FEAT DAILY NEWSLETTER Sacramento,
California http://www.feat.org
“Healing Autism: No
Finer a Cause on the Planet”
________________________________________________________________
January 31, 2002
News Morgue Search www.feat.org/search/news.asp
PUBLIC HEALTH
* Putting the Brakes on Mandatory Vaccinations in California
(and Elsewhere)
EDUCATION
* Teacher’s Aide Sentenced To Jail For Molesting Students
ADVOCACY / AWARENESS
* Autism Advocacy Speakers Bureau
Putting the Brakes on Mandatory Vaccinations in California (and Elsewhere)
[On January 23, a hearing took place before the
California State
Senate Committee on Health and Human Services, which took testimony in their
efforts to decide whether to add two doses of Hepatitis A and four doses of
Prevnar vaccines to the state’s mandatory childhood immunization schedule.
On that same day, the FEAT Daily Newsletter carried a transcript of the
testimony made to that committee by autism research advocate Rick Rollens.
”Childhood Immunizations Mandates: Politics vs. Public Health Rollens
Testimony on Mandatory Vaccines” is the name of the hearing and can be found
at http://www.feat.org/scripts/wa.exe?A2=ind0201&L=FEATNEWS&P=R11628
Barbara Loe Fisher, Co-founder & President
National Vaccine
Information Center also testified at that hearing. Fisher effectively
summarizes the case for vaccine reform and the importance of the individual
right to informed consent.]
Senator Ortiz and members of the Committee,
thank you for inviting me
to participate in this hearing on the politics and public health issues
involved in vaccine mandates. This is the first hearing of its kind in any
state that I am aware of and, as usual, California is leading the way in
looking at progressive ways to address the very real health care concerns of
citizens.
I am appearing here on behalf of the 4,500
California parent and
health professional members of the National Vaccine Information Center,
which is a 40,000-member national, non profit organization founded in 1982
by parents of vaccine injured children. My organization worked with Congress
in the 1980’s to create the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986
and we were instrumental in helping to obtain the safer DTaP vaccine
licensed in 1996 for America’s babies. Our mission is to prevent vaccine
injuries and deaths through public education and we support the availability
of vaccines for all who want to use them but we also endorse the ethical
principle of informed consent and believe that the zealous enforcement of
vaccine mandates threaten that principle.
My 20-year experience as a vaccine safety
consumer advocate includes
co-authorship of the 1985 book DPT: A Shot in the Dark, which was used as a
reference by the Institute of Medicine in its historic reports on vaccine
adverse events in 1991 and 1994, as well as appointments to the National
Vaccine Advisory Committee in 1988 and the Institute of Medicine Vaccine
Safety Forum in 1995. I am currently the consumer voting member of the FDA
Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee.
Personally, I come here as a parent of a son who
had a neurological
reaction to his fourth DPT shot at age two and a half that caused brain
dysfunction, including multiple learning disabilities and attention deficit
disorder (ADD), but who was fortunate not to lose his life or be left with
mental retardation, uncontrolled epilepsy, autism, or other severe
disabilities like so many of the vaccine injured children I have come to
know. When my son had his vaccine reaction in 1980, children in America
were told to get 23 doses of 7 vaccines. Today, children are told to get 37
doses of 11 vaccines. In those 22 years since my son had his vaccine
reaction, the numbers of American children with learning disabilities,
attention deficit disorder and asthma have doubled; diabetes has tripled;
and the incidence of autism has reached epidemic proportions, increasing 200
to 600 percent in every state, marking a staggering 3400 percent increase in
the prevalence of autism in our children.
Nobody knows why this has happened. But everyone
at the Centers for
Disease Control and American Academy of Pediatrics, the two medical groups
that make vaccine policy in this country, vigorously deny that the many
vaccines they have urged be mandated in the past quarter century could have
anything to do with why more and more of our so children are chronically
ill. They say that vaccines only rarely cause chronic health problems.
Yet, the haunting question remains: if we have
wiped out polio and
almost eliminated measles, mumps, rubella, whooping cough and other
childhood diseases with vaccines - why are so many of our children stuck on
sick? Why are our special education classrooms so crowded that we can’t find
enough money or train teachers fast enough to care for these learning
disabled, hyperactive, autistic, asthmatic, diabetic, emotionally disturbed,
sick children?
Something is wrong with this public health
report card.
And before we go any further and mandate one
more vaccine for daycare
or kindergarten entry - whether it is Prevnar or hepatitis A or some other
vaccine - we had better find out if the repeated manipulation of the immune
system with lab altered viruses and bacteria adulterated with mercury,
aluminum, formaldehyde and other toxins, which are administered to our
babies from birth through the first five years of life when the brain and
immune system is developing at its most rapid rate, is contributing to these
skyrocketing increases in chronic illness in our children. Without basic
science research into the biological mechanisms of vaccine injury and death
and without methodologically sound, long term studies which follow groups of
highly vaccinated, lesser vaccinated and unvaccinated children over time to
measure for all morbidity and mortality outcomes, it is illogical and
scientifically irresponsible to assume that there is no connection between
the ever increasing numbers of vaccines we mandate for children and the ever
increasing rates of chronic disease in our children. Making this kind of
scientific investigation a societal program and funding priority would, at
the very least, give us a better understanding of the genetic and other
biological factors which predispose certain children to vaccine-induced
immune and brain dysfunction, including whether there is a complex
interaction between genetic factors, a particular vaccine or combination of
vaccines and simultaneous exposures to environmental contaminants such as
pesticides, molds and other toxic insults.
I understand that you are looking at whether the
process for mandating
childhood vaccines in California could be improved. You have a difficult job
to do because when you make laws, you often rely upon expert advice in areas
where you don’t feel you have enough expertise. Medicine is an area that a
lot of us feel like we don’t have the knowledge or expertise to make
independent decisions.
As a mother who graduated from college but never
went to medical
school or got a Ph.D., I urge you not to totally defer to the experts on
this one. You are smart or you wouldn’t have been elected. As legislators,
you educate yourselves about everything from freeway construction to
pollution to the death penalty. Those are complex issues just like this
one - and it doesn’t take a medical degree to tell the difference between a
good scientific study and a bad one.
I voted “NO” when I was asked in 1999, as the
consumer member of an
FDA Committee, to vote on whether Wyeth Lederle, the manufacturer of
Prevnar, had proved the vaccine is safe. I was the only “no” vote, but I
voted “no” with confidence. I remembered being taught in a high school
science class that when correctly employing the scientific method to prove
an hypothesis in an experiment, you cannot compare two unknowns. The Prevnar
pre-licensure clinical trials, which Wyeth Lederle paid Kaiser Permanente to
conduct, compared two experimental vaccines against each other. To compound
this basic methodological flaw, Kaiser and Wyeth Lederle, allowed most of
the children in the trial to be given the more reactive DPT vaccine rather
than use the safer, less reactive DTaP vaccine. This placed the children in
that five-year experiment in greater danger and allowed the drug company to
write off the seizures that occurred as being caused by DPT and not Prevnar,
when in fact, they didn’t know. Even so, the groups of children who got
Prevnar suffered more seizures, higher fevers, more irritability and other
reactions than did the children who got the other experimental vaccine. It
was a no-brainer as far as I was concerned: Kaiser and Wyeth Lederle had
proved nothing about Prevnar vaccine safety.
And another question: why did the CDC’s
policymaking committee vote to
recommend “universal use” of Prevnar by all children before the FDA
Committee even got a chance to review the data and take a vote about whether
it should be licensed at all? The same thing happened with the ill-fated
Rotavirus vaccine for infant diarrhea that was pulled off the market in
1999, less than a year after it was released, because it was causing bowel
obstructions in babies. The CDC had voted to recommend that all babies get
rotavirus vaccine weeks before the FDA Committee voted on scientific proof
of safety and efficacy. And before the FDA Committee even got a chance to
vote on Prevnar, Wyeth Lederle and Kaiser Permanente officials were being
quoted in national press releases that Prevnar was an ear infection
vaccine - when their own trial data showed that the vaccine only decreased a
child’s chance of getting an ear infection by 7 percent!
The FDA has never licensed Prevnar as an
ear infection vaccine but
lots of doctors in America tell parents it is because that is how the
vaccine has been promoted. No wonder Prevnar vaccine was the number one best
selling new pharmaceutical introduced to the market in the year 2000 -
generating more than $450 million for Wyeth Lederle that year.
Which brings us to the uncomfortable issue of
conflicts of interest
that exist when experts, who sit on vaccine advisory committees, also get
paid by vaccine manufacturers to conduct clinical trials on vaccines they
make and sell. It happens too often and it contributes to the erosion of
trust in the integrity of a mass vaccination system where the same doctors,
who report parents to child social services for child abuse if the parent
doesn’t want the child vaccinated with every mandated vaccine, are the same
doctors who refuse to obey the 1986 law and report injuries and deaths
following vaccination to the federal Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System
(VAERS). The estimate is that less than 10 percent, perhaps less than one
percent, of all doctors report serious health problems that follow
vaccination. So instead of the some 12,000 reports that are made every
year, there may be as many as 120,000 to 1.2 million vaccine-related adverse
events occurring annually that nobody is counting or following up on. And
this means that the more than 3,000 Prevnar vaccine adverse events that have
been reported to VAERS since 2000 and the more than 2,500 hepatitis A
vaccine adverse events that have been reported since 1996 are only a
fraction of what has really occurred.
The truth is we really don’t know how many
children are getting
seriously ill and dying following vaccination in America every year. Doctors
and public health officials, anxious to persuade themselves and the public
that vaccine risks are minimal, use the remarkably unscientific argument
that it is all a “coincidence” when something bad happens to a child after
vaccination - the vaccine is never, ever to blame. And so more and more
parents, who took a bright, healthy, normally developing child to a doctor’s
office for routine vaccinations, are coming forward with their dead and
damaged children asking you to fix a mass vaccination system they know is
broken.
I urge you not be afraid to rely on your
intelligence and common sense
to evaluate the merits, potential risks, and very real costs associated with
mandating new vaccines such as Prevnar and hepatitis A. There are more than
200 experimental vaccines being developed to prevent everything from tooth
decay to stomach ulcers, as well as a supervaccine to be given at birth that
will inject raw DNA from 20 to 30 different viruses and bacteria directly
into the cells of newborns. The vaccine manufacturers and physician special
interest groups that will lobby you for mandates know that drug companies
and doctors have been protected from liability for vaccine injuries and
deaths since the 1986 vaccine injury compensation law was passed. I worked
with Congress in the early 1980’s on that law and have watched it be turned
into a cruel joke as 2 out of 3 vaccine injured children are denied federal
compensation for their often catastrophic vaccine injuries because the DHHS
and the Department of Justice officials fight every claim, viewing every
award to a vaccine injured child as admission that vaccines can and do cause
harm.
Please remember that when you mandate, rather
than recommend, a
medical procedure like vaccination that carries a risk of injury or death,
it sets the stage for violation of informed consent, an ethical standard
that has guided the practice of medicine since World War II. One of the
reasons I traveled from Virginia to be here today is to defend the human
right to informed consent which is embodied in the religious and personal or
conscientious belief exemption to vaccination now protected in California
law. In many other states, public health and education officials are
determined to eliminate these exemptions from the law. We have examples of
parents in Wyoming, New York and other states being detained by state
government officials and interrogated for hours about the sincerity of their
deeply held religious or conscientious beliefs only to find their previously
held exemptions revoked; their children barred from attending school and a
threat that their child will be taken away from them.
Those exemptions are the closest we come in
America to preventing the
unchecked implementation of utilitarianism, which attempts to justify the
forced sacrifice of some in service to others. There is nothing that causes
a crisis of trust in government more than when the people live in fear of a
law that forces them to risk their lives or the lives of their children
without their consent. I hope that this Committee, in considering any new
vaccine mandates or other laws which force vaccination - even in times of
emergency - will protect the inviolability of the informed consent ethic
which, at its most basic level, respects the right of the individual to
voluntarily decide what he or she is willing to die for.
We do have a specific recommendation for
improving the process by
which vaccines are considered for mandates, but in recognition of the time
constraints today, I will submit the fact sheet and recommendations that the
National Vaccine Information Center and California Vaccine Awareness have
prepared to you in writing. Again, I am honored to be here and thank you for
this opportunity to share my thoughts with you.
The National Vaccine Information Center website is at http://www.909shot.com
_______________________________________________________
>> DO SOMETHING ABOUT AUTISM NOW <<
Subscribe,
Read, then Forward the FEAT Daily Newsletter.
To Subscribe
go to www.feat.org/FEATnews No Cost!
_______________________________________________________
* *
Teacher’s Aide Sentenced To Jail For Molesting Students
http://www.newsobserver.com/ncwire/news/Story/906697p-905066c.html
Hendersonville, N.C. AP - A former teacher’s
aide who kept a journal
about his sexual encounters with young students was sentenced to 62 years in
prison Monday.
A jury found Laurence Freeman McKisson, 53, guilty
on seven counts of
taking indecent liberties with children and two counts of first-degree
statutory sexual offense.
He was found innocent on two counts of indecent
liberties involving an
autistic child who had changed his story while on the witness stand.
During the trial that began last week, McKisson
was confronted with
his own handwriting—a journal in which he logged each sexual contact with
four boys who testified against him.
The journal also included encounters with 13
other local children and
children in at least five other states dating back 20 years.
Dozens of examples of child pornography were
also seized from
McKisson’s home in Etowah, including magazines featuring naked prepubescent
males.
District Attorney Jeff Hunt said he won’t try
McKisson on the more
than 30 other charges which remain. That would only waste time, taxpayer
money and further traumatize the 13 other children, he said.
The next legal fight will likely play out in the
civil courts. At
least four of the families’ attorneys sat in the back of the courtroom
taking notes during the criminal trial.
School board attorney Walter Currie said he’s
convinced the parents
will sue the Henderson County school system where McKisson was a teacher’s
aide at various schools.
The school board will defend itself, Currie
said, because it couldn’t
have known McKisson was a pedophile. The teacher passed all background
checks and had no criminal record.
Testimony indicated that McKisson was covert in
his sexual encounters
with the children. The assaults took place behind bookcases when he was left
alone with a child.
A number of the assaults happened when McKisson’s
co-teacher was
away—once on a field trip and another week on her honeymoon. The
co-teacher had also left McKisson in charge of special needs students who
went to a “resource room” for one-on-one tutoring. Testimony indicated he
put an alarm on the door, possibly to signal someone’s approach.
Before McKisson was sentenced, his attorney,
Skip Goldsmith, turned to
the families and told them their sons were courageous and that they should
turn from the trial and move on.
“This situation,” he said, “can make you bitter
or it can make you
better.”
* *
AUTISM ADVOCACY SPEAKER’S BUREAU
Planning Your 2003 Conference
Autism Research, Autism Treatment
and Autism Care
Your Conference Explains What They
Are and Why They’re Needed
BUT WHAT ABOUT
How to Get It, Who Should Do It and Who Will Pay For It?
Speakers on The Simmering Politics
of Autism
RICK
ROLLENS
LENNY SCHAFER
Autism Research
Advocate
Autism Research Advocate
Former California State Senator
Founder and Editor of the
Co-Founder M.I.N.D. Institute,
FEAT
FEAT Daily Newsletter
Autism Society of
America
Families for Effective/Early
Board
Director
Autism Treatment Board Director
Russell’s
Dad
Izak’s Dad
Non-circuit. Limited dates for engagement available.
Conference promotional service included. Contact speakers@usit.net
_________________________________________________________________
Lenny Schafer, Editor@feat.org
* CALENDAR EVENTS@feat.org Michelle
Guppy
Catherine Johnson PhD * Ron Sleith * Kay Stammers
* Edward Decelie
UNSUBSCRIBE: FEATNews-signoff-request@LIST.FEAT.ORG