Antony Barnett and Tracy
McVeigh
Sunday June 30, 2002
The Observer
British drug giant GlaxoSmithKline has finally admitted that thousands of
babies in this country were inoculated with a batch of toxic whooping cough
vaccines in the 1970s.
Some experts believe that these Trivax vaccines - which had not passed
critical company safety tests - may have caused permanent brain damage and
even fatalities in young children.
In 1992, the family of an Irish boy, Kenneth Best, who suffered brain
damage from one of these toxic vaccines, was awarded £2.7 million in
compensation by the Irish Supreme Court.
Despite a long and fierce battle with the drug giant, the boy's family
finally won this historic case after his mother Margaret made a startling
find when sifting through tens of thousands of company documents.
She discovered that the Trivax vaccine used on her son, from a batch
numbered 3,741, had been released by the company despite it having failed to
pass a critical safety test. Documents revealed that the 60,000 individual
doses within this batch were known to be 14 times more potent than normal.
At the time the Irish judge accused GlaxoSmithKline - then known as Glaxo
Wellcome - of negligence and attacked the company's poor quality control at
its Kent laboratory. Immunology experts condemned Glaxo in court for what
one US scientist described as an 'extraordinary event'.
Last year an investigation by The Observer found evidence to suggest that
vaccines from this faulty batch, which may have wrecked Kenneth Best's life,
had also been used in Britain.
Liberal Democrat MP Norman Baker raised questions in the House of
Commons, asking whether vaccines from this batch had been given to British
babies. Then Health Minister Yvette Cooper wrote to the company asking for
information.
Now, almost a year later, GlaxoSmithKline has replied that it is 'highly
probable' the toxic batches had been used in Britain.
The Department of Health is under pressure to make efforts to trace the
children who received the suspect vaccines.
Last week in the House of Commons, Health Minister Hazel Blears said:
'Unfortunately they no longer have details of the quantitites of vaccine or
the places where the vaccine was supplied.
'Since vaccines were not centrally purchased and distributed at that time
there are no central records either. Information on individuals who received
these vaccines will only exist if the general practioner at the time of the
immunisation recorded the batch number and the patient's notes are still
available.'
Baker will now write to the Minister to demand that she asks health
authorities to check the records to find out who received the vaccine. It is
believed that at least one boy from Wales died after receiving a jab from
toxic batch 3,741, although the parents have never been informed.
A spokesman for GlaxoSmithKline told The Observer : 'We do not accept
that these batches were harmful.'