MMR
- risk of brain disorders?
By JENNY HOPE, Daily Mail
he
MMR jab 'significantly' increases the risk of developing autism and
other brain and nerve disorders, according to a study.
U.S. experts say the vaccine may be a factor in up to 15 per cent
of such conditions.
The findings were hailed last night by campaigners who say the
triple MMR vaccine is behind the rising number of youngsters with
bowel disorders and autism.
They say it is the first time there has been an authoritative
analysis of data on adverse reactions to vaccines and claim it
vindicates both their warnings and the alert sparked by British
expert Dr Andrew Wakefield five years ago.
The news will increase pressure on the Government to make single
vaccines against measles, mumps and rubella freely available.
Jackie Fletcher, who set up the support group Jabs, also called
for a full research programme into MMR.
Use of the controversial vaccine in Britain is already at a
record low of 80 per cent among two-year-olds, when at least 95 per
cent is needed to prevent measles outbreaks. But the Department of
Health continued to insist last night that studies worldwide had
shown the vaccine was safe.
The new research, by a team led by top geneticist Dr Mark Geier,
involved analysing information on an official U.S. database showing
vaccine reactions between 1994 and 2000.
Dr Geier found a 'statistically significant' increased risk of
children suffering a range of disorders within five to 20 days of an
MMR jab.
These included autism, mental retardation and encephalitis, which
causes brain inflammation.
Dr Geier, who has published over 70 scientific articles and is
regarded as an expert on vaccines in the U.S., Canadian and English
courts, said: 'The studies tend to confirm and extend the work by Dr
Andy Wakefield that caused so much concern in the UK.'
Details of the study, to be published in the medical journal
International Paediatrics, were released yesterday in the doctors'
newspaper Pulse.
Dr Geier has also carried out research into the effects of a
mercury-based preservative called thiomersal which is used in
childhood vaccines.
He is due this summer to publish further research which claims to
show a causal link between mercury in vaccines and brain disorders.
Dr Geier has also written to U.S. senator Hillary Clinton, who is
heading a review of American vaccine compensation policy, warning
that a 'tragic and massive autism epidemic' is under way and MMR may
be one cause.
His letter says: 'Our best estimates are that thiomersal
contributed to about 75 per cent of the cases of
neurodestudiesvelopmental disorders while the MMR contributed to
about 15 per cent.'
Mrs Fletcher, who believes her son Robert, now nine, was
seriously damaged by MMR, said monitoring for side effects was less
thorough in the UK than in the U.S., where children cannot enter
school without proof of vaccination.
But Dr Elizabeth Miller, head of the immunisation division at the
Government's Health Protection Agency, said: 'The research of this
group is well known, and they have published a number of using the
Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System database.
'This database consists of voluntary reports, similar to the
yellow card scheme in this country. Such reports are not designed to
test hypotheses and great care needs to be taken in analysing such
data to avoid generating flawed results.'
A Health Department spokesman said the Committee on Safety of
Medicines had advised that this type of analysis cannot be used to
determine and compare the incidence of adverse reactions associated
with different vaccinations.
He added: 'Therefore, because of serious methodological flaws,
the conclusions of the authors concerning the association between
MMR and the outcomes studied cannot be justified.
'The CSM has fully investigated the claims of a link between MMR
vaccine and autism. The view of the CSM remains that the available
scientific evidence does not support a causal link between MMR
vaccination and autism. This view is in line with the consensus of
several national and international scientific organisations.'
|