Are you a woman between the ages of 25 and 55, with or without children, with
or without a job outside the home, suffering from some unpleasant combination of
fatigue, depression, crankiness, weight gain, or low sex drive? If so, you may
be suffering from the hottest new medical disorder to come screaming down the
pike: Hurried Woman Syndrome (HWS).
This Tuesday, "Good Morning America"'s Charles Gibson announced the arrival
of this troubling new epidemic. First to be interviewed was Dr. Brent Bost, the
Texas OB/GYN who coined the term Hurried Woman
Syndrome and subsequently wrote a book titled--cleverly--The Hurried Woman.
As Dr. Bost explains it, the relentless stress of today's busy lifestyles--with
women trying to juggle housekeeping, child-rearing, and often outside jobs--is
taking its toll on us both physically and emotionally. Even more ominously, the
hassles of our frenetic lives may prompt many of the same brain-chemistry
changes associated with depression, meaning that some of us may need to be
medicated in order to return to our normal, jolly selves. This should come as
welcome news to the folks at Pfizer, since Dr. Bost's estimates that some 60
million American women may suffer from this tragic disorder.
All I can say to Dr. Bost (and the folks at "Good Morning America") is
"bollocks." What we're looking at here isn't some sinister new syndrome. It's
called modernity--the fact that there's now more to life than making and raising
babies (something that is becoming increasingly difficult in its own right)--and
you'd be hard-pressed to find a woman not burdened by it on some level. Yes,
this creates stress, which makes us crabby and tired and overwrought and less
interested in shagging. But let's not pretend it's some specialized disorder
that strikes only women of a certain age. Excess stress can take a bite out of
anyone--just ask any man with high blood pressure and a psychotic boss.
But this society isn't content to diagnose itself with something as boring
and unsexy as garden-variety stress. Nooooo. We like to come up with clever,
niche disorders that make us feel special--even when they wind up applying to
half the population. Our ability to generate trendy new epidemics is
awe-inspiring, especially with problems that skirt the line between the physical
and the psychological. In some cases, we'll take a narrow, fringe disorder and
redefine it to the point that it affects enough people to be worthy of a massive
public-education campaign (and government-funded drug research). This is what
the medical establishment did with Social Anxiety Disorder, whose definition has
gradually expanded to include nearly all forms of shyness (see
my piece in the August 2, 1999 issue of TNR). And
increasingly it looks like what we did with ADD. (To our children no less!)
In the case of HWS, the impulse seems to be to the opposite: Take a
near-universal problem of modern life and carve out a narrow enough swath of
sufferers for it to qualify as a syndrome. All the better if it's one that will
suit the prevailing zeitgeist. That's why frazzled women are such an obvious
choice. How many books, magazine pieces, and Oprah episodes each year are
dedicated to the increasingly complex, dizzying blend of work-life stresses
women face today? Of course we deserve our own syndrome. We just didn't know
what was wrong with us until some guy down in Texas put a name to it.
Indeed, one point of HWS seems to be to help women legitimate their
stress-related symptoms. After interviewing Dr. Bost, Charles Gibson chatted
with the co-directors of UCLA's Female Sexual
Medical Clinic, Drs. Jennifer and Laura Berman. (They're sisters. How adorable
is that?) Perky Dr. Jennifer's response to the identification of HWS was one of
relief one behalf of all women: "Well, they've been hurried for years and years
and years and were thought to be irritable, you know, anxious, obnoxious. And
now, finally, you know, there is, I won't say an excuse, but sort of a medical
condition that explains a lot of what we feel and what we go through."
Gag. Must we medicalize everything in order for it to be real? I'll tell you
what's wrong with women: We have stupidly agreed to do it all. We bought into
that "you can do anything a man can do" line, without pushing the reciprocal
expectation that men will do much of what we were originally doing. This is why
many dads still expect a ticker-tape parade when they change a diaper or wash a
dish. It's also why, when women come home from ten hours at the office, their
brains immediately shift into life maintenance mode, spinning through a mental
checklist of thousands of chores yet to be done. It's not that men won't help
when asked--repeatedly; it's that most never look around for what needs to be
done without being asked--repeatedly. (When's the last time a man spontaneously
checked to see if the house was low on toilet paper or Saran Wrap?)
That said, women do not need some trendy medical diagnosis to legitimize
their fatigue and low libidos. (Speaking of which, maybe if you guys would get
up off your asses and empty the dishwasher occasionally without being asked,
your honeys would have more energy for a quick snog.) We need to manage our time
better. We need to learn to say "no"--or even "help." And we need to learn to do
it without going around babbling about how we have Hurried Woman Syndrome.
Otherwise, it's just a matter of time before we start hearing about the real
threat to our nation: Overworked Man Syndrome--which is, of course, an outgrowth
of Hyper-achieving Teen Syndrome, itself a by-product of Over-scheduled Toddler
Syndrome. All of which ultimately lead to Totally Bonkers Seniors
Syndrome--which, naturally, will need to be covered by Medicare. How's that
for something to stress about, ladies?