Vaccination should be only used as a last resort against foot-and-mouth
disease, Northern Ireland's agriculture minister has said.
Brid Rodgers' comments came as a government-commissioned report,
published on Tuesday, recommended vaccination should be part of any
strategy to control a future foot-and-mouth outbreak in the UK.
The Royal Society inquiry said animals on an infected farm should still
be culled but suggested healthy livestock on neighbouring premises should
be vaccinated as a "major tool of first resort" to prevent the disease
spreading further.
But Mrs Rodgers said she remained to be convinced that vaccination was
the right option.
Bird Rodgers not convinced over vaccination
|
"Unless you had to use it, we would be very reluctant because of the
impact on the export trade.
"It is something you would have to keep at the back of your mind and
use if necessary, depending on the situation," said Mrs Rodgers.
"We didn't find it necessary as we were able to keep ahead of the
disease and we didn't need to use vaccination. We were very lucky."
Northern Ireland's first outbreak was detected on 1 March last year
among sheep imported from Britain to south Armagh.
Thousands of sheep and cattle were culled as cases of the disease were
discovered in County Tyrone and in the Glens of Antrim.
'Cull not sufficient
The report, from Britain's foremost academy of science, is the first of
two major studies into the government's handling of the epidemic last
year.
The crisis resulted in the deaths of nearly four million animals, and
the destruction of thousands of farmers' livelihoods.
The Royal Society report said the mass cull and severe clampdown on
livestock movement implemented by government officials was essential to
contain the highly infectious disease - but these measures were not enough
on their own, it said.
Thousands of animals were culled
|
"The rapid culling of infected premises and known dangerous contacts,
combined with movement control and rapid diagnosis will remain essential
to controlling foot-and-mouth disease and most other highly infectious
diseases," the report said.
"In many cases this will not be sufficient to guarantee that the
outbreak does not develop into an epidemic."
The Royal Society recommended Britain liaise with its European partners
to ensure the necessary emergency vaccination procedures can be used by
the end of next year.
The report stressed that routine vaccination should not take place in
the UK, as long as the risk of disease entering the country remained low
and provided proper procedures to handle a future outbreak were put in
place.
The Royal Society urged international research groups to investigate "a
vaccine that conferred sterile lifelong immunity against all
foot-and-mouth strains", which would globally reduce the threat from the
disease.
Currently, individual vaccines are only effective against a limited
range of disease strains and animals have to receive regular boosters to
maintain their immunity.