Vaccination News Home Page

http://www.activedayton.com/ddn/news/ap/ap_story.html/Washington/AP.V1359.AP-Right-to-Sue.html

Lobbies Push for New Lawsuit Limits

By SHARON THEIMER
Associated Press Writer

 

 

WASHINGTON (AP)--Capitalizing on GOP control of Congress and the White House, lobbying interests as diverse as doctors and asbestos users are pressing for new limitations on when, where and how consumers can file lawsuits.

In some cases, they already have the blessing of President Bush, who succeeded in winning limits on lawsuits when he was Texas governor in the 1990s.

Lobbyists have taken a verbal cue from the president, who often refers to proposals to limit lawsuits as ``job creation bills.'' They're recasting pitches that have traditionally lampooned trial lawyers to focus more on the faltering economy, arguing that lawsuit curbs will help save struggling businesses, preserve jobs and protect access to health care.

``It became an economic development issue,'' said Bruce Josten, the lobbyist for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, among the politically powerful groups leading the charge to restrain malpractice lawsuits.

And in the subtle game of influence, groups tend to avoid traditional terms like ``tort reform'' or ``malpractice liability limits'' to describe their current efforts.

``We think that plays into the hands of the people who don't want to fix the broken system,'' said Dr. Donald Palmisano, a New Orleans physician and attorney who takes over as American Medical Association president next year.

The AMA is among those that have honed their arguments to convince Americans that limits on their right to sue would benefit consumers. The group has armed itself with statistics showing that emergency room doctors, obstetricians, surgeons and other physicians have abandoned some parts of the country because of costly malpractice lawsuits and the expensive insurance they must carry to protect themselves.

That means patients in some communities are forced to drive long distances for health care, the doctors argue.

AMA is lobbying for a federal law limiting noneconomic-damage awards, such as those for pain and suffering, to $250,000 in medical lawsuits. Their proposal would impose a federal cap in states that have no limits.

The group's political action committee gave about 60 percent of its $2.1 million in donations in the last election to Republicans, according to the nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics, which studies donations.

Opponents of further limits, particularly the powerful American Trial Lawyers Association, are girding for battle. ATLA has many Democratic allies and has helped foil some past efforts to limit lawsuits. The association contributed at least $2.4 million this election cycle, roughly 90 percent of that to Democrats, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.

``Most Americans who know what the issues are would certainly not agree that a mother whose child is killed during a horribly botched delivery should be told that her child's life is worth only $250,000 at most,'' ATLA spokesman Carlton Carl said.

One advantage opponents hope to capitalize upon is the narrow split in the Senate, where Republicans have only a slim majority. That means some Democratic votes will be needed to get the necessary 60 votes to avoid legislative roadblocks known as filibusters.

Several liability provisions have passed Congress since Bush took office, some even as Democrats controlled the Senate. Those include limiting liability for teachers, vaccine manufacturers, the makers of airport screening equipment and airport security firms and limiting civil lawsuits filed as a result of a terrorist attack.

Several other interest groups are also seeking limits on specific types of legal claim.

The National Association of Manufacturers and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce want to limit lawsuits from people exposed to cancer-causing asbestos but not yet sickened by it. They say a flood of asbestos lawsuits is driving companies into bankruptcy.

And, the National Federation of Independent Business wants legislation that would limit lawsuits against businesses with 25 or fewer employees.

Supporters of lawsuit limits are finding allies in the Bush administration. Health Secretary Tommy Thompson released a report earlier this year mirroring many of the AMA's arguments on medical malpractice.

The president met personally with Palmisano and promoted legislation to limit malpractice damage awards during a swing through North Carolina in July.

``I don't appreciate the fact that we see a health care system that is broken and riddled with bad--bad law and we're not moving,'' Bush said.

 

AP-NY-12-05-02 1457EST

Copyright 2002, The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP Online news report may not be published, broadcast or redistributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press.

 

Home | National headlines | World headlines

Help | Get newspaper home delivery


 

Final curtain for the Palace Theater

Centerville man jailed in abduction, beating

Fire hits business twice in a day

Two shot after dropping off car at auto body shop

Accused wrong-way driver crashes cruiser

More local stories

 


 

Raiders' dynamic top-scoring duo

Will OSU's Nugent be named nation's top kicker?

Despite second-half rally, Miami falls to Xavier, 68-58

Bengals face worst record in team history this season

High school basketball scores

More sports stories

 


 

Beavercreek man dies in I-675 crash

Seven shot when house hit by gunfire

Troy bank teller charged with theft

Wal-Mart's super site takes shape

Piqua's library has to flesh out Web site

Area's most-wanted criminals

 


 

Down on the Factory: Are cheaper grocery prices worth risks?

Ohio's broken mental retardation system

How the area's biggest traffic jam will happen

Does Ohio welfare trap people in poverty?

Nazi codes broken with help from Dayton

Visit AdsForCARS.com
Visit People2People.com

ActiveDayton.com

Win UD/Duke Tix
Holiday Guide
Area Bazaars

The Marketplace

Search for ads and coupons from the printed newspaper

See all coupons | all ads

Classified ads...

• DaytonClassifieds home page
• Recent home sale prices
• Find a home
• Find an apartment
• Find a job
• Find a better car
• Find garage sales
• Sell your stuff!
 

The Marketplace Online Ads

• Autos & Car Care

• Beauty & Fitness

• Entertainment & Leisure

• Finance & Banking

• Home Services & Improvement

• Lawn & Garden

• Restaurants

• Retail

• Services

• BBB buying guide

Special features

• UD Arena

• Winter Weather Survival Guide

• Guide to higher education

• Gaming Guide, How to Play and Where to Stay

• Get Free Travel Information

• See what's happening downtown

• Forecast: Valley features sponsored by Dayton Metro Library

• Continuing Education Opportunities

• Our take on health care

• Area's most wanted criminals

Copyright © 2002, Cox Ohio Publishing. All rights reserved.
By using DaytonDailyNews.com, you accept the terms of our visitor agreement.

Vaccination News Home Page

ALL INFORMATION, DATA, AND MATERIAL CONTAINED, PRESENTED, OR PROVIDED HERE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED AS REFLECTING THE KNOWLEDGE OR OPINIONS OF THE PUBLISHER, AND IS NOT TO BE CONSTRUED OR INTENDED AS PROVIDING MEDICAL OR LEGAL ADVICE.  THE DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO VACCINATE IS AN IMPORTANT AND COMPLEX ISSUE AND SHOULD BE MADE BY YOU, AND YOU ALONE, IN CONSULTATION WITH YOUR HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.