Quality controlled: Putting practice guidelines to work
Evidence-based practice guidelines are increasingly touted as the key
to quality care. Now the push is on for physicians to prove they're
following along.
By
Andis Robeznieks, AMNews staff. Dec. 23/30, 2002.
Additional information
Not too long ago, when a child came into a doctor's office with an ear
infection, the standard practice was to prescribe a 10-day supply of
antibiotics. No questions asked.
"It turns out antibiotics weren't needed -- or at least not for 10
days, but that evidence is just coming out," said Mary E. Frank, MD, an
American Academy of Family Physicians board member who received her
medical degree in 1973.
"I think one of the things physicians are caught on right now is that,
a lot of things we've done forever, we have no evidence on," she added.
"Antibiotics for ear infections was something you were taught, and it
continues to be published."
Old practices such as this are being put to rest, because evidence
shows that 80% of patients with uncomplicated infections recover within
one to seven days without antibiotics; and, of those treated with
antibiotics, 93% recover during the first week.
Evidence-based practice guidelines have become an integral part of the
quality movement in health care but Dr. Frank -- who heads a
five-physician practice in Rohnert Park, Calif. -- said physicians are
being flooded with new and, occasionally, conflicting information, and
sometimes it's just too much to process.
"You're taught that patients are individuals and taught to make
individual assessments. Now they're saying, 'Don't do it,' and you don't
know what to do," she said. "The result is you get people who say, 'I
don't know what to make of this, so I'll just keep doing what I always
did.' "
80% of patients with uncomplicated infections recover within a week
without antibiotics.
|
That isn't likely to work indefinitely, however, because current calls
for using evidence-based practice guidelines are accompanied by a
requirement to document their use.
Dr. Frank said this is difficult for physicians who have yet to adopt
electronic record-keeping. For example, doctors who use electronic medical
records may be able to find out how many of their 5-year-old patients are
getting immunizations with just a few keystrokes. But for doctors who use
a paper system, getting that same information is a multistep process.
First, Dr. Frank said, a list with all the names of patients younger than
5 would have to be printed out, and then each of their individual files
would have to be pulled and checked.
"That's where the information glitch is," she said, adding that the
AAFP soon will launch a drive to get 5,000 offices (representing 20,000 to
30,000 physicians) equipped with EMR technology by 2005.
If trends continue, drives like these are definitely needed.
Cookbook medicine
Sometimes derided as "cookbook medicine," practice guidelines are
described by many insurance companies and business groups as key
ingredients in the quality-of-care recipe. These organizations are also
cooking up different ways to get doctors to adopt the practice guidelines
they think are best.
Dr. Frank said she's even heard of a proposal to report physicians to
licensing boards if they don't adhere to certain quality standards.
It takes an average of 17 years for original medical research to be
put into common practice.
|
"There's a way to do it without getting punitive," she said. "I think
sticks don't work as well as carrots."
Nevertheless, Dr. Frank admits that some type of incentive is often
needed as studies show it takes an average of 17 years for original
research to be put into common practice.
In hopes of speeding up the process, myriad organizations have
established guidelines and are urging physicians and institutions to adopt
them.
Among those who have developed guidelines are the Leapfrog Group, a
national consortium of 125 companies employing up to 33 million people;
the Midwest Business Group on Health, a group with more than 70 member
companies in a six-state region; and the Committee for Economic
Development, a national organization of 250 business leaders and
educators.
The CED has called for designing managed care contracts that develop
custom strategies for "the 10% of patients who account for 70% of health
spending." It also calls on physicians to adhere to evidence-based
standards and advocates rewarding physicians who help people stay well, at
a lower cost, rather than treating them after they get sick, and incurring
more expenses.
Recognizing one size does not fit all
Perhaps the best-known practices being advocated by employers are the
Leapfrog Group safety practices, which include: using computerized
physician order entry to submit prescriptions, staffing intensive care
units with trained specialists and referring high-risk surgeries or
conditions to hospitals with high annual volumes and experience with those
surgeries and conditions.
Leapfrog Executive Director Suzanne Delbanco, PhD, said the call for
uniform standards is not the same as advocating a one-size-fits-all
approach to medicine.
"We know every patient is different, but -- if there is research
suggesting that certain practices, on average, improve patient care -- I
think that is something that should be adhered to," she said. "The reason
why physicians think of it as 'cookbook medicine' is because they consider
the complexity of how patients vary and don't feel one protocol is
appropriate for all.
"But there is certain evidence that certain things work," Dr. Delbanco
added. "There is a huge need for greater adherence to what the evidence
says works, and that's what practice guidelines are meant to do."
Even the American Heart Assn. is getting into the act. The AHA has its
"Get With The Guidelines" program, which is designed to save 80,000 lives
annually. The organization spent $337 million conducting research and
professional education on the guidelines, which seek to close the
"treatment gap" after an initial heart attack that often can lead to
another heart attack or disabling heart failure.
If a hospital develops or revises existing protocols in accordance with
the AHA's secondary prevention guidelines, then submits patient data and
other proof that the policy has been implemented, it can be designated a
GWTG-Coronary Artery Disease Hospital. After this designation, an
institution can receive a "performance achievement award" if it shows
compliance rates of at least 85% with eligible patients.
The other part of the quality equation is performance measures.
"Performance measures are derived from guidelines, but they are not the
same thing," said Karen Kmetik, PhD, a clinical quality improvement
specialist with the American Medical Association. "A measure tells us how
often something in a guideline has been done."
Certain groups are offering physicians financial incentives if they
meet the group's performance measures.
Most recently, a group of California purchasers, health plan directors,
physician group executives and medical directors formed the Integrated
Healthcare Assn., which launched a pay-for-performance initiative based on
patient satisfaction, prevention, chronic-care management and
information-technology investment.
If physicians follow the prescribed guidelines and meet the measures, a
performance bonus will be issued.
Whose guidelines?
Some physicians may feel they deserve a bonus just for slogging through
stacks of paperwork.
"We accept 14 different insurances plus Medicare and Medicaid," Dr.
Frank said. "I have binders with all their guidelines, and they all have
guidelines -- for asthma, diabetes, back pain, you name it.
"One week, Health Net will send you their diabetes guidelines, then
PacifiCare will send you their diabetes guidelines, and then Brand X will
send you their diabetes guidelines," she added. "If you scan them all and
all 14 look the same, you can throw 13 of the 14 away."
And although different organizations might -- more or less -- require
the same practices for diabetes management, Dr. Frank said that is not the
case for all conditions, and treatment guidelines for prostate cancer, for
example, vary from organization to organization.
"There's not necessarily consistency from one group to another," she
said. "Some docs just throw them away; others go back and check each file
individually one by one."
So the challenge becomes not only to get physicians to adopt the
guidelines, but also to obtain and learn how to use and implement the
technology.
In an initiative funded by an Agency for Healthcare Quality and
Research grant, the AMA's Dr. Kmetik is heading a coalition of physicians,
employers, health plans and payers in an effort to get all the players
reading from the same quality playbook.
But Dr. Frank has her own ideas on the subject of quality, and they
don't necessarily include performance measures and financial incentives.
"Quality has a broad definition," she said. "Quality isn't measured by
how many Pap smears you do or how many immunizations you give.
"As a family doctor, the reward is when I see patients for a long time
and I see people who live longer, healthier, and are more productive.
Where I practice, in Sonoma County, Calif., that has to serve as my
reward."
Back to top.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION:
Weblink
AAFP online quality initiative
(http://www.aafp.org/x3843.xml)
AHA
program, "Get With the Guidelines"
Report,
"A New Vision for Health Care: A Leadership Role for Business," in pdf,
from the Committee for Economic Development (http://www.ced.org/docs/report/report_healthcare.pdf)
Leapfrog Group
(http://www.leapfroggroup.org/)
Midwest Business Group on Health
(http://www.mbgh.org/)
Back to top.
Copyright 2002 American Medical Association. All
rights reserved.
