|
Understanding autism:
breaking out of the bubble
(Filed: 29/04/2002)
The growing number of children diagnosed as
autistic is causing alarm among parents and doctors. In the first
part of a series, Christine Doyle investigates whether the disorder
is more prevalent - and explains what little we know about it
|
MORE than 500,000 people in Britain have autism. For
many, life is a confusion of sounds, smells and sights. Some describe it
as living in a mental bubble - away from everyone else. Parents
desperately try to break through to their offspring, unable to accept
that an apparently normal child is slowly withdrawing into a world of
his or her own and taking little pleasure in hugs and ordinary human
emotions.
|

|
|
|
Elliot Thomas [left], who has autism, with his twin brother,
Calum
|
Leo Kanner, an American doctor, was the first to
recognise, in 1943, the classic symptoms of such "early infantile
autism", though its history stretches back into ancient myths and
stories of changelings. Until the Sixties, however, autism was seen as a
relatively rare disorder. There remained a belief - a hangover from the
psychoanalytical era - that "bad" parents were somehow to blame.
Nowadays, it seems there is an "epidemic" of autism.
Most people, apparently, know of someone who has it and teachers report
more and more cases in their classrooms. Broader definitions and growing
recognition help to explain the apparent rise in prevalence of a complex
continuum of autistic conditions now classified as Autistic Spectrum
Disorder.
Yet, there is suspicion that the rise in ASD is not
fully explained.
Many parents are anxious about a possible link between the combined
measles, mumps and rubella vaccine, and autism and bowel disease.
One major question from parents and campaigning groups is whether the
vaccines or other environmental influences could combine with an
underlying genetic susceptibility to trigger ASD.
For the National Autistic Society, which this year
celebrates its 40th anniversary, public anxiety about MMR has helped to
focus attention on the plight of those with autistic disorders and on
such crucial issues as early diagnosis and planning the best support.
The need has never been greater, says the society, which steps up an
anniversary campaign on May 12 to increase awareness of the impact of
autism.
Dr Lorna Wing, consultant psychiatrist for the
society's centre for social and communication disorders, and who has a
grown-up daughter with autism, says: "We need, above all, to prevent
parents being frustrated for years on end by their inability to get a
proper diagnosis and help."
Today, we start our guide to autism and talk to a
mother about her struggle with medical and educational obduracy.
What is autism?
A lifelong developmental condition now called Autistic
Spectrum Disorder. It affects the way people communicate, relate to
others and how they behave. Rigid, repetitive behaviour, resistance to
change and a lack of imagination are common symptoms.
At one end are those so severely impaired that they may
understand little and be unable to do anything for themselves. At the
other are
people with Asperger's syndrome, who tend to have fewer problems
with language, although they may sound strangely formal or stilted.
Those at the more able end of the spectrum usually have average or
above-average intelligence. A few have flashes of brilliance, as
displayed by Dustin Hoffman's character in Rain Man, despite extreme
difficulty forming friendships or understanding other people's feelings.
Interestingly, one researcher also thinks there is a
group of people whom she calls "loners", who are really very bright
Asperger's sufferers. Distinguishing between the variety of autistic
disorders is not easy. Dr Wing notes: "What starts out as classic autism
in children can evolve into being more like Asperger's."
What worried parents say about
their children
Communication Does not respond to name. Cannot
say what he or she wants. Language is delayed. Seems to hear at times,
but not at others. Does not point or follow directions. Used to say a
few words, but now doesn't.
Social Doesn't smile socially. Prefers to play
alone. Gets things for himself. Does things early. Has poor eye contact.
"Tunes out" from parents and is not interested in other children.
Behaviour Tantrums. Hyperactive and unco-operative.
Doesn't know how to play with toys. Gets rigidly stuck on one toy. Lines
things up. Oversensitive to certain textures or sounds. Has odd movement
patterns - such as spinning.
How early should children be
diagnosed?
Dr Wing has no hesitation. "As early as possible.
Parents who have nerved themselves to consult their GP are sometimes
told that it must be glue ear or that their child will grow out of it.
Yet the strange two-year-old can all too swiftly become a disruptive,
unteachable four-year-old."
Doctors must listen to parents, says Dr Wing. "Parents
know their child." And, she notes, to the trained observer, videos of
babies often reveal early signs of autistic behaviour, suggesting that
one day much earlier diagnosis, perhaps within the first few months,
will be possible.
But too many doctors still focus on physical symptoms -
the lumps and bumps. "It is their training. Things are improving, but so
often doctors look at the attractive kid in front of them and they are
bewildered. The National Autistic Society runs five-day courses for
health professionals, and we hope this will have an impact."
Diagnosis involves careful questioning, language
testing and evaluation. Even so, Dr Wing sometimes knows the answer
straight off. "At the assessment, a child might rush through the door
looking at no one and start lining up the fridge magnets."
Her advice to worried parents is to insist on swift
referral to a paediatrician, psychiatrist or psychologist with a known
interest in autism. Absolute signs for referral include:
no babbling by 12 months
no gesturing (pointing, waving, bye-bye, etc)
by 12 months
no single words by 16 months
no spontaneous two-word phrases by 24 months
(autistic children may repeat or "echo" what is said to them)
any loss of any language or social skills at
any age.
If autism is suspected but not yet confirmed, Dr Wing
advises parents to treat children as if it had been. "It is good advice
with any child. Try to stay calm and organised with a timetable. Be very
careful to convey exactly what you mean. Notice if the child is
understanding and, if not, show them in simple, physical terms.
Remember, children with ASD can understand what they see more than what
they hear.
"Don't push your affection on to them. But play
tickling games. Most enjoy being tickled. After a bath, they might come
and sit on your lap when warm and sleepy. Keep rules to a minimum, but
be sure to keep to them."
How common is autism?
The first prevalence studies in the Sixties using Leo
Kanner's definition of "classic" autism found a rate of five in 10,000
children. Since then, there have been at least 40 major prevalence
studies of the wider Autistic Spectrum Disorder, including 10 by Dr Wing
and her colleague Dr Judy Gould.
In a recent review of autism research, the Medical Research Council
concludes: "There appears to be fairly good agreement that autism
spectrum disorders affect about 60 per 10,000 children under eight." Of
these, 10 to 30 per 10,000 have narrowly defined autism. The MRC notes:
"These
estimates make ASD far more common than was generally recognised."
The most recent study from Sweden adds children with an
IQ of more than 70 to give a prevalence rate of 90 per 10,000 or almost
one per cent.
There are no equivalent figures for adults.
Is the rise in autism 'real'?
Dr Wing believes that most of the rise is explained by
greater recognition and diagnosis. "Autistic disorder also exists among
people with other mental disorders and now we include these. Autism can
also co-exist with tuberous sclerosis [characterised by nodules in the
brain], Down's syndrome and other conditions, even dyspraxia and
dyslexia.
"It really is not so pure and simple as once thought.
Psychiatrists are beginning to look back: I can remember people with
what might be termed chronic schizophrenia who were autistic."
Dr Wing does not, however, exclude the possibility of a
real increase in autism. "The question cannot be answered definitively."
She would like to see new prevalence studies, designed to show if rates
for particular sub-groups have changed.
What does the future hold?
Drugs such as Seroxat and modern anti-depressants help
to relieve anxiety, which can be socially paralysing for some people
with Asperger's. Many who are severely affected will require specialist
help all their lives - some in residential schools and homes.
Much depends on intellectual ability, says Dr Wing. "We
find that if an especially able person resolves to pass for normal they
will manage to fit in. But there is no way you can force them to. It is
their decision: they usually start thinking, when they are adolescent,
about whether they will have a job, be independent, get married, even.
"Others do not give a damn; they are not the slightest
bit concerned."
Postcode
lottery
Su Thomas, co-founder of Pace (Parents' Autism Campaign
for Education), campaigns tirelessly for better services and schooling.
Her son Elliot, seven, has autism. Callum, his twin (left), does not.
On Wednesday, she will listen critically as MRC
specialists explain their recent review of the prevalence rates on
autism to MPs attending a meeting of the All Party Parliamentary Group
on Autism.
Su says: "This is a fast-moving time for ASD. In some
areas, the rate of increase in prevalence seems phenomenal: a
paediatrician told me of a rise in his borough over 15 years from one to
25 children a year.
"Whether the rise is real or due to better diagnosis,
there are still huge numbers of children who need help. 'The Government
and education authorities must urgently investigate the size of the
problem nationwide and plan ahead. The present 'postcode lottery' for
specialist school places is appalling - there is a shortfall of many
thousands."
Return to top
Next story:
How to freshen up the breath
|