Ten areas of London have been slated in the league tables for failing to
vaccinate children against mumps, measles and rubella.
In their annual league tables the government looked for the first time
at the new Primary Care Trusts.
Ambulance Trusts were also rated for the first time and achieved good
marks with nearly 40% of all trusts reaching the top three star grade.
But mental health campaigners have condemned ratings for mental and
community health trusts, claiming the government failed to consider the
patient's experience.

An awful lot of London GPs have been worried about the possibility
of a measles epidemic

|
|
A BMA spokeswoman
|
Government figures found worrying levels for MMR vaccination rates in
10 London boroughs.
'Herd immunity'
In Haringey the protection levels for MMR fell to just 68% and in Tower
Hamlets it dipped to 70%.
GPs say vaccination levels must reach 95% if they are to create a so
called "herd immunity" to protect children from outbreaks.
A spokeswoman for the BMA said: "An awful lot of London GPs have been
worried about the possibility of a measles epidemic.
"Obviously there is a huge challenge to reassure parents of the safety
of MMR.
"But the overwhelming consensus amongst medical professionals is that
it is safe.
"Somehow we have to find a way to convince people to have their
children vaccinated."
In contrast 100% of children in Kettering and 98.6% in Bromsgrove
Primary Care Group were vaccinated.
Star ratings
The ratings studied a number of other key areas of service, including
how many patients were able to see a GP within 48 hours; the number of
teenage pregnancies and how many deaths there were from circulatory
diseases.
From next year the Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) will be given star
ratings, which will mean extra funds for the highest performers.
|
Trusts failing to meet eight minute target
|
|
Sussex Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Wiltshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Avon Ambulance Service Trust
Mersey Regional Ambulance Service NHS Trust
|
The Ambulance Service Association (ASA) said they were delighted by
their trusts performance.
Richard Dimet, chief executive of the ASA, said: "The ratings announced
today are a credit to ambulance staff and crews throughout England.
"However, no one is complacent and everyone in the ambulance service is
committed to delivering even higher standards of care in the future."
Criticism
But Health Which? criticised the ratings as "flawed and misleading" and
claimed some of the services were "massaging the figures."
Four trusts failed to meet the eight minute target for category A calls
and nine failed to meet the 14-19 minute targets on category A calls.
Another three were named the worst in England for failing to meet the
15 minute targets for GP urgent calls.
|
Trusts failing to meet 15 minute targets for urgent GP calls
|
|
Greater Manchester Ambulance Service
London Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Oxfordshire Ambulance Service Trust
|
The Royal Berkshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust was awarded three stars
for meeting more than 85% of its life threatening calls within eight
minutes.
But Health Which? claimed the trust had only classified 10% of its
calls as life-threatening, compared to nearer 40% in other trusts.
Long waits
And the mental health charity Rethink condemned the performance
measurement of mental health trusts, which they said took no consideration
of the patient's views and did not take into account long waits for
treatment.
Just over two thirds of community trusts, which provide mental
services, were given two star ratings and four trusts got three star
ratings.
Bedfordshire and Luton Community NHS and South Warwickshire Combined
Care NHS Trust were given a zero rating.
But Cliff Prior, chief executive of Rethink, said: "Rethink believes it
is vital that mental health trusts are measured just as rigorously as
other parts of the NHS.
"But people who use mental health services will be surprised to see
such positive results it is simply not the experience they have.
Marjorie Wallace, Chief Executive of mental health charity Sane,
agreed.
"Sane's survey of psychiatrists and the 1,000 calls a week to our
helpline paint a far gloomier picture of mental health services and
highlight the absurdity of performance measures for people with enduring
mental illness who need time, space and activity rather than quick
turnover. "