Mayor condemned over MMR advice

by Maxine Frith
Doctors' leaders today launched a furious attack on Ken Livingstone after
he advised London parents not to give their children the MMR jab.
Delegates at the British Medical Association annual conference in
Harrogate accused the Mayor of "breathtaking irresponsibility" in calling
for the introduction of single vaccines as an alternative to the triple jab.
Four prominent London GPs have written to the Evening Standard saying
that Mr Livingstone would have to share responsibility if any children died
as a result of a measles outbreak because of low MMR uptake.
The letter is signed by Dr Tony Grewal, Dr Gillian Braunold, Dr Chaand
Nagpaul and Dr Laurence Buckman.
They say: "Mr Livingstone does not have the right to put the health and
well-being of London children at risk by ill-informed advice to parents to
avoid MMR vaccination.
"Measles has already raised its ugly head in London as a result of
falling immunity rates and Mr Livingstone must share responsibility for the
disability and even death that will inevitably result."
The Mayor's comments, made on a radio programme yesterday, are to be
condemned at a debate on MMR at the conference later today.
On the programme, Mr Livingstone said: "This whole debate is about
administrative convenience. My advice to Londoners is that if you can, get
it done separately."
He suggested that the Government was only in favour of the MMR
combination rather than three separate injections in order to save money.
He added that there was "no way" he would let his soon-to-be-born child
have the MMR vaccine.
Dr Grewal told the Evening Standard today: "It was an unbelievably and
breathtakingly irresponsible thing for the Mayor to say.
"If one child dies or is seriously brain-damaged as a result of measles,
I will point the finger at Ken Livingstone.
"This seems to me to be a cynical attempt to draw attention away from the
other troubles he has been having recently." Dr
Tony Stanton, the head of London's GPs, said that the Mayor's office had
snubbed numerous attempts by the BMA and local medical committees to advise
him on the capital's health issues.
He said: "We did try to talk to the Mayor but we got nowhere. He didn't
seem to be interested in what we might have to say.
"This will not help London GPs who are already having huge problems
persuading parents to have their children immunised.
"It is extremely unhelpful and seems to have been based on little
understanding of all the evidence that says MMR is safe and effective."
He added: "Ken Livingstone has done potentially years of damage in
London."
Dr John Chisholm, chairman of the BMA's GPs committee said: "It seems to
have been an extremely unfortunate comment on the part of the Mayor.
"International research overwhelmingly points to the safety and efficacy
of MMR and no link has ever been proven with autism and bowel disease.
"Doctors do what is best for their patients, not what is administratively
convenient."
Email
this article to a friend</ a>
© Associated Newspapers Ltd., 03 July 2002
Terms and Conditions
This Is London
 |