The idea of music as a healing force is not new. Ancient Greeks worshipped
Apollo as the god of both music and medicine, and in the Egyptian and Greek
education systems, healing and sound were considered a highly developed sacred
science.[1] Today, the medical profession recognizes the value of art -- music,
drawing, sculpting, and writing -- in the healing or palliative care of a wide
variety of patients: the chronically or terminally ill, the disabled, the
neurologically impaired, and the mentally challenged. Physicians and other
healthcare workers, psychologists, behavioral therapists -- and, of course,
musicians -- are among the believers. Some believe in it so devoutly that they
are willing to donate their time to the cause without financial gain. Read on to
see some examples of such individuals, and the charitable organizations they
have formed. Songs of Love: The Medicine of Music.
A few years ago, John Beltzer, a successful New York-based
musician/songwriter, had the idea that he would integrate his love for music
with his love for children -- more specifically, his compassion for terminally
ill children. Wouldn't it be nice, he thought, if songs could be written and
performed for sick children to make their illness more bearable? Or even to
contribute to their healing? He discussed the concept with other singers and
songwriters and, before long, he had put together a team of talented people who
were writing personalized songs and performing them at children's hospital wards
and private healthcare institutions -- and sometimes even making house calls.
Beltzer founded the Songs of Love Foundation, and, along with other
volunteers, currently collaborates with about 350 musical artists to give
"encouragement and love to those who need it most through the medicine of
music." Since its inception, this nonprofit organization has visited thousands
of children in more than 150 hospitals and other healthcare institutions in the
United States, and has worked with families to bring the joy and inspiration of
music to children's hearts.
Many schools have gotten involved with the Songs of Love program. Beltzer
brings the sheet music for a personalized song, along with a profile and photo
of the child for whom the song was written, to the participating school, and the
students learn how to sing and record the song on site using equipment provided
by the Foundation. A few days later, the students and their selected child will
receive the recorded Song of Love.
You can be among the performers or songwriters; see the "Join Us" section on
their Web site. If your talents lie elsewhere than music, you can help out by
ordering an original CD compiled by the foundation or a "Songs of Love" T-shirt,
or by making a tax-deductible financial contribution.
Starlight Children's Foundation
Since 1983, this international nonprofit organization has brought a variety
of entertainment to more than 850 hospitals worldwide, giving a much-needed
boost to over 85,000 sick children each month. Starlight offers 6 core programs,
on both an inpatient and outpatient basis, that provide the medicine of
laughter.
"Hospital Happenings" brings cheer to the pediatric ward through holiday
parties and visits from clowns, musicians, and other entertainers. Parents and
medical staff members are also invited to these gatherings.
Recent happenings have included a "Kermit the Frog" show, hoedowns, sock
hops, and Hawaiian luaus.
Under "The Kids Activity Network," Starlight provides families of pediatric
patients with an opportunity to reconnect and meet up with other families going
through similar situations at a variety of events and outings.
These events are organized for the families of children who have
noncommunicable illnesses and vary widely by location; they include theme park
visits, plays, movies, and parties.
"Starlight Fun Centers" are mobile entertainment units containing a
television monitor, videocassette recorder, and Nintendo game system. What child
wouldn't feel less depressed and less isolated after playing a game of Nintendo?
Caregivers have reported reduced need for medication and decreased levels of
stress among their pediatric patients who are offered this diversion. Similar in
concept, "PC Pal" affords hospitalized children the opportunity for interaction,
entertainment, and education through the use of mobile personal computers with
custom-designed software (Figure) and Internet access.
"Starlight Sites" transform ordinary hospital spaces into cozy recreational
environments that provide kids with a safe and comfortable respite from the
otherwise institutional decor. These modules are equipped with games, toys,
books, and multimedia equipment and contain warm and appealing furnishings and
decorations.
Through its "Wishes" program, Starlight has granted more than 21,000 wishes
since the organization's inception. Granting a wish to a sick child can mean
anything from awarding a trip to Disney World to arranging a meeting with a
celebrity. Some children's wishes are more material, such as bicycles,
computers, or toys.
Corporate sponsorship has gone a long way toward enabling The Starlight
Children's Foundation to improve thousands of children's lives. Among the
foundation's numerous corporate sponsors are Colgate-Palmolive, Nintendo of
America, Toys R Us, and American Airlines. The organization also depends on
individual donations, and purchases can be made through The Starlight Store
(sale proceeds benefit the foundation). North Yorkshire Music Therapy Centre
Based in Malton, the British Isles, this registered charity employs 4 trained
music therapists who travel to rural community hospitals, special schools, day
care centers, and individual homes. Using a variety of acoustic and electronic
instruments, the therapists help patients of all ages to express themselves and
communicate through the power of music. Concentration and memory can be improved
by music therapy, the therapists say, as can movement, strength, and
coordination. This form of therapy can also benefit those with terminal
illnesses, mental health and emotional problems, speech or language impairment,
a history of alcohol or drug abuse, dementia, eating disorders, stress, and
autism.
Usually, it is a general practitioner, psychologist, teacher, or caregiver
who refers an individual for music therapy. One of the therapists then pays
several visits to the referred individual and performs an assessment of his or
her needs.
Individual music therapy sessions are usually 30 minutes long, and group
sessions can be as long as 1 hour. They are held at weekly intervals, and the
music therapists provide written reports at regular intervals to chart progress
in meeting the goals that were set during the assessment period.
The North Yorkshire Music Therapy Centre relies on grants and donations.
Although you cannot make a donation online, you can contact Penny Hamer at
admin@nymtc.demon.co.uk to find out how.
Conclusion
Music therapy is a burgeoning profession. It is being offered in traditional
clinical settings where individuals with emotional, developmental, or physical
disabilities are cared for, as well as in other areas of healthcare delivery (eg,
hospice care, substance abuse programs, oncology treatment centers, pain/stress
management clinics, special education programs, correctional settings, early
intervention centers, preschools, day care settings, home-based programs, and
residential treatment centers). Music is frequently used in these settings to
combat depression, alleviate pain, relax or sedate the patient, and brighten the
patient's perspective on life. A qualified music therapist creates a structured
and positive environment in which the elements of music are used to enhance an
individual's self-awareness and spiritual growth, thereby increasing his or her
quality of life.[2] (See the Suggested Reading section for books and articles
about music therapy.) The healing power of music cannot be overestimated. Some
inspiring quotations that reinforce this notion are cited in Table 1. Medical
care alone can keep a sick child alive, but it is the child's emotional state
and quality of life that often determine how well he or she responds to that
care.
"You, the listener, determine the final impact: You are an active conductor
and participant in the process of orchestrating health." -- Don Campbell
(author) "Where is music? You can find it at many levels in the vibrating
strings, the trip of the hammers, the fingers striking the keys, the black marks
on the paper, or the nerve impulses produced in the player brain. But all of
these are just codes; the reality of music is the shimmering, beautiful,
invisible form that haunts our memories without ever being present in the
physical world." -- Deepak Chopra (author; lecturer; CEO and founder of The
Chopra Center for Well Being in La Jolla, California) "(Music therapy) can make
the difference between withdrawal and awareness, between isolation and
interaction, between chronic pain and comfort -- between demoralization and
dignity." -- Barbara Crowe (past president of the National Association for Music
Therapy) "Music is a moral law. It gives soul to the universe, wings to the
mind, flight to the imagination, a charm to sadness, gaiety and life to
everything." -- Plato "Simply put, music can heal people." -- Senator Harry Reid
(Democrat-Nevada) "Almost all children respond to music. Music is an
open-sesame, and if you can use it carefully and appropriately, you can reach
into that child's potential for development." -- Dr. Clive Robbins (Nordoff-Robbins
Music Therapy Clinic) "I regard music therapy as a tool of great power in many
neurological disorders -- Parkinson's and Alzheimer's -- because of its unique
capacity to organize or reorganize cerebral function when it has been damaged."
-- Dr. Oliver Sacks (neurologist and author of Awakenings and The Man Who
Mistook His Wife for a Hat)
Contact Information for Web Sites Mentioned in This Article
North Yorkshire Music Therapy Centre 13a Newbiggin Malton, North Yorkshire
YO17 7JE Phone/FAX: 01653 698129 Email: admin@nymtc.demon.co.uk
Founded in 1998, AMTA's purpose is the progressive development of the
therapeutic use of music in rehabilitation, special education, and community
settings. Predecessors of AMTA included the National Association for Music
Therapy founded in 1950 and the American Association for Music Therapy founded
in 1971. AMTA is committed to the advancement of education, training,
professional standards, credentials, and research in support of the music
therapy profession.
The Healing Music Organization
http://click.topica.com/maaaqBxaaSGYsa4JjTrb/
The Practitioners portion of the Healing Music Organization lists people and
organizations who offer sessions in sound healing, music therapy, vibrational
medicine and areas of color, art, and movement therapy. The Healing Music
Association is an organization of people who utilize sound and music in the
healing arts. The purpose of this association is to promote education,
scientific study, and a sense of community for people to share their experiences
and knowledge about sound and music in healing.
One in 40 Australian children has received medication for emotional or
behavioural problems, according to the first comprehensive national survey on
the issue.
Ritalin and similar behaviour-modifying drugs, used to control attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), were overwhelmingly the most common. The
disorder is believed to affect 11 per cent of children, and the new survey found
13 per cent of those were taking stimulants.
But of all the children identified as taking stimulant medicines, one in four
did not have a diagnosis of the disorder. Instead, they were taking the drugs
for other problems such as autism or aggressive behaviour.
"Regrettably, ADHD medication doesn't fix aggression, it doesn't fix most of
the other problems," said the study's coauthor, Joseph Rey, professor of child
and adolescent psychiatry at the University of Sydney.
Medication was clearly valuable in children with severe ADHD, in which both
poor concentration and over-activity were present. But the diagnosis had
recently been expanded to include poor concentration or impulsive behaviour
alone.
"Should all those kids be treated? . . . a child who has his or her head in
the clouds could be for a variety of reasons that may not be ADHD," Professor
Rey said.
The value of stimulant drugs in the inattentive-only version of the disorder
was unproven, he said, but the drugs would certainly boost the concentration of
any child or adult. That could raise the spectre of parents seeking the
diagnosis of a disorder in order to improve a child's academic performance.
The study - an offshoot of the the Commonwealth-funded Australian National
Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing - sampled a representative group of almost
3600 children, aged six to 17 years, whose parents completed detailed
interviews.
It found boys with ADHD were at least twice as likely as girls to be treated
with Ritalin or dexamphetamine, the other major drug in the category, and up to
six times as likely if their condition largely showed up as inattentive
behaviour. Younger boys with the condition were also more likely to be
prescribed the drugs.
Seventeen per cent of those aged six to 12 were on medication compared with
12 per cent of 13 to 17 year olds. But the situation was reversed for girls. In
the younger age group, four per cent of girls were on stimulants, compared with
10 per cent of adolescent girls with ADHD.
Children taking Ritalin were more likely to be from low-income families with
less-educated parents, perhaps because the disorder was more common in some
social groups, said the study's lead author, Professor Michael Sawyer, head of
child and adolescent psychiatry at the University of Adelaide.
But, he said, it also raised the question of whether "children (are) being
treated with stimulants because they have a condition that might respond to
them, or because they conform to particular demographic characteristics".
"What we want to know next is, amongst those children who receive medication,
what dosage do they receive, over what period of time?" he said.
* * *
CARE
"Model" Social Skills Day Camp Opens In Sacramento
"Announcing the availability of a truly unique service for children and
adolescents diagnosed with autism. This program has been a long time coming and
it is finally here. Sacramento now has a place for children and adolescents with
autism to go after school and on the weekends to improve their social skills as
well as develop individual recreation and play repertoires."
We are thrilled to announce this new program for children, adolescents and
teens diagnosed within the autism spectrum. This project is the result of four
intensely committed individuals who have combined their passion and experience
to provide a center where individuals with autism can come to recreate,
socialize, and enhance individual and group skills and access programs in the
community that they would not otherwise be able to access. It is our goal at
Advance Education, Inc. to assist participants in achieving social integration
as well as develop their ability to learn and participate as members of a group
and community.
In this endeavor we have hired dedicated and energetic staff that are
committed to assisting your children in achieving success. Advance
Education will be partnering with Sacramento City Parks and Recreation to
provide a wide variety of activities and integration/inclusion opportunities for
your children.
How to Enroll Your Child
Step One: Contact your service coordinator at Alta California Regional Center
to request the service. If you are going to be paying privately, you may contact
Advance Education immediately.
Step Two: Contact Advance Education and make an appointment to visit the
program and reserve session time for your child.
Step Three: Complete the intake process with the Director.
Step Four: Bring your child to the center for his/her sessions and see the
progress!
Please feel free to ask questions at any time. Our team members are here to
make your child's participation successful and enjoyable for your whole family.
We are happy to assist you in any way we can.
If you need assistance in the enrollment process, please contact Michelle
Wenell at 916 920-4012.
General Information:
June through August ONLY.
Monday through Friday 8:30 am - 7:00 pm
Saturday 10:00 am - 7:00 pm
Sunday 11:00 am - 4:00 pm
September through May:
Monday through Friday 2:00 p.m. - 7:00 p.m.
Saturday 10:00 a.m. - 7:00 p.m.
Sunday 11:00 a.m. - 4:00 p.m.
[Visit their website for more information at
www.advanceeducation.com.
Mention you read about this in the Schafer Autism Report and you will get a
promise to receive a handy pocket reference card to go along with the latest
edition of "Recovering Autistic Kids for Dummies" soon to be released along with
"State Guest Celebrities: Their Cooked Books, Recipes, Halfway Houses and
Gardens" by Martha Stewart's new Work-Release Press. I'm kidding of course, the
reference card is too big to fit into a pocket. -Lenny.]
* * *
EDUCATION
Students' Private Records Found Outside NY City School
Included records about special education students, most of whom were
identified as having cerebral palsy. . .and I.E.P.'s
Anyone walking by Martin Luther King Jr. High School in Manhattan on Friday
night was free to learn Jarnell Branford's address, her phone number, her Social
Security number, even her educational progress.
And they could read confidential information about many of her classmates,
too - their grades, disciplinary reports and, for disabled students, medical
reports - just by poring through boxes and boxes of records apparently discarded
with the trash.
"I think this is awful that my kid's personal papers were thrown out like
that," said Trinal Branford, Jarnell's mother. "I feel that is just awful."
Dozens of residents of nearby buildings and passers-by thumbed through many
of the thousands of pages of documents left on West 65th Street, near Amsterdam
Avenue, outside the school.
The records, many of which are from the last few years, included information
that appears to be protected by United States Department of Education
regulations requiring schools to "protect the confidentiality of personally
identifiable information at collection, storage, disclosure and destruction
stages."
The regulations, available on the department's Web site, require schools to
destroy or remove personally identifiable information from the records of
special education students. In addition, the Family Educational Rights and
Privacy Act of 1974 requires that schools keep personally identifiable
information secure and access to it kept to a limited number of people.
Schools risk losing federal financial assistance if they violate the act or
the Education Department's regulations.
The Manhattan high school superintendent, W. L. Sawyer. Mr. Sawyer said he
opened an investigation into the disposal of the records after being notified by
Board of Education officials.
"I am still trying to ascertain what type of documents they were," Mr. Sawyer
said yesterday afternoon. "I am obviously going to investigate this very
carefully and obviously this is something that should not occur."
"A violation of children's privacy has most certainly occurred," Mr. Sawyer
said, adding that he planned to meet with school officials on Monday to discuss
the matter.
Police officials were contacted by The New York Times early yesterday after
neighborhood residents called the newspaper to report the presence of the
records. The police officials said that they had no jurisdiction to confiscate,
remove or discard them.
A police spokesman, Officer George Jensen, said that the documents were "not
our records, not our jurisdiction," and that if school officials "put something
out, they deemed it to be trash."
The records were still on the sidewalk as of early yesterday. But Mr. Sawyer
said that sanitation workers had removed most of them by the afternoon.
One box included letters that students had written to one another to be
included in a time capsule; another included records about special education
students, most of whom were identified as having cerebral palsy.
Many documents are what are known in educational circles as I.E.P.'s, or
individualized educational programs. Those records document each special
education student's eligibility for special accommodations and services, and
outline the school's plan to guarantee that student an education that meets his
or her needs.
"This is simply outrageous and unprofessional," said a parent of a special
education student whose records were left outside the school.
"It's unbelievable," said a man who identified himself only as a neighborhood
resident. "It has everything there. Someone could take on the kids' identity.
It's just so crazy that they could do this; it's mind-baffling."
With 3,000 students, Martin Luther King Jr. High School is large even by New
York City standards.
Enid F. Margolies, a former director of educational safety, development and
support for the school system, was recently appointed interim principal,
succeeding Steve Gutman, a 36-year veteran of the school system. Mr. Gutman
retired in September 2001 but returned in February after the removal of Ronald
Williams Wells, during whose tenure there was a spate of violence involving
weapons at the school, including a January shooting. Board of Education
officials who toured the school at the time complained that some people who were
in the building were not enrolled in courses but were carrying photo
identification cards.
Mr. Sawyer has said that Dr. Margolies will oversee efforts to improve the
school's security and curriculum as well as its transformation into two smaller
academies next year.
* * *
The Cost Of Public Vs. Private Schools: Comparisons Are Tricky Special
Education costs are a key factor
[By Norman Draper in the Minneapolis, Minnesota Star Tribune.]
Do private schools offer a better education value than public schools?
A look at spending for public and private schools in Minnesota can certainly
raise questions. Consider this:
It cost $10,685 during the 2000-01 school year to educate a child in the
Minneapolis public schools, where hundreds of kids flunk state basic-skills
tests every year.
But the tuition was $8,375 for a high school student at Minneapolis' private
Minnehaha Academy, where 95 percent of graduates go on to college.
And at Ascension Catholic school in Minneapolis, where most students are poor
minority children, and where passing rates on state basic-skills tests were far
higher than those of Minneapolis public schools, tuition was a mere $1,200.
Such comparisons become especially relevant in the wake of Thursday's U.S.
Supreme Court ruling in favor of school vouchers. Vouchers allow students to use
public funds to pay private-school tuition.
Gov. Jesse Ventura latched on to the comparison between what private schools
charge and public schools spend last February, stating that the tax money needed
to educate a public-school student is more than the cost of tuition at one of
the metro area's top prep schools. That, he said, indicates that something is
wrong with the public schools.
But a closer look shows those numbers are misleading.
With the cooperation of several Twin Cities public and private schools, the
Star Tribune examined how both sectors break down their finances. The picture
that emerged is one of two systems that, though they're both in the business of
educating children, spend their money so differently that it is tough to say for
certain which offers more educational bang for the buck.
Among the newspaper's findings:
* Tuition doesn't cover the cost of a private-school education. At St. Paul
Academy and Summit School, one of the Twin Cities' most prestigious prep
schools, the average tuition will be $15,900 next year. But the cost of
educating the average student will be $17,800, higher than the per-pupil cost of
any public school district in Minnesota.
The gap is greater at many other private schools. Tuition and fees at
Victoria's Holy Family Catholic High School in 2000-01 were $6,800 per pupil,
but the total cost of educating that student was $10,136. That's a higher
per-pupil cost than all but 11 of the state's 345 public school districts.
Private schools make up much of the difference by soliciting donations from
parents and alumni.
* Private schools aren't just privately funded. They get millions of dollars
for textbooks and health and counseling services from the state, as well as bus
service from neighboring public schools and the use of public-school facilities,
according to the state Department of Children, Families and Learning.
The suburban Mounds View district funneled $529,625 in state funds to private
schools within its boundaries during the 2000-01 school year.
Public funds "pay for our school nurse," said Pamela Clarke, the head of St.
Paul Academy and Summit School.
Minnehaha Academy financial figures show that Kristi Classen's third-grade
class of 22 children got $1,349 in state funds in 2001-02 for books and other
materials. "If we lost that state funding, we would really be hurting," said
Minnehaha Academy lower school Principal Kathy Johnson.
* Private schools admit whom they want. Public schools must accept every
school-age child -- and the costs of serving them. At Minneapolis' Roosevelt
High School, $1.8 million was spent on special education in 2000-01. That same
year, Holy Family Catholic didn't spend a dime on special education. Minnehaha
Academy, with about three-quarters the student population of Roosevelt, spent
$60,000.
* Public high schools spend hundreds of thousands of dollars each year for
vocational programs to help students who aren't on the college track. Vocational
education at New Brighton's Irondale High School cost $618,000 during the
2000-01 school year, and just $16,000 at Minnehaha Academy that year.
While the Supreme Court's school-voucher ruling could open the door
nationwide for more state voucher programs, its impact on Minnesota is
uncertain. A state voucher proposal probably will be put before the Legislature
next year. But a similar proposal by Gov. Arne Carlson in 1996 was rejected, and
feelings among current state leaders are mixed. Both Gov. Jesse Ventura and
education Commissioner Christine Jax have voiced concerns about using public
money to fund private, especially parochial, schools.
Still, every year, thousands of parents struggle with the decision of whether
to dip into savings to send their kids to private school. Thousands more wonder
whether their property-tax dollars are being spent wisely by local public
schools.
Making comparisons
To learn more about public-and private-school spending, the Star Tribune
gathered detailed financial information from four public and two private
schools. Public schools included Roosevelt High and Andersen Elementary in
Minneapolis and Irondale High and Valentine Hills Elementary in the Mounds View
district. Private schools were Minnehaha Academy in Minneapolis and Holy Family
Catholic High School in Victoria.
Across broad categories, such as regular instructional costs, private and
public schools can show similar spending trends. But within those categories,
differences emerge.
One of the biggest is in teacher salaries.
Public schools, which negotiate contracts with teachers unions, pay more for
teachers than private schools. Sometimes much more. Minnehaha Academy's lowest
teacher salary for the 2000-01 school year was $24,256, and its highest $55,710.
The lowest teacher salary at the public Valentine Hills Elementary, in Arden
Hills, was $28,000, and the highest $60,506.
Benefits can be vastly different. Holy Family Catholic averaged about $3,455
in benefits for its teachers in 2000-01. Average teacher benefits at Valentine
Hills were $11,856 that year. Some state officials argue that teacher pay is
where public schools fail to spend responsibly, negotiating generous contracts,
then cutting staff and programs when the books don't balance.
What's tough to say is whether better pay allows public schools to attract
better teachers. Some good teachers go for the bigger public paychecks, while
others say the smaller class sizes and fewer behavior problems of private
schools are worth less money.
Public schools such as Andersen, which have lots of poor and
non-English-speaking students, are generally much more expensive to operate than
most private schools.
In addition to the regular classroom teachers, last year's part-and full-time
Andersen staff roster included these specialists: master teachers in reading and
math to improve classroom teaching, a social worker, two English-language
teachers, two special-education teachers, a psychologist, a bilingual program
aide, an American Indian home liaison worker, a gifted-and-talented teacher, a
nurse and an occupational therapist. And that's not a complete list.
By contrast, the elementary school at Minnehaha Academy shares a counselor
between the Minneapolis and Bloomington campuses and a nurse with the middle
school.
"We don't have the kinds of staff and aides that public schools have," said
Principal Johnson. "We can allot more [in instructional supplies] to every grade
level because we don't have instructional aides in every classroom or any kind
of pullout special-ed programs. Our teachers do playground duties, where aides
do those duties in public schools."
But even with higher teacher pay, suburban public schools with lower
concentrations of poor and non-English-speaking students can be cheaper to
operate than private schools.
For instance, administrative and office costs at Irondale High School were
much lower at $476 per pupil than Minnehaha Academy's $777 per pupil. Irondale's
per-pupil costs for operations and maintenance and instructional support
services (which includes assistant principals, media centers, staff development
and computer-assisted instruction), also were lower than Minnehaha Academy's.
Minnehaha Academy president John Engstrom thinks that's in part caused by
expenses for such things as fundraising and admissions, which public schools
don't have. He thinks it's also due to a strong commitment to technology.
"We've got a head of technology and four support people who just service our
network and keep it running," he said. "When something goes wrong we fix it in a
day or two. I don't think that's often the case in the public schools."
Equipment envy
Minnehaha Academy's big technology investment notwithstanding, private
schools often focus their resources on the basics: small class sizes, classroom
supplies and a core group of courses with few frills. St. Paul Academy and
Summit School's average class size of 15 would be the envy of any public school,
but Clarke can think of reasons to be envious in return.
"Often, the public schools have more and better equipment, particularly in
the sciences," she said. On a visit to St. Paul's public Arlington High School,
a school placed on academic probation by district officials for substandard
student achievement, Clarke marveled at the bountiful equipment.
"They had wonderful computer labs with dozens of computers," she said. "I was
very, very favorably impressed."
But not all private schools are alike. For example, in terms of its
demographics, Ascension has more in common with Andersen than Minnehaha Academy.
There can be a facilities and resources gap separating private schools, too.
"One of the public misconceptions of private schools is that they are all
very well funded," said Jim Field, president of the Minnesota Independent School
Forum. "I've been in some private schools that have very shabby facilities and
are very poorly equipped."
You don't see much difference between the basic public and private school
classroom, said Richard Engler, president and principal of Cretin-Derham Hall, a
Catholic high school in St. Paul.
Visits to a number of schools bear him out. The basic supplies are
similar: books, blackboards or whiteboards, posters, chalk, colored markers
and worksheets.
Older schools, public and private, have old desks and chairs and frayed
carpeting patched with duct tape. Many have wall-mounted TV sets, computers and
a CD or cassette player in the room.
Michelle Zenk-Olson's fourth-grade class at Minneapolis' Andersen Elementary
is a bright, active room slathered with displays: posters, colored illustrations
of multiplication tables and months of the year, featured student biographies
and the like. Much like Classen's Minnehaha Academy third-grade room.
What's different is where the money comes from to buy such things.
Classen's supplies mostly come from the $2,500 classroom budget she shares
with the school's other third-grade teacher. Plus, there's that book and
materials subsidy from the state and a separate technology fund.
Meanwhile, Zenk-Olson must dig into her own pockets to furnish her classroom
with the things she wants.
"I know my first week, just getting this room ready was well over $400," she
said. ". . . Everything comes out of your own pocket. Everything."
What numbers don't tell
Beyond these differences, there are other ways that school cost figures can
mislead. For example, Holy Family Catholic High School reported much higher
per-pupil costs for administration and operations and maintenance costs than the
other five schools surveyed. But Holy Family is designed to hold 1,000 students.
It opened in 2000 with 147 students, and was up to only 217 last year. Such a
small number of students is going to make its costs appear much higher.
"When we are at 1,000 students, the administration won't increase in size,"
said Holy Family Principal Kathleen Brown. "There are positions that need to be
filled whether you have 20 students or 1,000 students."
Certainly, some private schools seem to be offering a good deal for the
money.
Dorwatha Woods Adderly, Minneapolis' Ascension Catholic's principal
administrator, figures her per-pupil annual costs at about $4,000, a pittance
when considering the school's high poverty rate but impressive test scores.
But in most cases, trying to pit public against private schools based on
school spending is like trying to compare those two different fruits.
"It's really hard to compare the two systems, because they are systems with
two different purposes," Field said. "The private schools in the state exist to
serve a specific purpose or population separate from government-supported
schools. . . . Public schools have the task of educating everyone who comes in
their door."
* * *
MEDIA
Hope and Inspiration Fills the Summer issue of the Autism Asperger's Digest
[From the Editor of the Autism Asperger's Digest.]
The July-August 2002 issue of the Autism Asperger's Digest, the nation 's
only magazine devoted to autism spectrum disorders, has just been released.
"It's an issue perfect for those lazy days of summer, when it's too hot to do
much else. These are stories filled with hope and inspiration, from determined
parents and dedicated professionals" stated Managing Editor Veronica Zysk. "One
mom shares the gut-wrenching feeling of hearing the autism diagnosis, even
though she suspected it right along. Another mom talks about the special gifts
her daughter has brought to her life. A dad writes about the often amusing,
characteristically autistic bedtime ritual he shares with his son, while a young
man with autism openly expresses his appreciation to his mom for not curbing his
autistic tendencies. It's a feel-good issue filled with useful information for
parents and professionals."
The Autism Asperger's Digest magazine debuted in late 1999 and remains the
ONLY magazine in the U.S. today for the autism community. Subscribers receive
six information-packed issues each year. To learn more about it, visit their
website at
My 2 year old son was diagnosed with autism last week. Coincidentally, we
have also discovered that our house has severe dryrot and mold problems. One of
the molds we found produces mycotoxins. Our local doctors say they know of no
evidence linking molds/mycotoxins to autism, and an autism concern shouldn't
prompt us to move out while we wait for repairs to being next year. Does anyone
have any info regarding molds, stachybotrys, or mycotoxins causing or increasing
autism? jmatthias@apl.com
******
The latest edition of the 40-page, monthly autism newsletter, Looking Up, is
out now and it includes Education Special: 'One in 86 primary schoolchildren in
England is autistic'; Children with special needs, including autism, could lose
out as UK government hardens rules on excludiing pupils from schools; 'My
autistic son learned to socialise in mainstream classroom'; How Floortime
'worked wonders for my son'; Ontario study makes dramatic claims for Applied
Behavioural Analysis programme; Dana's diploma challenges pre-conceived ideas on
Asperger's syndrome. Also, Gymastics And Genetics, other Research and More
I am a mother of a 5 1/2 year old autistic son, we are from India. At present
I am In U.S for his tretment. He has a speech delay along with autisitic
features, I would be very grateful if parents who had now-older children with
the similar problems, if you'll have any material to share which is useful for
training my son, especially his speech and language. lobonanc@rediffmail.com
******
New book out: 'Autism: Now What? The Primer for Parents, Teachers and
Professionals.' $9.95, Free Shipping, Available to Non-profits and some other
organizations for $3.00 Limited time offer and some restrictions apply. Phat Art
4 P.O. Box 711 Stratham, NH 03885 Ph.# 603-778-9990 Fx.# 603-778-9669
publisher@phatart4.com,
Epidemiologist wanted: The Program Office of the National Children's Study at
NICHD is recruiting for a staff scientist to help develop a large cohort study
of environmental effects on children's health and development, as part of a
federal multi-agency effort. This is to be a very large national multi center
study of approximately 100,000 children and their families followed from before
birth to adulthood. This position is expected to support the scientific
planning, implementation and analysis and reporting of the study. Duties will
include synthesizing scientific data, writing study protocols, scientific
supervision of NCS research projects, interpretation and reporting of results,
serving as (or becoming) an expert on specific aspects of the study, and working
with study committees and working groups to provide scientific support. For more
information about the proposed study and the position, see the Web page at
or contact Ms. Tammy Locklear locklea1@niehs.nih.gov.
******
I am considering an SSRI (Prozac, Paxil, etc) for my nearly 3 yr old autistic
daughter. Her obsessiveness and anxiety are reasons for considering the med.
Already doing gfcf and behavior therapies. Any successes or failures stories to
share? Debi H. fightingautism@yahoo.com
******
We are looking to purchase a used platform or sling swing similar to those
used in OT. Does anybody have one to sell or know of where we can purchase?
Thank you! Betsy8626@earthlink.net
******
Has anyone used the SRA's Direct Instruction for Reading and Math? I am
looking to share a purchase with anyone who is interested in Level A,B for
Reading and Level B for math. Or if anyone has used them and wants to unload the
Presentation books, please e-mail me Schong6@hotmail.com.
******
Announcing the launch of a new service that aims to link job seekers with
recruiters who work with autistic people in the UK. This service has been
developed in direct response to the research we carried out with autismconnect
users last year. It is free to job seekers, and you can find out more at
ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND
MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION
PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS
OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR
LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND
COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH
YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"