SYMMES TOWNSHIP - It's 11:30 a.m.
when Joe Greenlee files into the middle school cafeteria at Cincinnati Hills
Christian Academy with his classmates.
Inside, Joe goes one way. His friend, the one holding a peanut butter
sandwich, walks the other.
They can't sit together.
For Joe and six other food-sensitive children at his schoolthis isn't
just lunch; it's a potentially fatal half-hour.
That's why the eighth-grader sits at a separate table, segregated from his
classmates. (His friends can join him, but only if they don't bring along foods
containing nuts or nut oils.)
This has been Joe's life since the fifth grade, when the middle school
established a peanut-free area for him. At other schools, he ate in isolation.
"It's hard to not worry when you know one wrong bite can kill your child,"
said Joe's mother, Nancy Greenlee of Sycamore Township. "The table protects
him."
Joe and his classmates are among an estimated 8 million Americans - 2.7
percent - who suffer from food allergies. Of those, 3 million are allergic to
peanuts, the leading cause of severe allergic reactions in the United States.
Each year, up to 100 deaths are blamed on peanuts.
Such allergies are on the rise. Dr. Amal Assa'ad, a pediatric allergist at
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, recently built a database from
patients that showed peanut allergies occur more frequently than cow's milk or
egg allergies, which traditionally were more widespread.
No one knows for certain why this is happening, but a study released this
year found topical ointments containing peanut oils applied early in life could
lead to allergies as an adult. Another theory is that roasting peanuts could
make them more allergenic.
Nuts at school
As the number of peanut-sensitive children increases, schools are
finding ways to cope.
RESOURCES
Cincinnati Food
Allergy Awareness, Support and Training (FAAST): www.faastcincy.org; e-mail:
help@faastcincy.org; (513)
588-6863; PO Box 565, Loveland 45140.
Schools like Cincinnati Hills and Cincinnati Country Day School in Indian
Hill opt for peanut-free tables, which are rapidly becoming fixtures in Tristate
cafeterias.
That option isn't without controversy. Some think the peanut-free tables
further ostracize children who already have trouble participating in social
events and field trips. They advocate just the opposite - places where students
who eat peanut products sit together.
Cincinnati Hills administrators chose the peanut-free area after discussions
with parents, teachers and students.
"It's difficult, because you don't want the peanut-free table to be like
isolation," said Cincinnati Hills middle school principal Diane Blackburn.
"That's why we tried to keep ours pretty close to the other tables and give it a
cool name."
The table in the "Peanut-Free Zone" is small and square, while the others are
long rectangles. It sits a few feet away from the others, tucked into a far spot
in the cafeteria.
Industrial antibacterial wipes, rather than regular cleaning fluid, are used
to clean the peanut-free table and chairs after each lunch period.
Despite the disparities, the peanut-free zone has become kind of hip.
"It's fun. I get my own place to sit with my friends," said sixth-grader
Brooke Spicer.
The middle school has almost entirely banned peanuts. The cafeteria never
serves anything with peanuts, nuts are forbidden from school functions and the
teachers' lounge is peanut-free.
While most Tristate schools handle food allergies on a case-by-case basis,
some have additional nut policies:
In Bellevue schools, students are asked to keep the peanuts at home. Also,
lunchroom cooks do not use peanuts in any form.
At Princeton City Schools, menu items identify if foods contain nuts.
Appropriate substitutes are provided for any allergic students.
Hilltop Elementary School in Wyoming previously had an "allergy table" for
students affected by such things as milk and peanuts. The most sensitive
students moved on to the middle school, eliminating the need for a separate
table.
Bite of reality
"I think every parent of a child with food allergies has at one
time been called too sensitive or paranoid," said Jennifer Redmond, executive
director and founder of Cincinnati Food Allergy Awareness Support and Training.
"(But) I'm not talking about a rash here. Unless you have been in a
position where your child has almost died, you don't understand."
PEANUT ALLERGIES 101
Common foods that
cause allergic reactions: Milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts (walnut,
cashew, etc.), fish, shellfish, soy and wheat.
Most common symptoms after ingestion:
Itching and swelling of the lips, tongue or mouth.
Itching and/or tightness, hoarseness, and hacking cough.
Hives, itchy rash, swelling of the face and/or extremities.
Nausea, abdominal cramps, vomiting and/or diarrhea.
Shortness of breath and/or wheezing.
"Thready" pulse. Symptoms appear: Typically within minutes to two hours
after the person has eaten the food to which he or she is allergic.
These reactions are called anaphylaxis. That is: a
sudden, severe, potentially fatal, systemic allergic reaction that
can involve various areas of the body. Anaphylactic reactions can be
mild to life-threatening. The danger: Anaphylaxis causes 30,000 trips to the
emergency room and about 100 deaths each year nationwide.
Individuals who are allergic to foods and have asthma are believed
to be at a higher risk for developing an anaphylactic reaction. If someone has an anaphylactic reaction: Call 911 and
request epinephrine or check if person carries a supply. Get the
person to a hospital as soon as possible. He should plan to stay at
least four to six hours. Source: The Food Allergy & Anaphylaxis Network
The problem is a severe allergic reaction known as anaphylaxis. Symptoms,
which range from diarrhea to hives, occur within minutes to two hours after
contact with the allergy-causing substance.
Redmond of Loveland prefers to use the technical term when she discusses the
allergies of her 11-year-old son, Brian.
"If I say 'food allergy,' it's easy for people to brush you off. They think
it's no big deal," she said. "But say 'anaphylaxis' and they listen."
Food-induced anaphylaxis causes 30,000 trips to the emergency room each year,
according to the Food Allergy & Anaphylaxis Network.
So just don't eat peanuts, right? It's not that simple - especially for
people like Joe, who is also smell and touch sensitive.
Once when Joe dropped his pencil in class, a child who had recently eaten
peanuts picked it up. When Joe grabbed the pencil, he broke out in hives and
couldn't breathe.
The last time he attended a Reds game, the scent of roasted peanuts gave him
hives for two weeks.
"The kids used to tease me about it when I was younger. But when they
realized how serious this is, they stopped," he said.
Many products contain peanuts or peanut-containing ingredients. Some are
listed under different names (for example, hydrolyzed plant protein), while
others aren't listed.
Peanut-free products can be cross-contaminated by other foods - often
chocolate, baked goods and cereals.
Peanuts are even found in some kitty litter, wallboard, fireplace logs, paper
and animal feed.
"It's tough to cope with the fact that your child is safe nowhere," Redmond
said. "Even in your own home, there are things that can get in."
Field trips and school parties are also problematic.
"So many things at school revolve around food," said Cynthia Betcher,
Cincinnati Hills high school nurse and board member of Cincinnati Food Allergy
Awareness Support and Training.
"The best thing parents can do is to have some snacks already at school,
so their kids don't have to abstain from the fun."
This became an issue recently as tension heightened in Iraq. Safe,
peanut-free food was necessary for these children as schools prepared for
possible lockdowns.
The challenges don't change with age, either. Kids are messy, so it's tough
to keep offending foods from young children. But teen-agers can be just as much
at risk.
"They have this 'It's not going to happen to me' attitude," Redmond said.
"Plus, they have more exposure to different things."
And more exposure to the opposite sex. A report in the June 6, 2002, New
England Journal of Medicine showed that more than 5 percent of people with
severe food allergies had a reaction prompted by kissing. This can occur by
locking lips with someone who has eaten nut products up to six hours prior to
smooching.
Controlling allergies
There is no cure to peanut allergies.
In the event of accidental ingestion, epinephrine (adrenaline), is the
medication of choice for controlling a severe reaction. It is available by
prescription as an EpiPen auto injector.
At the Cincinnati Hills middle school, many staff members carry EpiPens in
the event of an emergency. Allergic children carry their own, too.
Emotional support is also available for families with food allergy sufferers.
Cincinnati Food Allergy Awareness Support and Training , for example, was
started by Redmond in 1997 with nine members. Today there are 300.
"As your child gets older, they need to know that there are other kids out
there like him or her," she said.
The group does educational counseling, too, including a back-to-school
program for schools and parents each year.
"I've seen an enormous change in Cincinnati since we first started," Redmond
said. "Schools are increasingly more accommodating."
More hope is on the horizon.
The first drug designed to protect those who are severely allergic to peanuts
is slowly moving toward federal approval.
"I've got a lot of hope that by the time my son is college age, there will be
something other than avoidance and an EpiPen out there," Redmond said. "But we
have to tackle this with the mentality that there might not be."
The still-experimental drug, called TNX-901, significantly increased the
threshold of sensitivity to peanuts during trials.
"It'll change our lives," Greenlee said. "Then I'll just have to say, 'No
drinking. No driving.'
DISCLAIMER: All
information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for
general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the
knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended
as providing medical or legal advice. The decision whether or not to vaccinate
is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in
consultation with your health care provider.
"A foolish faith in authority is the worst enemy of truth."
-- Albert Einstein, letter to a friend, 1901
"I know of no safe depository of the ultimate powers of the society but the people themselves, and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion by education."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to William C. Jarvis, September 28, 1820
"What's the point of vaccination if it doesn't protect you from the unvaccinated?"
-- Sandy Gottstein
"Who gets to decide what the greater good is and how many will be sacrificed to it?"