Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News (Jul 12, 10:50 PM)
Jul. 12--Scientists have built the polio virus from scratch
in the laboratory, a sign that terrorists could make
dangerous viruses from widely available genetic information.
Guided by the published recipe of the polio virus's
genetic structure, molecular biologists at the State
University of New York at Stony Brook linked small pieces of
easy-to-obtain DNA to make a virus template. A routine
chemical process then converted the template into the polio
virus itself, the biologists report in a paper released
Thursday by the journal Science.
Tests of the synthetic virus in mice produced symptoms
similar to those caused by the natural polio virus, once
feared for its ability to induce paralysis and sometimes
death but now nearly eradicated.
It's the first time scientists have built a synthetic
copy of a virus based on the genetic blueprint, or genome,
of the natural form, said Eckard Wimmer, one of the paper's
authors.
"Nobody has ever put together an entire genome and made
virus out of it," he said in a telephone interview.
Information on virus genomes is easy to access from
papers published in scientific journals and online
databases. "You open the Internet and lift out a sequence
and go to work and make a virus without ever having seen the
virus in your laboratory," Dr. Wimmer said.
Dr. Wimmer and collaborators Jeronimo Cello and Aniko
Paul undertook the project just for the sake of proving that
genetic information can be used to re-create a virus. But
their success also demonstrates the potential for terrorists
to create from scratch a variety of deadly viruses not
otherwise easy to obtain, Dr. Wimmer said.
"This work is very important to put society on alert," he
said. "This is an inherent danger in biochemistry and
scientific research. Society has to deal with it. ... It
won't go away if we close our eyes."
Other scientists said the new report was not surprising.
"Certainly this has been something that's been possible
in principle for some time," said Steven Block, a
biophysicist and bioterrorism expert at Stanford University.
"So certainly it's not a breakthrough in a major sense. ...
But this may raise public consciousness about the issue."
Scientists have speculated that terrorists might try to
create deadlier viruses, such as smallpox, from published
genetic recipes.
"To chemically synthesize smallpox would be a major
undertaking, but doable," said Stephen Johnston, a molecular
biologist at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical
Center at Dallas.
Making smallpox virus would be more difficult than making
polio virus, he said. The polio virus is relatively small,
composed primarily of about 7,500 chemical units called
nucleotides. Smallpox is a more complicated virus and is
much bigger, made from nearly 190,000 nucleotides.
"It is much more difficult to do currently, but with
progress in science and technology, it will be possible in
10 to 15 years to make smallpox," Dr. Wimmer said.
Apart from spotlighting a terrorist danger,
reconstructing the polio virus could lead to benefits for
medicine, such as rebuilding other viruses in a weakened
form to help devise new vaccines.
To produce the polio virus, Dr. Wimmer and colleagues
assembled short stretches of DNA (averaging 69 nucleotides
in length) into the proper sequence to match the virus's
genome, the genetic blueprint for making new copies of the
virus. (The DNA segments are routinely obtainable by mail
order.) The polio virus itself is made of RNA, a related
molecule that also can store and transmit genetic
information. So the researchers mixed the DNA template with
chemicals that converted it into the corresponding viral
RNA. Mixed into a soup of cell parts, the RNA orchestrated
production of polio virus particles.
The synthetic virus was purposely produced with slight
variations from the original blueprint so that the
researchers could distinguish it from the natural form.
Though much weaker than the natural virus, the synthetic
version still produced polio symptoms in mice that had been
genetically engineered to be susceptible to infection.
Making viruses other than polio would require
modifications to the methods reported by the Stony Brook
scientists, Dr. Wimmer said. But Dr. Block of Stanford said
he doubted that routine virus synthesis would become a major
weapon in terrorist arsenals.
"Someone bent on producing biological weapons wouldn't go
this route," he said. "There are much easier ways to do it."
Of greater concern, Dr. Block said, would be efforts to
combine different viruses into a chemical chimera with the
most dangerous properties of both.
"I'd be more worried about people patching together
chimeric viruses," Dr. Block said. "Imagine something as
contagious as measles but as lethal as Ebola." The polio
virus synthesis, he said, is not relevant to the creation of
such chimeras.
The polio synthesis does suggest, however, that future
vaccination policies ought to reflect the danger of virus
reconstruction from genetic data, said Dr. Wimmer. "It could
be a problem that has to be taken into consideration," he
said.
To see more of The Dallas Morning News, or to subscribe
to the newspaper, go to http://www.dallasnews.com.
(c) 2002, The Dallas Morning News. Distributed by Knight
Ridder/Tribune Business News.