A small but groundbreaking study of infants who received vaccines
containing a mercury-based preservative has found the levels of mercury in
their blood were well within the federal safety limits.
The study, reported Saturday in The Lancet, a London-based medical
journal, also found that infants excrete the mercury much faster than
expected, suggesting it does not build up from one vaccination to the next.
The preservative, thimerosal, is no longer used in American vaccines for
infants under 6 months old, but the issue is important to parents of
autistic children who have filed hundreds of damage claims and lawsuits
against thimerosal's maker. A clause protecting Eli Lilly & Co., the
manufacturer, from lawsuits was added to the domestic security law signed by
President Bush Nov. 25.
The director of the Institute for Vaccine Safety at Johns Hopkins
University, Dr. Neal Halsey, praised the study as "much needed and done
quite well," although more work needs to be done.
But Sallie Bernard, director of Safe Minds, a parents group suing the
vaccine industry, vehemently attacked it, calling its optimistic conclusions
"very much off-base."
Mercury is unquestionably poisonous. At extreme doses, it causes tremors
and madness. Children who accidentally get high doses tend to speak and walk
later and have tics and lower intelligence, but not autism, medical experts
say.
Small amounts, however, are common in soil and plants, in power plant
fumes and in dental fillings. Fish are the largest source for humans, and a
tuna sandwich may contain more mercury than a vaccine shot.
No study has proved that thimerosal causes any ill effects, but at the
urging of federal health officials, vaccine makers began eliminating it in
mid-1999. The study began with that recommendation.
Thimerosal, which kills funguses and bacteria, is still used to preserve
vaccines sent to the Third World, and the World Health Organization defends
it. The vaccines prevent common diseases there, so the benefits far exceed
potential side effects.
The Lancet study, led by Dr. Michael Pichichero of the University of
Rochester, tested the blood, urine and stool of 33 infants ages 2 months to
6 months, all of them seen by Rochester, N.Y., pediatricians injecting
thimerosal-containing vaccines. They were compared with 15 infants seen at a
clinic in Bethesda, Md., using mercury-free vaccines.
In their first six months, children typically receive three doses of
diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis vaccine, one or two for hepatitis B, and
sometimes up to three for haemophilus influenza. Other vaccines, like polio,
may not contain thimerosal.
The Environmental Protection Agency's safe level for mercury in
children's blood is 5.9 parts per billion. That, Pichichero explained, is
based on a study of children in the Faroe Islands, south of Iceland, whose
mothers ate whale blubber polluted with mercury and PCB's. When the mothers
had 59 or more parts per billion of mercury in their blood while pregnant,
their children scored lower on intelligence tests several years later. The
EPA took one-tenth of that -- 5.9 parts -- as a safe level.
All but one of the infants in the group exposed to thimerosal had blood
levels of 1 to 3 parts per billion; the one exception went to 4.1. In the
mercury-free control group, only one baby had even a measurable level of
mercury..