Rose Stevens (Director of
Public Relations for the Eagle Foundation) wrote:
I have summarized some of
the key points that Dr. Rastogi made on Radio and Television on Jan 30/2001
regarding Homeopathy as a safer alternative to vaccinations
Professor
Dr. D. P. Rastogi
M.A D. M.S. Hons
(Cal) Gold Medallist
M.B. S Hons (W. Bengal) D.
F. Hom (Lond)
Honorary Physician
to President of India (1988-1992)
Chairman-Post Graduate Committee Central Council of
Homeopathy
Immediate Past
President-Homeopathic Medical
Association of India
Formerly- Director, Central Council for Research in Homeopathy
- Principal, Nehru Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital
-Member- International Advisory Board--Journal of
Alternative Therapies U.S.A
Advisory
Board--British Homeopathic Journal
Board of Studies, University of Rajasthan, India
Professor Emeritus- Homeopathic Medical College, Beed, Maharashtra
Honorary Visiting
Professor
Nehru Homeopathic Medical College & Hospital,
University of Delhi
Dr.
B. R. Sur Homoeopathic Medical College, Hospital and Research
center,
Govt of Delhi
Father Muller Homeopathic Medical college, Mangalore
JPS Gov't Homeopathic Medical College Hyderabad
Dr. V. V. Dave, Homeopathic Medical College, Anand
Recipient
Hahnemann Award 1995
Dhanwantri
Award 1997
Ever since beginning of the history of
vaccinations there has been a controversy regarding the efficacy and safety of
vaccines. Take for instance, Dr. Edward Jenner, who developed the vaccine for
the small pox. He gave this vaccine to his 10 month old son and the child
remained mentally retarded until he died at the age of 21. It is possible that
the manufacturers of vaccines may be putting profits ahead of safety and the
need for safer vaccines are not given priority. Homeopathic physicians offer
safer alternatives against all types of viral infections, without any side
effects whatsoever. These are also very cost effective.
The recent debate in the Canadian Medical
Association Journal over the cost effectiveness and efficacy of the flu vaccine
that is being administered in Ontario is a prime example. Dr. Demicheli, an
Italian epidemiologist, argues with Dr. Schabas that the efficacy rate is only
60% and this refers only to the ability of the vaccine to produce antibodies.
Indeed, when the ability of the vaccine to prevent clinical disease is measured
the efficacy is only about 25%. This is less than a placebo response. I would
have liked to have seen the government use 10 million dollars from the 38
million that was spent on this mass immunization for double blind studies using
homeopathy as a method of flu prevention. I am surprised that the Canadian
government is not investigating other alternatives, in lieu of the many adverse
reactions that have recently been reported in British Columbia and Quebec. It
makes me question if the doctors themselves have not been keeping up to date
with the many publications in prestigious medical journals noting the adverse
reactions to the flu vaccine and the positive studies using homeopathy..
.In 1989 there was a double blind , placebo
controlled influenza study done on 487 patients, who had been referred by 149
different doctors. Over half who were given the homeopathic remedy called
oscilloccoccinum, for treatment of influenza-like symptoms, recovered from the
flu within 48 hours. The Lancet was not only impressed with the results but by
how well the study was conducted . The study was published in the British
Journal of Clinical Pharmacology in 1989.
It is unheard of in India for any one to
take a flu vaccine. We have remedies for the flu such as Eupatorium, Gelsemium,
Baptisia and Influenzinum, which are given according to the symptoms the
patient presents with. The very nature of the way a virus mutates is suggestive
that it is extremely difficult to accurately predict which strain of flu to use
for the next year's epidemic. This is the beauty of Homeopathy. We do not need
to be astrologers, to predict which strain will hit next year, as homeopathy
deals with treating according to the symptoms. The flu vaccine is grown on
chick embryos and anyone with an egg allergy may have an adverse reaction..
Preservatives and adjuvants, such as mercury and formaldehyde which are in the
flu vaccine, may cause problems for some people.
There are many countries that recognize
homeopathy as part of their health care system. The royal family in England is
a great believer in Homeopathy,and the Queen of England has her own Homeopathic
physician.Why has Canada not looked into homeopathy as a safer alternative?.
Dr. Samuel Hahnemann , the founder of
homeopathy, first used Belledonna as a preventive medicine for scarlet fever in
1801. Epidemics can be effectively eradicated using homeopathy. He suggested
Rhus Tox and Bryonia for the typhus epidemic in 1813. He knew about energy
medicine over 200 years ago and how it works on the vital force of the body
with the principle of "like cures like".
Dr. Boenninghausen used Thuja and Variolinum
for the prevention of smallpox and Dorothy Shepherd used Pertussin as a
preventive for whooping cough . Dr Allen used Diptherinum as preventive for
diphtheria for 25 years. There are reports of studies done in India and Brazil
about the efficacy of Homeopathic medicines used as preventives. For example,
in August of 1974 , in Guarantingueta, Brazil, there was a serious outbreak of
meningitis. Eighteen thousand six hundred and forty children were given
Menigococcinum 10CH while 6340 did not receive it. In the 18,640 , only 4 cases
developed the disease while in the 6340 there were 34 children who developed
meningitis.
In India, in a Capital of the State, there
was a severe epidemic of meningitis and two doctors working in the hospital got
the infection and died. The Health Minister of the State , who was a medical
doctor, invited the homeopathic physicians to offer the homeopathic preventive.
Meningococcinum was the suggested medicine and was administered to all the
staff of the hospital and to all patients that were admitted. The result was
that the morbidity was much reduced and the mortality became zero.
Some years ago in India an epidemic of
pneumonic plague was effectively controlled by a homeopathic medicine called
Phosphorus, and in another district viral encephalitis was controlled by giving
Belladonna.
It is not unusual for the Indian government
to announce on the radio or television what homeopathic remedy their citizens
should take when an epidemic has struck. In an Indian state known as Rajasthan,several
districts were affected with malaria epidemic which was successfully controlled
/ treated with Arsenic Album .
Not only is Homeopathy effective in treating
epidemics but it is also effective in helping victims with vaccine damage. In
India, we do not see such an alarming increase in the rate of autism . Could
this possibility be due to the fact that Indian children do not receive nearly
as many vaccines as their North American counter-parts? Canadian children
receive over 22 vaccines before they enter school.
Many more vaccines are being developed as we
speak. I would find it highly unlikely that an effective vaccine for AIDS is
ever possible considering how quickly the virus is mutating.
In the British Homeopathic Journal in 1993
my study on the evaluation of homeopathic therapy in 129 asymptotic HIV
carriers was published.These patients were treated with homeopathic medicines
on the basis of the individual's constitutional(both mental/emotional and
physical ) characteristics. Twelve of the patients reverted back to negative
serology for HIV antibodies after treatment varying 3-16 months. One hundred
and seventeen patients were followed for five years and the majority remained
symptom free while receiving homeopathic treatment .In 1999 the British
Homeopathic Journal reported the results of a homeopathic double blind study
which I was involved with also. This study was done on patients with HIV
infection. Assessment of progress was made by evaluation of CD4+ve lymphocyte
counts, which was the prospectively defined main outcome measure of the study:
The results were compared with the base line immune status. The study suggested
a possible role of homeopathic treatment in HIV infection in the symptomatic
phase as evidenced by the statistically significant elevation of base line
immune status in persistent generalized lymphadenopathy.
In conclusion, as a practicing homeopath for
over 40 years, I am impressed with the immense benefits using homeopathic
medicines. I can only surmise that countries like Canada are not yet aware that
safer and more cost effective alternatives such as Homeopathy have been used
with great success in other parts of the world .In India, even though we are
known as third world country, our government supports our right to choose which
modality of medicine best suits our needs. It has been a privilege to share my
knowledge with you, and I hope that it may inspire your government to integrate
homeopathy into the medical system in your country.
ALL
INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR
GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE
KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED
AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE. THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO
VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU
ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.