Vaccination News Home Page

http://society.guardian.co.uk/publichealth/story/0,11098,748125,00.html

Guardian Unlimited
 
Login

Go to:  

SocietyGuardian.co.uk
Home   Health   Housing   Regeneration   Local government   Voluntary sector   Social care   Talk  
Jobs   Careers   Policy   Conferences   Glossary   Big issues   Comment   Help  


 

  Public health

  Search this site

 Recent articles
Robert Winston: Blaming IVF doctors alone is wrong

 
Couple in IVF mix-up wait for court date

 
HRT study cancelled over cancer and stroke fears

 
Leader: Humane abortion

 
Treat news of Aids vaccine with caution

 
US may vaccinate 500,000 health workers against smallpox

 
DIY abortion pill plan outrages Pro-Life lobby

 
Researchers doubt value of vitamin pills

 
Drug promises heart disease revolution

 
So what did Ken really say about the MMR?

 

 

  Public health

Livingstone advises parents to shun MMR jabs

David Batty and agencies
Tuesday July 2, 2002


The mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, has called on the government to provide single jabs for measles, mumps and rubella, arguing that the controversial MMR vaccine was too risky to "inflict" on young children.

The mayor, whose partner Emma Beal is expecting their first child this year, said the triple vaccine was being promoted because it saved time and money.

Mr Livingstone told BBC Radio 5 Live that his own child would receive single jabs.

Some parents have claimed that MMR caused their children to develop autism or bowel disorders.

But the government has said there is no scientific evidence to support these claims and insists the triple vaccine is safe.

Commenting on the alleged risks posed by MMR, the mayor said: "There's no way I would inflict that risk on a child."

He said children as young as 14-months-old were "incredibly vulnerable" and it did not seem wise to "whack" all the vaccines into a child at once.

"I think the government should make single jabs available until you can show there is no risk."

Parents were wary of government advice over the safety of MMR after other health scares such as BSE, he added.

"This whole debate is about administrative convenience, rather than chasing them [parents] up separately, it is about saving time and money," said the mayor.

"It is not like you cannot have separate jabs - it is just that it is cheaper.

"My advice to all Londoners is that if you can, get it done separately. I do not think there is a risk."

Confusingly, a spokeswoman for the mayor denied that he had advised parents against inoculating their children with MMR.

She said: "The BBC report quite grossly misrepresents what he said. All he said was, whether the concern about the combined vaccine is real or not, that parents should have a choice.

"He was not recommending the single jabs over the triple vaccine but was stressing his personal opinion that parents should get their children vaccinated in some way."

The mayor's comments came after the British Medical Association conference warned that parents do not trust medical advice on the MMR jab because they know GPs are paid to recommend it.

Dr Hamish Meldrum, a GP from East Yorkshire, called for the abolition of the target payment system at the BMA's annual conference in Harrogate.

Currently GPs receive payments if they immunise 70% of the children on their patient list and the amount increases significantly if they achieve 90%.

Dr Meldrum, joint deputy chairman of the BMA's GP committee, said many parents were aware of the target payment system and in some cases it made them doubt their GP's advice.

"Colleagues have had patients say to them you are only giving this advice because there is money in it for you," he said.

Talk about it
Should parents be allowed access to single vaccinations? Would you allow your child to have the MMR jab?

Related articles
01.07.2002: Measles cases quadruple
28.06.2002: MMR 'may cause 1 in 10 cases of autism'
17.06.2002: MMR row resurfaces
12.06.2002: Research gives MMR vaccination all-clear
13.03.2002: Measles returns to Scotland
08.03.2002: A healthy challenge to the media
06.03.2002: Measles spreads as jab is shunned
22.02.2002: MMR analyst urges swift research on risk group
20.02.2002: Three out of four parents favour single jabs for MMR
14.02.2002: Injection of confidence for MMR
14.02.2002: Measles outbreak grows in London
07.02.2002: Blair warning as measles panic grows
07.02.2002: Sarah Boseley: The MMR vaccination and autism
07.02.2002: Defiant parents stand by decision
07.02.2002: Catherine Bennett: Needled Tony should rethink on the MMR jab
07.02.2002: MMR: the facts
07.02.2002: Leader: No compromise over MMR
06.02.2002: Q&A: measles and MMR
21.01.2002: Comment: Injecting some sense into the anti-vaccination lobby
24.12.2001: How seeds of doubt were sown by doctor
22.12.2001: Blair urged to set jab row example
10.08.2001: The battle over immunisation

Big issue
Public health

Useful sites
Nicky Campbell Five Live phone-in
Sense: Remember Rubella (pdf)
UK Public Health Association
British Medical Journal
World Health Organisation
British Medical Association
BMJ paper: Mumps, measles, and rubella vaccine and the incidence of autism
General Medical Council





 


Printable version | Send it to a friend | Read it later | See saved stories



UP

 

SocietyGuardian.co.uk © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2002
 

Vaccination News Home Page

ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE.  THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.