Vaccine Experts Upset by Renewed Safety Doubts
Tue December 10, 2002 01:59 PM ET
By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Correspondent
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Campaigners who doubt the safety of
vaccines have launched a renewed effort to find a link between
diseases such as autism and childhood shots, worrying experts in the
field.
Indiana Republican Rep. Dan Burton reopened hearings into the
alleged vaccine-autism link on Tuesday, and several groups railed
against a decision in Congress earlier this month that made it
harder to sue vaccine makers.
Doctors say vaccines may have been the biggest advance in health
of the last century, saving millions of lives. But their success has
opened the door to questions about safety.
The House Government Reform Committee was scheduled to hold a
hearing on vaccine safety on Tuesday. Burton, its chairman, has an
autistic grandchild and blames vaccination.
"We are taking a closer look at the science," said Nick Mutton, a
spokesman for the committee. "You can't argue with the numbers and
the amount of cases. It is becoming an epidemic among our children
and something has to be done about that."
Burton has held such hearings for years. Repeated reports have
shown no link, including several university-based studies and a 2001
independent Institute of Medicine report saying there was no
evidence to show the measles, mumps and rubella, or MMR, vaccine
causes autism.
Children are usually diagnosed with autism around age 2, just
after they finish their series of vaccines.
FOCUS ON MERCURY
The latest focus is on thimerosol, a mercury-based preservative
used in vaccines for decades.
It is no longer used in childhood vaccines -- not because it was
shown to be harmful but because U.S. government officials were aware
that people believed that mercury may be linked to autism.
"There's always been a minority opinion in the United States that
vaccines aren't safe," Dr. Peter Hotez, chair of the department of
microbiology at George Washington University and an adviser to the
Sabin Vaccine Institute, said in a telephone interview. "There
currently is no evidence that there is an association between
vaccines and autism but somehow it still lingers."
Hotez said Burton and other vaccine critics are looking in the
wrong place. "I have an autistic child and I wouldn't think twice
about vaccinating her with the same vaccine series yet again," Hotez
said.
"Autism has a strong genetic component. It is inconceivable that
something like a vaccine could generate the complex set of neural
pathways needed for autism."
He and other vaccine experts were angered by the tone of Burton's
inquiries, which they said only raise questions among those who
would otherwise have no doubts about vaccine safety.
"I think Dan Burton is not looking after the health of the
citizens of his own state of Indiana," Hotez said.
A study published in November in the Lancet medical journal found
that children given thimerosol-containing vaccines had safe levels
of mercury in their blood as defined by the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Food
and Drug Administration along with nongovernmental groups such as
the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases, have been pushing
public education campaigns aimed at keeping up traditionally strong
public support of immunization. |