Conflicting evidence and studies emerging on both sides of the Atlantic on
the MMR/autism controversy in the past few days have left parents even more
confused.
Last Wednesday Dr Arthur Krigsman, a paediatric gastroenterologist from the
New York University School of Medicine, told a US congressional committee on
autism that he had found an identical pattern of inflammatory bowel disease in
90 per cent of his 43 young autistic patients, to that reported by Dr Andrew
Wakefield four years ago when he first raised questions over MMR.
As the Eye reported in its special report MMR: The Story So Far, Krigsman's
work is one of a handful of small clinical studies which gives the lie to
government claims that Wakefield's work has not been replicated. It is
understood that Krigsman is now going to look for measles virus in his patients'
guts.
The committee also heard that measles virus had been found in the spinal
fluid of two autistic children. This means it would have direct access to the
brain. Dr Jeff Bradstreet, medical director of the International Child
Development Resource Centre, told the committee that spinal taps on his own
autistic child and another had revealed measles virus; and that research work
was now underway with other autistic children and normal control children to
explore the significance of the discovery.
Dr Wakefield, the London gastroenterologist who first sounded alarm bells
about the MMR vaccine, told the same hearing that preliminary studies had shown
that 25 autistic children who had had a second dose of MMR, compared to those
who had received only one, had suffered a worsening of their physical and
behavioural symptoms, suggesting evidence of a link between their condition and
the jab.
He said research by his group and collaborators and other small pockets of
researchers in the US had now found that children with regressive autism had a
novel form of inflammatory bowel disease not found in normal children and
consistent with a viral cause; that the measles virus had been found in the
diseased intestine where it would be expected if it were the cause; that the
measles virus had been found in only a small minority of developmentally normal
children; and, referring to the latest study from Prof John O'Leary's team from
Trinity College, Dublin, that in 12 autistic children it had been identified as
vaccine strain.
Meanwhile, in the UK, a study billed as "the most in-depth analysis of the
scientific literature to date" published in Clinical Evidence concluded that
"there is no evidence that MMR or single measles vaccines are associated with
autism or inflammatory bowel disease". The work was yet another review of the
same body of work which others have trawled over before and it would be
surprising if it had come up with any other conclusion. The trouble is, as a
similar review carried out by the American Institute of Medicine (IOM)
acknowledged, "the epidemiological evidence lacks the precision to assess rare
occurances of a response to MMR leading to autism". The IOM called for more
research comparing MMR-vaccinated children with non-vaccinated children and
investigating whether vaccine strain measles was present in autistic children.
The UK review not only had no new research work, but it excluded the whole
body of research that Wakefield was referring to - about 20 papers in total -
includng that which revealed the vaccine strain virus. Independent researchers
from Bazian, a company promoting evidence-based health care, who carried out the
review, said they followed strict research criteria and ruled out all small
clinical studies which were open to bias. But it is the small clinical studies,
which are actually looking at what is happening to these children, that are
causing alarm.
One such study is that of Prof O'Leary. Though he himself declared last week
that he still advocated immunisation and his new work showing the presence of
vaccine strain measles virus in the guts of autistic children does not prove any
link between MMR and autism, his work does raise serious questions.
What is the virus doing in the guts of these children? Is it causing the
damage or is it there because autism and bowel disease mean the children can't
clear it from their systems? Could it be elsewhere in their bodies?
News from the US that the virus has also been found in the spinal fluid -
albeit only in two children - has alarmed parents even more. Julie Loch, a
pharmacist whose son Oliver is severely autistic said, "Many like my son are
awaiting MRI scans due to further increasing and alarming neurological problems.
The measles virus has now been found in cerebro spinal fluid in others,
suggesting its presence in the brain. Are our children sitting time bombs, that
will at some point develop the fatal brain condition SSPE?"
Instead of relying on reviews of old research and studies, the case for new
research to answer these questions one way or another is overwhelming. Why won't
the government embark on it?
Jeff Bradstreet At Burton Hearing on MMR Vaccine, Monkey Virus in Spinal
Fluid Jeff Bradstreet, M.D., F.A.A.F.P. Medical Director and Founder, The
International Child Development Resource Center and an autism parent, Palm Bay,
Florida
[Last week we presented the testimonies of Congressman Dan Burton and Dr.
Andrew Wakefield from the U.S. House Of Representatives, Government Reform
Committee On The Status Of Research Into Vaccine Safety And Autism on June 19,
2002. Thanks to Jeff Sell, here is the transcript of Dr. Jeff Bradstreet's
remarks. Bradstreet has treated over 2000 children with autism and does clinical
research. Dr. Bradstreet's complete presentation and extensive references can be
found at the website URL below.]
Unfortunately, the nature of autism is so complex that to do it in five
minutes will be challenging. So I have submitted, under tab five, a more
complete review of the nature of our research. I will try and get through my
slides quickly, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you very much for the hearing and for an opportunity to present this.
Dr. Weldon and I previously met two weeks ago in your office with the deputy
secretary of health and human services, Claude Allen, to present this data to
him. So he has been made aware of it. And it was a very encouraging and very
positive meeting. I look forward to the outcome of that over time.
With that, the next slide.
The prevalence may be both misunderstood and underestimated. Two recent
studies, one from England and one that was a CDC study with Brick Township,
indicated between 57 per 10,000 and 67 per 10,000 children. However, autism is
primarily a boy-related disorder; four to eight times as many boys suffer with
this disorder. That means that the prevalence is therefore in the order of one
percent for boys.
Next slide.
The economic impact. We estimate that there are approximately 420,000
children with autism in this country at this time, based on those studies,
greatly less than what the "Time Magazine" article set at one million. However,
that puts a price tag, over the next 50 years to take care of these children, in
excess of $1 trillion.
That was a lot of zeroes. I had to go through that a couple times on my
calculator to make sure that that was correct. But that is the real number. The
lifetime costs could be $3 trillion to $4 trillion for the families and for
society, with the lost wages and other factors.
Next slide.
The biological evidence for causality is growing significantly. And for those
members of the committee who may not be familiar with me, I am a physician. I am
also a parent of a child with autism. And I am a clinical researcher associated
with studies currently ongoing at 14 medical schools around the world.
The growing evidence is substantial that measles virus is still the front
runner with the viral etiology aspects of things. And not all children suffer
from measles virus-related disorders. But we'll show you today some examples
that are quite, I think, impacting.
Additionally, autoimmunity continues to be published by a variety of
researchers at multiple medical schools that there is a unique disorder
affecting the autoimmunity in these children where they become immune to their
gut and their brain. And that is a disaster for them.
Mercury -- and, to a lesser extent, lead -- remain significant toxic burdens.
And we presented that data to the Institute of Medicine in July of last year.
Next slide.
The first case -- I'm going to present two cases today. I'll try and go
through them briefly.
Matthew (ph), who was born in 1984 from an uncomplicated pregnancy and an
easy delivery, had a normal early development, except he did develop some gait
abnormalities that are very consistent with what you might expect from Mercury.
We'll see that data later on.
He had a rapid decline after each of two MMRs. He did receive those in
combination with other vaccines, however.
He developed autoimmunity to myelin basic protein, a critical insulator of
the brain. He suffered seizures shortly after the second MMR. And he has
consistent immune deficiency with protracted low mythecide (ph) counts.
Next slide.
He has inflammatory bowel disease that has been documented on an endoscopy
and biopsy. He has persistent measles virus genome in that inflammatory disease.
He has persistent measles virus in circulating white blood cells. He has
persistent measles virus "F" gene in his cerebral spinal fluid, which is the
fluid that surrounds the brain, implying it is present in the brain as well.
He has auto-antibodies to measles virus in his spinal fluid. He has
auto-antibodies to myelin basic protein in his spinal fluid, elevated a million,
a very low serum sulfur level and cysteine level and very high Mercury as a
result of that.
Next slide.
And next. That is my son, who is also the, I think, inspiration for our
research and the work that we do. He was a very happy, well- connected child
prior to his MMR. That's about approximately at 12 months of age. And that is
Matthew (ph), completely lost, about two months after his MMR vaccine.
Next slide. That is a copy of the laboratory result documenting the presence
of measles virus in his terminal ileum.
Next. Copy of the laboratory result from Utah State University where Matthew
(ph) had spinal fluid analyzed that showed antibodies to myelin basic protein
and to measles virus in his spinal fluid.
Next slide. This shows the presence of antibodies in his RBCs. Excuse me, the
presence of virus in his red blood cells. It is also present in his
cerebral spinal fluid. Next slide. And this is his first mercury titer,
showing marked elevations of mercury. And if you can see for all those,
essentially the only thing that is truly abnormal is a significant increase in
Mercury.
Next slide. The first challenge to us to get Mercury out of his body resulted
in an extremely high titer. That number of dots actually represents 24
micrograms for gram of creatne (ph). It would take it well off the slide,
perhaps into the next room.
Next? This is an interesting correlation. Mark Blacksill (ph) presented this
to the Institute of Medicine last year. And that shows the rising titer of
cumulative Mercury in the vaccine program in California, compared to the
prevalence of autism in California.
Next? And I want to superimpose on that a very interesting graphic derived
from the government website on the use of methylphenidate, also known as Ritalin
or Concerta. And look at the time relationship between the rise in that.
Next? It's identical. In 1990, the rise in the mercury titer started to go
up. And in 1990, there is a striking and continuous rise in the use of Ritalin
in this country, which I think is rather telling.
Next slide, please. This is the thimerosal versus autism relative risk that
was produced in the CDC confidential study that was acquired under the Freedom
of Information Act, showing that by the time approximately 37 micrograms of
Mercury is administered, there is more than a doubling of the relative risk of
autism.
Next. This is a copy of a transcript from the Simpson-Wood (ph) meetings. It
is page 229, where Dr. Brent (ph) -- who is not employed by the CDC; he is a
public health official from one of the states -- said that the medical-legal
findings in the study, causal or not, are horrendous. If an allegation was made
of a child's -- the behavioral findings were caused by thimerosal-containing
vaccines, you will not find a scientist with any integrity who would say the
reverse of the data that is available.
So we are in a bad position, from the standpoint of defending any lawsuits if
they were initiated. And I am concerned.
I think that may set part of the tone for what we have seen happen in the
last several years.
Next slide. Additionally, there was a very good documentary on this. Parents
are aware. And I think it's very important for Congress to be aware that the
parents are receiving information from a variety of outlets.
This is not just your doing or undoing a vaccine policy. Parents are well
educated. They are hungry for information. And they currently don't
believe many of the reassurances that are being provided by CDC. Next
slide. Case two is very similar to my son. And I present it so that you
will realize that this is not -- my son was not an isolated case. He had,
again, normal developmental milestones. He arrests shortly after his first
MMR at 15 months. He again has antibodies to many things in his brain and
persistent measles virus in places that it doesn't belong, including his
cerebral spinal fluid.
Next. Lab slide. This indicates that, in fact, he has antibodies to myelin
basic protein and to measles virus in his spinal fluid.
Next. He has this unique antibody. And this is the presence of MMR antibody,
which is actually the "H" protein or the hemogluten (ph) protein from the
measles virus of a special antibody titer that was derived using MMR vaccine.
And this was done in Dr. Singh's laboratory at Utah State University. Also
positive in spinal fluid.
Next. We presented this data, Dr. Singh and myself, at the American Society
of Microbiology last month, which indicates that 50 percent of children in our
society had antibodies to this special measles, mumps, rubella-derived protein
in their cerebral spinal fluid. Also, 86 percent have antibodies to myelin basic
protein in their spinal fluid. And again, a very high percentage, up to 100
percent, had antibodies to myelin basic protein in their blood.
This is not present in normal controls. This is a controlled study. We now
have significant controls. And we do not see these present. This is not an
antibody leakage phenomenon. This is real disease in these children.
Next. Again, Scott (ph) has documented measles virus in his terminal ileum in
his blood, as well as the spinal fluid. These are laboratory data.
Next. And I want to include from Dr. Menkes (ph), his comments, where he
concludes that, in fact -- this is related to the MMR vaccine in this particular
child. Dr. Menkes (ph) wrote the textbook, "Child Neurology." He is considered
to be one of the foremost experts, both on child neurology and on vaccine safety
and has concluded that measles, mumps, rubella vaccine is causing this syndrome.
Next. That's the child. I think it's always important to put a face. This is
impacting human lives.
Next slide. I would leave you with some questions. I think we have some
important things that we need to ask. These are in the handout. But as we work
through this, I think we need to know that what if Dr. Wakefield, myself, Dr.
Singh, Dr. O'Leary and Dr. Menkes (ph) and others are right. What then? What
would be the reaction to public health officials if, in fact, this data is -- as
we believe it is -- verifiable?
In addition to that, what is the response to treating these kids? How are we
going to get this virus out of these kids and restore them to good health? And
have we traded a very rare occurrence of severe side effects to natural measles
infection for a very common occurrence of autism?
* * *
RESEARCH
Transmission Disequilibrium Testing Of Arginine Vasopressin Receptor 1A
Kim SJ, Young LJ, Gonen D, Veenstra-VanderWeele J, Courchesne R, Courchesne
E, Lord C, Leventhal BL, Cook Jr EH, Insel TR. Laboratory of Developmental
Neuroscience, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry,
University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
Impairment in social reciprocity is a central component of autism.
In preclinical studies, arginine vasopressin (AVP) has been shown to increase
a range of social behaviors, including affiliation and attachment, via the V(1a)
receptor (AVPR1A) in the brain.
Both the behavioral effects of AVP and the neural distribution of the V1a
receptor vary greatly across mammalian species.
This difference in regional receptor expression as well as differences in
social behavior may result from a highly variable repetitive sequence in the 5'
flanking region of the V1a gene (AVPR1A).
Given this comparative evidence for a role in inter-species variation in
social behavior, we explored whether within our own species, variation in the
human AVPR1A may contribute to individual variations in social behavior, with
autism representing an extreme form of social impairment.
We genotyped two microsatellite polymorphisms from the 5' flanking region of
AVPR1A for 115 autism trios and found nominally significant transmission
disequilibrium between autism and one of the microsatellite markers by
Multiallelic Transmission/Disequilibrium test (MTDT) that was not significant
after Bonferroni correction.
We also screened approximately 2 kb of the 5' flanking region and the coding
region and identified 10 single nucleotide polymorphisms.
PMID: 12082568 [PubMed - in process]
* * *
Cerebral Blood Flow SPECT, Metabolic FDG-PET May Be Useful in Autism Dx
Galuska L, Szakall S Jr, Emri M, Olah R, Varga J, Garai I, Kollar J, Pataki
I, Tron L. Debreceni Egyetem, Orvos- es Egeszsegtudomanyi Centrum, Nuklearis
Medicina Tanszek, Debrecen. galuska@ibel.dote.hu
The authors have analyzed and compared the results of the 99mTc-ECD-SPECT and
FDG-PET examinations, performed in alert state, of 12 children suffering from
infantile (9 subjects) or atypical (3 subjects) autism.
In addition to frontally increased FDG metabolism, a decreased blood flow
with left-sided dominance was found bifrontally and bitemporally in the
infantile form (perfusion-metabolism mismatch).
The regional differences in cortical FDG uptake were not significant in
atypical autism, although both the blood flow and the metabolism of the thalami
were decreased.
Based on the results, the authors suggest that, beyond the usually
inconclusive structural (CT or MR) examinations, cerebral blood flow SPECT and
metabolic FDG-PET investigations may be useful in classifying the disease.
PMID: 12077922 [PubMed - in process]
* * *
COMMENTARIES
Anti-Science Activists Label Pro-Vaccine Safety Advocates "Antivaccine"
Commentary by Barbara Loe Fisher, Co-founder and President National Vaccine
Information Center
In the latest efforts by anti-science activists to label pro-vaccine safety
advocates "anti-vaccine," a trio from Northwestern University have published an
article in the June 26, 2002 Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA)
entitled "Content and Design Attributes of Antivaccination Web Sites." In what
must surely be a lull in the careers of Robert M. Wolfe, M.D., Lisa K. Sharp,
Ph.D., and Martin S. Lipsky, M.D., these three have spent a lot of time and
effort pouring over the content of what they have dubbed "antivaccination"
websites in order to come up with an analysis purporting to get to the heart of
the thinking and motives behind organizations and individuals who operate
websites questioning the safety and efficacy of vaccines.
The National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) which operates the oldest and
largest vaccine safety advocacy website, offers the following observations about
the content of the article and the thinking and motives of its authors:
1. This is not science, it is an op ed piece.
2. The information on the internet, thank goodness, is not peer
reviewed by doctors like these authors or we wouldn't be able to believe what
is on the internet anymore than we are able to believe what is published in
JAMA.
3. They need to include a dictionary in their article. What exactly
is their definition of "antivaccination?" Is it the label they apply in the
second sentence of the first paragraph to those challenging "the safety and
effectiveness of recommended vaccines?" If that is the definition of
anti-vaccine, we can label these authors anti-science for suggesting that
challenging and testing existing knowledge in science be abolished in favor of
protecting the status quo.
4. The hallmark of good science is replication. We call for a public
release of the names of all the websites these authors have labeled
anti-vaccine so their analysis can be independently analyzed.
5. In just one of the many examples of intellectual bias, the
authors perseverate about the internet access the public has to personal and
emotional experiences of families with vaccine injured children. They, however,
apparently have no problem with the use of visual images of children who were
injured or died from polio as an incentive to the public
to get vaccinated. 6. This article is a sophomoric attempt to label the
vaccine safety and informed consent movement as "anti-vaccine" in order to
deflect attention from the very real gaps in scientific knowledge about the
biological mechanisms of adverse responses to vaccination.
Should the Institute of Medicine be labeled anti-vaccine for repeatedly
publishing reports over the past decade calling for increased scientific
research into outstanding questions about vaccine safety? Instead of analyzing
websites which are pointing out and asking for answers to outstanding scientific
questions about vaccine safety, these doctors should be pulling their
microscopes out of storage and finding out why some children are not able to
handle the 36 doses of 11 vaccines they are now getting.
They could work to develop genetic and other biomarkers to identify and
screen out high risk children. That would go a long way toward re-instilling
trust in national vaccine policies and eliminating some of the nagging doubts
about vaccines that parents of learning disabled, hyperactive, epileptic,
autistic, asthmatic, diabetic and mentally retarded children talk about on the
internet.
7. History shows that challenge to the status quo, which is embodied
in much of the free speech that is taking place on the internet, is a first
necessary step to meaningful reform of powerful institutions. We proudly stand
by the content of our website at
www.909shot.com
which details our 20 year public record of working to institute vaccine safety
and informed consent protections in the mass vaccination system, including
playing a major role in obtaining a safer pertussis vaccine for American babies
licensed in 1996. We will stand by that accomplishment any day even if we
haven't published peer reviewed articles in JAMA.
Finally, this kind of pretentious posturing by doctors who claim that they
engaged in "critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual
content" did not remove the responsibility from JAMA editors to exercise a
little self discipline and pass on this one. What the publishing of this kind of
junk science does is fuel the suspicions of parents that those in power are
determined to silence the voices of people suffering because science will not
listen and does not care. It is a sad commentary on an even sadder reality that
faces many families with vaccine injured children.
* * *
Blind Faith In Anti-Science Hides The Informed Truth
Falsehood flies and the truth comes limping after; so that when men come to
be undeceived it is too late: the jest is over and the tale has had its effect.
- Jonathan Swift
Commentary by
Nicki Turner, director of the Immunisation Advisory Centre, New Zealand.
The tale of childhood vaccines and autism is a sad one. Even though there is
now a large bulk of excellent scientific evidence that MMR does not cause
autism, it is too late. The story is out and the damage affects the credibility
of the vaccine. The immunisation rates drop, the disease comes back and our
children suffer.
This article responds to the Dialogue view expressed by Barbara Sumner
Burstyn (June 24). I am saddened to see how a call to be more honest with
scientific knowledge has degenerated into slander and name-calling.
My concerns have been directed to health professionals to consider the
accuracy of the information they are distributing. What midwives recommend to
patients should have a basis in science.
Science is not truth - it is a tool using an accumulation of knowledge to
build a verifiable body of knowledge. It is the foundation on which our practice
of medicine is based.
We all know there have been errors in medicine, and there will be again. But
while acknowledging the limitations of science, we can recognise the tremendous
gains.
Control of infectious disease means we do not expect our children to die or
be maimed from vaccine-preventable diseases.
Immunisation is universally acknowledged as one of the greatest advances in
science, and its achievements are well documented - for example, the eradication
of smallpox, the eradication of polio in the Southwest Pacific and measles
eradication in many countries.
In the name of informed consent, a range of issues were expressed by Barbara
Sumner Burstyn. These have no grounding in genuine scientific debate.
Informed choice needs to be informed.
I support the statement that we must lose blind reason. But when I look at
statements which say vaccines cause SIDS, autism and Crohn's disease (good
research shows they do not), we have moved into an era of blind faith in
anything that is anti-science because all science must be faulty.
Is this just a new form of rigidity in a world looking for absolutes? We have
probabilities, not absolutes. Why do we have to accept absolute statements that
are incorrect disguised as informed consent?
It is not informed consent to tell parents there is thiomersal
(mercury) in childhood vaccines; there is not. There used to be. It was used
widely as a preservative. It has been phased out of childhood vaccines as better
technology has developed.
Genuine informed consent would look closely at the rigorous double-blind
controlled trials that are the benchmark of vaccine licensing and look at the
quality of the trials. Genuine informed consent would not tell us they do not
exist.
The Government uses these studies to assess the safety and effectiveness of
vaccines before deciding to license a vaccine.
Surely genuine debate should be about the adequacy and quality of the
evidence that is used.
Genuine informed consent cannot ignore herd immunity. Herd immunity is an
old-fashioned term and is known more sensibly as community immunity. It is the
principle that bugs circulate in communities.
The less immune protection in the community (either from vaccine or past
disease), the more bugs. Hence more disease in that community.
There are many heart-rending examples of disease outbreak throughout the
world when immunisation rates drop, such as whooping cough epidemics in the
1980s in Britain, Japan and Europe which caused many children to die. Even today
measles outbreaks occur in pockets of unvaccinated populations in Holland.
Why can we not debate the quality of the science? Why this trendy need to
deny there is research? Why treat the deeply held belief of some
pseudo-scientist as fact.
Opinion is not fact. Fact is a painful, slow accumulation of knowledge
through peer-reviewed, published research. Let's understand science with all its
limitations and use it as the tool it is.
Local Boy's Wish Granted - Playground Is A Dream Come True
[By Debbie Roberts for Florida Today Weeklies Thanks to Dennis Debbaudt.]
Dodging rain drops to find a good viewing spot, friends and family members
waited to see Tristan Clinton's reaction to the new play area in his backyard.
Although the 11-year-old was unable to verbally communicate his excitement to
those around him, the happy gleam in his eyes told the story well enough.
Tristan, an autistic child who experiences numerous seizures on a daily
basis, just had a dream come true: his very own playground, complete with
swings, a slide, a clubhouse and various climbing areas - all funded by the Make
A Wish Foundation.
"As a family, we tried to think of things that Tristan would enjoy," said the
youngster's mom, Kathy Clinton. "He loves to go to the park, but because of his
medical issues, it's difficult to take him out to places, so a playground in our
backyard was a perfect option for us."
Clinton explained that Tristan's seizures sometimes are severe. They can be
triggered when he is overheated, such as while playing outside during hot summer
weather. Having a playground close at hand will help make life easier, and the
curative benefits are an added bonus.
"Swinging is very therapeutic for children with autism, because it calms them
down. He has a balance beam out there, and balance beams tend to bring out
language in children who have language deficits," said Clinton. "There's also a
playhouse, so we can have sessions out there when it's a little bit cooler,
maybe in the fall. All of it will help bring out language and that's a real
focus with him."
The Make A Wish Foundation is widely known for granting wishes to children
with terminal illnesses, but the nonprofit organization also helps children with
life threatening illnesses. In Tristan's case, his seizures - sometimes up to 30
in one day - fit the criteria needed to make a request.
"About 40 percent of children with autism also have seizures, and no one
knows why," said Clinton. "Tristan has had seizures so severe he has turned blue
and stopped breathing."
Kathy Clinton is the founder of Hidden Potentials, a nonprofit organization
started six years ago to help special needs children. Program participants have
a wide range of disabilities, including autism, Down syndrome, cerebral palsy,
hearing impairments and attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder.
"I started Hidden Potentials because of the work we were doing with Tristan
and the progress that we made with him through a home program we developed," she
said. "The methods we used were so successful he started talking and behaving
more appropriately. I knew there were other children out there who could benefit
from these methods."
This fall, Tristan will be in fifth grade at Coquina Elementary School, where
he attends a small class with other autistic children. When not in school, the
youngster enjoys watching animated music videos, looking at books and wrestling
with his 8-year-old brother, Logan.
"I don't know what I'd do without Logan," said Clinton. "He's very
considerate of Tristan's needs. Growing up with Tristan has also given him such
a sense of compassion for all people who are different, who have special needs.
If we're in a group of people and there's a child who has a language impairment,
Logan is the first to go over and play with that child. He's been given a great
gift in life, and he's a great 'big brother' for Tristan."
Tristan's "wish granters" are Herb and Jean Oschmann of Titusville. He is the
eighth Brevard County child - and the first in Titusville - they have helped
since becoming involved four years ago with the Make A Wish Foundation.
"We started donating money to Make A Wish and one year, at Christmas time, we
got a note asking if we would be interested in becoming volunteers," said Jean
Oschmann. "It's very rewarding to work with the children and their families."
The Oschmann's granddaughter, 7-year-old Alex Scott of Port St. John, has
even pitched in to help grant wishes. She also saves the toys tucked inside
McDonald's Happy Meals, so she can give them to the children.
"I think it's good to help people," said Alex.
Tristan's father, Richard Clinton, said he is grateful for the Oschmann's
thoughtfulness while granting a wish for Tristan.
"The Make A Wish Foundation recruits people who really care about kids and I
think that's very important," he said. "They are trying to make the best out of
difficult situations and they have a lot of compassion. They've gone above and
beyond in our son's particular case, because they really paid attention to his
needs."
Added Kathy Clinton, "I would say to other families, that if they have a
child with a life threatening illness, they should contact Make A Wish. It
doesn't matter what your income is, or if you live in a big house or a small
house. They are there to help you and I think that's a wonderful thing."
The Make A Wish Foundation is in need of volunteers in the Brevard County
area. Those interested in learning more about the organization, and how they can
help, should call 1-888-874-9474.
* * *
Readers' Posts
Childrens Resource Center in Scottsdale, AZ has worked with autistic
children since 1981. We would like to build an alternative medical center
housing various therapies, medical treatment, homeopathic remedies and special
dietary needs. We are asking for your support. Tax-deductible contributions will
allow us to hire a Development Director to begin major fund raising. For
information, call 480/483-9130 or info@childrensresources.com.
******
Hi, we are relocating to Cabarrus County in North Carolina. We were wondering
how the school system is with providing services in school and at home. We have
a 4yr old PDD son. Our email is RayJsMama@yahoo.com
******
In regards to the article "US Experts back MMR Doctor's findings". I am
wondering where these Doctors are and what can they do to treat our children
with these problems. The 13 year old child that was in so much pain reminds me
of my daughter. She has had severe problems for years even on the restricted
diet. I know she is in pain but no one wants to do anything. Her doctor in
Atlanta didn't want to put her through doing a scope but feel it is necessary to
find out what is wrong. Can anyone tell me where these supportive doctors are?
Kathy Hudson jhud2@earthlink.net
******
I am a mother of a beautiful 8-year old autistic son with autism. I am also a
psychology student at Purdue University in Indiana. I am asking for your
assistance with an autism research project I have been funded for. It will only
take a few minutes of your time and will hopefully benefit our loved ones.
I am the parent of a 21 year old high Functioning Autistic son. We are
looking for peer groups (other high functioning) Autistic adults or Aspergers in
or near the Birmingham Alabama area. If any one in the area knows of such groups
please respond to offmyrocker8@hotmail.com.
******
We live in the southern suburbs of Chicago and are looking for an alternative
placement for our son who is high-functioning to receive his education. The
public junior high is just too overwhelming for him, and his behavior has become
problematic. Does anyone know of any good
therapeutic schools in Illinois? Tterlis@aol.com
******
My son has Gastro Intestinal, digestive,possible malabsorption, metabolic
disorders. He has had diarhea for 4 months with no weight gain (he is 28 mo
old) and I am desperately looking for a doctor to help us. Can anyone make
any recommendations or share their experiences with this? dgfindley@yahoo.com
******
I live in Contra Costa County in the SF Bay Area in California. I am looking
for a pediatrician who is knowledgeable and willing to evaluate autism-related
problems - e.g. bowel problems, auditory problems, dietary issues, mercury level
testing. mverga@earthlink.net
******
I am moving to the NH/VT/Western MA area. I have a masters degree in clinical
psychology, and over four years experience designing, implementing, and
supervising home-based ABA programs for children with autism. I certainly would
appreciate information on the services available to young children with autism
in these regions. Are in-home programs funded by the families, state, schools?
Thank you for your input. Sarah puddle_dive@hotmail.com
******
>> FREE (Almost) READERS' POSTS <<
For Individuals, organizations, non-commercial and
commercial. Limit your posting to no more than 60
words please. There is no charge for this service,
but posters are obligated to thank all those who take
the time to answer your ads. This is a consideration
for others with autism after you and yours, who seek
assistance from appreciated readers. Send submissions to:
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"