West Nile
vaccine fails on horse
By Lisa Schneider
lschneider@forumcomm.com
The Forum - 08/08/2002
The equine vaccine for West Nile virus is not foolproof.
An infected Cass County horse that was euthanized at the end of July
appeared to have been adequately vaccinated, state veterinarian Dr.
Larry Schuler said Wednesday.
Vaccines are never considered 100 percent effective, he said.
“You do have some vaccine breaks.”
The virus is spread to humans and horses via mosquitoes. There is no
vaccine for humans and the inoculation for horses has yet to be fully
approved by the USDA.
Regardless of not having full USDA certification, the vaccine has
proven itself effective and worthy of full approval, said John Tuttle,
manager of professional services for the vaccine’s manufacturing
company, Ft. Dodge Animal Health of Overland Park, Kan.
It was released last year under emergency conditions, he said. There
was only a 2 percent rate of failure last year, he said.
The Cass County horse had received both shots required for full
protection. However, the horse was infected before the vaccine had time
to take full effect, said David Calderwood, veterinarian at Casselton
Veterinary Service.
It takes four weeks after the second shot to become fully protected,
he said. After the first rounds of inoculations, immunity increases and
only one shot per year is required, he said.
Even though horses are still at risk immediately after the first
series of shots, horse owners should not hesitate to get their horses
vaccinated now, he said.
“Horse owners have to know the disease is here to stay,” he said.
“It’s too much of risk not to get vaccinated.”
The vaccine should be fully approved by the USDA by the end of the
summer, Tuttle said.
Meanwhile, horses in North Dakota are being infected at a faster rate
than those in surrounding states such as Minnesota and South Dakota,
Schuler said. While the official count of infected horses in North
Dakota remains at 15, the North Dakota State University Diagnostic Lab
will release the results of 48 tests today.
“There’s getting to be quite a few” cases, Schuler said. There are a
large number of samples coming in not only from the eastern parts of the
state but from all over. “We will probably see an escalation until we
get a frost to reduce the mosquito count.”
Minnesota counties are also seeing more cases, most from the eastern
part of the state, said Mike Schommer, spokesman for the Minnesota Board
of Animal Health.
Ten horses in Minnesota have been infected with the virus, two from
Clay County, Schommer said. Twenty-two Minnesota birds have been
confirmed as being infected, he said.
After the two birds in Fargo were confirmed as being infected
Tuesday, Fargo Cass Public Health was inundated with phone calls from
citizens, half reporting dead birds and half with West Nile virus
questions, said Brady Scribner, environmental health practitioner with
Fargo Cass Public Health.
Fargo Cass Public Health has sent 37 birds to be tested at a lab in
Wisconsin, including 12 Wednesday, Scribner said. It takes two to three
weeks to get results back, he said. Public Health is still collecting
birds that have died within 48 hours of being found, Scribner said.
Readers can reach Forum reporter Lisa Schneider at (701) 241-5529