuitry and many more of them. Everyone has millions of minicolumns
yet their presence cannot be detected grossly with even the most sophisticated
brain-imaging equipment. A microscope is needed to detect the structures that
are about forty-millionth of a meter in diameter (a meter is 39.37 inches).
In autistic individuals, often defined as non-communicative and
self-centered, these microscopic structures are even tinier and more numerous so
the individuals are literally bombarded with communication and stimulation from
the environment. "Even the flickering of a fluorescent light can interfere with
an autistic person's concentration," Dr. Casanova said.
Computer modeling of their tiny minicolumns indicates excess signaling
between cells along with too little inhibition, he said, noting that about one
third of the people with autism also develop seizures, another condition in
which signaling and inhibition are out of balance. In fact, case reports have
shown that anti-seizure medications - which limit the flood of signals reaching
the brain - have reduced the autistic symptoms of those who also have epilepsy.
Dr. Casanova theorizes that if inhibitory medications, such as anti-seizure
medications, were given early enough to an autistic child, in the first few
years of life while their brains are being hard-wired, they could help normalize
the flow of stimulation reaching the minicolumns. The Augusta researchers
already have begun studying the minicolumns of people with epilepsy to determine
their pathology as well.
This peculiar pathology linked to autism begins during early development when
germinal cells, which have great potential for developing into different types
of cells, start dividing to form the brain's major component, the cortex. "In
the cortex, the germinal cells continue to migrate. This provides for
progressive layering of cells into minicolumns, almost like rainbow Jell-O," Dr.
Casanova said. "So autism results from a defect during creation of the cortex."
But, based on his group's research, Dr. Casanova suggests that these
microscopic differences in cell organization may not be a defect at all but a
step in brain evolution that enables people to truly focus on complex issues
facing today's society, such as technology and science. "Evolution is usually
depicted as a ladder where one rung follows the next," he said. "It is really
more of a bush with sideway branches or improvisations. Variation in the size
and number of minicolumns may represent one such improvisation." Today, less
than 1 percent of the population is autistic but the numbers have steadily
increased since the 1940s when the first figures began being gathered.
Co-authors on the Neurology article include Dr. Daniel P. Buxhoeveden,
research associate, MCG; Andrew E. Switala, computer programmer and
mathematician, and Dr. Emil Roy, computer applications expert at the Augusta
Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center.
Brain tissue used in the study came from the Autism Research Foundation in
Boston and funding was provided by grants from the Theodore and Vada Stanley
Foundation and the VA Merit Review Board. "We are grateful to the Autism
Research Foundation and to the families who donated brain tissue for study," Dr.
Casanova said. "Without the generosity of both, this type of research would not
be possible."
_______________________________________________________
>> DO SOMETHING ABOUT AUTISM NOW <<
Subscribe, Read, then Forward the FEAT Daily Newsletter.
To Subscribe go to
le_Type1&c=Article&cid=1016104565304&call_page=TS_Health&call_pageid=9688675
05381&call_pagepath=Life/Health&col=969048872038
Peering cautiously inside his mouth, she felt her stomach turn in shock. Two
bloody stumps were all that was left of her 3-year-old's once-perfect front
teeth. Little Tony had ground them nearly to the bone, leaving the nerve roots
dangerously exposed.
Another child would have been in agony, but her son sat quietly sucking his
shirtsleeve.
"I was horrified," recalls Cindy Faria, of Oakville, who rushed the boy to
the dentist. "We couldn't believe he wasn't crying ... how could he not feel
it?"
The boy needed an emergency root canal. The operating rooms were full but the
dentist, believing Tony's insensitivity to pain would allow the procedure to be
performed without anaesthetic, went ahead. Tony didn't flinch.
Cindy Faria had already suspected there was something wrong with her
firstborn, but this incident left no doubt in her mind. And a specialist soon
delivered a gut-wrenching diagnosis Tony was autistic.
The Farias were devastated. Autism is a severe neurological developmental
disability that typically appears during the first three years of life. It
affects boys four times more often than girls. Although autistic children appear
perfectly normal, they spend their time engaged in puzzling and disturbing
behaviour like teeth grinding, spinning, arm flapping or banging their heads
against a wall. A third never learn to speak.
Faria remembers fearing the worst for her son.
Shortly after Tony's diagnosis, she attended a program where autistic adults
and children were being taken care of. She saw a woman in her 30s suddenly run
out and staff had to drag her to the ground. "I watched her screaming," recalls
Faria. "She was incredibly upset because in the struggle she had dropped her
doll. I just stood there crying. All I could think of was that this is what
could be happening to Tony in just a matter of years."
This glimpse of what might be her son's future prompted Faria to immerse
herself in the new medical research on autism. She learned that autistic
children in the United States were treated successfully with intensive
behavioural therapy, known as applied behaviour analysis (ABA). ABA therapists
work one-to-one with a child, intensively reinforcing correct behaviour,
language and academic skills. ABA costs an average $60,000 a year and children
typically require several years of treatment, but studies show the therapy can
work miracles nearly half of autistic children can be taught to function
normally. Most of the other half will show some improvement.
Many U.S. jurisdictions classify this as medical care and pay the cost, but
Ontario classifies autism not as a neurological disorder that would be covered
under the Ontario Health Insurance Plan, but as a psychological disorder with
services falling under the Ministry of Community and Social Services. The Farias
discovered that this ministry wouldn't pay for ABA.
"When it came down to it, we knew our son's health mattered more than
anything ... we were desperate," says Faria. "We would spend anything we had to,
if it meant even a chance he could be helped."
She sold her two sandwich stores. The couple mortgaged their house and cashed
in retirement savings. Over the next four and a half years, they spent more than
$200,000 on ABA therapy.
Tony progressed in ways they never dreamed possible. Today at age 7, he
attends a regular Grade 2 class. He has a best friend. He also plays soccer and
baseball and loves Pokémon and the Power Rangers.
"Except for learning more subtle social skills, like how to be cool, he is
just like every other kid," his mother says.
"Our family has been lucky in some ways," she adds. "We were in a position to
borrow money. But now it's very stressful. We're in extreme financial debt and
we still have to pay to keep Tony in therapy. How can anyone say this is fair?
To date, we have saved the taxpayers millions of dollars that it would have cost
to care for him for the balance of his life. It's not right that the government
refuses to pay to give him the care he needs."
In 1999, the Farias and 19 other families of autistic children sued the
province for $75 million for failing to provide medically necessary treatment
and educational services for their children. Parents in British Columbia had
already filed a similar class action suit against their provincial government.
In July, 2000, the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled that the
provincial government had discriminated against autistic children. As well, it
ruled that autism is a "medical disability just as cancer is and ... both
require treatment." The judge also stated that the government's failure to
provide treatment violated children's rights under Canada's Charter of Rights
and Freedoms. British Columbia has appealed the decision. Faria and the other
parents are still fighting their case in the courts.
"Children are at the mercy of the grown ups in this world to decide whether
or not they are worth saving," Faria adds. "I feel that in Ontario my son has
been declared disposable."
`I don't spend a cent on myself, not even to go to a movie. We eat macaroni
most nights. It's the only way we can afford the cost of therapy'
Norrah Whitney,
mother of an autistic boy
`I feel that in Ontario my son has been declared disposable'
Cindy Faria, mother
of an autistic boy
Ontario has since initiated a $39 million a year autism treatment program for
a limited number of children age 2 to 5, but there are 900 children on waiting
lists for that treatment. Hundreds of other families can't qualify because their
children's symptoms are not deemed serious enough. And hundreds of children are
being aged out of the program at 6 even though they still need the therapy. The
Farias do not qualify because Tony is 7.
In January, Norrah Whitney, a Toronto single mother of an autistic 6-year-old
son, filed a complaint with the Ontario Human Rights Commission arguing that
cutting off treatment at age 6 is a violation of human rights.
"If he had cancer, the province wouldn't cut off chemotherapy just because he
has reached age 6," says Whitney. "Autism is really no different."
When he was 2 1/2, Whitney's son, Luke, ran into walls, ate his feces, and
the only sounds he uttered were guttural noises.
Whitney and her husband separated, largely because of the stress of coping
with Luke. Whitney and Luke moved into a tiny basement apartment. Relatives lent
Whitney money to start her son in ABA therapy. Finally, last year Luke was
accepted into the government-funded program. "He's a different child now," says
Whitney, who works part time and last year contributed $25,000 to the $55,000
cost of her son's program.
"I don't spend a cent on myself, not even to go to a movie," Whitney says.
"We eat macaroni most nights. It's the only way we can afford the cost of
therapy.
"Luke is finally learning to talk, finally beginning to relate to people. But
his only hope of continuing to improve is to keep going in this therapy. But I
cry every night wondering how I am going to keep the therapy going for Luke,
wondering what his fate would be if I have to give up ... this is truly a
nightmare."
Ontario's minister of community and social services, John Baird, says
autistic children who reach 6 are served in the education system, but parents
like Whitney and Faria have found this service does not include ABA therapy, the
only effective treatment for their children.
"Parents like ourselves are having to do it all on our own," Faria says.
"It's devastating enough to have a child who is autistic, but then to have to
fight the system every step of the way is complete injustice."
Health experts say the issues raised by the Farias and others are serious,
especially given the large numbers of children with autism and the fact that the
disorder appears to be on the rise.
In the U.S., the number of children diagnosed as autistic increased 20 per
cent from 1999 to 2000, says Marianna Ofner-Agostini, a professor at the
University of Toronto's department of health sciences. Preliminary studies in
Ontario indicate the number of parents seeking medical help for autistic
children nearly doubled between 1996 and 1998, says Ofner-Agostini, who
estimates there are more than 3,000 autistic children under 6 in the province.
Concerned that autism has become a major health issue, researchers at Queen's
University in Kingston are set to begin a national study of the prevalence of
autism.
Ofner-Agostini says no one knows whether the numbers are up due to better
record-keeping and diagnosis or because there has been an actual increase in the
number of children suffering from the problem.
The cause of autism remains mysterious as well. Some experts say routine
immunizations in young children might be involved, but there are no studies that
have proven any connection. Others suggest that autism is caused by a defective
gene and that an environmental trigger such as the vaccine or even a relatively
new environmental toxin may activate that gene.
"We are really in the dark," says Ofner-Agostini, herself the parent of a
2-year-old girl, Nadia, who suffers from the disorder.
She and her husband are re-mortgaging their home to pay for Nadia's
treatment.
"She bangs her forehead against the wall so often that it's covered in huge
bumps and bruises," she says. "We just can't afford to wait until she might get
some government help."
Baird describes the Ontario government's program as the best in Canada. "I
don't pretend we are going to be able to meet every need, but three years ago,
we had nothing and we've gone from nothing to $20 to $40 million. We acknowledge
that there are more families that need help, but we are doing our very best."
He says just 55 eligible children are waiting for treatment.
However, NDP health critic Shelly Martel and Liberal social services critic
Michael Gravelle say 900 children between 2 and 5 are on waiting lists for
autism treatment. With waiting time for some of those children estimated at one
to two years, some will reach 6 and be aged out of the program.
"I've been told my Nadia is number 580 on a waiting list of 600 (in
Toronto) and two years is the wait we can expect," says Ofner-Agostini. "This
isn't acceptable ... there wouldn't be that kind of wait if she had any other
medical problem. Why does our society allow these children to be left out?"
_______________________________________________________
APRIL 21, 2002 - 12 Noon to 5pm
THIRD NATIONAL AUTISM AWARENESS RALLY:
"The Power of ONE! I.D.E.A."
FREE and OPEN TO THE PUBLIC