Return to Vaccination News Home Page

Subscribe to the Vaccination NewsLetter

View past & current Scandals (columns by Sandy Mintz)

Search This Site using keywords

http://www.guardian.co.uk/medicine/story/0,11381,959953,00.html

Drama at MMR research launch

Press Association
Tuesday May 20, 2003


The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) today ejected a press conference on a study that showed a link between the MMR jab and autism from its headquarters because it feared being seen as endorsing the findings.

The American researchers were told to leave the RCN's head offices in central London when they arrived to set up their press conference early this morning.

A spokesman for the researchers said RCN officials gave them only a few minutes to pack up and find another venue.

The research, published today in the medical journal International Pediatrics, found a significant link between the mumps, measles and rubella jab and autism compared with another triple jab given to children.

But an RCN spokeswoman said the college could not be seen to be endorsing the findings in any way.

She said: "People would have implied that the RCN considered the MMR vaccine to be unsafe, which isn't the case. We are very supportive of MMR.

"Therefore it did not seem appropriate for us to host this press conference."

The spokeswoman said college officials only knew the content of the report late last night, although the researchers dispute this.

The authors, Dr Mark Geier and David Geier, drew their findings from a database set up by the US centres for disease controls and protection to enable health workers to report adverse reactions to childhood vaccines.

The study looked at reports of suspected neurological problems after the MMR jab and the diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis (DTP) combined vaccine.

Between 1994 and 2000 almost 25m first doses of MMR and around 63m doses of DTP were given to children.

Among those given MMR, there were 133 reports of suspected neurological problems such as autism, mental retardation or brain damage.

There were 29 reports of autism among boys, eight among girls and the relative risk was five times higher in those given MMR compared to DTP.

The authors concluded that MMR was associated with a marked increase in neurological disorders compared to the DTP vaccine.

They said the MMR programme should carry on but using dead instead of live forms of the viruses.

UK groups campaigning for single vaccines said the study justified their concerns about the jab and called for a public inquiry into its use.

Jonathan Harris, of the campaigning group Jabs, said the study "completely vindicates the concerns of both the parents and carers of the children affected".

"We now call upon the government to hold a public inquiry and conduct a total review of their childhood vaccination programme and to suspend the use of MMR whilst further independent studies are made and make single vaccinations available on the NHS."

But the health protection agency (HPA) and the Department of Health (DoH) said the study was seriously flawed.

Dr Mary Ramsay, consultant epidemiologist at the HPA, said: "This research is seriously flawed - it compares children of different ages who have received different vaccines and the conclusions are incorrect."

She said MMR was given at 15 to 18 months of age whereas DTP vaccinations were given at two, four and six months.

"Regardless of the other weaknesses of the data, the failure to compare children of the same age is enough to explain the apparent excess of cases reported in the MMR group," she said.

Dr Ramsay said the findings contrasted dramatically with other studies that have used valid methods and found no increased risk of autism following the MMR jab.

The link between MMR, autism and bowel disorders was first raised by Dr Andrew Wakefield in 1998.

Dr Wakefield, who is now the chief medical scientist for Visceral, a charity which funds research into bowel problems and autism, said: "Based on this study and others, it is now untenable for the DoH to refuse parents a right to choose the individual vaccines in preference to the MMR for their children."

According to recent research by Cardiff University's school of journalism, media and cultural studies, almost all scientific experts reject the claim of a link between the MMR and autism.

Full text
Research paper: Pediatric MMR Vaccination Safety (pdf)

Talk about it
Should parents be allowed access to single vaccinations? Would you allow your child to have the MMR jab?

Related articles
29.04.2003: Measles - the comeback
20.02.2003: MMR research supports triple jab
10.02.2003: Error warning over separate MMR jabs
07.08.2002: Demand surges for MMR single vaccines
28.06.2002: MMR 'may cause 1 in 10 cases of autism'
17.06.2002: MMR row resurfaces
12.06.2002: Research gives MMR vaccination all-clear
13.03.2002: Measles returns to Scotland
06.03.2002: Measles spreads as jab is shunned

Big issue
Public health

Useful sites
Department of Health: MMR
International Pediatrics
Jabs
Health Protection Agency
Sense: Remember Rubella (pdf)
UK Public Health Association
British Medical Journal
World Health Organisation
British Medical Association
BMJ paper: Mumps, measles, and rubella vaccine and the incidence of autism
General Medical Council

 

Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2003

 

Return to Vaccination News Home Page

DISCLAIMER:    All information, data, and material contained, presented, or provided here is for general information purposes only and is not to be construed as reflecting the knowledge or opinions of the publisher, and is not to be construed or intended as providing medical or legal advice.  The decision whether or not to vaccinate is an important and complex issue and should be made by you, and you alone, in consultation with your health care provider.