|
Special report: home affairs
4pm update
Government forced to
admit vaccine error
Staff and agencies
Friday July 5, 2002
The government was today forced into a second embarrassing admission of
error, as public health minister Hazel Blears revealed assurances that no
vaccines used in the UK contain material derived from cattle were wrong.
In fact highly processed and inactive substances which might have
originated from bovine materials were sometimes present in finished
vaccines, she admitted.
It is the second correction issued by the government this week, after the
work and pensions department revealed it has overestimated public savings in
private pension schemes by up to £30bn.
Ms Blears apologised to MPs for the inaccuracy, saying it was due to
wrong advice given to ministers by the medicines control agency.
Ms Blears stressed that a thorough investigation by experts on the
committee on safety of medicines (CSM) had concluded that vaccines did not
pose any demonstrable BSE risk.
"The CSM, after an exhaustive and rigorous review, found no source for
concern in relation to TSEs about the safety of vaccines used in this
country," she told the house.
TSEs, or transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, include BSE and its
human version, variant CJD.
Fears about the presence of BSE in vaccines were raised in October 2000
when an oral polio vaccine was recalled as a "precautionary measure".
The vaccine, made by Medeva Pharma, had used material derived from UK
calf serum dating back to 1985, when the BSE epidemic was at its height.
Foetal calf serum was regularly used early in the manufacturing process
of vaccines. But in the case of the polio vaccine, it was also used in the
later stages.
The chief medical officer had concluded that the decision to withdraw the
vaccine was correct at the time. However, experts agreed that foetal calf
serum had "no detectable infectivity" and the CSM had decided that the risk
of Medeval polio vaccine transmitting variant CJD was "incalculably small".
Ms Blears said ministers now had three reports, from the CSM, the chief
medical officer, and the Medicines Control Agency, which together provided a
comprehensive analysis of the issues relating to TSEs and vaccines.
It was clear from the reports that some statements had been made in
parliament which were either incorrect or misleading.
"Ministers made these statements on the basis of incorrect advice and
information given to them at the time by the medicines control agency, which
licences medicines for the UK market and monitors the safety of medicines in
use," said Ms Blears.
"I repeat my apologies to the house and also convey those of my
predecessors for the fact that incorrect or misleading information was thus
given to parliament, albeit in good faith."
Dr Evan Harris, Liberal Democrat health spokesman, said some questions
were still left unanswered.
He said: "Why has it taken nearly two years since the government first
suspected that parliament had been misled for the record to be corrected?
"The government has still not said what action it will take against one
of the manufacturers of an oral polio vaccine, withdrawn in October 2000,
which used UK-sourced bovine material well after this was made unacceptable
under government guidelines.
"Liberal Democrats are satisfied, on the information provided, to support
the government and the chief medical officer's assertion of the overwhelming
benefit of the current vaccination programme compared to any safety risk.
"Parents should continue to vaccinate their children. But such support
relies on continued openness from the government."
Get the day's top headlines straight to your mobile
|
Sign up for the Backbencher |
Our free weekly insider's guide to Westminster
Email us at
politics.editor@guardianunlimited.co.uk
David
Blunkett
Home affairs
Secure Borders, Safe Haven (pdf)
Police reform
Civil registration
Home Office
Printable version |
Send it to a friend |
Read it later |
See saved stories

|