“Around the world, in countries where vaccines are not available, almost 900,000 children a year die of measles.” They are not dying because they don’t have measles vaccine; they are dying because they are malnourished, living in poverty, living in unhealthy conditions, which makes measles and other diseases more serious for them. In developed nations, until vaccination changed the epidemiology of measles, it was rarely serious. - SM
http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/30/health/30VACC.html
|
August 30, 2001 Study Clears Two Vaccines of Any Long-Lasting Harm
By PHILIP J. HILTS
The findings come against a backdrop of recurring fears, in the United
States and abroad, that those rare fever-related seizures may be linked to
later autism and developmental problems. The fears are unfounded, the study
concluded. "This study is very reassuring," said Dr. Karin Nelson, a child
neurologist at the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke,
who was not involved in the research. "It is very large, it confirms the
studies that we have done before, and it goes farther in following up
children to show there are not additional problems after vaccination." The study, being published today in The New England Journal of Medicine,
looked at medical data for 639,000 children, about 2 percent of all the
nation's children under the age of 7. It found that those who got the
vaccines and then experienced seizures had no more chance of further seizures
or neurological problems later than those who did not have seizures after
being vaccinated. Two vaccines were studied: one given to prevent diphtheria, tetanus and
pertussis (or whooping cough), and so called DTP, and the other to prevent
measles, mumps and rubella (or German measles), called MMR. The study was far larger than previous such work, and, in their effort to
determine whether seizures caused by high fevers after vaccination, known as
febrile seizures, had any long-term effects, the researchers followed a
majority of the children past the age of 6. That was typically five years
after the first of the vaccinations was given, and three to four years after
the second. "We didn't find any evidence of later problems up to that age, so we
think we would have spotted it if something else had occurred," said the
lead author, Dr. Robert L. Davis of the University of Washington in Seattle,
who worked with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in producing
the study. Children in the study were vaccinated from 1991 to 1993. The form of DTP
vaccine that they received, which apparently caused rare febrile seizures, is
no longer used in the United States. It has been replaced by a form called
DTaP, which studies suggest has one-third or fewer of the side effects of the
older type. Previous studies had shown that in rare cases DTP and MMR caused children
to have high fevers, as well as febrile seizures that lasted from a few
seconds to 15 minutes. But febrile seizures are fairly common in children
even without vaccination, occurring in about 4 percent of them by the time
they have passed through adolescence. "The seizures come on when fever is high," Dr. Nelson said,
"and it is a terrifying event for the families to have a young child
convulse and then look as if they are dead. But terrifying as they are, they
are not dangerous in terms of causing problems later." Of all the children in the study, only 63 had experienced febrile seizures
after being vaccinated; 521 had had such seizures as a result of illnesses
not related to vaccination. Seizures not connected to a fever are much more worrisome than febrile
seizures, Dr. Nelson and Dr. Davis said. These seizures are sometimes linked
to disorders like epilepsy and mental retardation. The study found that
between those children who got febrile fevers and those who did not, the rate
of nonfebrile seizures was no different. "This study," Dr. Davis said, "is useful because it gives a
clearer picture, and greater confidence that vaccines are not associated with
nonfebrile seizures." Concern and debate over the safety of DTP and MMR have flared in the
United States, Britain and elsewhere recently, and periodically during the
last 30 years. Indeed, fears about them have caused some parents to avoid
vaccinating their children, a decision with sometimes disastrous results.
Large outbreaks of disease have followed the drops in vaccination in several
countries, and smaller outbreaks of measles and whooping cough have occurred
in some American communities. For example, studies have shown that anti-vaccination arguments by some
doctors in Britain three decades ago brought a huge drop in vaccination
there, to 30 percent of all children from 80 percent in just a few years.
What resulted was an epidemic of 100,000 cases of whooping cough, with at
least 34 deaths. In Japan, a similar drop in vaccination resulted in a 1979 epidemic of
13,000 cases and 41 deaths. Dr. Robert Chen, an epidemiologist at the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, said such epidemics were an unintended consequence of
"mature vaccination programs" that have nearly eradicated many
diseases in developed countries, creating a sense of complacency in doctors
and parents who have no personal experience with the diseases the vaccines
can prevent. Many parents today do not realize how serious diseases like measles and
whooping cough can be. Around the world, in countries where vaccines are not
available, almost 900,000 children a year die of measles. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||